gstdaisuki
patreon
A Discovery with Paul Hutchinson (Part 2)
🕑 Added 2024-03-30 22:22:11 +0000 UTCIn the middle of asking some questions via email, Paul discovered the source files for several modules that we had both assumed were lost. This was quite an exciting moment, so I wanted to share it separately.
the previous interview was formatted to remove the interleaved blocks of quoted text. this is presented in a more raw format, as I think that shows the discovery process better.
from anosci, Mar 11, 2024, 7:01PM
I had some more music questions.
The first two X-Men games had 33 and 45 RPM options for all of the music.
Do you remember how that made it into the game?
Because after hearing your tales of pirate radio and record shop digging, I feel pretty confident that this speed-select design was your idea!
Also, you previously shared the Amiga modules from X-Men 3, before the conversion to Game Gear data.
I believe that X-Men 3 was your final Game Gear game.
Was the “Amiga -> MIDI data” technique a new process, or did you do that for every preceding Game Gear game?
from Paul Hutchinson, Mar 11, 2024, 8:51PM
Yes, the 33/45 rpm option was my idea. :) Ed liked it. He keeps saying we should do a game together again, “before we die”. And he said it should have a retro flavour, and have weird dance music in it. Maybe one day we will do that, I am up for it. (I am considering doing a Pico-8 title at some point here.)
Hmm. I don’t think X-Men 3 was the only Amiga to MIDI data music I did. However, I don’t remember when the cross-over was. I would have to go back and check over everything. I’ll have a quick look and let you know if I actually find out, eh.
from Paul Hutchinson, Mar 11, 2024, 9:12PM
Ok, so I checked the ASM files. X-Men 1-3 all have music derived from Amiga MOD files. There is text denoting the MOD title, and names of the samples which were used in the MOD. If you are interested in more on that I can dig a bit more, and get you those names. They are samples from records I had at the time (Art Of Noise, Linx, etc.). Obviously, the Game Gear instruments were not the same sound.
from anosci, Mar 11, 2024, 10:12PM
I’m curious, at least! I’d love to hear the original MODs but I assume you were only able to find X-Men 3
from Paul Hutchinson, Mar 12, 2024, 9:04AM
Music! …
Ok, this is getting interesting. I see “babybeat” in the list of MODs used in X-Men 1. I found a playlist on YT with 10 tracks. In the menu of the game there are 8 tracks to preview. Track 10 on the playlist is 08 on the menu. Given the heartbeat type sound I hear, that is the most likely candidate for “babybeat”. Obviously, since there are 10 tracks in the playlist, and there are 10 references to MOD in the code, all of the tunes in the code were used in the game. Now I am not certain about the connection of this particular tune to “Midnight (Live)” by Orbital. It could be that it is another track that I posted, because I posted quite a few. Hmm. It’s what my memory says, but I could be wrong? In any case, it means that “babybeat” as a MOD was transferred from Amiga to PC. There is a chance I have it on the CD from 1999. I just need to find that, again. The MODs do sound quite different from the GG tunes, because it is samples vs sound-chip noises. I just tried to make something that sounded good enough when converted to GG format. There are no samples, for one thing, and the tempo is different. I had made some tunes on my Amiga, and then decided to present them as potential tracks for X-Men 1, and they were accepted (for subsequent X-Men titles I made tracks specifically, as denoted by the titles of the MODs). Normally, Sega would have a musician compose tracks for a game (in MIDI).
In-browser play of X-Men
https://archive.org/details/gg_X-Men_1993_Sega
Key 1 to start, arrow keys to navigate, and left-CTRL to play tune
Silence = 00
X-Men playlist, 10 tracks, (at 45 RPM?)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUmRxFtMhfI&list=PLw5ZGhvK7sSLqfx4HdldmkLPdFpM3pqFY
Track 1 = 01
Track 4 = 02
Track 6 = 03
Track 5 = 04
Track 7 = 05
Track 3 = 06
Track 2 = 07
Track 10 = 08
So, Track 8 and Track 9 (in the playlist) are not playable via the GG menu. Hmm. Title Screen and Ending Theme. Maybe we left off the Ending Theme because it was supposed to be a reward for finishing? Unless you just get it anyway, at Game Over (I do not recall). The Title Screen theme is just there. Oh, well.
