Patrefans
Hannibal Forge from patreon
Hannibal Forge patreon

DEFUNCT - DRAFT DISCARDED

🕑 Added 2025-12-31 03:37:50 +0000 UTC

Comments

Hannibal Forge

I appreciate this feedback, and a sincere thanks for your service! My intent was to convey that Leonidas is emotionally immature about intimacy, and that his trauma directly correlates to an aversion to it, which is what he perceives female nudity as: intimacy. This is a mix of his upbringing, fear of closeness, and his experience (or rather completely lack thereof) with romantic entanglement. Your point about infantilizing him ties into what Draconic said below, so I think that's a good building block. I'll review this chapter shortly when I hop out of bed, but thank you for this blunt assessment.

BlodWedd

Edited Chapter Review (Constructive Criticism) I’m trying to give honest, constructive feedback here. Overall, I didn’t enjoy this chapter. It felt overly preachy, with long monologues and emotions that came across as exaggerated. The events themselves are fine—and may even be necessary for the story—but the way they’re presented makes both Aylar and Leonidas feel emotionally immature, almost childlike, despite the fact that they’re adults. Some of the dialogue also felt unnatural. For example, a line like “infuriating and alluring” doesn’t sound like something a woman would realistically say to a man she’s attracted to—it reads as overwrought rather than authentic. I understand that Leonidas was raised in a particular way, but it stretches credibility that a modern American—and a former soldier—would be so oblivious or overwhelmed by simple nudity. Speaking personally as someone who served, I know the kind of mental resilience and emotional calluses soldiers develop. Physical exposure alone shouldn’t rattle him this much. Emotional vulnerability? Absolutely. But not basic nudity. That’s especially noticeable because in the first book, Leonidas comes across as mature, experienced, and grounded. This chapter undermines that established characterization and weakens the credibility of your main character, which is concerning. Concrete Suggestions Redirect Leonidas’s initial anger When Aylar first gets upset, Leonidas could clarify that he isn’t angry at her for being there, but at Ceruvial—for intentionally hiding her and engineering the situation. That preserves tension without infantilizing him. Cut the monologues aggressively Many of the internal and external monologues could be reduced by at least half. Focus on distilling them to their most essential emotional or narrative beats. Lean into emotional trauma, not physical discomfort Leonidas’s lack of intimate relationships, combined with the loss of his comrades and allies, is more than enough trauma to explain emotional hesitation and difficulty with closeness. You don’t need to make him unusually shy about nudity or put him in a position where two women are effectively scolding him like a child. In short, the chapter would benefit from trusting the character’s established maturity and shifting the conflict toward emotional vulnerability rather than exaggerated awkwardness.

Hannibal Forge

He is very stunted about intimacy, and he equates nudity to intimacy.

DraconicReconcile

I'm not so sure if these are flaws of the story so much as purposeful flaws of Leonida's character but Il just comment anyways. Also, it's been a while since the first book so i dont exactly remember how old Leonidas is mentally compared to his body's biological age. With all that said - Ace sounds.. frankly immature? Which, if that's what you were going to go for, then you nailed it. But the reason I bring this up is because Ace has been in a war for as long as his first life before bringing him back to his original world. He should've seen blood, dead bodies, etc, basically trauma from the world the system brought him to that he should basically be somewhat desensitized to nudity. I get that with Ace and Ceruviel's relationship as teacher that it would make the sight of her make him feel uncomfortable, but pushing his emotional maturity back to school boy levels.. feels.. forced? With Aylar, I get more so, but not completely. I don't remember how old she is, but for all she's boasting about her age.. I feel like she could have articulated her feelings better in a more.. understandable way that should give Ace just much of a jolt that it can give him compared to the words she gave him just now. For all the trauma that Ace has gone through, he seems remarkably mentally stunted in sexual contexts basically? That's what I'm observing and again, I'm not sure if this is a character flaw or a writing flaw, I'm just observing.


More Creators