Frolic
patreon
Chapter 3
🕑 Added 2025-06-22 14:00:00 +0000 UTC🪄To bring you up to speed, Time-Turners: this chapter offers a glimpse into the other side of Severus’s choice, a shadow of what could have happened if he had let fear rule him instead of courage. It does not replace the main timeline but deepens the stakes of what he must overcome.
Chapter 3 shows an alternate version of Severus’s first day back, the path he might have taken if fear and regret froze him. The main story continues from Chapter 2’s events, the “Confident Return”, where he acted boldly and changed his fate early. The hesitant path is a mirror of what he fights inside himself every day. The scales must balance, the knife’s edge remains.
Thank you for reading!
The Great Hall stretched before them, vast and magnificent. Four long tables filled with students, hundreds of floating candles, and the enchanted ceiling reflecting the night sky outside. Severus had seen it countless times over two lifetimes, yet the spectacle still managed to steal his breath.
"It's even better than you described, " Lily whispered beside him, her face upturned in wonder.
He couldn't respond. The sight of the staff table had frozen him in place. There sat Albus Dumbledore in resplendent purple robes, his beard shorter than Severus remembered but his eyes just as piercing. Beside him was a much younger Minerva McGonagall, and further down, Severus felt his stomach lurch, Horace Slughorn, jovial and rotund, raising a goblet to his lips.
These people had been his colleagues. Some had died trusting him, others despising him. And now they would be his teachers again, unaware of the complex history that existed only in his mind.
The first-years lined up before the Sorting Hat, perched on its stool. Severus barely registered its song, lost in the overwhelming reality of his situation. Names were called. Children stepped forward. The hat made its pronouncements.
"Black, Sirius!"
Severus watched as the boy swaggered forward, sat down, and waited. The hat took longer than Severus remembered before finally shouting, "GRYFFINDOR!"
The Slytherin table muttered in shock while the Gryffindors cheered. Severus observed Sirius's triumphant smile as he joined his new house. In his first life, Severus had viewed this sorting as the first betrayal of a Black family tradition. Now he recognized it as an act of courage.
More names were called. Severus felt disconnected from the ceremony, floating above it all while simultaneously drowning in the implications of his knowledge.
"Evans, Lily!"
His attention snapped back. Lily squeezed his hand briefly before walking forward, her red hair gleaming in the candlelight. The hat barely touched her head before declaring, "GRYFFINDOR!"
She turned to look at him as she left the line, her smile apologetic. Severus managed a small nod. This part, at least, remained unchanged. But what else could he alter? Should he alter?
The weight of knowing pressed down on him. He knew which students would become Death Eaters. Which would die fighting against Voldemort. Which innocent-looking child would betray his friends to their deaths.
"I could change everything, " he thought, his mind racing through possibilities. "Or I could make it all worse."
"Lupin, Remus!"
The sickly-looking boy approached the stool nervously. Severus studied him with new eyes. Not just James Potter's friend now, but a man who would teach alongside him, who would die fighting for a better world, leaving behind an orphaned son.
"GRYFFINDOR!"
"Pettigrew, Peter!"
Severus's jaw clenched involuntarily. There he stood, small, unremarkable, frightened, the boy who would betray them all. The hat deliberated longer with him than most before declaring, "GRYFFINDOR!"
"Potter, James!"
James bounded forward confidently. The hat had barely settled on his unruly hair when it shouted, "GRYFFINDOR!" James pumped his fist in celebration, joining Sirius at the Gryffindor table where they immediately began whispering together.
More names passed in a blur until finally,
"Snape, Severus!"
He stepped forward, acutely aware of Lily watching him from the Gryffindor table. As he sat on the stool and the hat dropped over his eyes, he wondered: Could he change this most fundamental sorting? Should he?
"Well, well, " said a small voice in his ear. "What have we here? Oh my... this is most unusual."
Severus stiffened. The hat could see into his mind, all of it.
"Memories that haven't happened yet... a lifetime already lived... extraordinary. You've returned with purpose, I see."
"You can see everything?" Severus thought.
"Indeed. Your mind is quite the labyrinth, Mr. Snape. Or should I say, Professor Snape?" The hat seemed amused. "Now, where to put you this time? You've lived as a Slytherin already, with all its consequences."
Severus hesitated. He could ask for Gryffindor, stay close to Lily, perhaps prevent her friendship with James from blossoming.
"Ah, still thinking of the girl, " the hat commented. "But there's more to your return than that now, isn't there? You've seen a larger picture."
"I need to prevent what's coming, " Severus thought desperately. "The Dark Lord, the deaths, all of it."
"And you believe changing your house will accomplish this?"
The question struck Severus like a physical blow. Would it really matter? The essential conflicts that had shaped his first life existed beyond house affiliations.
"You bear knowledge that could alter the course of wizarding history, " the hat continued. "But knowledge without wisdom is dangerous. And wisdom, Mr. Snape, comes from knowing yourself."
Severus closed his eyes beneath the hat's brim. "I don't know if I can do this, " he admitted silently. "The responsibility is... overwhelming."
"Indeed it is. You stand at a crossroads far more significant than most eleven-year-olds. But remember, you chose to return."
After what seemed an eternity, the hat finally called out, "SLYTHERIN!"
The table decorated in green and silver applauded politely. As Severus removed the hat, he caught Lily's disappointed expression. He walked to the Slytherin table with leaden feet, wondering if he had already failed at the first hurdle.
Lucius Malfoy, a prefect in his fifth year, nodded approvingly as Severus sat down. "Another addition to the noble house, " he said smoothly. "Welcome, Snape."