In X-Men 1 …
;MOD Title is: renaissancegg
Samples = adamski2.raw ;chahihat.raw ;ahh.raw ;drum7 ;19hat ;tr909snare ;bassdeep.raw ;minor4
;MOD Title is: babybeat
Samples = shaker ;animate-bass ;aon-bongo1.raw ;GGbdrum.raw ;AoN-drm3.raw ;moog2 ;drumwack.raw ;SoSbass1.raw ;SoSstring2.raw ;SRdrm2.raw ;CHAhihat.raw
;MOD Title is: outgg
Samples = drum7 ;BHbass1.raw ;BHbass2.raw ;cymbal-crash ;chahihat.raw ;crash.raw ;jb-hhmed.raw ;hypnobass.raw ;BHacid1.raw ;BHacid2.raw ;BHacid3.raw ;out_there.raw
;MOD Title is: itchgg
Samples = linxvox.raw ;AoN-perc1.raw ;AoN-drm5.raw ;AoN-drm3.raw ;dancer-vox.raw ;dancer-synth1.raw ;scratch.raw ;KRAYScratch.raw ;cymbalong.raw ;hihat1 ;organ.raw ;drumanvil.raw
;MOD Title is: fishgg
Samples = Freq5.raw ;crash.raw ;DT4AAdrum2.raw ;DT4AAdrum.raw ;Freq1.raw ;SBpiano2.raw ;cymbalong.raw ;model500-cymop.raw ;futuresnare2 ;wavehi.raw ;N-JOImindflux.raw
;MOD Title is: trouzgg
Samples = DT4AAdrum.raw ;hihat1 ;DT4AAbass2.raw ;2U-4.raw ;hihatop1 ;DT4AA6.raw ;zoo7.raw ;where'smytrousers.raw ;zoo8.raw ;ere.raw ;yaseenem.raw ;theretheyare.raw
;MOD Title is: joygg
Samples = N-JOImf1.raw ;N-JOI-5.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;N-JOI-2.raw ;JBdrum2.raw ;N-JOIrz1.raw ;N-JOIrz2.raw ;N-JOIrz3.raw ;jb-hhmed.raw
;MOD Title is: ramgg
Samples = N-JOIph1.raw ;aon-drm5.raw ;model500-cymop.raw ;model500-cymcl.raw ;model500-clap.raw ;drumwack.raw ;2U-6.raw ;hold ;hold (offset tone)
;MOD Title is: turbogg
Samples = beep1.raw ;beep2.raw ;beep3.raw ;beep4.raw ;gunshot ;2U-3.raw ;chahihat3.raw ;spliffclap2 ;snare ;stick.raw ;zoo1.raw ;2U-2.raw ;DT4AA6.raw
;MOD Title is: xravegg
Samples = EBputv.raw ;JBhitme.raw ;shamen-guitar1.raw ;shamen-guitar2.raw ;SoSbass2.raw ;s&pcots.raw ;mtxpling.raw ;orch.hit ;bassdrum16 ;bassdrum7 ;breaksnareclap ;closehihat ;cymbal-crash ;tap.raw
Naming of samples …
Adamski, CHA = Crown Heights Affair, AoN = Art Of Noise, BH = Bassheads, JB = James Brown, Linx (David Grant), KRAYScratch is a sample from “The Krays” film (“Stop all that scratchin’, you’re making me bloody itch!”, “Where’s my trousers?” is another sample from same, I think), N-Joi, Model 500, Shamen, SoS = S.O.S. Band, zoo = “Zoo Rave” compilation CD, 2U = 2Unlimited, DT4AA = “Don’t Techno For An Answer” compilation CD
Bassheads - Is There Anybody Out There
Adamski - NRG
Model 500 - Sound Of Stereo
In X-Men 2 …
;MOD Title is: level1b
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw
;MOD Title is: level1
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;aon-vox6.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw
;MOD Title is: level2
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;BHacid1.raw
;MOD Title is: level3
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;BHacid1.raw
;MOD Title is: level4
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;BHacid1.raw
;MOD Title is: level5
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;BHacid1.raw
;MOD Title is: level6
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;BHacid1.raw
;MOD Title is: level7
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;BHacid1.raw
;MOD Title is: level8
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;BHacid1.raw
;MOD Title is: level9
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;808synth.raw ;amaski1.raw ;N-JOIph1.raw ;BHacid1.raw
;MOD Title is: level10
Samples = bassdrum28 ;animate-bass ;koto ;closedhi ;hihat-2ud2 ;snare25
In X-Men 3 …
;MOD Title is: x3l1
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;BHbass2.raw ;amaski1.raw ;eurostring.raw
;MOD Title is: x3l2
Samples = akaiclosedhh ;bassdrum7 ;snare1 ;hihat-2ud2 ;BHbass2.raw ;amaski1.raw ;eurostring.raw
;MOD Title is: x3l3
Samples = 909.ophi ;hip.snare ;breakdrum ;cymbal1 ;polysynth ;strings6 ;tubestring ;tricky.raw
;MOD Title is: x3l4
Samples = 909.ophi ;hip.snare ;breakdrum ;cymbal1 ;shamen-keys.raw ;tttt-bass1.raw ;goodpling ;inner ;funbass
