Frolic
patreon
Chapter 5
🕑 Added 2025-06-24 14:00:00 +0000 UTCNOTE: The Marauders who think rivalry ends in laughter, are yet to taste the poison their games will brew. Death Eaters in waiting, the price of their whispered oaths will come due when loyalty cuts deeper than dark magic ever could. And to Severus Snape, half boy, half ghost of his own mistakes, this is the edge where he stands, rewriting betrayal into defiance, loss into something that might just be worth saving.
The scales always balance, but not the way they think. Watch. Nothing here will end the way it did before. The reckoning comes hot and sharp in the chapters ahead.
The dungeons were colder than Severus remembered. Despite the firelight flickering against the stone walls, there was a dampness in the air that clung to his robes and seemed to settle into his bones. Severus trailed behind the other first-years as they followed the fifth-year prefect deeper into Slytherin territory, his mind still churning with the Sorting Hat's cryptic warning.
For each life you save, another may be sacrificed.
The words echoed in his mind, bouncing off the walls of his consciousness like the sound of their footsteps in the narrow corridor. What did it mean? Was fate truly so balanced that every positive change would demand payment in blood?
Watch the moon when seven sevens align.
Severus frowned. Seven sevens, forty-nine. Forty-nine what? Days? Weeks? Years? And what significance did the moon hold? He'd need to research lunar cycles, perhaps consult astronomy charts. His adult mind already cataloged possible reference texts in the Hogwarts library.
The prefect stopped before a stretch of bare, damp stone wall and turned to address them. "Remember this location and tonight's password. It changes every fortnight." He faced the wall. "Basilisk."
The stone wall slid open, revealing the Slytherin common room that Severus had once called home for seven years. The familiar green-tinged light cast from lamps hanging on chains from the ceiling, the dark leather sofas, the elaborate carvings of serpents adorning the mantelpiece, it was exactly as he remembered, yet somehow smaller than in his memory.
"First-years, gather round, " called a commanding voice.
Lucius Malfoy stood by the ornate fireplace, his prefect badge gleaming on his chest, platinum hair reflecting the emerald glow of the room. The older students dispersed to their respective corners, while the first-years huddled together before Malfoy.
"Welcome to the noble House of Slytherin, " Lucius began, his voice carrying the practiced cadence of someone who believed deeply in his own importance. "You have been chosen because you possess the qualities our founder valued: ambition, cunning, resourcefulness, and a certain... disregard for rules that don't serve your purposes."
Several of the first-years chuckled nervously. Severus remained stone-faced, watching Malfoy with the detached interest of someone who had witnessed this man's future and found it wanting.
"In Slytherin, you'll make connections that will serve you throughout your lives. We protect our own. We advance together. Remember that outside these walls, the other houses are united against us. They call us dark. They fear what they don't understand, our willingness to do what's necessary to achieve greatness."
Severus noticed Avery and Mulciber hanging on Lucius's every word, their eyes shining with the promise of belonging to something exclusive and powerful. He'd once looked the same way.
"Your blood and your heritage matter here, " Lucius continued, his gaze sweeping over them. "But so does your ability to bring honor to Slytherin. Win points. Excel in your studies. Show the school that ambition breeds excellence."
Lucius paused, then pointed to a bulletin board. "House rules are posted there. Curfew is strictly enforced. Professor Slughorn holds monthly gatherings for his favorites, the Slug Club. It's worth getting an invitation. Now, dormitories are through those passages, girls to the left, boys to the right."
As the group began to disperse, Severus noticed Lucius making his way toward certain first-years, those from known pure-blood families. He watched as Malfoy clapped Avery on the shoulder, whispered something to Mulciber that made the boy stand taller, and exchanged pleasantries with Rosier about his father's recent Ministry appointment.
Severus stood apart, observing. In his first life, he'd desperately wanted that acknowledgment, that subtle nod that said he belonged despite his half-blood status. He'd worked twice as hard to prove his worth, his knowledge of the Dark Arts, his disdain for Muggles, all to earn the approval of boys like Malfoy.
Now, as Lucius systematically worked the room, Severus realized he was being deliberately bypassed. The prefect's eyes slid over him as if he were merely part of the stone wall. It was a calculated slight, not overt enough to be challenged, but clear enough to establish hierarchy.
"Feeling left out, Snape?" Evan Rosier sidled up to him, voice low. "Malfoy knows everyone worth knowing. Everyone whose family matters."
"And yet he spoke to you, " Severus replied mildly, watching Rosier's face flush with anger before the boy mastered himself.
"My father sits on the Wizengamot, " Rosier hissed. "What does yours do? Oh wait, he's a Muggle, isn't he?"
Severus met Rosier's gaze evenly. "And my mother is a Prince. One of the oldest pure-blood families in Britain. I suggest you check your facts before attempting to insult someone, Rosier. It makes you look... uninformed."