Severus nodded mechanically, fighting the urge to recoil from the future Death Eater. Across the table sat Avery and Mulciber, boys who would become his friends and later his fellow servants to the Dark Lord.
The feast appeared, magnificent as always, but Severus found he had no appetite. He picked at his food while conversation flowed around him, his mind consumed by the impossible task ahead.
"You're quiet, " observed a girl beside him, Narcissa Black, he realized with a start. "Overwhelmed?"
"Something like that, " he murmured.
"It gets easier, " she said with surprising kindness. "Slytherin takes care of its own."
The irony nearly made him laugh. In his first life, he had embraced that sentiment wholeheartedly. The house had indeed taken care of him, guiding him straight into Voldemort's service.
After dinner, as the prefects led them to the dungeons, Severus caught a final glimpse of Lily following the Gryffindors upstairs. The distance between them seemed both physical and symbolic.
In the Slytherin dormitory, with its eerie green light filtering through windows that looked out into the depths of the lake, Severus sat on the edge of his bed while the other boys chatted excitedly about their first day.
He felt paralyzed by the enormity of what lay ahead. Every interaction, every choice, every word could alter the timeline in ways he couldn't predict. What if his attempts to save Lily only ensured her death by some other means? What if preventing one tragedy created another, worse one?
He knew too much and yet not enough. The broad strokes of history, yes, but not how his small changes might ripple outward. The butterfly effect made every decision potentially catastrophic.
Severus stared at his eleven-year-old hands in the dim light. Hands that had not yet brewed complex potions, cast unforgivable curses, or taken the Dark Mark. Innocent hands attached to a mind that was anything but innocent.
"I don't know if I can do this, " he whispered to himself, echoing his thought to the Sorting Hat. The other boys, busy unpacking their trunks, paid him no attention.
He had returned with such certainty, such determination to change everything. Now, faced with the reality of his situation, doubt crept in like the chill from the dungeon walls.
How could he possibly alter a fate that seemed so inevitable? The players were all in position, the stage set. History had a momentum of its own, a current pulling everyone toward their predetermined ends. And he was just one person, a child in the eyes of the world, trying to redirect a river with his bare hands.
Morning came too quickly. Severus lay awake long before the other stirred, watching green-tinged light dance across the stone ceiling as creatures swam past the dormitory windows. His first night back at Hogwarts had brought little rest, only an endless parade of calculations, fears, and half-formed plans.
He dressed mechanically, fingers fumbling with the unfamiliar smallness of his uniform. The Slytherin tie felt like a noose, a symbol of the path he'd chosen twice now. Perhaps the Sorting Hat had been right. Perhaps some destinies couldn't be escaped, only faced with greater wisdom.
"You're up early, " Avery mumbled from his bed, rubbing sleep from his eyes.
Severus nodded without elaboration. In his previous life, he'd been eager to impress these boys, to find acceptance among them. Now he saw them as children playing with matches beside a powder keg.
The Great Hall buzzed with first-day excitement. Severus picked at his breakfast, eyes repeatedly drifting toward the Gryffindor table where Lily sat, already deep in animated conversation with her new housemates. She caught his gaze once and waved. He managed a tight smile in return.
When the morning post arrived in a flurry of wings, Severus was surprised to see a barn owl land before him, extending its leg with a letter attached. His mother had never sent him mail during his first week at Hogwarts before.
The parchment trembled slightly in his hands as he unfolded it:
Severus stared at the letter, a strange tightness gripping his chest. In his first life, his mother had grown increasingly distant as his Hogwarts years progressed, beaten down by his father's cruelty and her own disillusionment. Her letters had become rare, then perfunctory, then nonexistent.
But this letter, this small act of maternal tenderness, felt like the first ripple of change. Had his different goodbye at King's Cross affected her somehow? Or was this simply a detail he'd forgotten over decades of bitter memories?
"From your mum?" asked Mulciber, peering over his shoulder.
Severus folded the letter quickly. "Yes."
"Mine's already sent me a package of sweets, " Mulciber boasted. "Said she'd send one weekly."
"How fortunate for you, " Severus murmured, tucking the letter into his robes. The casual mention of Mulciber's mother sent a chill through him. These children surrounding him had parents who would either die in the coming war or commit atrocities in Voldemort's name.
Including his own mother. Eileen Prince Snape would die alone and broken during his fifth year at Hogwarts, with Severus arriving home for summer holiday to find her cold in her bed, a potion vial clutched in her hand. Suicide or accident, he'd never been certain.
But now...
The realization hit him with physical force. His mother was alive. Young enough still. And this time, he could save her.
Classes passed in a blur that day. Severus moved through them in a state of heightened awareness, noting which professors would die in the coming wars, which students would take the Dark Mark, which would fight against it. The weight of his knowledge made simple interactions excruciating.
Should he deliberately perform poorly in Potions to avoid Slughorn's attention? Should he excel in Defense Against the Dark Arts to build skills he'd need later? Every choice felt monumental, every decision a potential catastrophe.
By evening, he'd made up his mind. He needed to write back to his mother, not the cursory note he'd sent in his first life, but something meaningful. Something that might begin to shift her path away from despair.
In the Slytherin common room, he found a quiet corner and pulled out parchment and quill.
He paused, quill hovering. What could he possibly say? That he knew her future? That he'd returned from death to prevent it? That her son had lived a life of bitterness and regret, only to die with a snake's venom in his veins? He still wrote to his mother.