;MOD Title is: x3l5
Samples = 909.ophi ;hip.snare ;breakdrum ;cymbal1 ;animate-bass ;sequencer ;pizza2 ;N-JOIph1.raw ;tricky.raw
;MOD Title is: x3l6
Samples = 909.ophi ;hip.snare ;breakdrum ;cymbal1 ;bassguitar.funk ;digdug ;exbells ;reflex
;MOD Title is: x3l7
Samples = 909.ophi ;hip.snare ;breakdrum ;cymbal1 ;polysynth ;strings6 ;bell11 ;digdug ;growl2
;MOD Title is: x3l8
Samples = 909.ophi ;drum7 ;comadrum ;cymbal1 ;comasynth1 ;comasynth2 ;ex800bass ;hitbass
;MOD Title is: x3l9
Samples = 909.ophi ;hip.snare ;breakdrum ;cymbal1 ;dang ;dbassic.raw ;dbassic2.raw ;d-50.res1 ;d-50.res2 ;d-50.res3 ;d-50.res4 ;d-50.res5 ;junob3 ;sequencer ;synth1
;MOD Title is: x3l10
Samples = 909.ophi ;hip.snare ;breakdrum ;cymbal1 ;koto07 ;bass37 ;Sample10_04 ;perco ;hitbass ;licks
;MOD Title is: x3l11
Samples = hip.snare ;breakdrum ;cymbal1 ;strings3majfl ;sinecz ;shamus ;pling ;tinewave ;synbrass
Probably more info than was necessary, eh. But I learned something! :D
from anosci, Mar 12, 2024, 4:57PM
this is interesting!
First of all, it’s rare that game music has titles! They’re not quite matched up with the order of the songs in the sound test, but that’s still neat to know.
plus it confirms my interpretation that these were rave / dance inspired tunes!
I could believe that 08 in the sound test menu is “babybeat”. It has a pretty soft melody, befitting of the title and theme, I think.
This also paints an interesting picture. Tell me if this lines up with your memories:
You had to write the music for Spiderman vs The Kingpin, so you hunkered down and used whatever tools you had.
Then when you learned you had to do the music for X-Men as well, you wanted something easier to work with,
so you proposed converting the MODs you’d already written.
…and then you stuck with that process for the next two games
> Unless you just get it anyway, at Game Over (I do not recall).
I checked, and you get the the (presumed?) “babybeat” track at Game Over
from Paul Hutchinson, Mar 12, 2024, 8:41PM
Yes, that’s about it, as best as I can remember.
I got pretty used to ProTracker.
Yes, at Game Over.
I listened to both tracks to try and compare. It’s difficult, because the tempo is very different, the waveforms are very different, and the instruments are totally different. I really need to find that disc, because if I can hear my original MOD it will help clarify if my memory is correct.
from anosci, Mar 13, 2024, 12:31PM
I suppose the obvious follow-up question would be: do you remember how you wrote the tunes for Spiderman vs. The Kingpin?
from Paul Hutchinson, Mar 13, 2024, 3:07PM
Joergen Bech wrote the sound subroutines, we worked together at Inner Prise (I think he is Swedish).
I am pretty sure that the music was just composed using those subroutines. As in, just typing it all up, into the assembler file. It was a bit laborious to say the least. There are no other tools to write the music. I looked at the code, and there is no mention of anything other than the code itself.
Less than ideal, eh.
But then, I am the type of programmer that will convert a C64 loading screen to an Amstrad loading screen, by typing in all the numbers defining each pixel (and getting it right). I did that for Druid (or Druid II, I forget which). Just brute forced it. I got Firebird to provide a print out of all the numbers for the C64 screen, and I converted them myself, and typed in the Amstrad equivalent. I think I got 250 quid for that, it was not fun, but maybe worth the cash, eh.
For Chakan, there was a composer who provided MIDI files. I wrote a conversion program to convert the MIDI into the format that the sound subroutines could use. Much easier, and I did not have to come up with the music myself.
Then for X-Men I added a MOD to MIDI converter, I think. Then ran that through the MIDI to sound subroutine format.
