Patrefans
Post Games from patreon
Post Games patreon

What we have in common with world-ending AI

🕑 Added 2025-06-13 19:39:14 +0000 UTC

Comments

Robby

Just listened, and I'm glad you touched on these topics! I teach on related material, and I thought maybe some context and further material might be of interest to other listeners. Bostrom gets a shoutout twice here, and he clearly is a huge influence on Frank, so I think it is worth mentioning that the story surrounding his work and his personal views is a bit problematic. He's really popular with tech bros, as they basically funded his Oxford center that he then ran into the ground, after he himself was called out for use of the N-word and saying white people were smarter than black people in a group email as a postgraduate. You might also argue that this sort of viewpoint is baked into the positions that came out of the Oxford center (longtermism and effective altruism) that many have suggested ought to be seen as a form of eugenics for the rich - consider that Musk was a benefactor of Bostrom. This Guardian piece is a nice discussion (https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2024/apr/28/nick-bostrom-controversial-future-of-humanity-institute-closure-longtermism-affective-altruism). Some other cool recent pieces that touch on points that came up - Hicks et al (https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10676-024-09775-5) have a nice argument that we ought not to think of ChatGPT or other LLMs as aiming at truth at all, and so not as "hallucinating" or "making mistakes". Instead, since LLMs are just probabilistic next word predictors, we would do better to think of them as bullshitters, i.e., as similar to people who bullshit in the sense that they do not care about the truth at all. On the other hand, Buckner has an interesting response to similar criticisms that suggest we ought not compare LLMs to human cognition in that it reveals an anthropocentric bias (https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/714960).

Directional Joy

Pragmata sounds a little Binary Domain to me, based off the thought that it looks, initially, average but may be looked at more fondly, in the future. I’ll keep my eye on it. 😃


More Creators