He read over the letter, wondering if he'd said too much or too little. Would these small words be enough to plant seeds of change? Or would they simply confuse her, coming from an eleven-year-old boy?
"Writing home already?" Lucius Malfoy's voice startled him. The prefect stood nearby, eyeing the parchment with mild curiosity.
Severus folded the letter quickly. "Just a note to my mother."
"Homesick?" There was a hint of derision in Malfoy's tone.
"Considerate, " Severus countered, meeting the older boy's gaze steadily. "Family connections are important, wouldn't you agree?"
Malfoy's expression shifted subtly, reassessing. "Indeed they are. The right connections define one's future." He gestured to the letter. "I'm heading to the Owlery now if you'd like company."
Severus considered refusing, then realized this might be an opportunity. In his first life, Lucius had been his earliest mentor in Slytherin, guiding him toward the Dark Arts and eventually to Voldemort. Perhaps this time, he could establish a different dynamic from the start.
"Thank you, " he said, rising from his seat.
They walked in silence through the dungeon corridors, up the stairs, and through the castle. Severus was acutely aware of the future Death Eater beside him, currently just a privileged, arrogant teenager with no concept of the horrors that awaited him.
"Your accent, " Lucius said finally as they climbed the Owlery stairs. "You're not from a wealthy family, are you?"
The question had been asked in his first life too, though Severus now recognized the calculated assessment behind it.
"My mother is from the Prince family, " he replied carefully. "My father is a Muggle."
Lucius's lip curled slightly. "Half-blood, then."
"Does it matter?" Severus asked, his tone neutral but his gaze direct.
"In Slytherin? Often."
"And to you personally?"
Lucius paused on the stairs, studying him with new interest. "You're rather direct for a first-year."
"I prefer clarity to pretense."
A smile touched Lucius's lips. "How refreshing. Most first-years are too intimidated to speak their minds." He continued climbing. "To answer your question, blood status matters in the circles I inhabit. But talent and ambition can sometimes... compensate for unfortunate parentage."
"How generous, " Severus said dryly.
Lucius laughed. "You're an interesting one, Snape. I think I'll keep an eye on you."
In the Owlery, Severus tied his letter to a school owl's leg, watching as it soared out into the twilight. He wondered what his mother would make of it, this letter so different from what her son would have written in another timeline.
"She'll be proud, " Lucius commented, following his gaze. "Mothers always are, especially of Slytherins."
Severus thought of Narcissa Malfoy, who would one day betray Voldemort himself to protect her son. "Some mothers love beyond all reason or expectation."
"Speaking from experience?" Lucius asked, raising an eyebrow.
"Observation, " Severus replied quietly.
As they walked back to the dungeons, Severus felt the weight of his letter lingering. He had offered his mother a glimpse of warmth and concern that his younger self had been too self-absorbed to show. A small change, but changes accumulated. Ripples became waves.
That night, lying in his bed listening to the soft breathing of boys who might become monsters, Severus thought of his mother reading his words. Would she sense the difference? Would she feel the love of a son who had lived long enough to regret his coldness? Would it be enough to pull her back from the edge of despair?
He imagined her hope kindling, hope that her son might be different than his father, that her life might hold more than endless suffering. The thought filled him with both longing and dread. What if he gave her hope only to fail her again? What if his attempts to save her only heightened her eventual disappointment?
Severus rolled onto his side, pulling the blanket tighter around his shoulders. He had returned to save Lily, to prevent a war, to redeem himself. But now he realized the terrible burden of caring for anyone in this second life: every connection was a vulnerability, every love a potential wound.
He closed his eyes, terrified of the responsibility of her hope. This was the cost of emotional connections he'd avoided for so long, they made you hostage to another's happiness. And he, who had failed so many in his first life, now held his mother's fragile future in hands that felt far too small for the task.
The corridor of the Hogwarts Express rocked gently beneath Severus's feet as he stood outside Lily's compartment, paralyzed. Through the glass panel in the door, he could see her, alive, vibrant, laughing with Mary Macdonald about something trivial and wonderful. Her hair caught the sunlight streaming through the window, creating a halo of auburn fire around her face.
Severus's hand hovered near the door handle, trembling. He'd been avoiding her for three days now, ever since their brief encounter at the Sorting Ceremony. Three days of ducking around corners when he saw her approaching, of eating his meals at odd hours, of taking circuitous routes between classes.
Three days of cowardice.
The train swayed around a bend, and he steadied himself against the wall. This journey home for the Halloween weekend was supposed to be his opportunity. A chance to speak with her away from the watchful eyes of their respective houses. Away from Potter and his gang, who had already begun their campaign of casual torment.
Yet here he stood, frozen outside her compartment like a statue.
"Just open the door, " he whispered to himself. "Just slide it open and say hello."
But what would he say after hello? How could he possibly explain the storm of emotions that overwhelmed him every time he saw her face? The crushing grief of memories that hadn't happened yet, her wedding to Potter, her death at Voldemort's hands, the decades he'd spent mourning her.
How could he look at eleven-year-old Lily Evans and not see the empty, lifeless body he'd cradled in Godric's Hollow, screaming his anguish into the Halloween night?
Inside the compartment, Lily turned toward the door, and for a heart-stopping moment, their eyes met through the glass. Her smile faltered in confusion, then brightened again as she recognized him. She waved, gesturing for him to come in.
Severus took a step backward.
"I can't, " he mouthed, though he knew she couldn't hear him.
Lily's brow furrowed. She said something to Mary and stood up, moving toward the compartment door.
