Patrefans
simonshen from patreon
simonshen patreon

【突發時空🇺🇸】美國總統大選第一場辯論十點簡評

🕑 Added 2020-09-30 03:28:00 +0000 UTC

Comments

Jim Jimmy

細心去Fact check Trump 講嘅每一件事, 會發現會9 成都係吹水講大話, 呢個大話精可以企到係今日呢個位度, 真係值得後世反思. 部分大話節錄: 1. 話自已推出行政命令, 保障病人買醫療保唔會因為Pre-existing condition 唔受保. 實情: 行政命令無法律效力, 得個up 字. 相反, 佢去推翻obamacare 先會令pre-exisiting condition 失去保障 2. 話自己夠膽同藥廠對坑, 令藥物大跌價, insulin 平過水. 實情: 特惠價錢嘅insulin 只式用於小部分買左昂貴私保嘅病人. 有某啲平價insulin 係藥廠因為肺炎嘅特別優惠, 唔關Trump 事. 3. 話自己同大藥廠傾過, 距離肺炎疫苗只係"weeks away", 仲批評其他話疫苗要等到下年嘅人嘅講法係出於政治動機. 實情: 呢個真係攪笑, 佢以為自己拍心口人哋就變到疫苗出嚟? 全世界都講緊疫苗研製成功最快都要年尾, 計埋批發要年中, 更快都唔會係"weeks away" 4. 吹噓自己力排眾議下首先就肺炎對中國封關, 仲話Biden 當時批評佢Xenophobic 仇外. 實情: 美國喺WHO 宣報肺炎係Pandemic 之後幾日封關 (2月2日), 同世界好多其他國家同步, 唔係首先, 而且決定係相關官員都一致贊成的, 唔係力排眾議. 睇返Biden 講Xenophobic 嘅前文後理, 係叫佢唔好借肺炎上綱上線散播仇外情緒, 唔係指封關.

Athena Tsui

Trump 一直唔了解 Biden 同極左派嘅關係,以為迫 Biden 講唔支持 Universal Health Care, Green New Deal, Defund the Police 就可以令 Biden 輸左派票。結果每次要 Biden 講,Biden 都好自豪咁講佢唔支持,甚至連 I defeated the socialist (Sanders) 同 I am the Democratic Party now 都講得好暢順。 Trump 因為自己要買極右派怕,所以唔了解點解 Biden 唔駛買極左派怕。原因係極左派對 Biden 完全冇期望,而且 Biden 從來冇用過言語去氹左派,所以 Biden 講乜都係左派預左嘅事實。相反因為極右派對 Trump 有期望,所以 Trump 講錯一個字都唔得。 共和黨喺 Twitter 話 Biden 唔支持 Green New Deal,以為可以離間極左派,點知 AOC 回應了一句 This isn't news 就講完了。

Athena Tsui

個 debate,最重要係影響左以下幾種人: 1) 家長見到一個唔傳統嘅總統,成個 bully 咁 唔比人講野 要自己講哂,好驚佢哋嘅仔女受錯教育 好多小學生,係要睇完辯論後,交讀書報告的,有啲學生睇到喊, 攪到啲阿媽又喊埋一份,走去搵人求助 Michelle Obama 今日要出嚟公開講野,同啲阿媽們做心理輔導 2) 曾經被 男上司 或 男朋友 唔比佢哋講野嘅女性,全部身同感受 3) 被大城市精英 睇唔起嘅鄉市人,睇見有人封左自由派個咀,唔准自由派發聲,極為振奮 根本辯論裡面嘅 points,係冇人聽到的,完全係一個情緒化嘅經歷 至於對大選嘅影響,(3) 係本來一定投 Trump 的,(1) 係本來 投共和黨 但考慮緊唔想投 Trump 的 ... net gain vs net loss 好明顯 註:所有民主黨軍師,都係叫 Biden 無論 Trump 做乜野,都唔好倍佢玩,一定要 stay out of the mud ... 所以 Biden 嘅指標,就係要唔好發脾氣

