Patrefans
GregsAirplanesandAutomobiles from patreon
GregsAirplanesandAutomobiles patreon

New Video Is Up

🕑 Added 2022-01-14 18:17:50 +0000 UTC

Comments

Chris Van Decar

Two thoughts, 1. Given the miserable/borderline criminally negligent performance of USN torpedoes, even if the Devastators? could survive and launch it would be doubtful the torpedo would detonate when striking an IJN ship. 2. Doesn’t the curvature of the Earth keep low flying aircraft with radar from detecting anything beyond 20nm? Great video, I could watch these all day, but work insists I show up if I want a paycheck😭😎

Ogiwan

Shattered Sword really is a fantastic book.

Greg I really enjoyed the video. I thought I should note that if you haven't read Shattered Sword by Parshall and Tully you should consider it. They make a fairly compelling case that the real significance of the initial torpedo bomber attacks was that they forced the Japanese carriers to maneuver hindering flight operations and preventing them from spotting their planes. Basically the CAP could have regained sufficient altitude after the second squadron was shot down given the impressive climb rate of the Zero. But the Japanese CAP had lost situational awareness and when the final attack came it was from too many different directions and they overcommitted on Thach's flight.

Richard Budd

Thanks for this. My dad was the radar/radio operator in an Avenger flying from the Shangri-La and he rarely talked about it.


More Creators