Panic seized him. Severus turned and fled down the corridor, pushing past a group of third-year Hufflepuffs, ignoring their protests. He didn't stop until he reached the space between carriages, where he pressed his forehead against the cold metal wall and fought to control his breathing.
"Coward, " he hissed at himself. "Pathetic, useless coward."
"Sev?"
He whirled around. Lily stood at the end of the connector, concern etched across her features. The space suddenly felt too small, the air too thin.
"Are you alright?" she asked, taking a tentative step toward him.
"Fine, " he managed, the word catching in his throat.
"You don't look fine." She moved closer, studying his face. "You've been avoiding me."
He couldn't deny it. "I've been... adjusting."
"To Slytherin?" She tilted her head. "I thought that's what you wanted."
"It is." The lie came automatically, then withered under her gaze. "It's complicated."
"Everything's complicated with you lately." There was no accusation in her voice, only genuine confusion. "You're different, Sev. Since the train ride here. Sometimes when you look at me, it's like..."
"Like what?" he whispered.
"Like you're seeing a ghost." She frowned. "Or like you're afraid I might disappear."
The observation struck too close to the truth. Severus felt exposed, vulnerable in a way that made his instincts scream for retreat. In his first life, he would have deflected, changed the subject, perhaps even lashed out in defensive anger.
But this was his second chance. And Lily deserved better.
"I had a dream, " he said slowly, the words forming as he spoke them. "A terrible dream that felt like years... like a lifetime. And in it, I lost you."
It wasn't entirely a lie. Sometimes his first life seemed like a nightmare from which he'd finally awakened.
Lily's expression softened. "That sounds awful."
"It was." He swallowed hard. "And now I'm afraid... afraid that if I make the same mistakes, it might come true."
"What mistakes?"
The train lurched around a bend, throwing Lily slightly off-balance. Severus reached out instinctively to steady her, his hand catching her elbow. The simple contact, her warm, solid presence under his fingers, sent a jolt through him.
She was real. Alive. Here.
"Choosing the wrong friends, " he said, finding his voice again. "Saying things I don't mean. Hurting you because I'm hurt."
Lily studied him with an intensity that belied her eleven years. "That doesn't sound like you, Sev."
"It could be, " he said quietly. "If I'm not careful."
She shook her head, a small smile playing at her lips. "I know you better than that."
The irony of her words twisted in his chest like a knife. She had known him, once. Known him and been disappointed by what she found.
"You might be wrong about me, " he whispered.
"I don't think so." Her confidence was heartbreaking in its innocence. "You're my best friend. The first person who showed me I wasn't a freak for being different. The person who opened up this whole magical world to me."
Each word was both balm and wound. In his first life, he'd clung to her friendship like a drowning man to driftwood, demanding she save him while making no effort to swim to shore himself. He'd expected her loyalty while offering nothing but toxicity in return.
"I want to be worthy of that, " he said, the words catching in his throat. "Of your friendship."
"You already are, silly." She touched his arm lightly. "Now, are you going to tell me what's really bothering you? Because I know it's not just some dream."
The train whistle blew, signaling their approach to King's Cross. Time was running out.
"I'm afraid, " he admitted, the confession tearing from him. "Afraid of going home. Of seeing my father. Of what might happen to my mother while I'm at Hogwarts."
This, at least, was a truth he could share openly.
Lily's expression clouded with understanding. "Your dad... is he still drinking?"
"Always." Bitterness crept into his voice. "And when he drinks, he gets angry. And when he's angry..."
He didn't need to finish. Lily had seen the bruises over the years, had heard the shouting from the Snape house on Spinner's End.
"Your mum wrote to you, though, " Lily said. "I saw you get her owl. That's good, isn't it?"
Severus nodded, surprised she'd noticed. "She seems... different. More like she was when I was very young. Before things got so bad."
"Maybe she's finding her strength again, " Lily suggested. "My mum says sometimes women lose themselves in bad marriages, but they can find their way back."
"I hope so." The thought kindled something dangerously like hope in his chest. "I've been writing to her more than I did... than I would have."
The slip almost gave him away, but Lily didn't seem to notice. "That's good, Sev. She needs you."
The train began to slow as it approached the station. Outside the windows, the outskirts of London scrolled past.
"We should get back to our compartments, " Lily said reluctantly. "But promise me something?"
"Anything, " he answered, too quickly.
"Stop avoiding me at school." Her green eyes held his firmly. "Whatever you're afraid of, we can face it together. That's what friends do."
The simplicity of her offer, her unwavering loyalty despite his recent strangeness, broke something open inside him. In that moment, Severus was overwhelmed by the miracle of her presence. Not just the fact that she was alive, but that she still believed in him, still saw something worthy in the awkward, damaged boy from Spinner's End.
It was more than he deserved. More than he had any right to ask for. And yet she offered it freely, without condition or expectation.
"I promise, " he said, the words a vow more binding than any Unbreakable Vow he'd ever witnessed. "No more hiding."
Lily smiled, the expression lighting her entire face. "Good. Because Hogwarts is too big and too wonderful to experience alone." She glanced toward her compartment. "I should get my things. See you on the platform?"
Severus nodded, unable to speak past the tightness in his throat.
As she walked away, he felt something shift inside him, a realization crystallizing with sudden clarity. He had returned to save Lily, yes. But perhaps the greater miracle was that she had always been trying to save him.
This time, he would let her.
