dungeonsanddads
patreon
[BONUS] Dad Then There Were None - Talking Dadatha
🕑 Added 2023-10-31 21:30:02 +0000 UTCThe Dad Crew is joined by special guests Amanda Schuckman, Elyse Willems, and Riley Rose Critchlow to break down the entire three-part murder mystery mini series.
They get into how Vince Vaughn was recording a podcast at the studios they were recording at right before they got there, the reaction to Will's rogue murder in the secret Murderer's Discord Chat, whether or not Freddie's bad accent work was justified, and what a sequel series might look like.
Listen to each episode here -- Episode 1 | Episode 2 | Episode 3
Or the Megacut of all three episodes here -- Megacut.
Attached are the character sketches Anthony and Amanda were talking about, thanks to @nesperus for the prescient work!
![[BONUS] Dad Then There Were None - Talking Dadatha](https://img5.patrefans.com/storage/5/pu/ue/563145-019e84c7-c66e-773a-bd3e-3c63f4edc6b7.png)
![[BONUS] Dad Then There Were None - Talking Dadatha](https://img5.patrefans.com/storage/1/go/yv/563145-019e84c7-c670-7fdf-8189-e29260cea823.jpg)
Comments
liam morin
johnny dollar reference lmao my mom listened to the old time radio podcast and has listened to all of those
Andrew Worthington
29:58 this reminds me of that show Numb3rs, so much fun back in school
Chris
DAD ON THE NILE. What tier do I have to subscribe to to get another one of these. This is my favorite thing the gang has ever done. edit: DadtectiveCon
Harlan elam
I loved this mini series and need to listen to it again now that I know who it was. So many funny parts in it
Brandon Curtis
I want more of this soon please!
Luna Luna
I’ve never seen Vertical Limit and have no idea what it’s about
Marbeline
Don't know if anyone else caught it but there was a point (around the time he really struggled with the accents out of character) where Freddie started with a British accent so I think the play that the character only had one good accent (British) makes sense
Shel B Kennas 1st fav sprite girl Loved returning to the Multiverse of Mavrus Happy Hogust Hoglidays to all nd to all a good tug
can we have barb on a Lusitania meets the terror mystery follow up?
Aimee Biggerstaff
Hoping y'all bring back Barb for another mystery one shot 🙏
Nubzly
Did the second “who done it” ever happen?
the chompie man
Love the idea of another detective ep. But after Beth putting me on house m.d via my phone listening in and showing me clips. I Want The House m.d case ep
Cassie Muldrow
I would listen to another mystery! Bring it!
Levi Mock
Please do this again. So wonderful. What a beautiful disaster. And yes. Make it longer.
Gabby Barnes
Loved it
Brandon Curtis
I cannot WAIT for another one of these
Luna Luna
I loved Amanda being so perfect murder, Beth being so Beth, and Will having this amazing character that was played really well
Trevin Sebek
More of this please!
Adam Puckey
I can't wait for the Detectacon Cruise series.
Marcell Szabó
I really hope that you guys will have an other murder centric mini series, and IMO Matt should be one of the detectives.
Kaleb Phillips
I absolutely loved this mini series. Loved the cast, the chemistry is just out of this world. Ngl though, if Will had his character shoot the dog, I probably would have stopped listening. Also glad to hear there are other people who appreciate Vertical Limit!
Boo
No matter what things go "awry"/unexpected, all of you make whatever the content a joy to listen to❤️ Looking forward to another mystery sleuthed by this group! Never disappointed by the characters thought up by each person here, they're always hilarious and fun🌟
Sonya Koloske
I seriously hope for more of this. I've relistened so many times and can't get enough. I really can't wait to have more of this group in the future
The Dragion
I love the idea of more of this can't wait
Lilyannifer
Yeah, in a novel it would totally work. But with the audio format it was impossible to notice two people not being in the same room, especially because there weren't more than one or two group scenes!
Lilyannifer
The double murderer plot is ridiculous, and there were not nearly enough hints (especially because the group wasn't together enough to notice those two not being in the same room, but that would have been really hard to achieve in a radio show format!) But I loved this because I love Christie, I love Ashley's depth and breadth of context, I love Will's deep and abiding commitment to characters. And also, Cards on the Table is 100% my favorite Agatha Christie novel. Yes, he looks at bridge scores a lot but he's not doing math about it, he's psychoanalyzing the players based on how they keep score and how they talk about the other players. Oh, but don't watch the David Suchet adaptation! They change the murderer and it's a whole mess. I am still mad about it, and it's been like seven years.
Yoka
What i dont understand: Is if they stole the rubys and took the identity of the person who had the ticket why did they need the 2nd Identity?
Sunny K
Not only am I beyond psyched to see a future installment of this with the same guests, I think it would be a blast to see the HRR crew in this setting as well for a future stretch goal! I owe this show a personal thanks for introducing me specifically to so many incredible comedians and writers, and I can’t wait to see Elyse and Riley and Amanda and old guests and new guests on the Patreon and main feed <33
Dj Travioli
I've listened to this series a million times just to hear Amanda say PEEEEPETRATOR. Like her fixing the pronunciation but not that the word is peRpetrator kills me. My partner and I randomly say it almost daily.
Tinyhumanbrain76
Please make it longer yesss
Tinyhumanbrain76
Same!!
Tinyhumanbrain76
YESS
Tinyhumanbrain76
DEF!!
