MARCH MADNESS 2023 - Day 30
🕑 Added 2023-03-30 16:00:07 +0000 UTCJelly has been avenged…OCEAN’S MOVES ON TO THE FINAL!
Today, we determine who Danny Ocean and crew will face for the win.
It’s Keanu Rotoscope Face vs. Ghostface.
It’s PHILIP K. DICK vs. SCREAM.

With PHILIP K. DICK, we’d narrow the field and cover 6 films:
- Blade Runner (1982)
- Paycheck (2003)
- A Scanner Darkly (2006)
- Next (2003)
- The Adjustment Bureau (2011)
- Blade Runner 2049 (2017)
We would not be covering MINORITY REPORT and TOTAL RECALL (1987) because we’ve already covered those on the main feed, and we’d be skipping the TOTAL RECALL remake and some other stinkers because, per David - “ugh, those might kill us”
With SCREAM, we’d cover the 6 franchise installments:
- Scream (1996)
- Scream 2 (1997)
- Scream 3 (2000)
- Scream 4 (2011)
- Scream (2022)
- Scream VI (2023)
So - are we going with science fiction? Or scary slashers?
Comments
chelsd
how did we let this happen
Tyler Duggan
This is wildly lame.
Sean Mackin
pretty silly
Sean Mackin
not like this
Ian Smart
Be serious…y’all let SCREAM lose?!?!
Olivia Haidar
Kids go wild for THE ADJUSTMENT BUREAU
RJ Burchatz
This is disappointing… Blade Runner x2 isn’t worth killer 6x Screams
Rudy A Martinez
all this pain just so Oceans can beat PKD later
Johannes Wiberg
No one. Everyone has the same taste as you. This must all be bots.
Seth Adams
Yawn. If it ain’t scream and it ain’t mortal kombat who cares
Chad Hotelling
I wanted Scream more, but either choice is a great one. I've weirdly wanted to watch The Adjustment Bureau for years, so this might be my chance. Though I'm sure Oceans is coming out on top
Patrick Orr
this bracket is absolutely bonkers, PHILIP K DICK???? hilarious end result here, convinced it’s all a set up just to get Ocean’s to win extremely easily
Jozef Raczka
I don't want to risk finding out A Scanner Darkly isn't as good as I remember it being, I was pretty mid on Blade Runner 2049 and would love to spend a few months intermittently trying to explain why Scream 2 is the best Scream. Long story short: Ghostface gets the vote.
Matthew Goderre
I would bet money that the majority of the people who have been voting for Scream voted for Hellraiser.
Carolina Avery
Scream good yall playin
Michael Kolodziej
Thank goodness. Scream SUUUUUUUCKS!
CT
For those bemoaning the lack of horror coverage, I point to the fact that y’all voted out Hellraiser in favor of effin Jelly. Hellraiser, which even with it’s huge slumps, is 1000x more interesting than Scream. And for some reason you went went Jelly.
Kai Beattie
Come on people, this is the only way we’re gonna get Wes covered!!!
Chris from Jacksonville
How silly does it get?
Tyler Dietz
For the Scream heads out there, now seems to be a good time to shoutout former Blank Check guests' podcast With Gourley And Rust (Matt Gourley & Paul Rust of the Escape From LA episode). They covered all the Scream movies a while back. It's not Blank Check, but it's got similar vibes and is in some ways just as good. I'm pretty sure I discovered it here in the Patreon comments or on Blankies Reddit. Thought I'd pay it forward.
Julian Gray
This is insane, Scream should be winning in a landslide
Zachary Marriott
This is BS
Nickelback McGruber
Well, guess I'll have to remove the Scream movies from my watch list and add in....The Adjustment Bureau 🫤
Anthony Fortelny
Why are y’all doing this to Scream?!
RJ Burchatz
…scream is 5/6 good to great films. Dick is 2 great and the rest are trash, come on folks.
Jonathon Pernisek
They're definitely never doing Craven.
PolterZeitgeist
C'mon, all those Screams have stuff to talk about!
Joel DeJong
There's never a GOOD time to say you don't really care for Blade Runner, but seeing it stop all over a series I rewatch every two years or so... I respect Blade Runner more than I actually like it. Same goes for the rest of the PKD movies. Scream 5-eva.
