Poll: Male Model

OhioOkie

I am more interested in the game than the actual pictures since he now have that educasted general serving him in such a submissive outfit.

nick

oh no. i'm not objecting to your style, i'm just offering opinion. honestly i don't know what you're after. whatever you decide to do is fine with me, but i am trying to help by adding more info. p.s. the changes i am suggesting are not me taking a shot at your ability; when i think of male elf villain, i think of kael'thas sunstrider from world of warcraft, so i compare tal'thelas to him.

tallytrix

That subtle revision has a huge impact, and I like it. Perhaps the lips could be a smidgen less full.

Proxxie

lol

PaddyOFurniture

Tried it. I think I see what you've done but I might just have an active imagination.

PaddyOFurniture

Ok.

Proxxie

It's much easier to see the differences if you flip directly between them in fullscreen. There isn't one huge difference, though, just a lot of small ones.

Proxxie

Edit: Most of the things you’re objecting to relate to stylistic decisions that I quite deliberately made. The females look like anime characters, and I want male elves to look like bishi anime characters.

PaddyOFurniture

Still don't see it but it's not a big deal. As long as everyone else is happy I'll just go along with it.

nick

incredible progress! a job well done, proxxie. keep in mind that everything looks great so far, but if more input is required to further improve the model (according to player opinion), then i have 2.5 more subtle adjustments that could help improve masculinity without sacrificing too much femininity. 1) larger/wider jawline. it looks great as it is, but it is looks smaller than what is easily identifiable for an adult male elf. a smooth jawline is fine, and demonstrates the biased feminine appearances elves have, but the size of his jaw seems more childlike currently. a little bit wider and perhaps more defined would show that he is a powerful male. stunningly beautiful, but still masculine (for an elf). 2) slightly larger, more defined nose bridge. same reason as above: his nose looks more like a child's nose, and less like a man's. arguably a nose can come in many different shapes and sizes at any age, so i'm now so sure how important this could be, but messing around with it could make the nose present a more masculine appearance overall. the nose doesn't really need to change shape, but it looks a little too weak at the moment, imo. 2.5) perhaps mouth being wider (along with wider jaw) and lips very slightly thinned. p.s. these are exactly the kinds of posts that make development so fun. they are hard work, but alpha/beta testing things makes the final result so much more valuable. p.p.s. the larger hands really help to make the male model feel more masculine too.

Sync

It takes a bit of looking, and the difference is subtle...but once you know it's there... The revised male models have the eyes moved a little closer together. And to me, that makes all the difference. :)

Vysirez

I do agree it might be a placebo effect, not that the pictures aren't different, just the differences I noticed are because I was told they are different and so I was looking for something. However I do think the second set of pictures are a tiny bit more angular, less soft/rounded. At least that is my impression the difference is small though.

I kind of do, but if you were to tell me a particular feature that is different, I wouldn't be able to tell you myself. I'm pretty sure his nose got a bit thinner though.

PaddyOFurniture

I honestly can't tell the difference between the two.

You know, I just realized, this is probably the placebo effect speaking to me, and Proxxie simply uploaded the two same images in an original and "revised" format. Nice try, Proxxie-boy, I'm onto you!

I like the revised one. The subtle change give him a hint of masculinity without taking away from his femininity. And that profile... could Tal...-whatever be our new companion? :O And if I was Alex, I would definitely shag his shirtless self. No homo! P.S. I enjoy the behind-the-scenes. They actually create the magic for me and makes me feel very engaged with the game.

Bane Uchiha

I thought the original one looked good, and i think the revised also looks good. I can't say one is better than the other, but i can say i'm looking forward to the next release.

Danielle

I like the revised one it has a touch more masculinity without going overboard just enough to say "I'm a male" though he still looks more like a half-elf then a full elf but I like it i wouldn't change a thing imo.

JustJustin

Now, I'm into girls, don't get me wrong, but the shirtless photo looks awesome as hell, wouldn't want to piss him off. Sad that Alex has done just that... I really like your art style, but it's making me like Tal now, he doesn't look evil, he looks like he could be a protagonist. They look very similar to me, blowing them up the only thing I was able to tell was that the revised one had eyebrow changes, overall they're both good, so go with whichever ends up with more I guess, I'm going for option 3.

Ver Greeneyes

The revised model looks better but still a bit awkward to me. I think the biggest thing that makes him look oddly feminine rather than just androgynous is his smooth, slender nose. I don't know if you can give him a stronger nose (with wider nostrils maybe) but that's what I would try tweaking. His lips also look a bit off to me.. or maybe it's the short distance between his mouth and nose. I dunno, hope this helps in some way.

Now that i'm looking at both of the picture, the original and the revised, i notice that he look more young in the original but the revised is more expressive. So my choose go for the revised one even if the original is good too.