Johnny

要睇下Trump 得罪幾多人🤔

Fevrier

我20年前嘅畢業論文就係關於電視辯論對選情有無影響,結果係:無。 就算係遊離票,最後都係因為上次投票傾向所影響。

Eric lin

兩個年過七十歲。香港人自覺Trump 會對大陸打壓良好。Trump 不過是商人,將來出己反己。對香港人會大打擊。政治人物無道德標準。教授有一點沒提過,當大選點票結果出問題,會否廷後當選。美國人會否可以等數月?

wai leung

如果第一場就已經分到勝負,未免又睇得太簡單,話晒今次選舉唔只影響美國,係整個全世界,尤其中共,肯定晨早睇實聽翻譯啦

Gary Lee

Trump 擅長泥漿摔角啊! 佢將辯論搞得越混亂,人們就會對討論越厭惡。佢地真正忌諱O既事情就唔會深入探討。呢個道理,我港好多議員都明。

salt water

其實選總統門檻不高,只要證明自己不是癡呆,已可勝出。

salt water

如果用周星馳嘅電影橋段嚟形容頭先嘅辯論,就用破壞之王嘅斷水流大師兄對外賣仔,點數氣勢當然係大師兄特朗普大勝,但外賣仔拜登戰術成功,打唔死外賣仔,所有觀眾係預期打死佢㗎嘛,所以,結論係就電影觀眾嗰句,大師兄食屎啦。

LindaFK

Just an observation, Biden kept staring at the camera to engage the audience as he spoke. On the contrary, Trump hardly looked into the camera.

salt water

拜登優於預期,所以反差特朗普差於預期。本來期望拜登語塞,邏輯混亂,特朗普會完全ko佢。結果特朗普霸道得來又引證唔到拜登癡呆,特朗普成功引了很多中間選民出來

KY

But CNN survey result shown people feel Biden do better.

Jon T

Thank you Simon for your summary. Nevertheless, after reading the analysis from CNN (couldn’t watch the debate at work), it is sad to know that when we are going through one of the worst global crisis in recent years, we still see grown adults argued like school yard children. It means little to me whether such debating style suited Trump or not, if I were a voter I would be keen to know how the administration would get out of the mess, and neither candidate seemed to present a concrete direction. “Don't get down in the mud with the pig, because you both get dirty and the pig likes it.”

Xavier Chang

謝謝教授分析!

Charles Kong

Nice debate Trump vs Wallace 👍👍

Mayla

多謝教授 太肉緊反而唔敢你直播

May Kwan

https://www.washingtonpost.com/elections/2020/09/29/presidential-debate-live-updates/

MK Lo

感謝教授

Wis

So couple things. biden's camp prepared him poorly, extra care should have been paid to have Biden stay on his own message as trump looking maximally disrupt was a given. 2, in the same vein, hunter Biden was a given, he had a slam dunk in Republican found no wrongdoing. All in all I don't think the debate changed any minds which in my books means bad performance for both but since Biden is ahead, the onus was on Trump to perform. (I'm going to conveniently skip all the other cringes, mostly from Trump and a few from Biden)

Meow

Thank you for the summary and analysis 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

Jason Ho

Thx!!

ET Jasper

多謝教授神速分析!

Paul Lam

biden感覺容易俾侵逼到發火 特別後尾講到hunter個度 而且biden講既成日互相矛盾 好似教授講果個green new deal咁

dreamcometrue

感謝即時分析

simonishandsome

Biden “won” this debate by exceeding people’s expectation to him. But one has to note that, in 2016 Trump “lost” all three debates. The main reason is that Trump doesn’t need to appeal much to Republicans, while the US left wing is so fragmented that I do think Biden’s line of not supporting Green New Deal would matter

hei lok wong

教授可否再介紹一下特朗普為何難以與極右極端主義切割?

Cally Wong

謝謝教授的詳細分析!

Neil Chu

特朗普贏氣勢輸風度. 拜登的表現比我想像中的好. 事前我擔心佢會突然斷片. 今場辯論 冇話邊個好過對方好多

hei lok wong

看得出教授真的是第一時間就把分析發上來了,少有地有些錯字和排版問題,不過無礙閱讀!很精彩!

Charles Lo

精準評論👍🏻

Corina

Thank you 🙏


More Creators