Harry Kolmer
Don't tell me it's okay. It's not okay. It's heartbreaking
Chris Dobson
I'm going to just keep voting for the thing that loses until morale improves around here.
Rudy A Martinez
Somewhere a Phillip K Dick fan has dressed up as Ghostface and started murdering Scream fans to secure the PKD win. RIGGED.
Eli Green
This truly is March madness
Cynthia
Voting against slapstick and Maggie Cheung and now voting against slashers and a slew of 90s hotties: who *are* we? Is this what we want to be? Vote for Parker Posey, vote for the fashion, vote for is Jamie Kennedy hot in scream debates, vote! for! scream!
kennedy
PKD opens up a new kind of franchise curation to the podcast and that’s why I’m ALL IN BABY!
J M D
P.K. Dick: I wanna rewatch some absolute bangers and also some total weirdos with the boys
Rory Dunn
I love Craven but I truly never see him being covered on main
Cody Johnson
Carpenter also won MM. From what I heard, they basically said they weren’t going to do Cronenberg unless he won a March Madness (that’s why I really wanted him to win). That would be 22 films which is even less than Craven. I just don’t see them dedicating half a year to a horror director with the kind of filmography that Craven has.
Kevin Love Hewitt
Watching them as he and others talk over them in search of constant content to not actually be quiet and watch the movies shouldn’t be his first time watching the movies.
Donald W Pratt
Scream currently over 1500 votes short of the numbers it had against Police Story.
Michael Rogerson
If you combined some early movies into a single episode (a la Demme) and skipped everything that wasn’t given a theatrical release, you could easily do it in less than 20 episodes! It would be no longer than the Carpenter series
Evelyn Chavanne
Voting Scream because these commentaries are for sure the only way they WILL cover Craven.
Cody Johnson
That’s probably never going to happen because his filmography is too big.
Michael Rogerson
His filmography is so varied and has a perfect mix of certified super classics like The Hills Have Eyes/Nightmare on Elm St, and underdiscussed gems like Red Eye/The People Under the Stairs. Even the Scream movies wouldn’t get old because he alternated them with a bunch of really interesting projects (including his weird attempt at making a prestige-y oscar movie with Meryl!)
Kaitlin
That's fair
Michael Rogerson
voting against scream bc they need to just do Wes Craven on the main feed - and if they do the commentaries, they’ll never cover him properly
Rob myler
They’ll absolutely do Dennis
William Evans
Choose Dick so they never do Scott and Villeneuve on the main feed
Jeff Burnett
Genuinely floored by these results. I thought Scream was gonna obligate Dick
Chris from Jacksonville
Scream was a great movie. Then they made 5 sequels that were pretty much the same thing over and over. Vote Dick!
Justin Bertolero
Y’all really messing this up? Choose scream!!!
Seth Lambert
We’re so close to a Scream miniseries. Please friends, don’t mess this up!
James Manning
Maybe? I guess we won’t find out. See ya Scream.
Kevin Rowley
Would have been happy with Scream or Elmore Leonard or Jelly. Would also be happy if Ocean's wins. But I truly can't wait to hear David geek out over Blade Runner.
Lundon Boyd
what a relief to not have to hear about any scream movies past the 1st one
George Wishart
This is bananas. SCREAM seems like the obvious choice. But even if it loses, my hunch is they eventually do the series anyways.
J S
I love scream but feel like PK Dick would give so much more variety
Danie Jensen
It bums me out how much horror always gets destroyed in these.
Evelyn Chavanne
Darn... The tangents that Screams would generate every movie would be great.
fartinscorcese
Does this include the 1999 Andrew Fleming picture?
fartinscorcese
Screaming for some Dick
Josh Landreth
Pls
Josh Landreth
Scream
HappyCroc
I'm riding Dick all the way to victory!
HappyCroc
No, but I watched it once and I do need someone to explain why.
HappyCroc
I would love a Ridley series, one of the most interesting careers with all kinds of genres and some all time great movies. I've been anti-Dick and anti-Leonard all month for these reasons. But I just don't want a Scream series at all.
Zach Altschuler
I'm not precious about either, and think Scream would make for a better commentary series, but let's be honest, whoever wins this is getting steamrolled by the Oceans juggernaut.
