Poll 2/2!! ^.^

Daniel

I appreciate it more each time I watch it

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Movie is a masterpiece and one of the highest rated films on MyAnimeList of all time.

Dooly

The movie was awful.

Daniel

Really looking forward to when they start Violet. Curious if they're going to do release order or chronological order with doing the OVA.

Stonewielder

Ana has already seen VE

Nut Kon

at this point just vote violet evergarden and be done with it, this is like the 2nd? 3rd time this has happened? XD

koax I.N

↓understandable^^; but maybe dicided in this time... Hmm!? It seems...actually a pretty close race(°▽°) ok, revote, and do from these 2/3.

Stonewielder

I like all 3 series but I'd rather see both of them react to something neither has seen at all, so I'm going with Bunny Girl Senpai.

Joseph Joestar

March Comes in like a Lion last makes me sad

Anonymous Name

This pretty much happens anytime they do a poll on Patreon, few people pick which show they want and then talk trash endlessly about the other shows they don't think should win. It's always toxic and there's pretty much nothing done about it, at least on Youtube there's seems to be *some* moderation.

Verne

It's not winning, but I still voted for march comes in like a lion. Love that series, it's beautiful and I think they would have a great time dissecting it. All choices are fun tbh

NJ

For Ben and Anna? It's gotta be Violet Evergarden. I think it fits their stuff. And I think it brings something fresh in the current lineup of reactions. Besides, it'll show them what top-tier animation production really is, in a studio where the employees are treated well. They might not get anime-of-the-year, but KyoAni is probably the best anime studio out there. They deserve the respect and the love, especially after what they went through. And Violet Evergarden is some of their best works.

dg_2drunk

@Quinn I like the character dynamics and banter. A lot of anime are very stiff when it comes to male female interactions and I like that BGS doesn't do that. It feels natural and casual and not like a cringe dating sim as is so often the case. That being said I am still voting Violet Evergarden because it's way better for reaction videos (Anna already having seen it is a plus for me because I am interested in her reaction rewatching the whole thing). See how easy that was?

Sam

Voted Rascal but happy to see Ben react to Violet. I'll skip the last movie though...

jiyeoun

March Comes in like a Lion! That show is great

Ethannex

It looks like Violet might win! I'm excited to see Ben's reaction to Violet Evergarden as well as Anna's reaction to the additional OVA/Movies

mohal

Here's hoping Land of the Lustrous will get a chance again... I know they'd love it so much. Unfortunate how underrated it is.

John Spartan

Meh, I still like Bunky girl more than Violet or MCiLaL. But again, solid choices all around

long ass username

They’d love that show, arguably even more so than Violet but March is so much less known. Fortunately enough both shows are amazing.

Dooly

Voting for March, though unfortunately it doesn’t look like it’s winning.

Matheus Baio

I didn't watch March Comes Like a Lion yet but I voted for it, Bunny Girl it's Monogatari but worse. Violet: "I mean it's alright..."

Flippnote

I just love it all man ☹️ it’s still a spectacle, and such a unique world even in S1

DrWomanRespecter

The things I love about LOTL happen past S1, so I'd say March is better as of right now

Rafael Nier

March Comes in like a Lion! That show is underrated! I love the other shows, but this one holds a special place in my heart

Just a Dude

I love Violet, but I feel like if Anna has already seen it then perhaps March would be better

Flippnote

RIP Land of the Lustrous. You’re better than all these 😔

Jake Thompson

Personally I really like the dialogue, similar to other shows there's just a very good flow in the characters conversations. They talk like people, not like you can see the script.

Cas

Violet sweep!! hope you do the 2 movies too if it wins.

Gabriel Cabral

Bunny girl is great to analyse but is a bad match to watch right now, since monogatari is so similar in many aspects. March comes in like a lion is so slow paced that even I slowly dropped without noticing, it really didn't get me. Violet Everganden is good but not that great in comparasion with so many other shows. So this was the hardest poll to choose a pick on without a doubt, regardless I personally choose Violet Everganden because it's more to the point and a better pick to watch right now imo

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

@Quinn A very long list of things. You can find thousands of pages of text from Bunny Girl Senpai fans explaining in detail all the stuff they find great about it.

