The QB School patreon

Caleb Williams vs Oregon 2023 Full-Game Analysis

🕑 Added 2024-02-06 21:27:50 +0000 UTC

Comments

Andrew

Can't wait for the Bears to take the guy who turns down open receivers because of his horrific line and then scrambles and makes the most incredible play you've ever seen.

Craig Becerril

Not a huge fan of Rumble. I like to pause and come back, Rumble doesn't keep my spot in the video

Charles M Olmsted

Please compare college tape from Mahomes and Caleb Williams before you go anointing Caleb Williams.

KingKOBRA_ 19

good thing you’re not a nfl general manager. mahomes just won his 3rd superbowl doing all of the things you criticized caleb for doing. mahomes lucked out by going to andy reid but no prospect has the full package that williams has. find me a qb that is making the improv throws while having the capacity to be an effective runner.

Charles M Olmsted

I made a comment in another thread about how I think scouts should watch film with a filter on that hides the player’s appearance. When you expect to see genius, you often see genius.

Charles M Olmsted

How about looking as good as CJ Stroud? Or, if that bar is too high, not looking like Justin Fields 2.0?

Charlie

What would he have to do for you to see it? Like what would that even look like lol

Charles M Olmsted

Penix played well against good competition. And doesn’t appear to be quite as immature or undisciplined. Not saying that Penix is a First Round guy. Just saying that I might rather have a stud at another position and take Penix later.

TaikoTiger

Meh Penix accuracy is not consistent enough to be anywhere near CW

The QB School

Thanks, NW

Nickolai G Levin

I’m more curious how he compares to Maye.

Nathaniel Wilson

You have to open it in your phones browser, it won’t flip if you open it in Patreon built in browser

Connor Grochowski

is anyone else unable to flip the video to play horizontally?

Charles M Olmsted

I just see a guy who turns down a lot of open looks, has poor footwork, and I haven’t bought into the hype around him.

Matthew Hartmann

There's no way you watched the same video the rest of us did...

Aaron White Fishing

good stuff i been banging on the table for caleb I see no in the middle of the field throws. wanna see the drake maye tape

Charles M Olmsted

What am I missing here? I don’t see anything spectacular from this guy. He doesn’t seem to make people around him better. I don’t see any indications that his team is only in these games because of his skills. Making a handful of nice plays (less than one per half) is just a flash of potential. I would take Penix over him based on what I have seen so far.

Edward Bills

Love Justin, but it’s gotta be Caleb.

Jeffrey Stoll

can you do a break down comparing the strengths and weaknesses of the top 3 QBs in the draft? For example, what are you seeing that puts Williams above Daniel’s?