He turned away before Rosier could respond, heading toward the boys' dormitory passage. He could feel eyes on his back, not just Rosier's, but others. Good. Let them wonder. Let them question. This time, he wouldn't be so desperate for their approval that he'd sacrifice his soul for it.
The first-year boys' dormitory was a long, rectangular room with five four-poster beds draped in green silk hangings. Severus located his trunk at the foot of the bed furthest from the door, the same bed he'd occupied in his previous life. Some things, it seemed, remained constant across timelines.
As he opened his trunk to retrieve his nightclothes, the other boys filtered in: Avery, Mulciber, Rosier, and Wilkes. They spoke in excited whispers about Lucius Malfoy, about the common room, about the power they'd wield as Slytherins.
"Did you see how that Gryffindor prefect practically jumped out of our way?" Mulciber laughed. "They know better than to cross us."
"Malfoy says his father can get us box seats for the Quidditch World Cup next summer, " Avery added. "If we prove ourselves worthy of Slytherin, that is."
Severus changed into his nightclothes silently, listening. This was the beginning, the moment when alliances formed, when the foundations of what would become the Death Eaters were laid in childish boasts and promises of privilege.
"What about you, Snape?" Wilkes called out. "Awful quiet over there."
Severus glanced up, finding four pairs of eyes fixed on him. "Just thinking."
"About what?" pressed Rosier, clearly still smarting from their earlier exchange.
"About what the Sorting Hat told me, " Severus said carefully. "It said Slytherin would help me on the path to greatness."
"Well, of course it did, " Mulciber snorted. "That's what Slytherin is for."
"Yes, " Severus agreed, sitting on his bed. "But greatness isn't what most people think it is."
The boys exchanged glances. "What do you mean?" Avery asked.
"True power isn't about who you know or what family you come from, " Severus said, his voice soft but carrying in the quiet room. "It's about what you know. What you can do that others can't. What you understand that others don't."
He drew his wand, his old, familiar ebony wand that felt both strange and right in his small hand, and with a casual flick, extinguished the lamp nearest his bed.
"Magic is magic, " he continued in the semi-darkness. "And those who master it best will always rise to the top, regardless of their beginnings."
There was a moment of silence as his words sank in. Then Wilkes laughed nervously. "You're a weird one, Snape."
"Maybe, " Severus conceded, drawing his bed curtains closed. "But you'll remember what I said."
Alone behind the emerald drapes, Severus finally allowed himself to exhale. He stared up at the canopy, mind returning to the Sorting Hat's warning. For each life saved, another sacrificed. He'd come back to save Lily, to prevent her death at Voldemort's hands. But what would be the cost? Whose life would balance the scales?
And what of the seven sevens? Forty-nine... something. A deadline? A window of opportunity?
Severus closed his eyes, focusing on his Occlumency to quiet his racing thoughts. One day at a time. He'd navigate this maze of the past with caution and precision. He'd avoid the pitfalls that had claimed him before. He'd save Lily without losing himself.
But as sleep finally claimed him, the Sorting Hat's words twisted through his dreams like serpents: Watch the moon when seven sevens align... watch the moon... watch...
Severus woke before dawn, a habit forged from decades of rising early to brew delicate potions requiring the first light of day. For a disorienting moment, he expected to see the stark stone walls of his adult quarters. Instead, the emerald silk hangings of the Slytherin dormitory greeted him.
Eleven years old. Again.
He slipped from bed and padded to the bathroom, avoiding the creaking floorboard he remembered from his first life. The face in the mirror was jarring, sallow skin stretched over childish features, the hook of his nose not yet fully formed, his dark eyes too large for his face. Not the weathered visage of the man who had died in the Shrieking Shack, but the boy who had yet to make all those mistakes.
When he returned to the dormitory, the others were still sleeping. Severus dressed quickly, his fingers fumbling with the unfamiliar smallness of his uniform. He needed to plan, to strategize. Slytherin House was a viper pit even for first-years, and he had already marked himself as different.
The common room was nearly empty at this hour, just two seventh-years studying in the corner and a solitary figure by the window. Narcissa Black stood with her back to the room, gazing out at the murky waters of the lake. Even at sixteen, she carried herself with the poise of ancient nobility.
"You're up early, " she said without turning, somehow sensing his presence.
"As are you, " Severus replied, keeping his distance. In his first life, Narcissa had barely acknowledged his existence until he became useful to the Dark Lord.
She turned, studying him with cool blue eyes. "You're the half-blood. Snape."
He inclined his head slightly. "And you're Narcissa Black. Second daughter of the House of Black."
A flicker of surprise crossed her features. "You know your wizarding genealogy."
"I know what matters, " Severus said carefully. "And who."
Narcissa's lips curved into the ghost of a smile. "Lucius says you defended a Mudblood at dinner."
"I recognized talent, " Severus corrected. "Wasting magical potential based on birth seems... inefficient."
"Interesting perspective." She moved away from the window. "Most first-years don't speak so... precisely."