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Violet Evergarden or we things beyond human comprehension

Quinn

where have you been on reddit that doesnt unanimously love bgs for no reason lmao

Chuckyd

Violet i peak, march is nice and rascal is very meh.

Kevin

Zipzip don't tell me what to do. Ever. Please.

Quinn

What's great about Bunny Girl Senpai?

Cat_Sidhe

Oh man Rascal would be SOOOO good for your discussions

Zipzip

Kevin i think you might wanna stop replying to every single post to shittalk a show clearly many people voted to be part of this poll. This is not the place. Please.

Meow_Lin

Throwing a vote for Bunny, didn't really find the other two shows that great, so I go with Bunny. What the heck happened in the comment section? D:

KotBegemot

dude, it's Bunny Girl-senpai not Promised Neverland S2. There aren't bad shows in the poll. I'm sure they'd enjoy BGS and find things to discuss. They watch BNHA and seems like enjoy it quite a bit based on their thumbnails. If I'm neutral and don't know much about the options I usually don't vote but some arguments in the comments may sway my bias. And nothing sways my bias as much as elitist snobs. And I think I'm gonna stay subjective, I'm not arrogant enough to think that I can be objective when it comes to judging entertainment.

dg_2drunk

What exactly is the point of talking shit about the show you're not picking in the comments? Do you guys think someone reads it and is like "wow, I'm gonna pick what THAT guy wants!"?

Vladi

People eating it so its still alive yeah. They went thru reincarnated: stuck in game, as a newborn, as a creature/object, with my grandma, in otome game villainess, revenge, and so on 💀. Everyone has atleast one to pick and enjoy somewhat, even if we dont like most of them. Im surprised how much shit anime is made every season, so much time and money wasted.... but it is what it is, they trynna get the bread on table i guess

Julliant

Anime fandoms I guess, even if I don't disagree it gets way too sweaty. However voting out of spite can be just as bad, you're willing to jeopardize a quality piece of work just because of some randoms on the internet. Just ignore them , don't sink to their level, stay objective.

KotBegemot

I don't vote for anything if I'm neutral and just don't care. But if some fanbase is annoying and pissing me off I'm no longer neutral. Not the case here, Sangatsu FTW!

Ecodude

hoooly this comment section kinda looks like reddit with people hating BGS lmao

Vasto

I was thinking the discussion was about Violet Evergarden, March comes like a lion is the best pick out there, but im not a huge fan on any in this poll. Im just not slice of life guy at all.

Kevin

Voting for something out of spite is just a touch pathetic but go off I guess

Arakis

@Kevin Well, yes, it is, I do it all the time, but I don't do reactions. I think it puts unnecessary pressure on reaction-ers that have already watched the show. And the audience will always doubt what's authentic and what's not. It's kind of a lose-lose situation. Have you noticed how 99.99% reactions start with "I know nothing about this, I'm going completely blind"? This is not random.

KotBegemot

I don't hate Bunny girl as some of peeps here (goddamn some people HATE it here!) but I just don't think it's anything special. It's okay, it's fine. Violet is definitely way better but given that Anna basically saw the whole thing already the value of reaction is getting lower. And of course I'm biased but March Comes in Like a Lion is just a tier or two above those two shows. So yeah, we'll see I guess. Some Monogatari fans here (even though I'm one of them) though are kinda annoying with their snobby elitism hateboner. If I was neutral and never seen those three shows and read some of those opinions I would've probably voted for Bunny Girl out of spite lol

Vasto

Mha and Fate for me is Mid as the definition goes but here we are. At the end its all about opinions and tastes yada yada you know the drill, kino for masses sell like Marvel and other stuff that i never enjoyed but a lot of people did. Tldr March comes like a Lion is definitely the best pick here objectively but im not a huge fan of any of those.

Quinn

Sales isn't a good measurement because the isekai industry is still running lol.

Daniel

I've heard recommendations from all over the place, usually in the context of "if you like Violet Evergarden" I've just never gotten around to it. Might just have to make the time. I'm a sucker for things that rip out my heartstrings

RRGI

It's just a less fun, less interesting, less entertaining version of Monogatari. It's past the point of just being redundant at that point.

