BC MARCH MADNESS 2025 - Day 5
🕑 Added 2025-03-05 19:00:18 +0000 UTCI looove being able to write these posts in advance. I love a comfortable lead. Unfortunately, y'all are TESTING ME today.
In our first nailbiter of the tournament, FINAL DESTINATION wins by only 15 votes! They'll face Scream in the next round.

Today's matchup is probably the closest we're ever going to get to the David Sims Video Game Podcast, considering that he has two jobs and three children.
It's RESIDENT EVIL vs MORTAL KOMBAT.
With Resident Evil, we'd cover the six Milla Jovovich / Paul WS Anderson films:
Resident Evil (2002)
Resident Evil: Apocalypse (2004)
Resident Evil: Extinction (2007)
Resident Evil: Afterlife (2010)
Resident Evil: Retribution (2012)
Resident Evil: The Final Chapter (2017)
With Mortal Kombat, we'd cover the four live action movies:
Mortal Kombat (1995)
Mortal Kombat Annihilation (1997)
Mortal Kombat (2021)
Mortal Kombat 2 (October 2025)
No matter who you vote for, Paul W.S. Anderson wins.
Comments
Good
Idiots
Matthew Benson
Boo this
Abe Something
Jam the vote!
Anthony Regina
Disappointing results
Jay Kay
We’re getting MK either way and the RE movies are if nothing else bonkers
Gibboanxious
two franchises I don't care for
John
What are we doing here? Really? Resident Evil?
Ray Goldberg
tbh broke my heart when Griffin said Raccoon City is a travesty. Like, of course it is, but in such an entertaining way.
Beef Steak Tomato
They just Mortal Promised it would happen regardless, because MK is a fun lightweight series. Watching all the RE’s is an actually challenging undertaking that they would NOT opt to do unless forced. I say force them. It’ll be a lot like Apes, in terms of schlocky sci-fi overambition with great individual performances and extremely apparent budgets that pulls an Apocalypse weirdly early in its run and has to keep going.
Njord
Jay and/or Mike and/or Rich guesting on an episode would be fantastic.
jscro
Oh, Resident Evil, easy. Just for the continuity.
Joe P
Reflex thought when I saw this poll: “Mortal Kombat is obviously better.” Immediately followed by: “Wait, no it isn’t! These both suck!” Truly hope neither of these make it to the final.
Joe P
Correct
Conor Dabler
The check is blank but it’s in Hungarian Forint
Beardmask
Resident Evil, though they're both great series. I just want to hear Griffin's Red Queen impression "You're all going to POD down here."
Conor Dabler
Easy vote for Resident evil but they DO get a bit samey don’t they
Zak Marrinan
Time to get borderline experimental
Jean-Paul
The other JP wants MK because he plays sub zero for ez wins
Jean-Paul
RE because I want to hear them talk about Wesker. I need to hear from the Wesk Desk
Joseph Allen
The ridiculous MK song is awfully terrible but somehow better than any forgettable RE title and is tie breaker for two near equally unsatisfying franchises.
Robert
Resident Evil would get boring fast, guys.
Cosmic Cowboy
Resident evil all the way
Mr Sir
Sorry Ben, I have to go with my heart(RE)
D
Isnt Sims a huge RE/PA fan? Would love to hear these
Spencer Pommier
They should just cover Paul
mikey GOLDSMITH
But if RE wins how will I know if Ben likes subzero?
Owen Phillips
Resident Evil is winning because everybody forgets how boring every single one of them is
Isaac Adams
Would that we could just add the first MK to the RE films and avoid all the other MKs.
Mark Jackson-Brown
I adore the first Mortal Kombat movie, and the second would be wonderful to hear them go insane watching.... But I cannot deny that the RE series is just So Much More.
Regis L
Me too, man, me too.
Regis L
I abstain. It's literally impossible to choose. These series are the exact same level of shlock.
Nick Benson
How is RE winning? Those first two MK movies are insane
Jeremy Dankowitz
Finish him
Erin
I need the Raul Julia commentary so there is only one choice
Wyatt Gray
Mortal Kombat (1995) holds a special place in my heart, but I'm voting Resident Evil because I enjoyed the first two and have been meaning to watch the rest.
Masturov Desguys
I’ve been on the wrong side of every single one of these so far. This is definitely one of those “Everyone else is the problem” situations.
slatron
needs a "both" option
Harrison Cordle
Been loving the Mortal Kombat animated features coming out, I love been needing them to revisit the live action
Harrison Cordle
Leaving out Raccoon City ain’t right, it’s got some great moments and authenticity
Felix Durand
Paul WS Anderson series down the toilet smh. Let's go Mortal Kombat!!
