johnnyharris patreon

POLL: Which thumbnail would you click?

🕑 Added 2022-11-21 17:00:09 +0000 UTC

Comments

Justin Howard

The arrows and circles makes me wonder what's in that mountain. 🤔

Justin Howard

Francois Emond

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1DFI7JP3z2u495dKDlk0qOQmAYcBMDIFu/view?usp=drivesdk

Francois Emond

1 and 3 but I lean more towards 3. Feel like 3 with a “magnifying glass” zooming in on the arrow’s location would emphasize the scale of the mountain but then the thumbnail might become to crowded

Rishi Gens

I like how you can see the whole mountain in the 3rd one but in the first one the very grey mountain against the red circles and jacket draws my attention more to the actual bunkers and keeps me looking for longer

Ezra Hollis

2. Really love the concept of 2 but needs to be a little more refined. Center Johnny, make him slightly biggeradd a glow arround him (preferably hand panted so it seems like hes actually in front of a glowing beam, also add a shadow of johnny next to him but fade out as gets closer to the light. Make the text Switzerland smaller and hidden bunkers bigger (thats the focus), add the red paint stripe behind the logo. As a graphic designer, thats what i would do. i defiantly like it better than the other 2.

David Mora

1. Works cuz: (a) bright colors (b) extreme facial expression (c) simplest, most intriguing text 2. works cuz: has more of a clear story & mystery to it

Jay Swanson Too

Love that first one

Julian Brustad

Option 1 has the strengest “scoll-stopper” effect with the highest contrast and the eye contact. Well done 👍👌🤙

Peter Sturdee

I'm not a big fan of any of these. I do like "Switzerland's hidden bunkers" as text over just "hidden bunkers". One arrow is less busy than three, and more evocative than none. But the pictures of Johnny are all unflattering and make him look confused rather than curious.

Vijayeshwar Battula

I like 3 better, although 1 is really good too

David Mora

Agreed!

Robert Pettengill

I like both 1 and 3, slightly favoring 1 because more arrows implies a more interesting story.

Theo Da Kaffei

The light on your head in number 3 also made no sense to me. Yes, bunkers, dark. But my first thought was "Why does he need a light when to mountain is so bright and open?"

Theo Da Kaffei

Generally number 1, but the arrows make no sense and are confusing. In number 3 it makes at least sense for there to be a bunker where the arrow is pointing. But in number 1 this looks like random spots on the wall right next to you. I like the colors, your facial expression and the swiss flag, though. Number 2 manages to both look silly and hide one of the main elements, the bunker entrance, behind the glaring light beam.

Georgie Day

The mountain on Option 3 is the Aiguille du Midi. It is located in Chamonix, France, and not Switzerland. I suggest you change that mountain shot as it's not factually accurate.

Kimberley Duclos

I like that you seem to be exploring the bunker in Option 3.

Komal Sanjeev

2,3 look somewhat unrealistic. 1 has a realistic background and facial expression

Shadow Shinigami

Personally not a fan of red arrows, a combo of the picture from the second option and the layout of the third one would be my choice

Tiffany Baker

Cmonnn, you're gonna tell me he DOESN'T look like Spiderman in option 2?

Ara Kevonian

This is the winning answer!

Pablo Ordorica Wiener

Agree

Ara Kevonian

Not just that, but the arrows pointing at the caves instantly pique my curiosity.

Christopher Pickett

Option 1 - white text and it’s red/orange background matches the Switzerland’s Flag, and the orange shirt is a good contrast to the dark mountains

Luis Gomes

Same here

Blake Henry

I think the face from number 3 looks best but i like the background on number one better.

Vishwanath Puttagunta

I'd go with option 1. The colors match perfectly with the text, the coat and the flag. The other 2 are quite good as well, but the first for me conveys the information required to the viewer to click on it