Selmon Rafey
All of this to say, one of these guys has a way better chance at being on the main feed in the near future than Craven ever does - lets give the slasher franchise that aims to lampoon and recreate slasher tropes a chance to shine in goofy commentary form!
Sloane
Keanuscope
Selmon Rafey
of all of these, I think Denis is particularly ripe for a series - one of the blank checkiest directors in the business right now (getting entrusted with 2, maybe 3 movies in the Dune franchise? that's a big ol check). One of the few Nolan-y filmmakers around who makes detailed, large scale films that also are critically if not commercially successful. Would be an easy choice IMO, especially after Dune Part 2 comes out. Also, if they do a Blade Runner 2049 episode, I could see them doing a Patreon ep on Blade Runner so that it isn't left hanging Now, Ridley has a deep filmography, but also is one of the most blank check directors ever and could easily be done Spielberg style, pre and post win for Gladiator which reignites the blank check he got for making Alien as his second movie (followed by Blade Runner cementing his influence). Linklater would be a fascinating series: the Before Trilogy and especially Boyhood make for fascinating check cashing exercises (yeah, we're gonna trust you to cash a little check over the course of 12 years and hope this works out well? insane!)
Mike Ostrov
Y'all, they'll do Scream eventually. It's ok.
Nic B
WHAt
CT13
Huh, well PKD better beat Oceans.
Chuck Nipper
Get 👏 that 👏 D
Filip Boratyn
We’re not getting these episodes on the main feed in anyone’s lifetime
expeditioner
All right you guys convinced me to chance my vote
Steve Geiler
I'm so mad right now. I thought Scream would take this whole thing 🥺
Tobey
So bummed about losing Police Story, but I was really worried Scream was going to take this whole thing so I will accept my Ocean’s v Dick finale and be glad.
Rory Dunn
I don't think people understand that it's truly impossible to make Next interesting. You're voting for the worst commentary they could do (and not their fault! It's just that boring!)
Daniel McLane
So are your Mom's christmas cookies.
Jason Feffer
Following a slasher movie is a bit different from Star Trek
Jason Feffer
Everything you’re saying here is 100% correct. People here really aren’t thinking this through.
Selmon Rafey
Don't gimme wrong, Blade Runners rule and are all-timer movies, but I don't think they would make for great commentary episodes the way the Scream movies would! Vote for the discussion to be had, not just your favorite film! SCREAM!
Selmon Rafey
voting Scream if only because I don't want this pod's first conversations about Blade Runner, Blade Runner 2049, and Scanner Darkly to be in the freewheeling commentary format - those would be such good deep dive conversations during potential main feed episodes! Scream would probably only be covered in commentary form as i don't see them taking on a Wes Craven series, and it has had such an interesting up and down history over 20 years (whereas besides their original authorship, the "Dick series" has very little discussion between the pieces). Vote Scream!
Gerry Canavan
Oh, thank you! We have a few unreleased episodes but the energy went out of it when Aaron selfishly had twins... at least for a bit!
Colin
Scream franchise is overrated
Bob Lemmon
And discussion of then-hot/now-obscure actors careers
Austin McDougle
be honest with yourselves y’all only wanna hear a couple of the Dick picks. at least with Scream there’s continuity
Austin McDougle
AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHH (scream)
Jett Wallace
I have a theory that people are mostly voting Dick knowing it has no chance against Oceans, which is a real bummer.
Matthew Chmiel
Let me guess, you’re not a college basketball fan.
Sean Maloney
Hi Gerry, Grad School Vonnegut/Achebe is very special to me and was a deep comfort during quarantine. Thank you for making it. I will be listening if you and Aaron ever podcast again someday. Takes the sting out of my beloved Scream seemingly going down (so it goes) to see you stump for PKD.
Dan H.
I was really hoping scream would pull ahead.
DF
Hell yeah, next year should be March Politeness
Ryan Jenkins
I can't tell you how uninterested I am in the Philip K Dick stuff. But I'm also a believer in democracy.