Severus realized his error, his vocabulary and diction were too advanced. He needed to temper his speech patterns to match his apparent age. "My mother taught me to value words, " he said, deliberately simplifying his language.
"Your mother, the Prince witch who married a Muggle." Narcissa made it sound like a clinical observation rather than an insult. "A curious choice."
"We don't always choose wisely, " Severus replied, thinking of his own life's mistakes. "But we can learn from poor choices."
Narcissa studied him for a long moment. "Indeed. Breakfast begins soon. The prefects will lead the first-years up in thirty minutes."
With that, she glided past him toward the girls' dormitories, leaving behind the faint scent of narcissus flowers. Severus exhaled slowly. Narcissa had always been the most observant of the Black sisters, not as volatile as Bellatrix or as rebellious as Andromeda. She saw things others missed.
He would need to be more careful.
By evening, Severus had survived his first day of classes, a surreal experience of pretending to learn magic he had mastered decades ago. He'd carefully moderated his performance, showing aptitude without revealing mastery. In Charms, he'd allowed his feather to wobble before rising, despite knowing he could have silently levitated every object in the classroom. In Transfiguration, he'd transformed his match into a needle on his second attempt rather than his first, earning an approving nod from McGonagall.
Only in Potions had he permitted himself to excel, producing a perfect boil-cure potion that had Slughorn beaming with delight. "My boy, you have your mother's touch with the cauldron!" the professor had exclaimed, already mentally adding Severus to his collection.
Now, as students gathered in the common room after dinner, Severus positioned himself strategically, close enough to observe the central players, yet not so close as to appear eager for inclusion. He selected a high-backed chair near the fireplace, a battered copy of Advanced Potion-Making open on his lap. The same textbook he would one day annotate as the Half-Blood Prince.
"Already reading ahead, Snape?"
Severus looked up to find Lucius Malfoy standing before him. The future Death Eater's face was unlined, his eyes unclouded by the failures and humiliations that would one day haunt him.
"Knowledge is power, " Severus replied simply.
Lucius's mouth quirked. "So they say." He gestured to the chair opposite. "May I?"
Severus nodded, closing his book. This was unexpected, in his first life, Lucius had barely noticed him until third year, when Severus's facility with hexes had caught his attention.
"I've been watching you today, " Lucius said, settling into the chair with aristocratic grace. "You're... not what I expected."
"And what did you expect?"
"Another desperate half-blood trying to erase his origins." Lucius leaned forward. "But you're different. You don't apologize for what you are."
Severus met his gaze steadily. "Would apologies change anything?"
Lucius laughed, a genuine sound of surprise. "No, I suppose not." He studied Severus with new interest. "You know, Slytherin values ambition above all. Blood matters, of course, but power matters more."
"And intelligence?" Severus asked. "Does Slytherin value that?"
"Cunning, certainly." Lucius gestured toward where Mulciber and Avery were loudly recounting their Transfiguration class. "Raw intelligence without direction is useless. Look at those Ravenclaws, full of facts but no vision. No, Slytherin values intelligence applied toward worthy goals."
"And what goals do you consider worthy?" Severus asked, though he already knew the answer.
Lucius's expression grew serious. "The preservation of our world. The maintenance of traditions that have kept magic strong for centuries. The recognition that some are born to lead, and others to follow."
Severus nodded slowly, as if considering these ideas for the first time. "And where do half-bloods fit in this vision?"
"That depends on the half-blood, " Lucius replied carefully. "Some understand their place in the natural order. Others... rebel against it."
Before Severus could respond, a commotion erupted near the entrance. Evan Rosier had cornered a small second-year boy, wand pointed at the younger student's chest.
"Say it again, " Rosier demanded. "Tell everyone what you told your Hufflepuff friend."
The second-year trembled. "I, I didn't mean, "
"He said Slytherins aren't really the cleverest house, " Mulciber announced, appearing at Rosier's side. "Said Ravenclaw deserved that title."
A crowd was gathering now. Severus watched as Narcissa Black exchanged a look with her sister Andromeda, who had yet to be disowned for marrying Ted Tonks. The elder Black sister moved toward the confrontation, but Lucius held up a hand, stopping her.
"Let them handle it, " he murmured. "First-years need to establish hierarchy."
Severus set his book aside. "Is that what this is about? Hierarchy?"
"Everything is about hierarchy, " Lucius replied. "Surely you understand that."
Rosier had now forced the second-year to his knees. "Apologize to Slytherin House, " he demanded.
Severus stood. This, too, was different from his first life. Then, he would have watched silently, perhaps even joined in the torment to prove his loyalty. Now, he saw it for what it was, petty cruelty masquerading as house pride.
"Enough, Rosier, " he said, his voice cutting through the common room.
All eyes turned to him. Rosier's face flushed with anger. "Stay out of this, Snape."
"You're embarrassing our house, " Severus continued, approaching the group. "Terrorizing children doesn't demonstrate cleverness, it shows a lack of imagination."
