Patrefans
simonshen from patreon
simonshen patreon

【國際關係BB班】左 Vs 右(一)

🕑 Added 2020-09-21 02:01:59 +0000 UTC

Comments

Napoléon

反而比較少聽咁樣區分,尤其係國際關係嗰部分 多數都係用意識形態或者對社會議題嘅取態

pedestriant

想知好耐了,之前search 過幾次google 睇完都唔清晰。。,

LHC

左右永遠都係相對 同沈博的解釋,共產黨係中國就係右,係世界就係左

Fevrier

//中國無論怎樣強調「和平崛起」,只要「崛起」是 at the expense of others' falling,就是「左」。/// wah!!

Arnold Chan

用教授嘅睇法,我地簡單叫反對派/在野/The Opposite 就清晰不過囉。所以小弟認為左派係要有一啲socialism 成份,右派係有conservatism 同free economy concept成份。當然,正如你一開頭講,左右定義係唔同政體有唔同。至於港共政權係左定右?答案係以上皆不是,是古代奴才concept 也。

Somonica Sa

希望教授再出多尐依尐文講清楚。。。 近年巧多香港網友同絕大部份 KOL,玖唔答捌咩都叫 『左膠』,明明米帝浸爺粉絲最唔喜歡人帶口罩,無嗱嗱又變成 『左膠』喎。。。♡

Elaine Yip

左右的定義實在存有太不清晰的相對性。問題是左傾即有不斷革新的政策思維和推行, 但實際上那些革新政策是不是適合當時社會人民的需要或配合與國際建立良好關係。同時有沒有提昇人的素質, 學養, 肩負責任的精神, 使人與人之間拉近距離, 生活比較幸福快樂 等等改進 ...

Jon T

Indeed, the concept of political left vs right often gets lost in translation. I think for a number of geopolitical issues in say in HK or America, left vs right argument is becoming too reductionist, too simplistic and too partisan, especially in the days of social media. It would have been better if issues liked NSL (authoritarianism vs democracy) or BLM (institutional racism and injustice) are explicitly defined, so people would know exactly where they stand.

Anthony.K

但社會政策上 香港絕大部分都係立場偏左 除左自由黨

wai leung

一篇好文,應該要立入通識科必讀

Zomato

終於等到教授講呢個topic!

Chet Chan

希望沈先生有機會分折解說BLM movement 及 Antifa.

Daedalus Chan

左、右乃是政治光譜的其中兩個方向。就算起左友的討論上也有分極左、極右、溫和左、右等。就算係一個立場傾左的人,都唔一定係 agree 哂極左派的所有論述。

Laska

多謝你,我混淆左好耐,因為係咁話共產黨係左仔,仲以為中國邏輯再次與世界不同。依家終於搞清楚,舒服哂

Leo Ng

字面上解,右派是 right,對的那邊。左派是 left,剩下的那邊。 原則上,所有執政黨都應該說自己是right,而反對派的是left。 中共硬說自己是 left,而說反共的是right (對的),十分諷刺。

Anson Wong

But in US, Democrats are considered left and republicans are considered right, even when the sitting president is from the democrats. I thought it had something to do with idealogy?

Meow

So misleading and bewildering

Ellie Ellie

呢啲BB班啱哂我😅 啲人成日話要避免將政見二元對立,但左/右翼咪其中一類囉?

Ellie Ellie

正解!

Eric Au

左到盡頭便是右🤣

Wis

Thank you professor Shen. This is much needed especially for HKers would has the heart to engage but is often lost in the FB world

TH

Thanks ! I do find it very confusing 😂


More Creators