Patrefans
simonshen from patreon
simonshen patreon

【咫尺地球🇺🇸】特朗普的外交革命:百年後回望,或成改變時代巨人

🕑 Added 2020-11-09 14:00:03 +0000 UTC

Comments

Pickles

沈教授,你講了很多特朗普如何有貢獻,但最重要他對民主社會的一個破壞,似乎完全沒有被提及。 請看這四年來,他如何將三權分立的制度推向三權合作。司法部本應政治中立,但在他的死忠支持者 William Barr 手中,已經淪為公器私用。最高法院各個法官,當然可以有其不同意識形態,但在特朗普眼中,因為由他委派,變成認為是可以反轉多數人選舉結果地方。更莫論兩院共和黨議員,懼於其強大攻擊力,為求仕途安穏,皆不得不奉誠俯首聽命,選後表現,更表露無遺。 如此向三權合作,行政一尊天下邁進,正正吻合他口中推許中俄的終身制,亦符合他商人CEO一言堂的價值觀。 他對民主政制制衡的徹底破壞,讓人不禁感嘆,究竟我們支持抗爭,為了打倒一隻怪獸,自己卻盲目製造及吹捧了另一隻怪獸,這是否背離初心?

Jon T

Same, if there is an English version that would be great so I can analyze more. Joe Biden has always maintained that he will be a transitional president, but he will be building up the platform for younger generations to assume the leadership. Hence, it will be interesting to know the candidates in 2024 and thereafter. Obviously with China, the pandemic, and other geopolitical issues remain volatile in the next few years, these future leaders may combine a mixture of Biden and Trump’s style of presidency. Perhaps Simon can analyze the credentials of politicians on both sides, liked Hawley, Rubio, Harris, Buttigieg, O’Bourke and even Stacey Abram?

kate

I've always found the following a difficult topic to take sides: 偽君子vs 真小人. Reason is I believe we humans, given the chance, we more likely than not will do things that benefit ourselves even if it means breaking the rules or harming others. So does trying to suppress that tendency, thru teaching, frequent reminders mean we are being 偽君子?Or is it just we believe if we try hard enough to suppress our bad instincts we can eventually become the kind of person we'd like to be?

kate

Yes he did in a way became the emblem of American freedom, individualism but he also represents the worst example of some of the core values that underpin the success of freedom, individualism etc such as decency, integrity, honestly in ones character. I agree completely that many other US politicians are also not gd examples of these values. However, for the many middle class parents who are trying their best to bring up their children on the importance of good character, Trump's frequent reminder these last 4 years of the opposite has been unbearable. That's something I observed from most of my US friends with young children.

Marcus Mo

希望教授可以出返篇英文版

Chun Lee

其實Trump 競選時大講本土主義 但係出黎成績反而係外交最亮麗 都算係諷刺

yuenf

對應歐洲及印太有類似遠交近攻的哲學

Good Year

Trump 離來但Trump主意長存

salt water

2120年再算吧。到時美國社會會點,是否還復存在尚未可知?到時的福禍是否歸侵也無法估計。

Gary Lee

看見現行社會深層問題,而提出顛覆性解決方案,特朗普唔係第一家。我亦真心對能夠行出第一步表示敬佩。但如果要歷史回望是否偉人,我都仲係覺得,關鍵係能唔能夠帶領人類文明進步。無可否認,或者百幾年前唔係有馬克思嘅出現,人類社會今日未必會深切了解社會資源二次分配嘅重要性。但馬克思係唔係歷史偉人,就真係見仁見智。

Zero

雖然教授經常強調要睇結構,但如果將時間點回到2016 Trump 當選,用Obama留低的結構去睇Trump 在任做到咩野,好難預計得到佢今天的成就;咁樣講「睇結構」的思考方式會否忽略一些改變結構的Game Changer呢?

Frances

強如邱吉爾都會連任失敗嘅

Joyz

教授會否考慮publish英文譯本等我哋可以share 俾外國朋友睇?外國主流媒體很難見到這種論述,希望可以分享出去。

Marco

Marco Rubio點睇

Margaret Chan

歐洲國家的疲弱令歐洲國家要過份依賴中國...聽說他們都面臨破產邊緣...沈教授,有機會以後可以分析一下前因後過,和將來國大局的影響嗎 ?

Wendy Lam

即使連任不成功,侵侵已在歷史留名,佢為好多美國人跨出咗一大步(可惜而家又窒住咗)。另外,不要忘記,佢對華手段其實都驚醒咗好多國家,不能不提防中共! He is my MY BEST!!

Eric lin

https://news.yahoo.com/trump-lost-so-what-happens-to-the-gop-174205340.html

Gary

這篇文章應該封存一份 hardcopy 入時間囊,幾十年後再跟「正確」的歷史作比對……

Chor Gor

今日唔鍾意特朗普嘅,日後會多謝佢

AN05

Uncle Joe’s foreign policy will be closely watched and frequently compared with Trump’s administration. It could make or break Dems’ chance in 2022 and 2024.

Elaine Yip

非常欣賞這篇文章的見解, 我是絕對同意這作者的分析。

simonishandsome

Many has been paying attention to the elections. Analysis from all over the world, from their own perspective spreads. In the sinosphere is there unproportionally high coverage on the “chaotic nature” of Americans. This is not only inaccurate but shows the negligence to the culture of the United States, where chaotic is by nature and designated. We, the Humans as a species, evolves in thousands of years forgoing our own independence. We were individuals in a small group living in the wild. Then they form and expands, from villages to societies. Those who lived individually went outgunned and eventually extinct, the remaining gave up individualism for collectivism, independence for dependence. In the western world this peaks with the British Empire, from where every human act as a part of a greater machine, which forms a greater system. In the eastern world it was shown in day one, by the chinese word of "Country" - A state in which families are in. The United States of America is, however, a rebellious nation, maybe the first one which succeeded. Before that, utility and development simply sided with a collective society, thanks to the unintended selection process with those who are adventurous, open-minded and individualistic, for the first time, an individualistic nation which emphasise on collaboration worked. In the States, one could see the idea of maximised personal liberty, minimized intervention towards personal decisions. Pandemic response, chaotic in protests, gun rights are not coincidence with who is in place, or what organisation affiliated to, they’re instead attached to the founding principles from where the States is for. Now Biden and the left wing are initiating the first steps of aligning the country back to the Europeans’ system, which their ancestors spent their life fighting against. We are not in place, and won’t have enough evidence to judge which system is better or more sustainable, but at least we get to acknowledge, they did attempt to try to create a more in individualistic, free and libertarian world. Trump is not the best candidate, but sarcastically he became one of the most prominent defender of these values.

Tsz Wan Ho

特朗普只是把美國當一家公司來營運,算是前無古人,其實蠻 inspiring. 非常切合拜登昨日的演講提到 - everything is possible in America 😅


More Creators