Patrefans
RAB Thoughts from patreon
RAB Thoughts patreon

February 18th, 2025: Stanton, Stroman, Boone, Arenado, Brubaker, Leiter, WBC

🕑 Added 2025-02-18 11:00:11 +0000 UTC

Comments

Alex G

That would require a competent GM which Cashman isn’t. You don’t go a decade and a half winning nothing with a top 3 payroll every year by accident.

Peter S

I hope they stay firm and only take on Nolan A if it’s a really good deal.

Big Davey88

What's Ben Francisco up to these days?

Jingling Baby

Three big differences are that (A) Volpe has had several long hot streaks that Peña never came close to and (B) Volpe elevated his game in the playoffs and (C) Volpe was a big prospect so rightly or wrongly he has people believing in his ability

Mark Davis

What about Belli at leadoff? Decent OBP

Tyler

I've been wondering about the backup catcher situation for weeks now. I don't get why they traded both Trevino and Narvaez. Narvaez in particular was cheap and cromulent as a backup. I know the pitcher they got back is decent, but shouldn't the MLB roster come ahead of another lottery ticket prospect?

The Original Drew

I understand that rosters aren’t going to be the same going into October as they are on Opening Day but for the love of God can the Yankees at least build in some redundancies going into the season so we don’t have Dom Smith starting DH on Opening Day.

DocBob

What do the Yanks need to do to get better at developing hitters? Which positions need to be replaced?

DocBob

After seeing the Dodgers beat a sloppy Yanks in the WS and then sign a bevy of players this offseason, I'm even angrier at the Yankees for being so frugal. Now that Stanton is out, they need an everyday 2B/3B, an everyday DH and a backup catcher! C'mon, Hal, open up the checkbook! C'mon, Cash, trade those prospects! At this point, I'll take Arenado and Canha, please.

Nick Fugitt

Breaking the extension policy for Aaron Boone is a perfect representation of Hal's Yankees. Perfectly accepting of mediocrity with the hope that everything goes right (it will not)

John G

They don't have enough offense

Michael Axisa

I'd rather wait to make sure he's actually good before putting him atop the lineup. I'm fine starting him lower in the order to begin the season.

Brad Schlesinger

volpe’s had a few weeks of success before, but those few weeks don’t change the fact he’s a glorified ramiro pena with the bat. maybe after 1k plus of PA’s with an ops+ of 100 or better we can talk about him not hitting 9th. the level of copium and delusions of grandeur around this guys inability to hit is incredible considering he’s closer to ramiro pena than an average hitter

Steven O

Wouldn't Dominguez be a good choice for leadoff? He sees a lot of pitches, and has speed and power. Is that too much pressure to put on him?

The WallBreakers

Regarding Arenado/Goldschmidt... (just using traditional stats for a second and if they traded for Arenado) the bar has been so low at 3rd base (Jazz's post-deadline not withstanding) and 1st base most of the past two seasons that if both of those guys came over and hit .240/.320/.460/.780 with 20 HRs and 75RBIs it would be a major upgrade from the combined corner IFs of the recent past. That, coupled with above average defense and getting a chance to play for a contending team would generally mean they'd be a net positive. The $s are only the $s because we as fans are forced to think of them in this era of Yankees fandom.

Jamie

Giancarlo’s stupid sexy elbows....Great Simpsons reference.

David Simon

On the wells leadoff idea, isn’t that similar to when they had Rizzo lead off which both the Yankees and the Cubs did. That worked out a bit.


More Creators