Patrefans
simonshen from patreon
simonshen patreon

【IR冷知識🇺🇸】純技術探討:假如大規模郵寄選票出現在香港

🕑 Added 2020-11-06 02:58:29 +0000 UTC

Comments

Christie Leung

Which era do you live in? Postal vote is very common, I had an American colleague who voted for Hilary Clinton back in 2008 when she worked in Republic of Ireland. I myself always use postal vote. Postal vote (and in the future digital vote) has been going on for years, why questioning it now? Because you don't like the results (which to be honest isn't that great for Democrats anyway). Claiming you fight for democracy but turn against the system when the results do not suit you? Democracy is not just a ballot paper, it relies on active participation of educated public. The US has just shown us how miserably it can fail.

Joey

真的沒有留意到郵遞投郵其實真的很有問題!尤其是在保密及防止種票方面!!! 香港的話⋯諗起都恐怖!老人院、中資公司⋯⋯

kate

Thru all this, I found that I'm very tolerant of the sometimes slow and cumbersome process because I do trust the system. As cliche as it sounds, democracy is messy because you don't just blindly let one person dictate everything. Checks and balances are messy. But people's trust in the system makes them patient and tolerant of this messiness.

kate

To give a local data point: I'm an overseas Clark County, Nevada voter. 1) Any US citizen from anywhere in the world can vote thru mail ballot. Therefore the early proposal from HK govt to give special voting avenue for HKers living in Greater Bay Area makes no sense. Either all or no overseas. 2) Some states like Nevada already accept email ballot. But definitely not a perfect process: a) Nevada supposedly sent a mail ballot this year to everyone. I never received one even though I checked my overseas address many times. b) It took me filling in 3 online forms/ emails to finally get a response from someone about getting my ballot. c) The process is very manual - I actually emailed back and forth with someone at the local county 2-3 times before I finally received my electronic ballot. I still need to fill it in, print it out, sign it manually, scan it, and email it back! d) Privacy - because I chose email, I had to sign away my rights to anonymous vote.

Yu Yu

投比反TRUMP

12345

我覺得一旦郵寄選票過多時,會出現原則性同系統性問題,但各州都沒有處理,到當日也處理不好。 你們既解釋就像08年雷曼倒閉前,每一個人都話CDS沒有問題。問題重點是你們沒有考慮過大過多的情況下,可能發生的事。

遲下可能政府又會話內地地大物博,而且大部分選民係老人家行動唔方便,方便佢地整個郵遞投票出來,你懂的。不過就算無郵遞投票,可能選舉日搞個城市一日遊,車曬d選民去城市食完後投票,之後大家識做。

Chan Wai Bun

拜登面目及施政主張都模糊,美國選民可能不是投票給他,是投票給民主黨!

miuying yu

若如 張崑陽 帖子以「行政效率」所致而合理化了,相信將不會有任何修正和改善。 不明白為何不去堵塞,不能確保選票的合法性,選舉又有什麼意思? 明白特朗普為何反對 郵寄投票, 此舉是保障所有候選人。

katrina

如果俾人由大陸郵寄投票,仲多左個好處- 唔會俾內地人見到香港人有選舉

Eric lin

特朗普在末選前已經話defund postal service。 經國會委員會討論,郵政局保正可以處理所有選票。之於特朗普提七點後郵寄選票作廢。但每年四月十五郵寄交稅,亦以郵戳日期為準。所以不合邏輯

12345

特朗普話佢多次講過郵寄有問題,可以拿出來分析一下呢?

Wis

Prof Shen, thank you for your always excellent writing, I do feel your kindness and your own intellectual humbleness and nuance may not serve some subsets of your readers well. It is indeed true that since voting is handled by states, there has been issues for as long as people can remember. But as it relates to absentee/mail in ballots, there is just no empirical evidence to support any type of the "theories" that's out there in the US. in fact as you know, Oregon is entirely vote by mail and has been for some time. I think your point is especially important in how politically aware the general population is, the shenanigans that can and have happened in HK is not translatable to US as far as we have evidence for thus far. Since even other opinion journalists rely on your analysis, this is something that may dismay a lot of your readers but would be critically important in the conversation. Just my thoughts.

Tak Wong

(新)香港

CCT Lai

以後中xx不需要再統籌配票,二三佰萬郵寄票可輕易全取立法會七十度。雷廷動原黃𢇁作用也不大。

44yen

最尾的亮點


More Creators