This next episode is a heavy one

C&Rsenal

Oh yeah, the diminishing WWI list is a huge challenge

Richard Anderson

I wholly agree with above points. The shooting segments are the less interesting most of the time to most of your core supporters. There has only been a few instances where the shooting highlighted a little understood truth about a given firearm. Yes I like to see Mae out there handling the arms, but the history and context you provide is the core of what interests me (yes I do understand that all of the research isn't just you). I also assume that this path would facilitate a more orderly progression of episodes, since you wouldn't have to start and stop based on the physical availability of a given hard to find firearm.

Sounds like a very workable plan given that some WWI pieces are pretty unobtanium for one reason or another.

Comrade Crozier

Sounds like a great plan! The incredible depth of research is what hooked me on C&Rsenal.

I think that's an entirely acceptable workaround and personally the shooting parts are the less interesting part of the show. Don't get me wrong, I love them as well, but the historical information and the explanation of the mechanics of the guns, is what I'm here for. :)

Go for it.

OLLE3770

Sounds like the best way to do it.

Paul Hofmann

I like the idea for the history alone, and if it works to bait collectors for some pieces this would be magnificent.

Christopher Dooley

I can't think of a better way to address this problem. As others have said, the breakdown of the gun, the developmental history, and the service use are as much of a reason to watch and support the show as watching the guns go "bang". Watching the guns go "bang", and hearing Mae's assessment of the ergo's recoil, handling, etc ARE really cool though :)

Gavin Rea-Davies

This sounds like a sensible, reasonable, and practical solution to the problem of finding unobtainium gats. If you're going to do place holder segments, can I request they have a slight comedy twist to them? Mae with an inflatable/cardboard Gat, some amusing sci-fi prop, or best of all.... Crozier with a little model gat. Go one, let Crozier have some more time in the lime light :)

ManyMilesAway

As cool as the live firings are, I personally have always valued the historical stuff you guys do FAR more than seeing the guns actually shoot. I 110% support this idea.

C&Rsenal

I try to like them all as I read them. I can't always reply but it helps me make sure I've seen every one.

I think its a great idea! I enjoy the shooting segments and the Maeversation, they really add to the experience, but I really love the detailed histories you guys include with the guns. And of course anything to help you guys keep the show going is a positive in my book.

.... and I'll just like the hell out of all the comments to the affirmative. Done.

Martin Morehouse

Sounds like a plan, please continue!

Richard Anderson

Frankly I can't imagine any direction you take your efforts would be objectionable in the least. Lead on oh bearded one and we will follow.

Chris Ibey

I think it's a good idea.

A very reasonable idea. Also I for one will be excited to start seeing some neutral guns of the era that didn't make it into the war.

C&Rsenal

It's actually a bit trickier still than that. I don't care for jump cuts like most of YouTube so I have to script in visuals to give myself breathing and refresher spaces. I don't memorize every episode. Without historical photos I'll have to create some other asset, contextually appropriate, to give that interruption. Again, it creates a sort of difficulty vs throwing in an already available photo.

C&Rsenal

We will have to find something for her in the inserts

Tiger in man's clothing

I would rather get the history and such without the shooting than nothing at all. I understand that there are rifles that you will probably never get to shoot, but leaving them out just because you can't shoot them would be tripple plus ungood.

Ryan Ulick

good idea

John S Wren

Good idea. If you have the research you can't waste it. In all honesty the history and mechanics are what I'm here for. The best is the enemy of the good and all that.

Mustafa's Fleas

An elegant solution to a very difficult problem!

Brett

Go for it. I watch for the historical research - I'd hate to see all of that held up because the shooting segments are giving you trouble.

That sounds like a great idea. Go for it.

go for it

Bruce Brodnax

Brilliant solution! Please go ahead with this...

...go for it...if no actual piece on hand, hard to do a "Maeversation"...and will miss Mae...but, go for it...good plan....

I like your plan. I came fairly recently to your site; and it would have been helpful to have an overall look at your plan - sort of like an index in a book to see what is where and see your plan. Just a thought. It might take more than one session. I hope your book will be forthcoming as well; I'm looking forward to it. This work of yours has led me to another look at history of WWi, and WWII. Having a book on the small arms of each would be very helpful. Maybe even a history of small arms (knives to machine guns) in all wars in which America was involved, from pre revolutionary war to today woven into the history of the actions.

Alex

Works for me. I know how hard you work on the shooting segments, but those aren't why I watch/listen to episodes multiple times. The research and backstory are.

Stephen Woods

Briliant idea.

Sounds very reasonable, with no complaints from me! Do what you need to do to keep the content coming!

Bill Smithem

Sounds like a reasonable way to handle it.

Lynn Phillips

good idea!

Rob Laycock

I like that idea

Will Sullivan

No argument here.

Michael Boudreaux

sounds like a solid plan

Joshua Kerner

I love the idea. To be honest, those parts that would be the entirety of the “squib” episode are why I turn into for C&R.

Joseph Corsei

Another vote in favor!

John Elliott

Sounds like a great idea. The history of the design, use in the field, and the impact on any future designs is just as exciting and interesting to me.

Kevin R

I think that is a great idea!

