AutoSaveFamily
patreon
*NEW POLL!* (ends in 48 hours)
🕑 Added 2024-01-21 01:10:00 +0000 UTCThanks to feedback we will be filtering polls more specifically going forward, especially regarding when the show was released. For this poll, we are only including shows that were recommended by you guys that have started airing in the year 2023.
Thanks so much for your feedback and we will continue to hear you guys out so that our polls can be more balanced! ^^
Comments
Nut Kon
not sure if they're doing it but please dont react to episode 1-3 of apothechary without letting them have a discussion after each episode.. it was painful to watch for frieren, they had so much to say between each episode of 1-4 frieren!
Doodlegame
I doubt it would win anytime soon though. They still got quite a few top 5 of the year type shows to get through first. I'd put it somewhere in the top 15 of last year maybe. They are overdue for a romance though. Maybe Toradora?
TheMightyAnt
I understand the re:zero one because while watching the first season I hated him with a passion till he started to change himself.
Daniel Borrego
i finally watched the whole thing and its just ok. its got some wierd pacing though and some baffling story elements. i was not a fan of 'that part'. i thought it was needlessly brutal for literally no reason. i even read through the manga and its still unexplainable story wise. there are theories but honestly i think the author just put that in for shock value. think made in abyss aweful but with no follow through or punchline. its basically the OH NO, anyway meme as its completely handwaved just a scene later. even in the manga its basically never brought up again except for a line waaaay later.
Daniel Borrego
i almost dont want it to get a second season
Maryam186
I second this!
Peter
Can we get The Dangers in My Heart into the pool someday?
Tyler
86 is really good they should bring it back ether next poll or in a few.
Daniel Borrego
give Higurashi When They Cry a watch if you liked summertime rendering
JAMES D'ALESSANDRO
I will watch Heavily Delusion. Too many people seem to like it in this poll along with Apothecary Diaries. If I like it, then I will vote for it bext time.
Daniel Borrego
Shin Sekai Yori did it much better
Daniel Borrego
log horizon is WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY too slow for a reaction video. its a great show but its a show that needs to be binged.
Vladi
They could do polls for the most popular/good 2020, 2021, 2022 animes that they havent seen, separate from their 2024 polls or polls for older shows from like 2010-14 etc. But then again let them watch/finish what they have, having time for other stuff than anime/youtube its good👍
Vladi
officer this man ova here, give him a medal
zengei
Heavenly Delusion wasn't tied. It lost by 11%pt to Madoka. If you're talking about the YouTube poll, that's across a field of 5 candidates and the whole point is to whittle it down to then give patrons the final say (and that wasn't even the most recent YouTube poll). It doesn't make sense to just take whatever's next as it doesn't give people an opportunity to reallocate their vote based on their own preferences. Second among a field of three doesn't mean second most preferred overall, as this poll demonstrates. That's the entire basis of things like instant runoff and preferential voting. "And the people that voted for Madoka are most likely going to vote against Heavenly for this poll" just sounds paranoid. Rather than thinking people are making their selections to personally spite you, the alternative explanation could just be, shockingly, that they have different preferences to yours.
Pey2003
RIP Heavenly Delusion. Also, is 86 coming back to the poll? It keeps on getting paired up with other really good shows. I would be really sad if Heavenly Delusion and 86 were in a poll together. Would also like to ask for Summertime Rendering, Angel Beats, Log Horizon, and Assassination Classroom for the next poll for the mods reading, please. I think Ben and Anna will have a blast theorizing and discussing about those shows.
CH
Same, was super excited when I saw it winning the original YouTube poll 😕
Impulsife
I'm aware. I'm just not sure why it wasn't the logical choice to just instead choose to react to Heavenly Delusion from that poll since it had basically won as a newer show contender (madoka aside) in that poll against basically the same options as this poll
sleepysorceror
Don't worry they'll still react to older shows, this is just the poll specifically for the newer shows. They sorted off old and new shows into their own respective polls to reduce recency bias
L.C.
I think they do quite a good job of hearing people out and trying to do their best for their reactions so I don't ever complain. These just aren't on my list of what I wanted to see most from 2023.
L.C.
I am super happy with the current list of frieren, vinland, and re zero. All 3 of these anime are damn near perfection in my opinion. They were doing mushoku and are currently caught up with that and I love mushoku just as much as the other anime I just listed off. They also did made in abyss and that is peak anime as well. With all these top tier anime they have been doing I was a little worried about the fall off from these amazing anime reactions to ones that were just alright. Not that these anime are bad but I just don't care much for them as reactions. I feel like certain anime are better for reacting than others. This is all my opinion cause someone could think completely different from me. A lot of newer anime are great but its important to show love to some older anime as well.
DrWomanRespecter
Praying for March Comes in Like a Lion on the next older shows poll
DrWomanRespecter
Weird
Cubjitsu
Oh well, one day they’ll get to Heavenly Delusion. It’s a must watch for them imo
sleepysorceror
They separate shows by recency now when voting, so these 3 shows aired within the past year versus older shows, which is why there's another poll
Mambako
For me, Apothecary Diaries’ design of character is better, but I love the Heavenly Delusion’s world view and story development more. I hope we would get both of them, they both worth it.
sabeurre
Yes I'm really surprised with this one, I thought HD would win by a landslide based on last poll results
Impulsife
Wasn't Heavenly Delusion already tied in first place for the poll with Madoka Magica? I don't know why we're doing another one when we know Heavenly Delusion and Madoka were ahead by a landslide in that poll. And the people that voted for Madoka are most likely going to vote against Heavenly for this poll because there was some drama going on between the people who favored one more than the other between Heavenly and Madoka
Noctislolig
@Daniel Borrego Yep, it's a good adaptation. Sadly very underrated, probably because Netflix always releases every episode at once, which kills hype built up over time.