Severus stepped onto Platform 9¾, the familiar chaos of families greeting returning students washing over him. He scanned the crowd for his mother, surprised by the anxiety tightening his chest. In his first life, he'd been eager to escape home, viewing Hogwarts as his sanctuary. Now, he found himself desperate to see Eileen, to confirm with his own eyes that she was still alive, still fighting.
"There's my parents!" Lily exclaimed beside him, pointing toward a middle-aged couple waving enthusiastically. Mr. and Mrs. Evans, people he'd barely acknowledged in his first life, yet who would be dead of a car accident before Lily finished Hogwarts. Another tragedy he might prevent, if he could determine when and how it happened.
"Will you come say hello?" Lily asked, tugging at his sleeve. "They've always wanted to meet you properly."
The request startled him. In his first life, he'd avoided her parents, intimidated by their Muggle normalcy and the obvious love they showered on their daughters. He'd been jealous, resentful of their functional family.
"I'd like that, " he said, surprising himself with the sincerity in his voice.
As they navigated through the crowd, a familiar laugh cut through the noise, bright, confident, infused with casual arrogance. Severus froze, his body tensing instinctively as James Potter's voice reached him.
"Evans! Hey, Evans! Wait up!"
Severus turned slowly, decades of hatred surging through him with such force he nearly staggered. James Potter jogged toward them, his hair characteristically disheveled, his smile easy and expectant. Behind him followed Sirius Black, tall for his age and already carrying himself with the aristocratic confidence of his bloodline.
"Thought I'd introduce you to my parents, " James called as he approached. "They're dying to meet the girl who keeps telling me off in Charms."
Lily rolled her eyes, but her smile remained friendly. "I don't tell you off. I just correct your terrible wandwork."
"Same thing, " James grinned, then noticed Severus. His expression cooled slightly. "Snape."
"Potter, " Severus managed, his voice remarkably steady despite the hurricane of emotion within him.
This boy, this child, would grow up to marry Lily. To father her son. To die trying to protect them both. And yet, standing before Severus was also the tormentor who had made his school years a living hell, who had humiliated him repeatedly, who had stolen the only person he'd ever loved.
The cognitive dissonance was dizzying.
"Didn't expect to see you heading home for the weekend, " James commented, his tone carrying a subtle edge. "Thought Slytherins preferred the dungeons to daylight."
Sirius snickered. "Probably needed to replenish his supply of Dark Arts books. The Hogwarts library's restricted section just isn't evil enough."
The familiar taunts triggered a muscle memory of rage. Severus felt his hand twitch toward his wand, years of dueling instincts demanding retaliation. He could destroy these boys with spells they wouldn't learn for years, if ever. He could humiliate them as they had once humiliated him.
But they were children. Merely children.
And so was he, at least in body.
"Actually, " Severus said, his voice unnaturally calm, "I'm visiting my mother. Family is important, wouldn't you agree, Black?"
Sirius's smirk faltered slightly. Even at eleven, family was already a sore point for him.
"Come on, Lily, " Severus continued, deliberately using her first name rather than the more distant 'Evans' he'd adopted in later years. "Your parents are waiting."
He placed a gentle hand on her elbow, guiding her away from the two boys. It took every ounce of self-control not to look back, not to fire a parting hex at the pair who had once strung him upside down for the entertainment of the entire school.
"You handled that well, " Lily said quietly as they moved through the crowd. "Usually you'd have called them something nasty by now."
"Would that have helped?" he asked, genuinely curious about her perspective.
She considered this. "No, I suppose not. It just would have given them more ammunition." She smiled up at him. "Maybe you really are changing."
If only she knew.
"Lily!" Mrs. Evans called, waving enthusiastically as they approached. She was a slender woman with Lily's facial structure but blonde hair. Beside her stood Mr. Evans, tall with the same startling green eyes that his daughter had inherited.
"Mum! Dad!" Lily rushed forward into their embrace, the three of them forming a tight knot of affection. Severus hung back, uncomfortable witnessing such open familial love.
After a moment, Lily pulled away and beckoned him forward. "This is Severus. My best friend. The one I've told you about."
Mrs. Evans smiled warmly. "The young wizard who first told Lily what she was. We've been wanting to thank you properly for years."
"It's nothing, " Severus mumbled, unprepared for gratitude.
"Nonsense, " Mr. Evans said, extending his hand. "You opened up a whole new world for our daughter. That's not nothing, son."
Severus shook his hand, struck by the man's firm grip and direct gaze. This was the father who had raised Lily to be brave, kind, and principled. The man whose values had shaped the woman Severus had loved beyond reason.
"Lily speaks very highly of you, " Mrs. Evans added. "Says you're the cleverest in your year."
"She exaggerates, " Severus said, though a small, prideful part of him preened at the compliment. "Lily herself is exceptional at Charms."
"And you're brilliant at Potions, " Lily countered. "Professor Slughorn said your Cure for Boils was the best he'd seen from a first-year in decades."
Of course it was. He'd brewed it countless times over two lifetimes. But he couldn't say that.
"Speaking of potions, " Mr. Evans said, "Lily mentioned your mother is quite talented in that area as well. Is she meeting you today?"
The question brought Severus back to his original anxiety. "Yes, she should be here somewhere."
He scanned the platform again, worry gnawing at him. What if she hadn't come? What if his father had prevented her somehow? What if,
"Severus."
The voice came from behind him, soft but clear. He turned to find Eileen standing there, her dark hair pulled back neatly, her face thinner than he remembered but her eyes alert and present in a way they hadn't been during his first childhood.
"Mother, " he said, the word catching in his throat.
