Post "Poll - What will replace Death Note..." by "Badd Medicine" from patreon

EMB

Frieren and Solo Leveling are both great shows I'd like to see you all react to.

Matthew W

DONT WATCH JJK OR DEMON SLAYER. NOT A GOOD FIT FOR THESE GUYS. Vinland Saga however would be a great choice. FMAB is okay i guess

Josh Lomax

If you like Vinlamd Saga, then FMAB is right up your alley. It looks like it's gonna win but if it somehow doesn't, I'd highly recommend

Calvin Hendricks

i HIGHLY recommend Spy X Family its really good!

Gabriel Renato

Ok, now that i think about it, Mushoku its really not the best watch for Badd Medicine, but i stand with Classroom of the Elite. It is not a mediocre copy, it has it's own story, its twists and turns, and great characters. If you dont like it, thats another story, i as a Patreon have voiced my wants.

Rhiannon

The 2003 version has a better, darker atmosphere and color palette, the backstory hits harder in the original 2003 FMA and people get more attached to the characters. But after the first 8 episodes of FMA 2003 they should change to FMAB and skip the first 4 episodes (episode 1 is filler and episodes 2,3 and 4 are too rushed) and start with FMAB episode 5.

Rhiannon

1. Vinland Saga, 2. FMAB....100. Demon Slayer....500. Jujutsu Kaisen. You can't compare Vinland Saga and FMAB with Demon Slayer and Jujutsu Kaisen, they're on a whole other league.

Rhiannon

Vinland Saga is just as good as Full Metal Alchemist/Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood (I like both versions of FMA). But anime that are similar to Death Note and I'm sure they would like are Monster and Code Geass.

Rhiannon

I would recommend you guys watch the first 8 episodes of Full Metal Alchemist 2003, that way you will be more attached to the characters and 2003 FMA just has a better, darker atmosphere and color palette and then you should switch to Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood and skip the first 4 episodes of FMA Brotherhood and start with episode 5. Episode 1 of FMB is filler, episode 2 is the backstory that hits harder in the original 2003 FMA, episode 3 with the town of Lior/Liore is done better in FMA 2003 and episode 4 with the Shou Tucker story is too rushed in FMA Brotherhood and it takes its time more in FMA 2003. If it's too complicated to understand, skip the first episode of FMAB because it's filler made for those already familar with FMA 2003. Also, the backstory and first episodes are better in FMA 2003 than FMAB. FMAB is only better than FMA 2003 after the first episodes. The first episodes of FMAB are very rushed because in 2009 when FMAB aired most people already saw FMA 2003 so they were ok with rushed first episodes. But you guys are new to FMA and will feel that the start of FMAB is too haphazard because you didn't see the start of FMA 2003.

Rhiannon

Mushoku Tensei is down right a creepy, pervy story, it's really not a good anime to introduce to new anime watchers. Also Classroom of the Elite is a power fantasy for teenage boys and a mediocre copy of Death Note. Monster and Code Geass are way better written than Mushoku Tensei and Classroom of the Elite.

Gabriel Renato

I would be over the moon if you guys gave Mushoku Tensei and/or Classroom of the Elite a chance. I believe many would also love to see this animes.

SICProwl

You guys should really look into Ranking of Kings - it's amazing.

Badd Medicine

I would've been a little more clear in the pool... It is brotherhood. Every time I looked up Fullmetal it came up as FMAB.

Cinderkit5

I wouldn't recommend this. Starting one version of the show and then watching the other doesn't make sense. They should just watch brotherhood.

Cinderkit5

Please make sure you watch Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood and not the original FMA. Brotherhood is the better version of the show.

ReyGamma

Beastars? Seriously…

Sean

Vinland Saga is very good, right up their alley IMO

Bartimaeus

As someone who's around the age of these guys, but who grew up with anime, and has almost the same taste in media, I'd only recommend FMAB. I don't think they'd enjoy Demon Slayer and JJK, which don't have much complexity in their writing/story. Haven't watched Vinland yet.

Nano Jimenez

demon slayer 🙏🏽

Rhiannon

I would recommend they watch the first 8 episodes of Full Metal Alchemist 2003, that way they will be more attached to the characters and the 2003 just has a better, darker atmosphere and color palette and then they should switch to Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood and skip the first 4 episodes of FMA Brotherhood and start with episode 5. Episode 1 of FMB is filler, episode 2 is the backstory that hits harder in the original 2003 FMA, episode 3 with the town of Lior/Liore is done better in FMA 2003 and episode 4 with the Shou Tucker story is too rushed in FMA Brotherhood and it takes its time more in FMA 2003.