Nicholas Ford

Makes sense!

Bruce Stein

Yes!

Nicholas Mew

Sounds good, can't hurt to do it at this point in the game.

I like that idea!

mysteriousAnallid

Sounds like a great idea.

I think that sounds like a good idea. I agree with Brian above me

Brian Taylor

As much as I like seeing Mae shoot and give her opinions on the guns, for me the real interest is the history and mechanics of the guns and cartridges. So your plan forward sounds like a winner.

This sounds great, and I love the name!

Thomas C. Bogan

Sounds like a plan .

Yes

Works for me!

Greg Stachowski

Great idea! I agree with the guy above that including Mae would be good, keep the team together. Also from post 1923 stuff, we're there for you and the info you provide, the music or video clips are secondary (I would imagine all the stills of soldiers with equipment etc would easily fit under fair use).

Guido R.

Better than no videos at all! In case you already have access to the gun, why don't you let Mae do some of the demo sitting next to you, like ergonomics, sight picture etc would keep all those Mae fans happy? ;-)

Matthew Jackson

Seems like a sound plan.

Sure. Great idea. No need to hover around the stuff - showing marginal guns - while we are all kept in suspense waiting for hm.. other stuff. Still, be sure to find the usual slot for Mae. I would like to hear her expectations, later to hear her view. Anyway, I've seen the episodes more than once. As for post 1923, i.e. WWII. Don't invent problems that aren't really there. It may be that you appriciate a certain approach, but what if the net value for you and the viewers could be found using other, less demanding means? What if we could actually live fine without copyrighted music and footage - as long as we had the real gun, the real research, the real real you and Mae? What could simplify all the copyright issues? The decorations are not the core of the show; so ease the workload and do what no one does better. Like that with the animations, right?

I like the idea! Geoff Who notes Mae could do a spokesmodel pose in the background.

Stuart Burton

Instead of Maevision you could have a cartoon Mae going Pew pew pew

Matteo Manino

This work fine for me; Maeversation on the "bang process" is a unique e very useful, if the squib elp in finding weapon ok. Keep the great job O&crew.

Anything that takes the strain off the logistical nightmare you deal with is totally fine with me Othais.

Jeppe Christensen

Yes. Just yes.

Seems reasonable to me. Go ahead.

That sounds reasonable, but I would find a way to include Mae in the videos. She is actually what drew me to your videos after I randomly watched the first one I saw. I came for Mae, and I stayed for the outstanding overall quality.

Christopher Pettirsch

well I guess that's a pretty good plan behind you all the way.

Do so. To see it shooting is only 5% of the pie.

Afflickted

I think its a brilliant idea! You guys put so much passion and effort into each effort into each episode, anything that can make things easier for the whole team will only help to improve the channel over the long run. Plus, it would help to spread the word that you you need a specific firearm. It would dramatically increase visiblity.

This totally works.

This is a good idea

Steve Zeatlow

Sounds like a plan!

Leonard Heinz

I vote in favor of this, enthusiastically.

Lumpytusk

Often times, I listen to most of the episode and only watch the mechanically interesting parts - so cutting the gun out of the history section would not in the least affect me. Also, if I get to listen to smart people talk about rare guns, then I can deal with not having the visuals until you can find them later on.

Go for it!

I'm behind you on this idea, you've never failed to deliver in historical content, which in the end is the most time intensive part of each episode, you do what you feel is best for the channel

Sounds like a very practical solution to an increasingly difficult problem. I have really enjoyed all your efforts thus far, keep up the great work!

Paul Herbert Varga

Great Idea!

Old Man Winter

In my best Patrick Stewart voice "Make it so"

Eric Meyer

Sounds like a good idea.

C&Rsenal

I would prefer this. But sadly there are guns we are no closer to firing that have some truly interesting history behind them. I sincerely hope discussing them will lure them out for firing as well.

Excellent idea!!! Whatever allows you to produce more content easier, without sacrificing the quality that C&renal is know for is a winning solution!!! Keep up the great work - you guys rock!!!

C&Rsenal

I think we'll give her the updates and let her do the temporary explanations bits

C&Rsenal

Well Mr. Psychic you'll love the Kropatschek episode

C&Rsenal

Actually, we have a new partner there... more on the next episode.

C&Rsenal

Every. Time.

C&Rsenal

Actually... not a horrible idea for the placeholder

Sounds like a great idea

Mark Churchwell

Excellent Idea. As others have said, the shooting and disassembly are MAYBE 1/10 or so of the episode and the "Maeversation" at the end is maybe another 1/10. There's little reason to not do 80% of the work and save yourself the headache of finding the guns.

Ted Weldon

I think this a great idea, I watch mostly for the in depth discussion and historical background though I enjoy Mae shooting and her take as well.

Jeff Freeman

Works for me too.

C&Rsenal

We will likely start to roll in neutrals as we run out of material. Do not forget, adding any other era means abandoning an archive made of hundreds, if not thousands of hours of work this far and starting over on a new reference archive + fearing copyright.