Ally
Ghostface nation it's time to mobilize
Jon Tiberious
Finally it looks like scream is done
Filip Boratyn
Dick is all I want at this point. People are saying how cool it would be to see Griffin discover the Scream movies, but I actually find the commentaries to which he comes with opinions much more enjoyable. Or commentaries about nonsense movies that are just an excuse for a hangout. Don't count on anyone following the plot of a first watch too closely, or not missing important plot points because of lunch orders (not a complaint!). Dick gives us a cool new Patreon series format and a nice mix of great, weird and dogshit
Michael Hollenbeck
Noooooo Scream is so much better!
Lance
OK, you win - I changed my vote! Get a thousand more to switch and we'll be good to go. It'd help me ignore Blade Runner for another few decades.
Eleanor Mohrmann
BOOOO (both as in i am upset about how this vote is going and as in boo ghosts are scary like ghostface and i would like them to discuss him!)
Bill Sweet
The missing android head of PKD must be avenged
Noah Mittman
With Dick, you get Nic Cage in Next, it's no contest
Gerry Canavan
PKD! PKD!
Mikey
Thank god. Scream winning it all would be zzzzzzzzzz
JFox
It’s March Madness. Could you imagine fans being like “whoever wins, it’s fine.”? This was set up to have people root for their picks. Calm down and get in the spirit.
Jackson Clark
You love to see it! The real question is how do I decide between Dick and Ocean..
Jesse Isaak
Guys we can’t make griffin wait another year to watch Scream
Colleen Gaw
Nooooo I was praying for a scream sweep
JFox
Whaaaaat??? How is this even happening?
Kaitlin
Does anyone really need to watch The Adjustment Bureau again?
DF
This was a lot more fun 2 hours ago
Alexander Parker
DICK DICK DICK DICK
PG
Both of those could be interesting episodes even if I don't like the movies. With Scream I'd rather they just do Wes Craven on main feed.
Rudy A Martinez
why did they hype us..
Jason Feffer
Friendly reminder to anyone saying Scream would be best to wait till Halloween… Last year Roger Moore started in August and went through November. A Patreon series is only 2 movies per month, so 6 movies stretches 3 movies, right through the Fall.
Jake Hyslop
Who said they’re a populist film podcast only?
Art Curtis
They're skipping some fun dick (screamers, imposter). Vote Scream! The commentaries for the twists will be so fucking fun. They've not really done twisty mysteries OR slashers before. Scream baby!
Jason Feffer
This series would likely start in July or August, which means it would likely go through Halloween regardless. Roger Moore started in August and went through November.
Chris Lynch
Yeah. This would be the first time I would be watching the movies along side if scream wins. I am excited for griffin to Watch them For the first time. Plus the screams are all different! And what casts. And Ghostface exists in the Viewaskew Universe! 🤯
Rory Dunn
And you'd be wrong
Manish Agarwal
Dick in the (Ghost)face!
Eli Green
I'm pretty sure this is what an actual vote for scream would entail, they'd schedule it around Halloween
Rory Dunn
I love him but I doubt they've ever even considered him
Jason Feffer
It’s almost like the fanbase for a populist film podcast is refusing to have populist films covered this year. It’s becoming exhausting.
Chris Lynch
Come on G Face. Tear that Dick up! It’s such a weak series how did it get this far? Next would be fun. But paycheck and adjustment bureau? We want Deputy Dewdrop!
Eric Hill
Probably smarter to wait until after the Scream reboot trilogy directed by David Gordon Green gets wrapped up in 2037
Rory Dunn
It's just never going to happen
Rory Dunn
I'm sorry, what?
Jason Feffer
This is correct.
longhornsteve
DICK! DICK! DICK!
disk-kun, the mascot for the famicom disk system
Bummer Screamers isn't on the list but it's dick all the way for me babey
Alethia St. Joan
Ugh how grimly predictable.
Isaac Adams
I'll be happy with either winner but I want Dick.
Spam Boi
Of course the blankies were never gonna go all the way with Scream. What a let down :(
Jamie
As someone who was obsessed with PKD in high school and college, truly blindsided by these results and his dominance. But I am always meh on the franchises-that-arent-really-franchises.
Bradley Dame
Griffin and David and the crew have been putting out excellent podcast work out for nearly a decade now. Whatever wins will result in a good time because it's those folks making it. This fanbase can be such a bunch of brats sometimes
Luis Moro
SCREAM! SCREAM! SCREAM! *receptionist*: SCREAM! SCREAM!