Mulciber stepped forward. "Who do you think you are?"
"Someone who understands the difference between power and pettiness." Severus turned to the second-year. "Go to your dormitory."
The boy hesitated, looking between Severus and his tormentors.
"Now, " Severus said firmly.
The second-year scrambled to his feet and fled. Rosier turned on Severus, wand raised. "You've got some nerve, "
"I've got sense, " Severus interrupted. "Something you clearly lack if you think this display impresses anyone who matters."
He was aware of the entire common room watching, Lucius with calculating interest, Narcissa with cool assessment, the other first-years with varying degrees of shock and confusion.
"You defending Mudbloods and blood traitors now?" Mulciber demanded.
"I'm defending Slytherin's reputation, " Severus replied evenly. "True power doesn't need to be announced with petty displays. It's recognized without effort."
Rosier lowered his wand slightly, uncertainty creeping into his expression. "You think you know something about power, half-blood?"
"I know more than you imagine, " Severus said quietly. "And I know that true Slytherin ambition requires patience, subtlety, and intelligence, not bullying children for having opinions."
He turned and walked back to his chair, heart pounding despite his outward calm. This was not how his first week had gone in his original life. He was changing things already, perhaps too quickly, too dramatically.
As he reclaimed his seat, he caught Lucius watching him with newfound interest.
"Curious, " the prefect murmured. "Very curious indeed."
Years passed like drifting shadows beneath the Black Lake. The fire that once flickered in Severus Snape's heart, fueled by fear, fury, and regret, was slowly refined into something colder, sharper. Hogwarts remained the same in its bones, but Severus was a different creature entirely. He had grown into his magic with a quiet intensity, mastering potions, theory, and restraint.
Severus adjusted his prefect badge as he sat alone in the Slytherin compartment of the Hogwarts Express, watching the countryside blur past the window. Fifth year. O.W.L. year. The year that, in another lifetime, he had severed his friendship with Lily forever with a single, unforgivable word.
Not this time.
Four years of careful navigation had transformed him from an oddity into something of a legend within Slytherin House. They called him "The Prince" now, a nod to his mother's lineage, yes, but also to the quiet authority he wielded. He was not beloved like Lucius had been, nor feared like Mulciber wanted to be. He was respected, which was far more valuable.
The compartment door slid open, and Evan Rosier entered, followed by Avery and Mulciber. All three had grown taller, broader, their childish features hardening into the men they would become. Men who, in another life, had taken the Dark Mark alongside him.
"Holding court alone, Prince?" Rosier asked, dropping into the seat across from Severus.
"Enjoying the silence, " Severus replied, his voice deeper now, controlled. "A rare commodity around you three."
Mulciber laughed, a harsh sound. "Someone's in a mood. Summer with your Muggle father that bad?"
Severus merely raised an eyebrow. He'd long ago learned that neither confirming nor denying their jabs about his parentage gave them less ammunition. His carefully cultivated mystique, enhanced by his exceptional academic performance and his growing collection of self-invented spells, had earned him a strange position in the Slytherin hierarchy. Not quite one of them, but not an outsider either.
"Heard you spent half the summer with Lucius Malfoy, " Avery said, watching him closely. "At Malfoy Manor."
This was true. Lucius, now three years graduated and rising quickly in the Ministry, had taken an interest in Severus's talents. In his first life, that mentorship had led directly to the Dark Lord's inner circle. This time, Severus had different plans.
"Lucius appreciates intelligence, " Severus said simply. "Unlike some."
Rosier's eyes narrowed. "And does he appreciate your continued friendship with that Mudblood Evans?"
The word still made Severus's blood run cold, but he showed nothing on his face. In this timeline, he had never adopted the slur, never let it pass his lips even to appease his housemates. It was a small change that had rippled outward in unexpected ways.
"Lily Evans is the most talented witch in our year, " Severus replied coolly. "Only a fool would ignore that because of her parentage."
"She's still a Gryffindor, " Mulciber pressed. "And Potter's been sniffing around her since third year."
"Potter, " Severus said, the name still tasting bitter despite his efforts, "is a mediocre wizard with an inflated sense of importance."
This, at least, hadn't changed. James Potter and his band of Marauders remained a thorn in Severus's side, though the dynamics had shifted. Without Severus's initial hostility on the train, their animosity had developed more slowly, building from rivalry rather than instant hatred. Potter still hexed him when opportunity arose, but Severus, with the advantage of adult experience and wandless magic, was no longer an easy target.
And Lily... Lily remained his friend. His best friend. The miracle he'd worked four years to preserve.
"Speaking of our Gryffindor classmates, " Rosier said, leaning forward, "there are rumors about Lupin."
Severus stiffened imperceptibly. Remus Lupin's lycanthropy was one secret he'd kept closely guarded in this timeline. In his first life, he'd been obsessed with exposing Lupin, convinced it would finally turn Lily against the Marauders. Now, with the wisdom of years, he recognized the cruelty in that plan.