Tinyhumanbrain76
I need more of this. Like soon plz
Tinyhumanbrain76
PLEASE DO DADS ON THE NEIAL !!! I loved Babs and I hope yall follow her
Josiah Muskrat
MORE OF THIS PLEASE All I want in the whole world is a Barb Boopsie cinematic universe.
Jordan Aguilar
Loved everything about this! Even Beth’s outro was perfect 👨🏽🍳🤌🏽
Teagan Turner
Great idea
Danielle Geary
Fun fact: the og Knives Out parlour scene was filmed in at the Ames Estate in Borderland State Park
Manta Ray Jack
Just concurring that more of the extended crew is definitely what we want!
Derek Kupper
1000% I support bringing Amanda and Riley and Elyse back repeatedly. They are all fantastic and their interactions with the main cast are fantastic. Please please please more of them.
Abs B
Please please please can we get dectectacon! We need Barb and Hannibel House MD
Katherine R.
yes yes YES, so pumped to see more like this I adore the concept and the crew is fantastic!
Matt Miller
There's an NPR show called The Big Broadcast that plays old radio dramas, including lots of Johnny Dollar. More proof that Will is a huge NPR nerd
Drednot
"The 3 other pieces of shit""there's four of us""he respects one of us" no no no, 3 of you are pieces of shit, one of you isn't even worth his time.
Damon Frost
Like just play werewolves with this cast. No mistakes and I want Amanda to break someone’s heart.
lilguy31
confused what was the two killers motivation
Ellen H.
May we all go into life with the same confidence as Beth with her “I’ll F*cking solve it this time!” 💕
B. J. Boyd
You need to let the boys sit one out and have Beth and these guest performers do a micro-season of “Mazes and Mommies. *not a kink podcast”
Shorty Ireland
Low key, womanizer Beth might be my favorite Beth so plz keep it up, sugar tits.
Stanley Johnson
Barb and sledge need to be in the next one plz lol 😆
Marie-Claire Bovet
Ah yeah i think the thing with potatoes is it makes their fur smell suuuper bad. Also: (besides all the love ofcourse) could you guys upload a list of your favorite must read / dnd inspiration books? So lovecraft and christie. And what else? 🧦📖🕯️
Broden Orr
Even after this, I still have no idea what happened in this series and I wouldn't have it any other way
rockL
I will listen the hell out of Oops! All Detectives. Also, I'm on my Poirot mode right now. I do a cycle of Poirot and Marple for comfort shows.
InsomniacArrest
Loved this series! Want more so bad
Gmork
I'm an insurance adjuster and now I'm bitter that the world has kept this from me until now.
Benjamin Brinckmann
I really loved this miniseries, though for a next one I would honestly really want the mystery to be solved at the end. I was also wondering whether you guys are familiar with the Dungeon World ttrpg system? Its got this really interesting mechanic where the players have these hidden relations/unresolved issues between each other characters. Resolving these issues results in a level up. Combat is also narrative driven rather than turn based, similar to what you've already been doing.
JeSuisBegToDiffer
The best Agatha Christie style revenge on Will would be to have him be the detective in another Whodunnit and for him to discover that literally everyone else is a murderer.
Brandon P
Please more Elise :>
Gmork
How have I never before heard of Johnny Dollar?! This is amazing.
Rebecca
I just want Beth to know I also thought it was an ice axe. I was thinking "damn do they have an iceberg to get ice for their drinks on this blimp that's so weird."
Ann M
Johnny Dollar! The agent with the action-packed expense account!
Gavin Lippitt
thanks for not telling me
Seaglassslipper
Please more House!
AutumnOpossum
Thank you for being brave enough to release the behind the episode for this, it was such a mess and I loved it so much!
The Overthinker
This was so much fun! Love you guys!
james carter
Use the ending audio for the next talking dads please.
Sunny Hornbaker
probably next week, they're recovering from sick and travel and stuff, but can't throw off the order and planning of episode/teen talk
tori
please i would kill for elyse as a detective. and in a million other things please.
Creekie05
Can the cruise be the titanic
James Curtiss
Wait when do we get new episode?
Steve
Love this mini series. Can’t wait for part two!
Tory Kähler
I really hope we get detectivecon
Caitlyn Russell
This was the best campaign, I loved it so much.
Gmork
Would definitely listen to more.
Tessa Bell
I need the snippet of them singing the outro as my ring tone now
Doot Doot
This series took first place on my fav mini campaigns. Previously AMOD
MissXis
Definitely my favorite mini series! I've listened to it at least 4 times!
Marc Wasserman
where are the sketches? how are they attached?
Kat Rooney
Loved this mini series!! My fav after Mountains of Dadness, really looking forward to another mystery
Amber Robertson
The man with the action-packed expense account! Johny Dollar
Bram
You clearly didn't listen to the end of the last normal episode (I had to relisten too)
Gavin Lippitt
is this 2 weeks in a row without a normal upload? was there a post about this somewhere?
Kason Escobedo
I want more. Y’all are strong.
Cass
I was so confused and this helped so much 😂 my adhd did not help me in following the story
Jen the Reaper
We all need Barbara Boopsy in our life, more please
Alex
Intro is so cursed from the spooky music to the twang of talking dads I love it
Erin
Absolutely down for Dad on the Nile
D Benza
What a total bumblefuck mouthful of a name
Diana
One more please!
M
Elyse W is just comedy gold everytime. Please invite her back.
Simon Robertson
I’ve been looking forward to this so much
