dungeonsanddads patreon

[BONUS] Dad Then There Were None - Ep. 3 - Whodumbit

🕑 Added 2023-10-13 04:00:04 +0000 UTC

Comments

Stonefreesofie

My god laughing my ass of looking like a crazy person on the bus 🤣

Emily Conyers

i don't know how anyone is saying the intended murders are unsolvable when the secret passage that they discovered after the body was dumped lead right to freddie lol

S

justice for Beth I also pictured the axe thing

Kimberly Spirdione

I loved this so much! Officially on my go to road trip listening list. I'd kill to get BLeeM on one of these one shots

Fixed 211

I love Beth so much🤣💕

Lilyannifer

I think Anthony actually says there are ten people on the launchpad waiting to board the blimp. He specifies there are two npc passengers who "don't matter" and are potential murder victims, but I just relistened as well and I'm almost positive he says there are ten people outside the blimp. Which is impossible unless unnamed crew members are also there. Anthony definitely references at least four crew people (two in the engine room, possibly more there, Cole, and Captain) then the six PCs, and two NPC passengers. And Freddie's fake character. Ten people on board isn't a hint, or a red herring, I think it's just an error. Don't get me wrong, I loved this miniseries. But the misdirection was very poorly done, even listening back knowing the reveal there's hardly any evidence. There just aren't enough group scenes, and it's too hard to make it clear someone is missing in an audio format! This would have worked very well on screen, and could have worked in a novel, but really didn't have a chance in an audio format.

Adam Puckey

I didn't think it went badly at all. It was hilarious!

Adam Puckey

This is Beth at her finest 😂

Ezra Raftery

please make it cannon that the post guy was actually on the titanic cause with the season 2 retcon of the titanic i can see a big “and i would’ve gotten away with it, if not for those darn kids” kinda interaction

BrianLeFev

Gutted the Lupus joke didn’t get a laugh gotta be honest. Thought the second time it’d get some yuks! This was awesome. Daddies team love yall

Daisy Terry

everyone roasting Beth for picturing a climbing ice pick I was certain it was a small blade made of ice 😭

Vincent Ortiz

I love that Beth was so committed to the bit it under cut her ability to solve the murder

Ash Wilkins

It’s okay, buddy, the cast couldn’t figure it out either. Stop reading for spoilers, but they explain at the end that Will’s character kind of messed up a lot by obviously murdering the German man, who was blackmailing him. The actual murderer was Amanda/Freddy’s character, an unnamed thief, who was disguised as Belinda and Billy. He killed Jules and Cole in order to get to the rubies in the safe after robbing other people around Europe, then using the blimp to escape to Greece.

Chungus Bombadil

I've listened to this 3 times now and I think it's because I'm autistic and dumb af but I don't understand who killed who. Can someone please elaborate?

SodaPop419

Beth just slays this entire mini series lol. She has everyone in stitches constantly.

Yoka

But they say "so you are waving at us" and he says "yes"

princeofmushrooms

I thought it was dot because at one point she says something along the lines of “now I’ll definitely have a role”

princeofmushrooms

I raised my hand 😂

Lea

This is my favorite thing ever. I'm so happy with how it ended. I love mysteries so much and this was perfect! Do it again!!

Rob Gibbons

36-24-36? Only if she’s 5’3”. - Sir Mix of A-Lot

Nikhol (Squeaky Beaver)

Beth May is a national treasure

Autumn Kamibayashiyama

I 100% was thinking an ice axe too

Dylan Yuste

As a climber, %100 thought it was an ice axe or ice tool 😂

FusRohNahSon

Say what u want about Hitler but the mail was always on time

Stanley Johnson

I love this series 😍😍

Manaia Palmer

honestly I think the episode is funnier with Will's accidental rulebreaking, even if it didn't go as planned this is one of my favourite bonuses so far (also I thought the same thing as beth about the ice pick lmao)

Jay

This is my favorite bonus yet I think 😂 amazing as always y'all 👌

The Overthinker

This ep is insanely funny already, but Beth just tapping out on the creepy bit full stop got me good.

DungeonBrat

Barb was one of the two detectives though, it was Haus and Barb

KT

Having recently read "And Then There Were None", I can confidently say that making the culprit lay everything out in an epilogue is true to form

DeviantRabbits

Talmon Glidden

I just want to say I was also imagining a mountaineering ice pick, you’re not alone Beth

Josiah Muskrat

This was fantastic!! MORE OF THIS PLEASEEEEE!!

Kawboolay

This is so funny because I thought it was Freddie the entire time. He was WAYYYY too quiet through this whole thing.

Aly Wise

will did nothing wrong!! other than break the rules, but still!!! nothing wrong!!!

Creekie05

That’s my head cannon

Aly Wise

oh my god, the one who won’t give taylor the package 💀

Leg of Egg

Started listening at work and in the opening scenes I was wondering what a d&d session would look like as Ben Shapiro as a secret SS supporter. Little did I know

Cecilia B

Not me pulling over to a BK drive through and the n4zi song starts playing REALLY LOUDLY on my speakers

forestofthorns

I loved this. I would not say no to more whodunits like this!

Kennedy Quick

wow, Matt’s character survived, I’m impressed

Lindsey Decker

This was such a fun and funny mini-series! Y'all are all incredible. 🤩

TheEnbyLad

I love this soooo much omg!!! Great job everyone!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Anna Deason

In defense of Beth, I also was thinking of a straight up pickaxe used for climbing ice

Matt

Best side series by far. Had me laughing out loud for all 3 episodes. Matt’s character was gold.