She stepped forward and, to his astonishment, embraced him. It was brief and slightly awkward, but it was more physical affection than she'd shown him in years during his first life.
"You look well, " she said, studying his face. "Hogwarts agrees with you."
"It does, " he managed, still recovering from the surprise of her hug.
Eileen turned her attention to the Evans family. "You must be Lily's parents. Eileen Snape. Severus has mentioned your daughter often in his letters."
Letters. Plural. In his first life, he'd written home perhaps twice during his entire first year. This time, he'd sent an owl every few days, each message deliberately crafted to encourage his mother, to remind her of her own strength and worth.
Had it worked? The woman standing before him seemed... different. More present. More herself.
"Pleasure to meet you, " Mrs. Evans said warmly. "We were just saying how grateful we are to your son for helping Lily understand her magic before Hogwarts."
"He's always been observant, " Eileen said, a hint of pride coloring her voice. "Even as a small child, he noticed things others missed."
The simple compliment warmed something deep inside Severus. When was the last time he'd heard his mother speak well of him to others?
As the adults fell into conversation, Severus became aware of movement in his peripheral vision. James and Sirius were approaching again, this time accompanied by an elegant couple who could only be the Potters.
Fleamont and Euphemia Potter. Wealthy, influential, and doting parents who had raised their son with every advantage. Parents who would die of Dragon Pox before James finished school, leaving him a substantial fortune.
The sight of them, vibrant and alive, triggered another wave of disorienting emotion in Severus. These people had welcomed Lily into their home after her parents' deaths. Had treated her like a daughter. Had died never knowing their grandson.
"Evans!" James called again. "Come meet my parents!"
Severus watched as Lily politely excused herself and walked over to the Potter family. James beamed with undisguised delight as he made introductions, his hand gesturing animatedly.
The scene before him seemed to split in two, overlapping realities competing for dominance. In one, he saw children meeting parents on a train platform. In the other, he saw the complex web of tragedy that would eventually connect them all: deaths, betrayals, sacrifices.
"They seem nice, " Eileen commented, following his gaze to the Potter family.
"They're children, " Severus whispered, more to himself than to his mother. "They don't know what's coming."
And here he stood, caught between past and present, between knowledge and action, between hatred and understanding. The weight of it threatened to crush him.
They were children. Just children.
But so had he been, once. And no one had protected him from what was coming.
Lily rejoined them, her cheeks flushed with excitement. "The Potters invited me to visit during Christmas break! They have a cottage in Godric's Hollow with an actual magical garden." She turned to her parents. "Could I go, just for a day? Mrs. Potter said she'd arrange everything with Floo powder."
Mr. Evans looked bewildered. "Floo what now?"
"It's magical transportation through fireplaces, " Severus explained mechanically, his mind still reeling. Godric's Hollow. The place where she would die. The home where her body would lie cold on the nursery floor while her child screamed in his crib.
"That sounds... unsafe, " Mrs. Evans said uncertainly.
Eileen stepped in. "It's perfectly standard in our world. Like your automobiles, only much faster and without the risk of collision."
Severus shot his mother a surprised look. In his first life, she'd rarely engaged with Muggles willingly, having retreated so far into herself that social interaction of any kind became painful for her.
"Well, we'll discuss it later, " Mr. Evans said, patting Lily's shoulder. "For now, let's get you home. Your sister's been counting the days until your return, though she'd never admit it."
Petunia. Another damaged soul in the tapestry of tragedy that surrounded Lily. Severus had never given her much thought beyond contempt, but now he wondered: could that relationship be salvaged too? Would it matter in the grand scheme?
"We should be going as well, " Eileen said, glancing at the station clock. "Your father's expecting us."
The mention of Tobias Snape cast a shadow over Severus's mood. In his first life, these visits home had been exercises in endurance, navigating his father's unpredictable temper, protecting his mother when possible, escaping to Lily's house whenever he could.
"Actually, " Eileen continued, lowering her voice slightly, "he's working an extra shift today. We have the house to ourselves until evening."
Severus studied his mother's face, searching for hidden meaning in her words. Was this an invitation to speak freely? To reconnect without Tobias's looming presence?
"I'd like that, " he said cautiously.
As they prepared to leave, Lily caught his arm. "Meet at our spot tomorrow? By the river?"
Their spot. The place where it had all begun, where he'd first called her a witch, where their friendship had taken root. In his first life, it had remained their sanctuary until Hogwarts gradually pulled them apart.
"Yes, " he agreed. "Midday?"
She nodded, then surprised him with a quick hug before running back to her parents. The brief contact left him momentarily stunned, the simple affection of it unfamiliar to his adult consciousness housed in this child's body.
As he and Eileen made their way toward the Muggle side of the station, Snape turned to find Avery watching him from a distance, his expression unreadable. Their gazes locked for a moment before the boy turned away to join his own family.
"One of your housemates?" Eileen asked.
"Yes, " Severus replied, unease crawling along his spine. "Avery."
"Pureblood family, " she noted. "Old name, though not as influential as they once were."
"I don't know him well, " Severus said carefully.
"The Prince name used to carry weight too, " Eileen said unexpectedly as they navigated through the crowded station. "Before my father gambled away most of our fortune and my mother died of shame."
Severus nearly missed a step. His mother rarely spoke of her family history. In his first life, he'd pieced together the Prince legacy through fragments and overheard conversations.
"Is that why you married Father?" he asked before he could stop himself. "To escape the shame?"
Eileen's steps faltered. She glanced at him sharply, then away. "That's... a very direct question from an eleven-year-old."