C&Rsenal

No matter how good or terrible, I do.

works for me

Matt Faller

This seems a sensible and realistic approach to take. While the shooting segements are always entertaining, it's the background and historical relevance of each weapon that intrigues me, not whether or not Mae thinks it's muzzle heavy or has issues with loading it.

Jared Kennedy

I like this idea. It would allow you to complete ww1. I assume that you will be taking photos when possible. I do like the idea of seeing all the firearms and hearing the history behind it. I can wait for the shooting bit personally.

Think I accidentally deleted this while editing it; Look, do something whether this or something else or a combination of the two; I for one am perfectly fine (and may even be happier) with you not limiting yourself so severely to WW1 as examples get scarcer and scarcer. If you continue to insist on doing one period until the end every time it will continually get harder and harder towards the end of any one time period or focus, rather than fading into one as you fade out of another; it's unnecessary and clearly causes issues. You don't even need to do say ww2 or a gun that would get covered in a different war focus, but can just insert one-off episodes with a different sort of thumbnail if you want. Tbh I have a feeling that this is something that you'll need to do sooner or later. Perhaps also at the beginning/ end of new episodes you could put a labelled picture of the guns you're really looking for to shoot at the moment, which wouldn't distract or give away too much but possibly help a bit? I think that was basically all I said the first time

Josh Bowman

Sounds like a good plan to me.

Genius.

I like the research and history perhaps more than the actual shooting. Do it.

A Pete Bingham

Great idea!

Do whatever works best man! We're here to support you through the end!

Bryan Sportel

Do it. Honestly it makes sense as its kinda how you would do a restoration of a vehicle or airplane. Your in a way doing a restoration of these firearms.

Casey Muzio

If your asking for opinions I like the idea I wouldn't mind missing the shooting section of an episode especially if it lightened your work load and help keep the show on track for me I love the history and story of the guns what you don't get from any other channel

Certainly a reasonable approach. As we come to the end of the centennial of WW1, is it possible for you to branch out and touch on other eras, while still doing WW1 guns as they become fully available? That would seem to cut some of the week-to-week pressure, without abandoning the original project or creating future additional editing work.

Christian Hanes

Go for it

Lane Shinogle

I'm all for this plan

Adam G.

The history is the more interesting part of the show anyway so Im ok with this

Sounds good to me.

James Bond

I like it. I would miss Mae’s shooting and input, but it’s a good solution to the problem. Make it so :)

Jeremy

I’m for it

Jasper Welsch

Dude, don't kill yourself. It's your show. Do what is best. I'm behind you whatever you want to do. This sounds like a great idea. And if you need to sneak into WW2 every once in a while, I don't see that as a problem either.

Sean

*Palpatine "Dewit" intensifies*

Lord Chaos

Sounds like a plan. It does raise the question. Why would any one want to shoot a Fiat Revelli?

A David Merritt

sounds like a best compromise, given the rarity of some weapons.

Matt Rio

That sounds like the perfect solution. Besides, the majority of the content really is the research and historical content. Not to say I don't like Mae. 😀

Shaun Young

I would rather have the show without shooting than no episodes. The history is he more interesting part to me, the rest is the gravy on top. Very, very tasty gravy but not the meat of it.

I think it's a great idea, actually.

Why Not?

Vityaz

It's good with me. Go for it.

Daniel Falch

Great solution. The backround content is just as, if not more so, interesting than the shooting segments.

Red Marley

I think it would be better not to release an episode until it is complete - but I will support your decision either way

Sounds like a great idea! Good thinking!

Peter Starr

Sounds like an outstanding plan!

Thomas Stancomb

This is a good idea. I understand that it isn't perfect because there is information gained in firing a weapon. However, this is a far site better than going out of logical order, or just not getting an episode because of availability for shooting. The context and history alone are worth making an episode about. Everything else you guys do is just awesome gravy on top.

I love this idea.

ERB2

I think that's a perfectly reasonable solution to your problem, but maybe you can find another role for Mae in those episodes. Maybe she can introduce the episode, which can then be edited out in the final version?

David Key

Do eeet.

I can get behind this idea.

Ion

You should do that immediately. Another good idea would be to talk to other gun channels that have those guns to either use their footage and opinions on the gun or even loan the guns. Anyway, I’m down for that idea.

I wouldn't have an issue with it. Good knows I jump past the last section as it is. One thing that I would say is make sure you have snap caps or brass or something (venue permitting) for shooting mechanics reference.

Do it now. Thanks for all you put into this work. Great solution.

Nicholas White

Sounds good. It must be incredibly frustrating to get offers after the fact.

Whatever makes it easiest for you. Don’t worry about us, we will stick around.

Mark D Booth

Works for me still get really good info on obviously hard to find guns.

Phillip Holmes

If you are still handling the guns can you have Mae make “pew-pew” noises while holding them be the filler?

Brilliant! make it happen!

That makes sense. Please do it for your sake and the show's.

Sounds great to me!

I can certainly get behind this idea. Bravo.

Terry Rindal Jr

I like it. I will watch “Squib” episodes if that’s what you post. We all love Mae, but the history is part of why we watch and support.

It makes complete sense We support you not matter what.

If it means othais can sleep occasionally... sure.

Shane Hawkins

I can go along with this idea 100%.