Bradley Dame
Yes
Lance
This was a tough one. Love Scream, but 6 in a row vs a nice variety with Dick made me vote Dick. Count me as a vote for Scream as a special run around Halloween though! 6 in a row feels right then!
Philip M Bernstein
Please, the word is "Screaquels"
Max
It's annoying that PKD keeps winning. Are people really so excited to hear them talk about blade runner, a movie nobody has ever discussed at length, that they're sabotaging series that could actually be fun?
Creighton Budris
Goddamn this fanbase's taste is inscrutable
Jonah Kaufman
The Bad Dick films are definitely worse than the worst Scream films
JT Sitko
Paycheck is the perfect commentary. I am surprised the MST3000K reboot never covered it.
Michael Kalange
Compromise: Do dick and also cover Screamers.
Ted Bogart
Vote changed. I like PKD better, but I'd rather have silly commentaries on Scream.
Sam Greer
No, I’m hyped for both Blade Runners, A Scanner Darkly and Next! (I voted Scream, but feels weird to trivialize a potential series with such strange and interesting movies.)
Kat White
Don’t you guys wanna hear Griffin react live to seeing the scream sequels for the first time!! Screamsweep!!!
Bud Cutino
Oceans V PKD is a more compelling match for some reason.
Johannes Wiberg
Thanks man!
Ryan Noonan
Similar to yesterday’s matchup where the more fun commentary series is probably the one that requires watching a bunch of bad movies—but with the opposite result!
Thomas adams
They can always do Scream imo. PKD winning the whole thing would set a really fun precedent about be types of franchises they can explore.
Joe Douglas
Just think of the Lillard talk people!
Samuel Kay
Ghostface: I can't believe I'm losing to this guy
Harry Kolmer
Don't fuck this up guys. Scream needs to win.
Luna Linstrot
Maybe because I just listened to the Black Men Can’t Jump episode on Scream VI…. I would love a full dive on the Scream series. Especially little tidbits about casting and filming.
Benjamin Simko
Ridley Scott is never going to make main feed (I don't even have time to count how many films he's directed.... 30?), so this is a good chance to talk BR. Hope Villenueve makes the main sometime, though.
James Manning
I’m not opposed to good horror mini series. I just don’t think Scream qualifies as good.
Brian Hines
This is bullshit. Scream would be so much more fun
Ben Burbank
apparently everybody wants The D (even though the scream movies are more fun here)
RJ Burchatz
SCREAM OR BUST
Eli Green
Every scream movie is fun and the commentaries would be fun. Are people actually hyped for a paycheck commentary
Tom
gimme that Dick!
David Rosenblatt
You hit me w the phone (philip k) dick!
H Alex Younger
Please, for the love of god, I do not want Scream
Frog Dimples (Jesse)
Broooooooooo, I completely forgot this extremely relevant piece of context. Thanks for the reminder. I feel that should be in BOLD at the bottom of every voting post. 🤣
Daniel A. Barron
Whoah, Dick is the surprise favorite!
Rhett
Damn I thought Scream would clean up here. Paycheck is a fascinating movie that doesn’t exist and I’d love to hear it discussed but shit Scream is one of the most consistent, fun franchises of all time. Gimme Ghostface and Neve Campbell!
Jeremy Culver
Gonna have to face it you're aDICKted to love
Johannes Wiberg
For main feed style episodes, DICK would be my PICK. But these are commentaries. SCREAM would be a DREAM.
Cal O'Boyle
DICK HIVE
George Dunne
I'm going Scream but A Scanner Darkly (what a difference an A makes) was just a big movie for me in highschool. I'd be very happy with Dick if it ends up winning.
Deren Ney
Most of those Phillip k dick movies blow
Michael Harrison
I'm not averse to horror at all. Just love me some Dick.
Nick A
I’m gettin a little Woozy!!
Dean Carrano
I see what you did there
Alan French
Scream means Wes mini-series. We might not get this otherwise.
Kyle V
Yeah that’s making me feel better about these results
Matthew Farthing
Oh, thank G-d. I was really worried for a second.
Begemott
Jokes aside, I really want an excuse to watch A Scanner Darkly again.