I am looking through the code some more …
Breaking news … I just found a bunch of MOD files inside the Sega > TC > Prog folder.
OMG! Stand by for those … (BabyBeat!)
from anosci, Mar 13, 2024, 6:17PM
Typing music straight into an ASM file was shockingly common back then, so I believe it.
> I just found a bunch of MOD files inside the Sega > TC > Prog folder.
!!!!
excitedly but patiently waiting to hear these!
from Paul Hutchinson, Mar 13, 2024, 7:43PM
Hallelujah! :D
Okay, we have the original pre-conversion MOD files for X-Men 1 & 2. They are not the original MOD files. These have been modified to fit the conversion process, in order to get a decent sounding composition on the Game Gear. I have removed some samples from being played, even though they are probably still included in the sample set. I have substituted some samples for others, in order to get a better result. However, you do get a decent idea of how it all worked. This might be as close as we can get, but I will keep looking, eh. I also included some MODs that were in the same folder, but are not mine. A couple from the “Jesus On E’s” Amiga demo, as well as the “Coma” demo. Figured you might find them interesting too. I might have borrowed samples from those MODs to make my own.
I have to say I was quite emotional when I saw those MODs in the Turbo-C++ folder. Never expected them to be there this whole time. Hearing “Babybeat” again after all these years. Man. Thanks for getting me to look into all this, I would not have known they were there otherwise. Cheers! :)
3 attachments:
Xmen-Extras.7z
Xmen2MODs.7z
XmenMODs.7z
from anosci, Mar 13, 2024, 9:52PM
I cross-referenced the songs with the titles as they appear in smspower.com (here and here)
X-Men
baby -> Mandripoor
fishgg -> Brood Cave
itchgg -> The Savage Land
joygg -> Boss
outgg -> Morlock Tunnel
ramgg -> Game Over
renaiss -> The Hellfire Club
trouzgg -> Avalon
turbogg -> Ending
xravegg -> Title
X-Men 2
level1 -> Arctic
level1b-> The Danger Room
level2 -> The Hellfire Club
level3 -> Genosha
level4 -> Avalon
level5 -> Egyptian Base Part 1
level6 -> Egyptian Base Part 2
level7 -> Stryfe’s Moon Base
level8 -> Boss
level9 -> Ending
level10-> Title
critically speaking, I think most of these start with a solid idea that then gets a bit buried.
but it’s an amazing piece of context.
a lot of the rave timbre was lost in the gamegear conversion. it’s amazing to hear it put back, so to speak!
I can see why you fondly remembered babybeat. I think that might be your strongest tune here.
that and “OUTGG” (or at least, those two are my favorites)
I love seeing that you got something cool out of my barrage of questions and curiosity, too :)
digging around some more… “JOYGG” is an odd one: the pitch bends didn’t transfer to the Game Gear. though I’m not sure my own playback is accurate… there’s a lot of out-of-key samples that sound fine after the Game Gear conversion. Strange.
comparing babybeat to orbital’s “Midnight (Live)”… the two have a similar push-pull rhythm rhythm in the bass, but I wouldn’t call them the same.
though I could easily imagine the similarities causing a fan of one song to raise their eyebrow at the other.
from Paul Hutchinson, Mar 14, 2024, 8:26AM
Cool.
Yeah, the “missing link” MODs do not sound as good as either the originals, or the final GG version.
Oh, and I actually wrote a Pro-Tracker to GG format conversion program (DOS), no in-between conversion. I think there was, at some point, a dual set up, but I decided to make it simpler. The dual set up would have been a legacy from when I had to write a MIDI to GG format, for Chakan. I only have the final set of tools in my Turbo-C++ directory, none of the tools I used previously.
I agree with your assessment of the tune similarity. I think at some point I got it into my head they were more similar, and then that just became what I remembered. I am getting older too, so that is a factor. I am only human after all.
from anosci, Mar 14, 2024, 7:02PM
Never let the truth get in the way of a good story, right? ;)
from Paul Hutchinson, Mar 14, 2024, 8:39PM
Well, I am kind of big on telling the truth, tbh. I do acknowledge that I can (and do) get things wrong though. I remember when I was a kid, I swore that the words on a TV advert were “It’s full of peppery goodness”, when in fact, it was “It’s full of Cadbury goodness” (the ad was for Cadbury’s Finger of Fudge). I really believed that was what it said, and it did not matter what everyone else said it was. I was honest about my position, I was just completely and totally wrong. :D
Comments
ChupaCuervo
Great news!