"I'm observant, " he reminded her, echoing her earlier words. "And I'm not blind to what happens at home."
They reached the station exit and stepped out into the crisp October air. Eileen was silent for so long that Severus feared he'd pushed too far, too fast.
"I married your father because I thought I loved him, " she finally said, her voice low. "Because he seemed strong and certain in a world where I felt weak and lost. Because he looked at me like I was magical in the Muggle sense of the word, special, extraordinary." A bitter smile twisted her lips. "Later I learned he hated that I was magical in the literal sense."
The confession hit Severus like a physical blow. This was more than his mother had ever shared with him in his entire first lifetime.
"Why do you stay?" he asked, the question that had burned in him for years.
Eileen stopped walking and turned to face him fully. "Because where would we go, Severus? Because I've been away from the magical world for too long. Because your father, for all his faults, is still your father." She paused, studying his face. "But mostly because I've been afraid."
"Of what?"
"Of standing on my own. Of failing you. Of facing the magical world as a disgraced Prince with nothing to my name but a half-blood son and a broken wand."
The raw honesty in her voice made Severus's throat tighten. This wasn't the beaten-down woman he remembered from his childhood. This was Eileen Prince, the witch, the Slytherin, the survivor, speaking her truth perhaps for the first time in years.
"You haven't failed me, " he said quietly. "And you're stronger than you think."
She gave him a curious look. "Those are strange words coming from a child."
"Perhaps I'm not as much of a child as I appear."
The words slipped out before he could stop them. Eileen's eyes narrowed slightly, and Severus felt a brush against his mental shields, a gentle, probing Legilimency that surprised him with its subtlety. In his first life, he'd never known his mother possessed such skill.
He reinforced his Occlumency barriers instinctively, then immediately regretted it when he saw the shock register on her face.
"Where did you learn to do that?" she whispered, taking a step back.
Severus cursed himself inwardly. Of course she would recognize mental shields when she encountered them. And of course an eleven-year-old shouldn't possess such advanced magical protection.
"I don't know what you mean, " he tried, knowing the denial was futile.
Eileen glanced around the busy street, then took his arm firmly. "Not here. We'll discuss this at home."
As she led him toward the bus stop, Severus felt panic rising in his chest. He'd been careless, revealing too much too soon. Now his mother suspected something was deeply wrong with her son, or perhaps that he wasn't her son at all.
The fragile connection he'd been building with her might shatter under the weight of his impossible truth. And without that connection, how could he hope to save her? To save any of them?
They boarded the bus in silence, Eileen's hand still gripping his arm as if afraid he might disappear. Severus stared out the window as London rolled past, his mind racing through explanations, excuses, partial truths he might offer.
But perhaps the time for lies had passed. Perhaps, for Eileen at least, the truth was the only path forward.
The thought terrified him more than facing Voldemort ever had.
"Come, " Eileen said, her voice tight as they disembarked. She walked briskly down the narrow street lined with identical brick houses, her shoulders set in a tense line.
Spinner's End hadn't changed, wouldn't change for decades. The same soot-stained facades, the same curtains drawn against prying eyes, the same undercurrent of hopelessness that had shaped his earliest years. The polluted river still cut through the town like an infected wound, carrying the stench of the abandoned mill downstream.
Their house sat at the very end of the row, indistinguishable from its neighbors except for the slightly more neglected front step. Eileen unlocked the door and ushered him inside, closing it firmly behind them.
The familiar smell hit him immediately, damp and dust, cheap alcohol and old books. Home, in all its miserable glory.
"Sit, " Eileen commanded, pointing to the threadbare sofa in their small living room. The walls were lined with the books that had been Severus's only escape in his first childhood, his mother's magical texts carefully hidden behind rows of mundane Muggle titles to avoid his father's wrath.
Severus obeyed, perching on the edge of the sofa while his mother paced before him, her thin hands clasped tightly together.
"Explain, " she said finally, turning to face him. "Those were Occlumency shields I felt. Advanced ones. No first-year could possibly possess such mental defenses."
Severus considered his options. Denial would only insult her intelligence. A partial truth might satisfy her temporarily but would unravel eventually. The complete truth seemed impossible to articulate, yet it pressed against his chest like a physical weight, demanding release.
"If I tell you, " he said carefully, "you must promise to listen completely before you react."
Eileen's eyes narrowed, but she nodded once, sharply.
"I'm not exactly who you think I am, " Severus began, each word measured. "Or rather, I am Severus, your son, but I'm also... more."
"Explain, " she repeated, her voice colder now.
"I lived a full life already. I died at thirty-eight, and then... I was given a choice. To move on or to return." He met her gaze directly. "I chose to return. To this body, to this time, with all my memories intact."
Eileen stared at him, her face completely still. Then, without warning, she drew her wand from her sleeve, a wand Severus had rarely seen her use in his first childhood.
"Who are you?" she demanded, the tip of her wand aimed steadily at his chest. "What have you done with my son?"
"I am your son, " Severus insisted, keeping his hands visible and non-threatening. "Test me. Ask me something only Severus would know."
"A skilled Legilimens could have extracted any memory, " she countered, her wand unwavering.
"Then use Legilimency on me now, " he offered. "I'll lower my shields. You'll see I'm telling the truth."
Eileen hesitated, uncertainty flickering across her face. "If what you claim is true, you died at thirty-eight. What happened? How did you die?"
The question caught him off guard. Of all the things she might have asked, she wanted to know about his death?
"I was killed by a snake, " he said simply. "A magical serpent belonging to... to a dark wizard I once served and then betrayed."