Zak Goldberger
Gotta go DICK
John Millsap
I'm happy either way, but the boys so rarely talk horror I would love to see Scream go all the way
Zak Goldberger
I would really love for them to do a horror mini on patreon. I just want them to do a discrete franchise like Philip K Dick more.
Rhett A Mitter
C'mon - Scream would be a fantastic series
Scott Southard
GIMME THAT DICK
Jack Loar
Vote SCREAM
Adam
If you listen hard enough you can hear Alex Ross Perry is still talking from the Halloween episode
Sophie Raseman
This one is a Sophie's choice amirite
Matt Vaughan
"Yes, I like scary movies, why do you ask?"
Matthew Chmiel
I still don’t understand this podcast’s fanbase’s aversion to horror. It’s mind blowing we somehow got a Carpenter mini, but anytime something (legitimately) horror related makes it up the ranks in a Patreon March Madness; this group makes it loud and proud to smoosh it like a bug. Horror films are a large piece of film history and as we’ve seen with the Scream franchise, are a great place to play around with blending of genres, providing social commentary on film, satire, and subverting expectations. Horror fans are the real ones.
Holden Martinson
Oh, I see. That's a Dick joke.
Nate Shu
If Scream doesn't win, I feel like they'll just do them this year anyways around October as their horror series.
Jonah Kaufman
Don't let people convince you that voting against Scream is a vote for covering Craven on the main feed, he has 20 movies with many forgettable ones. They are not gonna cover him on the main feed
Jack LaMotte
SCREAM!!
Zach
I wanted scream to win but Park is doing so well on the main feed that I’ll let this slide…
Evan
Here's my argument for Dick, A Scanner Darkly fucks hard
Rudy A Martinez
Scream needs to win people. Griffin needs to watch them!
Sofia Car
DICKERINAS RISE
Christopher Roundhill
Voting Scream, because the only reason I've voted for Dick in the past is the idea of getting episodes on BR and BR2049. But all the stuff in the middle (besides A Scanner Darkly) is of no interest to me. Scream has a lot more potential for interesting commentary imo.
Seymour Butz
Someone has to stand up to Scream
Holden Martinson
Scream is a better hang. Plus, it would be cool for them to touch on slashers for once.
Jordan Coleman
Now this is freaking hard
James Manning
Dick in the lead! This is a welcome surprise.
TV's Kevin Lanigan
Vote Dick!
Eric
I scream, you scream, we all scream for DICK
City Fox
If Scream loses we riot! I must hear David discuss his love for Scream 3.
Clay Ammentorp
Remember that a vote against Scream commentaries is a vote *for* Scream, Nightmare on Elm Street, New Nightmare, Swamp Thing, Red Eye, and all-time Blank Check movie Music of the Heart on main feed (in 2029). Vote Dick!
Wade Hollomon
VOTE SCREAM PLEASE
Zack Kendall
There’s a movement that I don’t like.
Steve Geiler
VOTE SCREAM GOD DAMNIT!
miles bolyard
I SCREAM YOU SCREAM WE ALL SCREAM FOR TEAM SCREAM
Étienne Fillion-Sauvé
YES DICK
Steve Geiler
Solid point. But that's also my reasoning for not voting dick. I want that Denis Villeneuve series 😬
Kevin Grow
Get it Dick!
Joel Cunningham
This outcome is making me feel better about the current results of Bong vs Wong
Jonah Kaufman
Oh no, how is Dick in an early lead?!? I thought Scream would crush this, as it should
Anthony Regina
I doubt they ever do it. Vote Scream here.
Todd Kremer
I need scream to win more than I need oxygen to breathe.
Dersquerin
Dickheads overwhelmingly demanding Radio Free Albemuth be added to the list. Many people are saying this!
Joel DeJong
I literally had a dream last night about the gang covering the Scream series. Time to make it a reality...
Anthony Regina
It’s time to scream
Josh B
Don’t you cowards dare let Scream win this one. Not over Dick.
Missi Information
I'm screamin' for Dick, you're screamin' for Dick, we're all screamin' for Dick!!
Skimbleshanks The Railway Cat
I WANT DICK
Mike Finnerty
We have to get Craven covered on main feed, gang! He's too good to go behind the paywall!
ChewyWalrus
😱😱😱😱😱😱