"Rumors?" he asked, voice neutral.
"Disappearing every month. The excuses about his sick mother. Avery's cousin at the Ministry says Dumbledore made special arrangements for a student with a 'condition.'"
Severus shrugged. "Lupin's affairs are his own."
"You're not curious?" Mulciber pressed. "You, who notices everything?"
"I notice what matters, " Severus replied. "Lupin's monthly activities don't concern me."
The conversation shifted to O.W.L.s, to Quidditch prospects, to the usual start-of-term gossip. Severus participated minimally, his mind elsewhere. Fifth year was pivotal, not just academically, but strategically. The war that would claim Lily's life was building momentum beyond Hogwarts' walls. Voldemort was gathering followers, spreading his ideology. Severus needed to position himself carefully if he hoped to alter the course of events.
The compartment door slid open again, revealing Narcissa Black, now in her seventh year and Head Girl. Her blonde hair was twisted into an elegant knot, her robes impeccable.
"Prefect meeting in five minutes, Severus, " she said, her cool gaze sweeping over the others with polite disinterest.
Severus nodded, rising. His appointment as prefect had surprised no one, he maintained top marks in nearly every subject and had cultivated a reputation for enforcing Slytherin's internal rules with uncompromising fairness. What had surprised some was his refusal to abuse the position, a restraint that baffled Mulciber and Avery.
"Give my regards to your sister, " Rosier called to Narcissa as Severus followed her out. "I hear she and Rodolphus are planning a winter wedding."
Narcissa's expression didn't change, but Severus noted the slight tightening around her eyes. Bellatrix's marriage to Rodolphus Lestrange was a political alliance, one that would cement both families' allegiance to the Dark Lord. In his first life, Severus had attended that wedding as Lucius's guest, watching as Narcissa smiled placidly beside her fiancé while her sister pledged herself to a man she barely tolerated.
"My sister's arrangements are her own affair, " Narcissa replied smoothly, continuing down the corridor.
When they were out of earshot, she glanced at Severus. "You've changed, you know."
Severus raised an eyebrow. "Have I?"
"When you were a first-year, I thought you were playing some elaborate game, a half-blood with the confidence of an ancient bloodline. But it's not an act, is it?" She studied him with those perceptive blue eyes. "You genuinely don't care what they think."
"I care about what matters, " Severus replied, echoing his words from four years ago.
Narcissa's lips curved slightly. "And what matters to you, Severus Snape? Not blood purity, clearly, given your continued association with the Evans girl. Not house loyalty alone, or you'd have joined Mulciber's little crusade against Muggle-borns. Not even power for its own sake, or you'd have leveraged your talents differently."
They had reached the prefects' carriage, but Narcissa paused outside the door, awaiting his answer.
Severus considered her carefully. Narcissa Black was no Death Eater, not yet and not ever. In his first life, she had stood by Lucius out of family duty, but her true loyalty had always been to her son. She understood survival in ways the others didn't.
"What matters, " he said finally, "is having the freedom to choose one's own path."
Something flickered in her eyes, recognition, perhaps. "An unusual philosophy for a Slytherin."
"Perhaps, " Severus conceded. "But ambition without autonomy is just another form of servitude."
Narcissa regarded him for a long moment before opening the compartment door. "You might be the most dangerous person I know, Severus Snape, " she murmured. "Because you actually believe that."
Inside the prefect carriage, students from all four houses were gathering. Severus noted Remus Lupin among the Gryffindors, looking tired but less ragged than he would appear in later years. Lily was there too, her prefect badge gleaming against her robes, her dark red hair falling in waves around her shoulders.
When she saw him, her face lit up with a smile that still, after all these years, made his heart stutter. She crossed the compartment to stand beside him.
"Prefect Snape, " she said, green eyes dancing with amusement. "Ready to terrorize first-years with your glare of doom?"
"I reserve my glare for deserving targets, " he replied, the corner of his mouth lifting slightly. "First-years are merely annoying, not malicious."
Lily laughed, the sound drawing glances from the other prefects. Few understood their friendship, the Slytherin and the Gryffindor, the pure-blood scion (as many mistakenly assumed given his bearing) and the Muggle-born witch. But Severus had protected this bond with every ounce of his considerable will, refusing to let house rivalries or peer pressure sever what had been lost in another life.
"How was your summer?" she asked, lowering her voice as the Head Boy began the meeting. "Your letters were... sparse."
"Occupied, " Severus murmured. "Between Malfoy Manor and my mother's illness."
Lily's expression softened with concern. In this timeline, Eileen Prince still lived, though her health had deteriorated over the years. Severus had used his growing knowledge of potions to ease her suffering, to buy her time that she hadn't had before.
"We'll talk later?" Lily asked as the Head Boy called for their attention.
Severus nodded, his expression softening in a way reserved solely for her. "Always."
