Patrefans
Torsten Hewson from patreon
Torsten Hewson patreon

v2c52: Answers

🕑 Added 2021-08-06 18:42:34 +0000 UTC

Comments

fbt

The revised version is some seriously nice writing. I still have some qualms traceable to the structural choices impacting clarity a bit more than I like, but that's water under the bridge. Other than that, this is some *really* nice writing. The extra polish really makes this and the next chapter shine in terms of writing technique and skill (also very nice bits of story, but that's a sep topic rly). Amazing work!

Enkelados

Hmm not a fan of this development tbh. Repeating history is kinda boring.

fbt

if more than a few readers have trouble following it, it's likely it's not well done, I'd argue (exceptions exist, but genre fiction is the other end of the spectrum). Further, I think the example you gave is specious. A written narrative has very different requirements than actual experience of the child you mention. And even then, the kids experience (slanted and selective as it might be) would be intuitively understood by the kid (wrongly or not); he/she is not unable to parse their own experience. As I mentioned above, a written version of those events has additional burdens of clarity in order to be any kind of viable story. There are certainly exceptions in both poetry and prose. This, however, simply looked less well executed to me. But, that's just my opinion.

Kara Nina

@fbt it's intentionally vague - after all, we can now discern a rough picture of what happened, but no details. There aren't supposed to be any details, either, since this isn't a linear explanation but a wild mix of memories. If you think back to your childhood you don't think 'at the age of 4 my mother took me to a doctor on the 15th of August 2005, he confirmed her guess that I was nearsighted, the glasses cost 50 $ and we bought them a this one special onlineshop founded in March 2003 and received them 3 weeks later', instead you think 'I stumbled on my way to the sandbox in kindergarten when I wanted to show off my new glasses'

Imspinnennetz

I also got slightly confused the first time reading the section with the recording crystal. There needs to be a clearer distinction between Bi De's perspective and the person with the recording crystal's perspective.

fbt

idk, i found it kinda vague/confusing/hard to follow, idk about anyone else. Maybe just my short attention span :) or the fact that I normally avoid cultivation stories. Prolly just me.

Kristof Dohrmann

That would certainly be a twist, but I don't think this actually points to anything. The woman clearly is a previous version of the Earth spirit, which was dorment for a long time before Jin came. I doubt there is any connection between the old lady and Tianlan.

Justin van mele

So this basically confirms that Jin is walking the path of something of a druidic sage. This recording crystal may have a way for Jin to properly cultivate this method and have his first long chat with earth-chan.

Call0013

I would guess the other person did something similar to what Jin is doing, but not the exact same and Jin and Tianlan are pretty much doing the 2.0 version of what the last guy did.

Armo

There’s also the fact that there’s been an empire established since then, which is actively fending off demons that might threaten the Azure Hills.

Null

People forget the definition to live forever. I mean if you live forever you are going to have forever pain(mental, fiscal, spiritual etc..), hunger(many types for this one), other type of mortals desire that when we DIE are all gone.

The Lost Pages

Incredible chapter as always.

The GrandMage

Judging by the demon fighting and talk of him being corrupted, as well as the Spirit's avoidance of corrupted qi, I think the first time they did this they weren't prepared for demons and corruption, likely because he tried to spread too fast, maybe used pills and such to speed it up. In which case Jin's lazier method of teaching them farming techniques and if they pick up the qi stuff good, if not whatever is probably the better move.

Andrew

Thank you!

Stewart Boyatt

So, the Woman with the frizzy hair definitely talks like Verdant Hills granny right? I'm not crazy?

Arcane Hermit

Welp. Guess we're in one possible aspect of a potential/implied long term fate for "Rou Jin". That being part/one (digested/absorbed) by Earth Chan... And honestly, out of all (ex) Cultivator's, he's fine with just that. (I mean, who "really" wants to live forever?)

Alan McBrayer

We saw the name before in the volume 1.5 interlude. Tainlan Shan, I believe it means sky blue mountain or rather Azure Mountain, it was one of the names: "She was Big Little Sister, like Chunky said! Or… Tianlan Shan, like those other ones said? That one sounded right too... Or was she Fa Ram? Or was she “Mother Earth?” " Now we have a clue about the other ones. The interlude gave the impression that many had connected with her only to damage her. This sounds like the most recent or the most egregious.

Rat with a Pick

We have a Name For the Earth Child!

Philo

so it seems to me that what happens to the land happens to the cultivator as well.

Imspinnennetz

I am not sure whether the jealous thoughts of the cultivator corrupted the formation causing the collapse or the cultivator intentionally broke the formation to harm TianLan

Robert Mullins

I mean, nothing he did seemed related to earth.

Nicholas Roberts

Jin was not the first. Does this mean that the guy in the recording crystal was an Isekai as well?

Nicholas Roberts

I read it as if he made this formation to give to Tianlan, but instead it backfired and nearly destroyed her

Bunny Waffles

So the guy who made the formation was the one who hurt the land? I can't say I quite got that, instead I first read it as despite his efforts time and outside forces caused the collapse and he was powerless to stop it in the end.


More Creators