Pain flashed in Eileen's eyes. "My son becomes a servant to dark wizards in this future of yours?"
"Yes, " Severus admitted, the shame of it still fresh despite decades. "I made terrible choices. Choices I've returned to unmake."
Eileen lowered her wand slightly, her expression shifting from suspicion to a complex mixture of horror and fascination. "Why would you be given such a chance? Who gave it to you?"
"I don't know, " he answered honestly. "I found myself in a place that looked like King's Cross Station. You were there, or something that appeared as you, and I was offered a choice."
"And you chose to return to this?" She gestured around their shabby living room. "To Spinner's End? To... this life?"
"I chose to return to prevent deaths, " Severus said. "To save someone I... someone I failed."
Understanding dawned in Eileen's eyes. "The Evans girl. Lily."
Severus nodded, unable to speak past the sudden tightness in his throat.
Eileen sank into the armchair opposite him, her wand now resting in her lap. "Show me, " she said finally. "Lower your shields and show me the truth."
"It won't be pleasant, " he warned.
"Few truths are, " she replied with a bitter smile that reminded him forcefully of his own.
Severus closed his eyes, carefully dismantling the Occlumency barriers he'd maintained since awakening on the Hogwarts Express. When he opened them again, he nodded to his mother.
"Legilimens, " she whispered.
The intrusion was gentle but thorough. Eileen moved through his memories with surprising skill, witnessing flashes of his first life: his broken friendship with Lily, taking the Dark Mark, hearing the prophecy, begging Dumbledore to protect Lily, finding her body, the years of bitter regret, his role as a spy, protecting Harry Potter while hating the sight of him, and finally, the Shrieking Shack, Nagini's attack, and the crossroads at King's Cross.
When she withdrew from his mind, tears streamed silently down her face.
"My boy, " she whispered. "My poor, broken boy."
The compassion in her voice undid him. Severus felt his own tears spill over, his child's body responding to emotions his adult mind struggled to contain.
"You died too, " he said, his voice cracking. "During my fifth year. I came home and found you... I never knew if it was an accident or if you'd given up."
Eileen's hand flew to her mouth. "I abandoned you?"
"You were already gone in many ways, " Severus said. "Father broke you down year by year until there was nothing left."
She was silent for a long moment, absorbing this terrible knowledge. "And now you've returned to save Lily Evans, " she said finally. "But what about yourself, Severus? What about your own life?"
The question startled him. In all his planning, all his desperate strategizing, he'd thought only of Lily's survival, of preventing the war, of protecting others from the fate he knew awaited them. He'd never considered his own happiness as a goal worth pursuing.
"I don't matter, " he said automatically. "Only that I prevent what's coming."
"You matter to me, " Eileen said fiercely, leaning forward to grasp his hands. "You are my son. If what you've shown me is true, then you've been given an extraordinary gift, not just to save others, but to live differently yourself."
Severus stared at her, stunned by the passion in her voice. This was not the defeated woman he remembered.
"We've both been given a second chance, " she continued, squeezing his hands. "I won't waste mine this time. I won't let Tobias destroy us."
"What are you saying?"
"I'm saying we leave, " Eileen stated simply. "Not today, perhaps not even this year. But soon. Before history repeats itself."
The idea was so unexpected that Severus couldn't immediately process it. Leave Spinner's End? Leave his father? Create an entirely new path that had never existed in his first timeline?
"Where would we go?" he asked, the question of a child momentarily overtaking the strategist's mind.
"The magical world has places for those who seek them, " Eileen said with newfound determination. "I still have connections, distant though they may be. The Prince name still carries some weight."
Hope, dangerous, fragile hope, flickered to life in Severus's chest. If his mother survived, if they escaped Tobias's toxic influence, how might that change his own development? His relationship with Lily? His vulnerability to the Dark Arts and those who practiced them?
"There's so much I need to tell you, " he said. "About what's coming. About the Dark Lord and his followers. About the war."
"And you will, " Eileen assured him. "But not all at once. We have time now, time we're stealing back from fate." She studied his face, her expression softening. "You carry too much for one so young. Even with an old soul inside you."
"I don't know if I can do this, " Severus admitted, the fear he'd been suppressing finally breaking through. "What if I make things worse? What if I save Lily only to doom someone else? What if, "
"Stop, " Eileen commanded gently. "You cannot control every outcome, Severus. No one can, not even those who've lived two lives."
Her words struck at the heart of his terror. He wanted certainty, guarantees that his interference wouldn't create new catastrophes. But there were none to be had.
"All we can do, " Eileen continued, "is make better choices than we did before, and hope that ripples become waves."
Severus nodded slowly, her words echoing his own earlier thoughts. "Hope has never been my strong suit."
"Then it's time you learned, " she said with unexpected firmness. "Starting now."
As they sat together in the gathering dusk of Spinner's End, Severus felt the weight on his shoulders shift slightly. Not lighter, perhaps, but more evenly distributed. He was no longer alone in his knowledge, no longer the sole guardian of a terrible future.
Tomorrow he would meet Lily by the river. Their spot. Where it all began. He would look into her green eyes, alive, vibrant, undiminished by death, and remember why he had returned. Not just to prevent her death, but to preserve the light she brought to the world.
This time, he prayed, it wouldn't end in tragedy. This time, Lily Evans would live. The hope felt like balancing on a blade's edge, precarious and painful, but possible. Despite the overwhelming odds, despite the darkness he knew was gathering even now, Severus allowed himself to believe in that possibility.
It was, after all, why he had returned.