Rhiannon

I would recommend they watch the first 8 episodes of Full Metal Alchemist 2003, that way they will be more attached to the characters and the 2003 version just has a better, darker atmosphere and color palette and then they should switch to Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood and skip the first 4 episodes of FMA Brotherhood and start with episode 5. Episode 1 of FMB is filler, episode 2 is the backstory that hits harder in the original 2003 FMA, episode 3 with the town of Lior/Liore is done better in FMA 2003 and episode 4 with the Shou Tucker story is too rushed in FMA Brotherhood and it takes its time more in FMA 2003.

swingo

Yes, I think so too. However, Mason or someone else once said something like “Tell me about shows like SG and AIB”, so I'm recommending Kaiji, which is one of the origins of the genre.

Sophia Coronel

For fullmetal alchemist I highly recommend watching the brotherhood version !

Apollo

Kaiji is so good, it was one of the inspirations for the writer of Squid Game. I doubt they'll ever get around to watching it though since it has such a niche following, and they already have a ton of other suggestions to go through.

ShePlays Sims

Definitely Demon Slayer. Easy to follow, emotion, story, and the animation! great follow up after AOT and Death Note

swingo

I hope you to see these works too. "Orb: On the Movements of the Earth" "Kaiji: Ultimate Survivor" "Odd Taxi" "Beastars"

Katherine Banfitch

Watch the dub version of FMAB, it is the superior version!!!!

swingo

I voted for Vinland Saga, which is the only one I've seen. But if FMA is chosen, I'll watch FMA for that reason.

swingo

Me too.

Sean

I highly recommend the FMA:B Dubbed version, like others have already. I'm of the opinion that if there is a dubbed version available that is at the least comparable, if not just as good, then its best to watch in your native language. Makes for a better watch IMO

Glory

Please watch Fullmetal Alchemist dubbed! Sub is great but the dub is outstanding!

Jake Gering

I mean that's clearly what it is lol I'm looking forward to it as I've never seen it.

Hafidz

Why is Chainsaw Man not up there is beyond me

Cassandra

PLEASE make it Jujutsu Kaisen!

Dis Ramen

Please be Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood

Alanna Meyers 🍌

I don’t like anime so first reply gets my vote

rafaela

Guys, common! Jujutsu is so good

PokeTheBear

I personally just don't think they'll like JJK because there isn't much story. it's just pretty.

Frank the Tank

I hope the crew is ready. FMAB is going to be great

Samantha Cortes

Demon slayerrrrrr

Ron Jay

full metal top 3 and it ain’t 2 or 3

Fancy Francy

full metal alchemist ! the brotherhood version definetly

Senbu Johns

FMAB is widely regarded an almost perfect anime. The other 3 are more recent but pretty much at the top of their rankings at what they do. Vinland Saga is not as appreciated as the first 3 but I do believe it's the one you guys will enjoy the most out of the batch

E A M

Cyberpunk is so short they could probably fit that as an extra slot at some point, I’m sure they’ll get to it.

moonte

1. vinland saga 2. jujutsu kaisen 3. fmab 4. demon slayer

Patience

yes black clover is a magical anime and my hero is great but they might burned out on superhero shows

Frank the Tank

In what way?

romaiiiii

facts

Flow

all great options, hope we can get to them all eventually

Bmplol

Love FMA, Watched the oringal a long time ago and recently watched brotherhood, Id def watch brotherhood over original.

LilithCain

One is the one we all grew up with, the other is more accurate to the manga, I think. Both are valid!

Rena Unnie

There are two FMA, I never watched brotherhood, I watched the other version as I grew up with it.

ChainChompBraden

I watched their AoT reactions and don't at all recall them complaining during any of the slower paced moments in it. We'll have to see what they think when they do eventually get to Vinland Saga, but I have a hard time imagining them not being fully invested. It's also hard to claim it as overrated. It's not "niche" by any means, but it's never been as big of a name in anime as some of the more "mainstream" titles. The slower pacing of season 2 may play a part in that, but for those of us that do appreciate it, we *really* appreciate it. I think a "general" anime fan may prefer season 1 to season 2, but Vinland-specific fans prefer season 2.

