Patrefans
simonshen from patreon
simonshen patreon

【列國誌🇲🇲🇿🇦】和平獎之後:昂山素姬 Vs 曼德拉

🕑 Added 2021-02-19 10:19:41 +0000 UTC

Comments

LHC

對在生的人封上「女神」稱號都是言之尚早 尤其是政治人物 昂山當政後繼續得到高民望,但在外國眼中似乎跟獲釋前的印象不一樣 究竟緬甸人民需要昂山繼續做「民主女神」還是想要一個現實的當權者? 如果昂山只是當緬甸人想要的當權者,在其他國家的眼中或者不太重要?

LHC

Can we say it is a problem? Like if HKer moved to UK/Taiwan/Australia, their 2nd generation recognized themselves as HKer. We would be happy to see the heritage of HK can pass on.

avger

Ssu Kyi is therefore right in not showing favour to either side.

avger

In the long run the Rohingya probably lose out, because they are outnumbered (not necessarily because they are more merciful).

avger

A Rohingya armed group brandishing guns and swords is responsible for at least one, and potentially a second, massacre of up to 99 Hindu women, men, and children as well as additional unlawful killings and abductions of Hindu villagers in August 2017, Amnesty International revealed today after carrying out a detailed investigation inside Myanmar’s Rakhine State. Based on dozens of interviews conducted there and across the border in Bangladesh, as well as photographic evidence analyzed by forensic pathologists, the organization revealed how Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) fighters sowed fear among Hindus and other ethnic communities with these brutal attacks. “Our latest investigation on the ground sheds much-needed light on the largely under-reported human rights abuses by ARSA during northern Rakhine State’s unspeakably dark recent history,” said Tirana Hassan, Crisis Response Director at Amnesty International.

avger

Atrocities go both ways. The below is one well known report of Rohingyas committing atrocities.

Elaine Yip

昂山素姬沒有為羅興亞人滅絕發聲, 等同幫凶, 責任難逃的, 不佩民主女神稱號。至於仍有一定的民望, 只是比起軍方的貪腐獨裁和手段來說, 親昂山領導傷害較輕吧

Thomas Tong

Suu Kyi is definitely a controversial political figure. True. Mandela seems to be more respected for his contributions of racial equality in South Africa. However, Simon rightly pointed out her constraints in Burma. Netizens are arguing over whether she is held responsible for the Rohingya genocide. Well, of course, she must be one of them giving green light but the paradox is ..... did she have the choice? Of course, we may argue that she should fight for those people lives at all costs. She is to blame for sure BUT it may be unfair to her as well if we do not take her real situation into account. Accusing a person of not doing enough is very easy. Maybe, it is about time for us to understand that reality is always more complicated and tough than we thought. I am not here to defend this lady but the truth is she could only see her husband five times after her house arrest. I genuinely believe that she could leave Burma if she wanted but she knew that she could not get back again. If you were her, would you do that? Well, nobody knows if suu kyi has been corrupted or polluted by political power. What I know is we should judge a person from a broader and multifaceted perspective. Sometimes, judging the book by its cover is very unfair and shallow........

Ls Kwan

我猜他指的是若開邦的羅興亞人被殺和燒村的事,然後昂山在聽證會上否認有屠殺一事吧。

Ls Kwan

同意。軍方就是要把民主滅於萌芽。跟中國一樣。

Tom

This is probably not unique to countries in Asia. In England, there is a sizible Irish popular, who still identify themselves as Irish after generations. Whom until recently faces institutions discrimination, and might still do. For the uninitiated foreigner, regardless of the perspective, it is an easy "mistake" to call a Welsh, Scottish or Irish person "English". That is by far the easiest way to "annoy" them. This seem more like a global problem of understanding, or the lack of, of any historical issue involved more than one type of person.

Ls Kwan

我會這樣說,是因為看了這篇文章。正因為昂山是弱勢的,她只有民望,卻沒有太多實權。如果在羅興亞人的事情上發聲了,只會令國內的人更針對他們,特別是該國的激進佛教組織。外國的制裁,尚且不能有效制止國防軍的政變,更何況小小的羅興亞人? 當然,這絕不代表她不是權力擁抱者。我只是不想現在就下結論, https://theinitium.com/article/20170915-international-MyanmarRohingya/invite_token/dehzYrpkmE

avger

明顯,軍方和昂山在緬甸政府中是勢不兩立的; 雙方的分歧最近大爆發暴露出來了。你說的屠殺是誰幹的呢?

Vincent Cheuk Yin Lam

行大緬族主義唔會令昂山受譴責,但屠殺會,昂山民望咁高,有需要行到無差別屠殺,讚揚強姦婦女嘅行為嗎?根本就係權力擁抱者

Vincent Cheuk Yin Lam

甚麼支持者看法都是偽命題,昂山民望咁高,如果曾經真心為民主做嘢,就算冇可能民族平等,都冇理由擁抱屠殺行為。 根本昂山只係權力擁抱者

avger

西藏漢族人口迅速增長,從解放時期的數百人,到如今已超過8% (保守估計)。 但什麼是西藏,什麼是西藏人和西藏文化,不但達賴喇嘛(格魯派)有看法,其他寧瑪派薩迦派等領袖也有相同的看法;就如緬甸軍方和昂山素姬對什麼是緬甸什麼是緬甸人一樣。

avger

(除了ROHINGYA)

avger

緬甸軍方和昂山素姬對“什麼是緬甸”, 緬甸的歷史和各民族等的看法等等, 應該是較一致的,而且更準確地反映普遍緬甸境內的人的想法。

Ls Kwan

有趣的比較。昂山素姬面對軍方和商界各種錯綜複雜的利益關係,國內不同種族強力的民武團,又要面對中國巨人的金錢基建利誘和侵略,實在太不容易了。 要是昂山只是一個站在道德高地說話的人,一心追求理想中的民主,而毫不理會緬甸真實的經濟情況和宗教衝突,我猜她只會更快地被失望的民眾拉下來,或者是被國防軍當作緬甸追求民主的吉祥物。只有經濟發展了,憲法完善了,昂山才有bargaining power去全面對抗國防軍。 外媒認為昂山她不能在短短數年內令緬甸重生,就是墮落,這也太嚴苛了吧。

avger

It is better that we try to understand Asian problems from a perspective which also includes Asian historical understanding.

avger

There are numerous Koreans born and raised in Japan. There always was a racial problem on this issue. Both the Japanese and the Koreans remember from their history that Koreans are not Japanese. Only in a Western context would Japan-born Koreans be called "Japanese". In Western civilisation this is seen as a big problem, particularly in years past, because Japan-born Koreans were perceived to be disadvantaged, economically, socially and politically.

avger

Ssu Kyi is much misunderstood and maligned on the racial issue. Myanmar, unlike the other three Indochinese theravadist (上座部/小乘)countries (Laos, Cambodia, Thailand) which are less heterogenous, Myanmar has always been much more multi-racial. When she came together it was. always as a Buddhist land. The Rohingya however are are Muslim Bengali migrants from recent [British] times : at no time were they part of Myanmar's age-old history. The Army's view of the Rohingya, as well as Ssu Kyi's view of the Rohingya, properly reflects the view of the people of Myanmar. Only if one subscribes to contemporary Western interpretations of Nationality could it be argued that the Rohingya are part of Myanmar.


More Creators