Flippnote
That’s embarrassing for you
Flippnote
Real
ElectricAnt
Didn’t spoonfeed the poor baby enough
Vladi
its good one, hope some day it wins i guess xD
Daniel Borrego
heavenly was kinda meh. i dropped it after a few episodes.
Daniel Borrego
holy crap, i've never watch pluto and just looked at the graphic, then realised this is a remake of teh 3 part astro boy episode with the robot hunting super robot pluto!?!! what the heck?!
Pat C
Wdym? I've only watched 3 episodes but it seems pretty interesting so far?
JAMES D'ALESSANDRO
Apothecary is so good. I haven't watched Heavily.
Nut Kon
voting for apothecary so that heavenly will not win. do not need to see anymore of that show :D
Noctislolig
@Vladi It was really close though. Pluto was 1% ahead of Hell's Paradise until almost the end.
Vladi
in youtube it lost to hell paradide for 3rd place, i dont think it ever had a chance to beat heavenly from what i saw. But yeah i vote for apothecary aswell
Noctislolig
Damn... Pluto really lost to Heavenly Delusion last minute 😭 I guess my vote is for Apothecary Diaries then.
Rigo Rojo
Really wanted heavenly 😔
Vladi
Same, someday..... A new season def would help push it into the polls and votes but press x to doubt...
pls_ultra
wanna see them react to 86 sooo bad
Ésser Filosòfic
They should react to both Heavenly and Apothecary. I love both, despite me picking Heavenly so that it gains more traction
nikum
Tbh, both Heavenly Delusion and Apothecary Diaries are amazing shows and you'd love both imo, would be nice to see them back to back tbh.
Tyler
So sad to miss out on heavenly delusion.
FrizFroz
Heavenly Delusion is about as degenerate as Attack on Titan..
Vladi
i would say it depends on people opinions, i have seen people drop re zero because the characters didnt make sense for them and subaru was irredeemable asshole/neet.... Me personally i wouldnt even mind if they were repulsive xD (which they are not prolly) Just a show after all...
Vladi
I have seen hells paradise and heavenly delusions, but not the 3rd one, i admit thats the reason i voted for it. I wouldnt mind watching it weekly-ish on here.
Russell Gambardella
This is the first poll in which I haven't seen any of the choices. I'm excited to watch whatever is chosen alongside AutoSave for the first time!
Mark
i agree, im only here for vinland and frieren, which by themselves are worth the sub, and its a high bar but there are many shows worth the sub but not these or any other on their channel. name a 24 episode season anime or just name your top 5 anime of all time. full metal is said to be thebest in history i disagree but at its time and how they managed to do it on 64 episodes its ok. DBZ naruto one piece bleach death note and a lot more. now the 12 episode a season anime even 24 its hard to develop a story as frieren and vinland did by ep 1, they aim for the new anime fans and forget we the old schools are the ones who are loyal and those anime will get you subs, but i would never pay for any of those 3 never
L.C.
Don't take it the wrong way. I am happy with the other series they are doing. I just am not very interested in these anime for their reactions. I can think of a few dozen anime off the top of my head that I would prefer for reactions even though these are decent anime on their own.
DrWomanRespecter
There is quite literally nothing degenerate about Heavenly Delusion
Aaron Griffin
I think I'm close to caught up. At least I understand most of the core of the whole thing but there's some threads that need tying up. Definitely a wild manga. I hope to see many more seasons of the anime
Tramp
What's degenerate about Heavenly Delusion?
Tramp
I'm caught up on the manga, it's gotta be one of the best mystery stories I've ever read. So many stories are predictable but Heavenly Delusion always keeps me guessing wrong.
Tramp
Man I love both Apothecary Diaries but Heavenly Delusion is just such a more intense story. I want to see them react to both.
raiguard
There were more choices when the poll was public on YouTube. These are the top three from that poll. This specific poll was all recent shows, I imagine the next one will be exclusively older ones.
L.C.
No what I mean by that is I wanted more choices because for reactions I would rather see other things. Not saying these anime are bad. I prefer others for reactions though.
Will
I hope what you mean by that is that they're too good to choose between, because this was a brutal poll in the best way.
Tempered Glasses
Apothecary > Degeneracy
L.C.
Man... what are these choices.... Come on....
Maryam186
Apothecary Diaries !!!! You guys will love MaoMao
ElectricAnt
Either one > some nasty whore
Daniel Borrego
Heaven. Hell. < MAOMAO!!!!!!!
Kozmo
damn another L for Heavenly Delusion. I kinda wish they had a mystery box show to analyze again.
Aaron Griffin
Both Heavenly Delusion and Apothecary Diaries are great. I will be happy with either winning, but I'm voting for HD because it needs a second season!
Austin D
Hello?
Austin D
Which show are you talking about
godUsoland
Heavenly Delusion definitely!!!
Zombiie
Heavenly delusion gang rise up
Ash
Maomao supremacy.
Bibi
omg I can picture them shipping Maomao and Jinshi (like all of us do 😂 )
Bibi
i am in love with the mc from apothecary diaries she is so cool and adorable 🥰
Joel Mason
lol what??? You clearly didn't understand the themes of the show if you think that
Jay Rez
Please put Code Geass on the next poll
ElectricAnt
apothecary is the most repulsive show I've ever seen and I made it through dress up darling
Daco
Heavenly Delusion all the way
ElectricAnt
Tengoku supremacy
Austin D
They would absolutely adore apothecary. Right up their alley compared to the other two. Tho heavenly could be good still for them.
MaiSan
Let's go Maomao!
Jacob
If hells paradise doesn’t win this time definitely watch it later one please
Cubjitsu
Hells Paradise is a good show, but Heavenly Delusion is a must 🔥