The prefect meeting concluded with the usual instructions about patrolling schedules and responsibilities. Severus listened with half an ear, mentally cataloging the information while observing the dynamics between the other prefects. Remus Lupin kept stealing glances at him, wary, calculating looks that suggested the werewolf hadn't forgotten their strange encounter in third year when Severus had "accidentally" left a book about wolfsbane potions where Lupin would find it.
Outside the compartment, the corridor had grown crowded with students searching for friends or purchasing treats from the trolley witch. Severus and Lily stepped out together, immediately drawing curious stares.
"First patrol tonight after the feast, " Lily said, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear. "I was thinking we could compare notes on the Potions summer reading? Slughorn's essay prompt was deliberately vague."
"Deliberately challenging, " Severus corrected. "He's separating those who merely follow instructions from those who understand principles."
Lily grinned. "So you've already finished it, then?"
"Two weeks ago."
"Show-off." She nudged his arm playfully, a gesture that would have once made his younger self freeze with awkward pleasure. Now, he accepted it with the ease of long friendship.
A sharp laugh cut through their conversation. Further down the corridor, James Potter was holding court with the other Marauders, his prefect badge conspicuously absent. When he spotted Lily with Severus, his expression darkened almost imperceptibly.
"Evans!" he called, running a hand through his perpetually messy hair. "We've saved you a seat in our compartment."
Lily glanced at Potter, her expression cooling slightly. "Thanks, but I've already made arrangements."
Potter's gaze shifted to Severus, hazel eyes narrowing behind his glasses. "Still slumming with Snape, then?"
The corridor quieted, students sensing the tension. In his first life, Severus would have reached for his wand, eager to hex Potter at the slightest provocation. Now, he merely raised an eyebrow, his posture relaxed but vigilant.
"Careful, Potter, " Lily said, her voice carrying in the silence. "That prefect badge I'm wearing means I can assign detentions for disrespectful language."
Sirius Black stepped forward, his aristocratic features arranged in a sneer that reminded Severus uncomfortably of Bellatrix. "Come off it, Evans. Everyone knows Snivellus only got that badge because Slughorn's collecting Slytherins with talent. Even half-bloods."
Outside Slytherin, things were more complicated. While Severus had carefully cultivated his position within his house, the Marauders remained a persistent thorn in his side. They had never forgotten or forgiven his first-year rebuff of their "friendship" offer, viewing his continued relationship with Lily as a personal affront to James's pursuit of her.
"Black, " Severus said evenly, speaking for the first time, "your dedication to proving my point about maturity is admirable, if misguided."
Sirius's hand twitched toward his wand. "Big words from someone who hides behind his Slytherin cronies."
"I'm standing right here, " Severus pointed out dryly. "Hardly hiding."
Remus Lupin stepped forward, placing a restraining hand on Sirius's shoulder. "We should find our compartment, " he said quietly. "This isn't the place."
Severus met Lupin's gaze steadily. Of all the Marauders, Remus was the most reasonable, and the most dangerous, though few knew it. In this timeline, Severus had made a point of treating Lupin with cautious neutrality, neither seeking his friendship nor antagonizing him about his condition.
"Moony's right, " James said, though his eyes remained fixed on Lily. "We'll catch up at the feast, Evans. Save you a seat?"
"I'll sit with Mary and Alice, thanks, " Lily replied, her tone making it clear the discussion was over.
As the Marauders moved away, Sirius glanced back, his gray eyes cold with dislike. "Watch yourself, Snape, " he muttered, just loud enough for Severus to hear.
Severus inclined his head slightly, neither acknowledgment nor dismissal. He'd learned that sometimes the most powerful response was no response at all.
When they were alone again, Lily sighed. "They're getting worse, not better. I thought by fifth year they might have grown up a bit."
"Potter wants what he can't have, " Severus replied, resuming their walk down the corridor. "And Black follows his lead in all things."
"I'm not a thing to be had, " Lily said sharply.
"Precisely why he can't have you, " Severus agreed, allowing himself a small smile.
They reached an empty compartment and settled in, the tension from the encounter with the Marauders gradually fading as they discussed their summer reading,
Slughorn's likely first assignments, and Lily's family news. Severus listened attentively as she described her sister Petunia's new boyfriend, "absolutely dreadful, Sev,
like a walrus in a suit", and her parents' pride in her prefect appointment.
"And your mother?" Lily asked softly. "How is she really?"
Severus's expression sobered. "Stable. The potions I've been brewing help with the pain, but they can't cure what's wrong with her."
"Which is?"
"Years of magical suppression, " Severus said, the words bitter on his tongue. "Living with my father... she stopped using magic to avoid his rages. Magic isn't meant to be contained that way. It turns inward, becomes corrosive."
Lily reached across the space between them, taking his hand. Her touch was warm, grounding. "I'm sorry, Sev. I know how much she means to you."