DungeonBrat

Literally screw anyone who doesn't love this. (I'm being hyperbolic, for the record) Not every single bonus series needs great pacing. There were 7 players plus Anthony all juggling their own storylines and goals, and they did phenomenally. This bonus is freakin' hilarious, and I think they did excellent considering how many people were playing and the actual module itself. Great work, keep it up, y'all <3

Jess Houwen

Absolutely brilliant.

Jesse Barbour

Freddy being all over the place with the voices is such a classic lol

Ellen H.

This was genuinely the most chaotic and hilarious who done it 😂😂

Kingsley Onumbu

This was genuinely amazing and I am really happy with the decisions everyone made

Ray Castillo

I see where anthony wanted this to go, i really do wish it went in that direction but not gonna lie will and beth did fuck this up 💀 i was really hoping to hear more from the amazing cast they brought together like elise. But it was still absolutely hillarious and intriguing. I hope they can do something like this agai. WIth the roles switched.

Gay Icon Yog-Sothoth

SPOILERS Thank god it was addressed! I was so confused about Billy and/or Dot just not being mentioned for very long segments. And what a hot mess! Absolutely loved it!

Elle S

I appreciated that point of clarification at the beginning. I was also thinking of an ice climbing pickaxe 😬

Jessica Jensen

OK, so I just finished it and I am confused about something. SPOILER What was the point of the murders? If they started out with the rubies, what was the point of the murders? Was it because the other guys were going to try to steal them? If they ALREADY owned the rubies they didn't have to steal them so what was the point? I might have to listen to the whole thing again to see if I can make more sense of it.

Kyra Sims

I was thinking the exact same thing!!!

Justin DeSilets

So damn funny hell yeah

Isaac A

Unless of course the con artist has a partner that is Melinda/milly billions

Isaac A

I guess my milly billions theory isn’t plausible anymore🥶

Creekie05

Spoiler……. Wills character straiten arrow or narrow is the racist mail clerk on the titanic

pboperation

CRYING with laughter oh my god no apologies needed this was exactly what I want from a dndads cast whodunit holy moly

joanna goanna

Don't apologize. I don't think this could have gone more perfectly. It's one of the funniest bonuses that has been released!!!

SlwDnceChbby

Cosmo ain't got nothin' to do with my selection Thirty-six, twenty-four, thirty-six Ha ha, only if she's 5'3

Cooper Benton

**SPOILER** So I just went back and listened to episode one after finishing this episode and Anthony even says that there's only 10 people on the blimp. But if you count the different people there's actually 11 (including the captain) he was dropping hints the whole time!

Trevor Hickey

Anyone else still confused about Detective House and his partner?

Collin Hoepf

Oh my god Elise absolutely killed the on the spot mispronunciations in a way that blew my mind every time.

Savannah Florence

This one was the best of the three. I was laughing out loud the entire time 🤣

koolkid239

Taco

Grahamy

It may have been an unsolvable mess but I think it’s my favorite mini-series

Shawn Edmond

Well didn’t see that coming

Caden Stovall

The giant reveal was amazing! But for some reason when I first heard the characters and their names I immediately attached them to a certain animal (for example straight and arrow was a crane and sledge was a bulldog) so it took me an embarrassingly long amount of time to put two and two together.

InsomniacArrest

I loved this cast so much 😭 would listen to an entire other episode with the exact same characters again too, would watch them fail at solving another murder 🥺

Michael Cassidy

Matt didn't die in this one. Good job.

Yadi bo Body

I knew Freddie was too quiet lol

Benjamin P Parson Gomberg

I missed it, what was the joke?

Anna Deas

The way you guys set that up was INCREDIBLE, I need to listen back for all the stuff I missed 😅 Great job ❤️

Kitt

This is why we love Will, amazing

Trevor Hickey

Love em, buy Will wa basically every DMs wordt nightmare

Julia Laurence

Not me falling for the red herring 😂

Damana

I’m glad I’m not the only one lmao

Drednot

You gotta do one of these again, and next time just tell Will NO

Kyle Barnes

Oh Will

B. J. Boyd

Utter chaos. This was amazing.

James H

The first 3 minutes were pure gold The remaining 44 were just unmitigated chaos 💯 🤣

Josiah Muskrat

I would pay twice my current Patreon for regular content with this cast. Such a fantastic arrangement.

Rogzilla

Alright. Well now I need to relisten to the whole thing because that was INSANE.

Magnus

This was absolutely crazy in the best way! All the twist and turns and delightful red herrings made it great! Please bring back all the guests again!

Lindsay

36-24-36? Only if she’s 5’3

JD Heisey

Will did absolutely nothing wrong, he was just being the best red herring in the world. Funniest bonus episode since sons and sonsibility

George Thomas

*SPOILER* I love how as Freddie’s character was a conn artist and was also played by Amanda they technically follow rule 5 🤦‍♂️😂

Beck

I think that with the amount of time they had they may not have solved it regardless and the red herring was a delight. Also I KNEW it was a voice recording omg

Marcy Brown

Every guest was incredible, please please please have them back for more things. I love RHoDnD 🥹

Alyssa Brake

This was amazing, so ridiculous and funny

Jennifer

Okay I was picturing an ice AXE too lmao

Hayden Klaumenzer

In Beth's defense I was also thinking the ice pick was the ice climbing axe.

Tay

I chose the worst thing to listen to while benching. I nearly dropped the bar on me because I was laughing too much 😂

Wheat

I hope everyone comes to Beth’s defense on that, I totally loved the summer joke and felt my heart stop when Freddie stopped her and I realized what it was.