Dubious Legacy
Resident Evil rules (especially 5!) and I'd love to hear David defend the series, but I refuse to burn down the possibility of a Paul WS Anderson main feed series, which it would absolutely do. So Mortal Kombat it is.
fischurr
Oof I did not expect RE to be ahead. Hoping MK can pull off a Fatality late in the voting
Devin Bruns
Resident Evil all the way, although I will say how sad I am to not see Welcome to Raccoon City on the lineup. I know it's separate from the main ones, but it has a special place in my heart for how bad-good it is, and stays pretty close to the lore, kinda.
Chris Lynch
Voting for Mortal Kombat just for the Orbital song, and future Karl Urban
Manish Agarwal
Don’t really mind between these two: isn’t Ben a Mortal Kombat guy?
Nick Ingalls
Annihilation is top tier in my canon of films that forced my tween self to ask "Wait, is it possible for movies to be bad?"
David McElroy
John Derek energy
Brook Shelley
Resident Evil the only franchise that is clearly a long-running kink thing between husband director and wife actress
Jim Mccaffery
I mean no one can deny that Paul W. S. Anderson is an auteur, it’s just a monkey’s paw wish type thing.
Matt Vaughan
Folks, that's simply too much Resident Evil.
Adam Modlin
Guys, we need to get them to cover Mortal Kombat so they have to deal with the trash fire that is Annihilation
danny groover
William Peter Blatty miniseries so we can still get Exorcist III
Kyle Martinak
Mortal Kombat is an easy pick here. How much out-of-pocket insanity are we going to have when we're five commentaries deep into Resident Evil? Griffin is just going to start playing RE: Code Veronica on a second TV during the movie.
Benji Black
First RE movie is a legit solid claustrophobic horror movie, after that it goes off the rails in a really fun way.
CT13
The first MK alone wins this
Tom Jorgensen
In any case, Event Horizon bonus ep plz.
Doug F
What if there was a kombat that was mortal
Good
Mortal Kombat!!!!!!!!
Bill Woods
i mourn for exorcist 3 because i believe in slime
jahr
MK, only cause neither isn't an option for votes
David Rosenblatt
I don't see either of these going all the way
Papscott McGee
If Mike Epps was in any Mortal Kombat movie it might've had a chance
Devin DiMattia
Absolutely HATE the Resident Evil movies so I gotta go with Kombat on this one.
Olivia Haidar
Mortal Kombat is a lock for next year after MK2 is on VOD, let Resident Evil shine this year!
Abe Something
Seeing Resident Evil in the theater, as a non-gamer, because it was raining one day in 2002 is one of my cherished memories. I loved every bit of that dumb trash.
Kibblesmith
I keep eating shit in these but today is my day “you’re all going to die down here” let’s see that guy get cubed
Daniel A. Barron
I watched all six based on David’s embracing of them and I still have PTSD from it. They’re the worst!
John Holder
MOOOOOOOOORTAL KOOOOOOMMMMBBAAAATTT
Krista
Where’s everyone going? Bingo?
Robert O'Neill
Toasty!
Jordan Coleman
Resident evil movies are beyond fun
Anthony Pierre Coco
Voted Resident Evil, because I need David to explain why he thinks they're so amazing
Dersquerin
Mortal Kombat is so much more watchable
Aoife
Finish him (the resident evil series)
Darby Dixon III
Very mindful, very March
Spencer Pommier
I picked mortal Kombat because I don't want to watch movies I haven't seen
Robert F
You’re all going to die down here (in the comments)
Frog Dimples (Jesse)
Moooooooortal Kombaaaaaaaat!!!
Del Lorenson
Raccoon City is beautiful this time of year
Michael Cuculich
There is no better opening to a movie ever than the opening seconds of Mortal Kombat.
costcohotdog
Mortal Kombat for the Ben commentary!
JS
Resident Evil has so many big, wet, dudes and chains. And the 3rd one takes place in the desert! DRY! Totally a Ben series
Miles Lemaire
I think the RE series would overstay its welcome by the third entry.
Rory Dunn
WHAT A BATTLE. WHAT A MADNESS
TV's Kevin Lanigan
It is time for lots of discussion of “Alice.” This is what the people crave.
Richard Rush
I'd love Mortal Kombat but RE2 remains one of my all-time favorites. No competition.
Michael Curley
Stunning result. Also… Test your might, MORTAL KOMBAT!!!!!
Tanner Randall
Resident Evil is my long shot pick to win. A couple of those movies are pretty good and ALL of them are stupid fun. Would be a great time for everyone
Holden Martinson
Resident Evil for the good of the country. Also, Final Destination would rule so hard.