In his first life, Eileen had died during his sixth year at Hogwarts, a quiet, unremarkable passing that Severus had learned about via owl post from a neighbor. He'd attended her funeral alone, standing in the rain as they lowered her simple coffin into the ground, his father already drunk at home.
This time, he'd been able to ease her suffering, to show her that her son had become someone worthy of the Prince name. It wasn't enough, nothing could undo the decades of abuse and neglect, but it was something.
"I've been researching healing potions beyond the standard curriculum, " Severus said, allowing himself to lean slightly into Lily's support. "There are references in some of the older texts to brews that can repair magical damage."
"Dark texts?" Lily asked, her voice free of judgment but tinged with concern.
"Not all ancient magic is dark, " Severus replied carefully. "Some is simply... forgotten. Deemed too complex or too powerful for general use."
Lily studied him, her green eyes searching his face. "Just be careful, Sev. You know how some of those old potions can have unexpected consequences."
He nodded, grateful for her concern rather than condemnation. This was the difference between this timeline and the last, Lily's steady presence as his moral compass, gently questioning without accusation.
"Speaking of unexpected, " Lily said, changing the subject, "I noticed Narcissa Black seems to have taken you under her wing. That's new."
Severus shrugged. "We share certain... perspectives."
"On what?"
"The value of independence."
Lily looked skeptical. "Narcissa Black? The same girl who's practically been engaged to Lucius Malfoy since birth?"
"There are different kinds of independence, " Severus said quietly. "Not all rebellions are as obvious as your Gryffindor displays of defiance."
The conversation drifted to lighter topics as the train continued its journey north. Outside their compartment, students moved back and forth, some peering in curiously at the unlikely pair, the Slytherin prefect and the Gryffindor prefect, seemingly comfortable in each other's company despite house rivalries.
What they couldn't see was the silent calculation happening several compartments away, where the Marauders had gathered to plot their fifth year of mischief and mayhem.
"I don't like it, " James Potter was saying, pacing the small space. "Snape's got her completely fooled with this 'reformed Slytherin' act."
Sirius lounged across one bench, his casual posture belied by the intensity in his eyes. "He's still hanging around Mulciber and Avery. I saw them at Malfoy Manor this summer when I was staying with my uncle Alphard."
"What was Snape doing at Malfoy Manor?" Peter asked, looking up from the chocolate frog card he'd been examining.
"What do you think?" Sirius scoffed. "Lucius Malfoy's recruiting for You-Know-Who. Everyone knows it, even if the Ministry's turning a blind eye."
Remus, who had been quietly reading by the window, closed his book. "We don't know that Severus is involved in anything like that."
"Oh, come off it, Moony, " James said impatiently. "Snape's been obsessed with the Dark Arts since first year. Just because he's clever enough to hide it around Evans doesn't mean he's not involved."
"He's never actually used Dark Magic at school, " Remus pointed out. "Not that we've seen."
"That we've caught him at, " Sirius corrected. "Remember that hex he used on Bertram Aubrey last year? Made his head swell to twice its normal size. That wasn't in any standard spellbook."
Peter nodded eagerly. "And he's always writing in that potions textbook of his. Probably inventing nasty curses."
Remus looked unconvinced. "Creating spells isn't inherently dark."
"It is when Snape does it, " James insisted, running a hand through his hair again. "Look, we all know what Slytherin's like these days. They're practically holding Death Eater recruitment meetings in their common room."
"And Evans is still friends with him, " Sirius added, his tone suggesting this was the most damning evidence of all.
James's expression darkened further. "That's what worries me. She doesn't see what he's really like."
"Or maybe she sees something we don't, " Remus suggested quietly.
The compartment fell silent as the others considered this unwelcome possibility. James resumed his pacing, his mind clearly working through scenarios where he could expose Snape's true nature to Lily.
"We need to watch him more closely this year, " he finally declared. "Find proof of what he's up to with Malfoy and the others."
Sirius sat up, his expression brightening with the prospect of action. "I've been thinking about that. What if we created a map of Hogwarts? Something that would show where everyone is at all times?"
"Is that even possible?" Peter asked, eyes wide.
"With the right charms, yeah, " Sirius said, warming to his idea. "We could track Snape's movements, see if he's sneaking off to forbidden areas or meeting with known dark wizards."
Remus looked thoughtful. "The magic would be complex. Location charms, identity revealing spells, not to mention mapping the entire castle..."
"But you could do it, right, Moony?" James pressed. "With your charms expertise?"
"Possibly, " Remus admitted. "With all of us working together."
"Then it's settled, " James said, his expression shifting from brooding to determined. "This year, we find out what Snivellus is really up to. And when we do, Evans will finally see him for what he is."
The Marauders' compartment buzzed with renewed energy as they began planning their surveillance project, unaware that the object of their suspicion was at that very moment helping Lily perfect her Potions essay, his dark past, and darker future, carefully hidden behind Occlumency shields and years of practiced deception.
