Haley Cass patreon

Poll Time - Who is going to plan the most romantic Valentine's Day?

🕑 Added 2025-02-02 22:55:41 +0000 UTC

Comments

Lucy

I’d put Charlotte after Gianna ❤️

Dianna Norman

This was the hardest poll yet LOL! I didn't know who to pick.

heidstuff

Brooke is romantic in her own way. Taylor definitely feels it ❤️ But she may not be able to compete with the like Giana, Caroline or Charlotte 😅

Beca

NOT Brooke lmao

Rachel

This was my first thought!!!!

Rachel

In the most determined angle i pick Hannah. Her and her struggle to express her feelings paired with her POV in paragon makes me think she'd kill it

Jess

Taylor/Brooke being forgotten!!

Heather

Whole lotta folks sleepin on Ellie Beckett!

Bea

I just changed my vote to Sutton. She would be the most determined of all the ladies. And for Charlotte . She Loves Love!!!

Cristina C

I just got my copy of The Snowball Effect, so maybe my answer changes after I finish it, but for now 100% Gianna. If all I could do was imagine how to sweep my bestie love off her feet for the last 10 years, you have to know it’s gonna be epic.

Hanna Baptist

Gianna and Regan are a tie in my head, so I voted for my girl Regan because she's currently the underdog of the two!

Vesta Charleshouse

Most determined - it’s got to be Regan!

Allison

Key words: most determined! I think in any circumstances that’s gotta be Regan. (but if we’re just talking best/most romantic, it’s Gianna ofc)

JL

I could watch Ellie doing something quirky, yet sweet as hell for Mia. But yeah tons of tough choices. Charlotte and Gianna are the queens of gift-giving, Sutton is low-key and thoughtful (seeds and a book 🥰), and Caroline's enjoyment of any holiday (except Halloween, lol) is genuinely in the joy that Hannah and Abbie find in it. idk i can't vote.

Kathryn Crowley

Honestly i PERSONALLY dont think Regan would get i overmatched and i wanna use her cassmass story as proof but i think Gianna has been planning this forever!! I can just see her yearning every vday

Daphne

I can totally see Caroline putting something really special together for her beloved Hannah... but have to give it to Gianna. I mean, Gianna has waited for _years_ for this.

Kayla Bhadra

Gianna has waited 10 years to show Riley her feelings she’s going to put her whole heart and soul into it!

Chris

Haley holy crap look at all the girls listed!! Love it!! What a world you have created! Gianna gets my vote, lost time and all, but MR Charlotte fits in that category also.

Bronwyn Close

This is such a hard poll. How am I meant to choose between all my babies? I can see Riley and Gianna trying to one up each other in romantic gestures. But I ended up voting for Hannah. I think she’d want to show Caroline how much she means to her.

Alex L

I feel like Regan would be amazing be amazing and cook a killer meal etc but it’s so much she may get overwhelmed whereas Gianna would kill it.

Kathryn Crowley

As much as I love Regan and think she would be so romantic on Valentines I know that Gianna would put her entire soul into planning

Meri Kay Hodges

This is like Sophie’s choice! I can’t make a decision.

Makenzie

To be 100% fair here, I'm super late to the HCLU party, and haven't read all of the books yet. Based on this poll, I'm gonna have to finish them asap🤣, because I was so shocked that more ppl didn't vote for Sutton...my thoughts were...as far as I've gotten at least 😂..she has seemed to be the most romantic in the "traditional" kinda hopeless romantic kinda way. BUT, like I said.. it appears I have some serious reading to do😁.

Cherry Yeung

Watch… in a turn of events, Haley shocks us all with Ellie Beckett being the reigning queen of hallmark romance 😂

Cherry Yeung

Wait am I forgetting a big plot thing? I’m surprised Sutton is so low in votes? She LOVES love? I mean, the winner is obviously Gianna but still, Sutton is a huge romantic no? I guess she’s not very flashy about it?

Kriiss

#TeamRegan 💖 Haven’t met Gianna yet.

Gabi

😭😭 ugh too close to choose! Taylor/Brooke always have such meaningful experiences together and their stuff is almost the most personal. But but but Gianna loves her Riley so dang much And imagining Caroline spoiling both her Hannah and her Abbie?? Big smile for that.

Makenzie

Agreed 100%. I just finished in th long run, and it gave me all the feels.

Danielle

100% agree 😂

Danielle

I feel torn between Taylor, Gianna, and Regan. Taylor would do something super sweet and thoughtful but not too crazy because that isn’t Brooke’s speed. If you’re asking me, there’s nothing more romantic than making your partner feel seen. But Gianna would def. go all out. I picture their first Valentine’s Day as a couple being Gianna creating the Valentine’s date that she used to dream about being able to have with Riley but couldn’t. Then Regan would do something sweet and steamy. There would be baked goods and a nut-free home cooked meal, IMO (forever making up for her nearly deadly first home cooked meal for Emma)

Vivi

This exactly!

Lilisionnach

Totally agree with Gianna but I think Regan would give her a run for the title. However, just in the planning stage, I think Gianna has a better chance of following through on getting the plan to fruition (sorry Regan 🤣)

Gabby

Gianna 100% but Charlotte would go all out as well

Sonia

Same. I think it has something to do with both of them being in relationships for really the first time in their lives, so they’d be super extra about it.

Angélica

I have faith in Charlotte, but my heart says is Gianna, that woman won't rest until she gives Riley the best and most romantic Valentine's day date she could ever wish for.

Erin Hubay

Midnight rain Charlotte Thompson no question

Cat H.

Gianna, overachiever in loving Reilly, really. Also because she feels competitive with Herself and the need to satisfy the dreams of College Gianna. Especially after reading The Reunion there are small things she clearly wants for college Gianna… I could see that reflected in a gungho nature towards making each year better than the last. I can see married Gianna being like “step up my game!” Especially after kids and seeing Reilly overcome (cough go read the next chapters cough) and just being like “even more challenge accepted!”

Sean Riley

Taylor/Brooke seem like they would plan very meaningful Valentine’s Days. I can absolutely see Taylor planning a short trip somewhere that’s thoroughly romantic, Brooke planning a very detailed and specific but equally romantic evening. But both would make sure to be back to help with Lover’s Lane.

Liam Lintemuth

Sometimes I would like someone to recognize that Caroline hates these holidays and she knows it and the people she loves knows it but when it’s for them she goes for it so hard

Nel

Gianna or Reagan? Thats a tough one

Melissa S

I thought about Gianna and Regan right away.

Ahrisuzumiya

As much as I think Gianna would go over the top for Riley, I really do believe that Regan would go SUPER over the top for Emma, just by her energy alone! She would go to ends length to make sure Emma felt loved and cared for on Feb 14, haha. Let's just say if Regan was willing to do THAT for Emma on Christmas eve, I think Regan would try to top that on Valentines.

Haley Cass

You know, I had some thoughts about this as well - and the thing is: while they all (of course) deeply love their partner and want her to feel special and loved, their reactions to Valentine's Day, specifically, would be... varied. Like. Caroline will never love the hallmark-holiday even if she does enjoy celebrating it with Hannah, you know?

Sonia

Well, we now know how Regan goes “all out” for holidays…

Atlas

This one. Cause I can also see Brooke doing it up for Taylor even though she pretends to be super lowkey about it.

kassandra gravel

I feel like Charlotte is spoiling Sutton. But also Caroline is definitely spoiling Hannah too. And obviously Gianna is a big romantic. Can I vote for them all 😆