Patrefans
Mecanimus  from patreon
Mecanimus patreon

A Journey of Black and Red 210: The Great One

🕑 Added 2022-10-11 20:47:17 +0000 UTC

Comments

Ekko

Well, that all is true and the point about the officers is one I'm also often quite annoyed by. I love the history lesson, but this is alternate history with MANY differences to our world's timeline. This world has mages, vampires, communist France and many more things that change the course of history as we now it. Mecanimus has also mentioned in his posts that, by the American Civil War the timelines started to diverge from our own. So you can realistically say that Germany was losing, if the author wants it to be that way.

Mitch

So a couple problems with this chapter. The first is small, but as someone who has studied the first world War, the perpetuation of a myth can not be stood. The insinuation that officers hid behind the lines while their men did the dieing. In every combative army the officer class suffered a higher proportion of casualties then the enlisted men. It got so bad in Britain that they had to institute new regulations that forbade there officers from marching IN FRONT of there men on attacks. They were losing them faster then they could be replaced. The entire French cadet class of 1915 died or was wounder durring the war. The second issue, and this one is a major ot hole, is that by the end of 1916 Germany and the Central Powers were winning. France was gutted with many of its Divisions one bad battle away from open mutiny. Russia was 2 months away from revolution and their soldiers refusing to follow orders. The British Empire had done its best on the Somme and suffered horribly for it. The USA was still a year from joining the war. No from the german perspective surrendering at the end of 1916 would be simular to America surrendering to Japan in 1944. Why would you give up when you were winning?

Add_Identity

"Europe's suicide" is actually so accurate to describe WW1, so much was lost, there was no victory. Great chapter


More Creators