Vladi

I agree is not that great but it still sold quite a bit, and got movies, so the author cooked what he could... many series dont even survive more than 1 volume

Julliant

Bunny Senpai is alright, not great not terrible, but I reckon the timing is just not right when you are already watching Monogatari and that will be taking a fair amount of time to get to the end. I'm afraid you'll be stretched too thin with too many shows as well.

OptyfusPrime

Both really are excellent choices, us character focused story lovers are eating good.

Kevin

March Comes In Like A Lion is also a fantastic story, please check it out if you haven't

Quinn

Pretentious derivative 16 yo edgelord bait with 0 self awareness lmao that anime is so painfully 2017

Kevin

It's such a big blob of nothing. Story is just Monogatari but worse, animation is mid, can't for the life of me remember a single piece of music

Quinn

Being mid is more insulting than garbage, because the author tried their hardest and their hardest wasn't worth a damn. Being boring and derivative is worst than a series being bad.

Daniel

Crossing my fingers hard for Violet. Seeing people experience just about the most earnest and touching character focused story is one of my favorite things, and Violet is such a good fit for these two.

Vasto

Monogatari is one of my all time favourites, and Bunny girl senpai isn't even close, on the other hand Violet Evergarden its not for everyone i got bored in couple episodes, i actually watched whole Bunny girl senpai its was okay nothing special, but you guys are overreacting about how bad it was. Im not defending this series, its definitely not that awful compared to the giant pile of shit anime out there, i would love to see series like Mushishi or Helsing but here we are.

Kevin

People just want to watch the same story told 1000x worse, I fear

Quinn

calling march comes in like a lion boring when bunny girl senpai is right there is insane.

OptyfusPrime

March is the show that has gotten me into reaction type videos in the first place, it really is a special piece of work that has snugly cemented itself in my heart. It is, in my utmost humble but utterly biased opinion, a true masterclass. I feel like the both of you would enjoy this show as much as i did, and to this day still do. Especially season 2 is what i consider to be absolute ‘peak’, i have yet to consume any form of media that comes remotely close to it. I would be absolutely delighted and honoured to experience it all over again alongside the both of you.

Wanderer

There's no reason to watch Bunny Girl Senpai right after they started Monogatari lol

Vasto

1. Its not for everyone 2. while very artistic and well made, its can be just very boring for many many people

ElectricAnt

I’ll take sleep aid over pretentious cringe any day

Vasto

Violet Evergarden is so resident sleeper there is nothing going on there...

Joelle

Violet Evergarden please, that’s so up your alley

Kevin

And The Boys S1

smth positive_

they did that with jjk where ben watched season 1 and i still throughly enjoyed their rections and discussions

DrWomanRespecter

I’d take the half blind Violet Evergarden reaction over BGS, and that’s saying something

ElectricAnt

If BGS wins it’s so over

Kevin

Rewatching a show with your partner is fun though, especially if it is their first viewing

Quinn

one thing is just a straight derivative edgelord preteens idea of a good story and the other is one of the best anime ever made lol

Arakis

I mean, is it even fun having to (re)watch it, trying to avoid spoilers etc etc? Violet Evergarden is probably the best out of the three, but there's no reason to put her through the ordeal..

Kevin

Do it, even if it loses this poll

Kevin

Monogatari at home

Thomas Reinhardt

I didn't watch March comes in like a lion yet, but I trust the comments lol

Quinn

dollar tree monogatari

Brrmaster

All really great shows, looking forward to keeping up with whatever wins!

Matter

Walmart Mono winning...

Matter

you must adhere to their values only i fear.

Kevin

Thank you, holy fuck

Quinn

Kevin

Because it's an absolute waste of time are you dumb

Zipzip

its almost like different people value and like different things.

Zipzip

why not double down

Kevin

It's absolutely ridiculous

RRGI

Having Bunny Girl on while they're watching Monogatari doesn't really make sense lmao

Kevin

I cannot believe one of the most artistic and personal shows I've ever seen in my life is losing to absolute mid

David Pómez

After Monogatari 3gatsu? Sure life can't be this good.

Kochen51

Omg if Bunny Girl wins it would be so funny, but pls no

Max Bretl

LETS GO MARCH COMES IN LIKE A LION

DrWomanRespecter

MARCH COMES IN LIKE A LION, PLEASE, IM BEGGING YOU ALL