As the first week of classes settled into rhythm, James Potter sat in the far corner of the Gryffindor common room, a chessboard between him and Sirius serving as convenient cover for their hushed conversation. The fire crackled in the hearth, casting long shadows across James's face as he watched Lily Evans work on her Charms essay by the window.
"It's getting worse, " James muttered, absently moving a pawn forward without strategic thought. "Did you see them in Potions today?"
Sirius glanced up from the board, following James's gaze to Lily. "Snape and Evans? Hard to miss. Slughorn practically swooned when they turned in that perfect Draught of Peace."
"It's not just that." James's fingers tightened around his knight. "It's how she looks at him."
The previous day's Potions class had been particularly galling. While most students struggled with the notoriously difficult Draught of Peace, Severus and Lily had worked in perfect synchronization, him adjusting ingredients with subtle precision, her stirring with practiced timing. When silver vapor had risen from their cauldron exactly as described in the textbook, Lily had turned to Severus with a smile of such open admiration that James felt physically ill.
"You're overthinking it, mate, " Sirius said, though his tone lacked conviction. "They've been friends since before Hogwarts. Doesn't mean anything."
"Doesn't it?" James knocked over Sirius's bishop with unnecessary force. "She defended him to Mary MacDonald yesterday. I heard them arguing about it in the corridor. Mary tried to warn her about Snape's Slytherin connections, and Evans shut her down completely."
Remus, who'd been pretending to read nearby, finally closed his book. "Perhaps she sees something in him we don't."
"Or perhaps she's being manipulated, " James countered, his voice hardening. "You've seen how he operates, all respectful and proper in front of professors and prefects, but I guarantee he's neck-deep in Dark Arts with Mulciber and the rest."
Peter, who'd been dozing in an armchair, perked up. "I saw him talking to Rosier after Defense yesterday. They looked... intense."
James nodded grimly. "Exactly. He's playing both sides, the perfect student, Lily's devoted friend, while secretly cozying up to future Death Eaters."
"We need to expose him, " Sirius said, leaning forward. "Force him to show his true colors where Evans can't ignore it."
"Dueling Club, " James said suddenly, his eyes lighting up behind his glasses. "Next meeting is Thursday. Flitwick always lets students volunteer for demonstration duels."
Remus frowned. "James, Snape's top of the year in Defense. Even you have to admit he's formidable."
"That's the point, " James replied, a plan crystallizing in his mind. "I'll challenge him publicly. He won't be able to refuse without losing face. And when we duel..."
"You'll provoke him into using Dark Magic, " Sirius finished, a slow grin spreading across his face. "With Lily watching."
"Exactly." James's expression hardened with determination. "No more Mr. Nice Guy. It's time Evans saw what her friend is really capable of."
"I don't know, " Remus said hesitantly. "If you push him too far, "
"That's exactly what I intend to do, " James cut him off. "Push him until that careful mask slips."
The Great Hall buzzed with excitement as students gathered for Thursday's Dueling Club. The long tables had been pushed aside, leaving a raised platform in the center where Professor Flitwick stood, explaining the evening's agenda.
Severus stood near the back, his face impassive as he scanned the crowd. His eyes found Lily easily, she always stood out to him, her vibrant presence drawing his attention like a beacon. She caught his gaze and smiled, raising an eyebrow in silent question. Dueling tonight?
He gave a slight nod. They often partnered during practice sessions, their contrasting styles making them both better duelists. Lily favored creative charm combinations, while Severus relied on precision and timing. Together, they challenged each other in ways that pushed their abilities without crossing into dangerous territory.
"For our demonstration duel, " Flitwick announced, his voice magically amplified, "do we have volunteers?"
James Potter's hand shot up immediately. "I'll volunteer, Professor."
"Excellent, Mr. Potter! And your opponent?"
James turned, his eyes finding Severus in the crowd. "I challenge Snape."
A murmur rippled through the assembled students. While challenge duels weren't uncommon, there was something in Potter's tone, something deliberate and provocative, that caught everyone's attention.
Severus stilled, his mind racing. This was new. In his previous life, he and Potter had dueled frequently, but always in unsanctioned corridor confrontations, never in the structured environment of Dueling Club. Potter's eyes gleamed with something beyond their usual rivalry, a calculated intensity that set Severus's instincts on high alert.
"Mr. Snape?" Flitwick looked toward him expectantly. "Do you accept?"
Declining wasn't an option, not without appearing weak before his Slytherin housemates. More importantly, refusing would leave Potter free to spread whatever narrative he wished about Severus's reluctance.
"I accept, " Severus said quietly, moving toward the platform.
As he passed Lily, she touched his arm briefly. "Be careful, " she whispered. "James looks... different tonight."
Severus nodded, the warmth of her concern steeling his resolve. This wasn't just about Potter's challenge, it was about what Potter hoped to accomplish. And from the smug anticipation on Black's face in the front row, Severus knew this was a coordinated effort.
They were setting a trap. And Lily was meant to witness whatever happened next.