DustinEatWorld

No JoJo,Cyberpunk or MHA…😓

Zimm

All 4 of these anime are great follow ups after finishing AOT and Death Note

Storm

JJK Pleaseee

Kevin Arriaga

JJk plz😭

Shirokir

If you guys do FMA it needs to be FMA Brotherhood. That is the version that is true to the manga. The original FMA was made before the manga was finished and show just made up stuff to fill out/end the story.

Low

No My Hero Academia again... I will never recover from this.

Elizabeth Green

My hero academia? 🥹 Black clover? 🥹

Laila

If FMA wins please watch FMA: brotherhood!

ArtofWillyO

Which Full Metal is a really really good question. I genuinely think they should just watch brotherhood. Its the true adaptation of the comics.

ArtofWillyO

One of the greatest animes created imo. its all just opinions bro

Julian Robinson

FMA is so overrated 💔

Eryk Klukaczyński

i'm glad to hear that, too many grammar-you-know-whos jumped on me too many times, so I use this sentence to defuse them a little bit ;D

NevoDaSlowPoke

English is my first and i dont see any mistakes maybe im just dumb tho lol

Leif

Heavy agree with that

Eryk Klukaczyński

Is it Fullmetal Alchemist (2003) or Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood? Because the difference is rather big, the 2003 version happened before the manga was finished, so it's not such a truthful adaptation, especially beyond episode 25. FMA Brotherhood adapts the whole manga and, in my opinion, is better. Of course, the original adaptation is not bad, but later, when material to adapt from was missing, anime creators made a rather boring story when compared to what happened in the manga. Also, the original adaptation is missing great characters like Lin or Oliver. Sorry for any grammar mistakes, english is not my first language.

Pop

You guys will love FMA

Marco Gutierrez

I think they're more than comfortable enough to experience some of the anime tropes. Hell FMA has more of them than Code Geass does. Battles will literally just come to a halt and turn into an episode of the Loony Toons. It happens right in the first episode too. The same cannot be said for Code Geass. It only has a handful of those goofy anime moments actually. They've also responded well to the handful of anime moments they've already experienced, like when Sasha was starving in basic training in AoT or pretty much any time Ryuk is on screen in Death Note. That's why I think Code Geass would have been better. Not to mention that they've also talked highly of Gundam before so they clearly like mecha anime.

Kaisen Carter

Highly recommend Vinland! if not this time, I hope to see you guys watch it someday 🙏

Topiia Music

Im gonna need them to start either Black Mirror or Doctor who this year, I beg!

Denver Gray

Just floatin on my boat, another month at sea waitin for Vinland...looks like it's gonna be awhile still

Conor Moriarty

There’s that remake coming out tho right? I’m personally waiting for that to jump in

Conor Moriarty

If I had a nickel everytime someone said they wouldn’t enjoy something before they watched it

Lassor

FMA is really cool, but it would be nice to see some newer stuff like the other 3 :D

Dotdot _142

You won't be disappointed.

Dotdot _142

Cyberpunk is so good, wish they would at least consider it, because it's only a few episodes.

Sanji Sama

I find it unbelievable that JJK is losing by so much, I understand FMA winning but still.

zimy__

Nooooo come on vote JJK 😭

YuviOnPatreon

I wish they'd included Naruto, but I guess it's too much to ask for a 100,000,000 episode show 🫣

Ginzo

I seen it and didn't vote for it for two reasons: I think it's overrated. Great writing =/= great show. Don't get me wrong, I think it's really good, but not this masterpiece fans are claiming it is. But more importantly, I've watched most of their reactions on their channel and they tend to favor the action shows more than the introspective, deep-thinking type of shows. So I voted for a shonen, FMA, instead. They complained a bit when AoT went from heavy action to the slower set up bits that weren't even that long. What do these people voting think that they're going to say when Vinland does a complete tonal shift in season 2? lol They will no doubt still enjoy the show but I don't think they're going to love it as much as Vinland fans seem to think. At least, not all of Badd Medicine.

Ginzo

Rule 1 of reaction polls. Don't put non anime on the poll with anime. The non anime will lose 99% of the time.

Ginzo

Code Geass has too many anime tropes that they aren't familiar with. They're slowly easing their way into the world of anime and I think FMA is a better bridge for that purpose. And also Code Geass is pretty mediocre during much of the 1st season. It isn't until the 2nd season that the show becomes a must watch.

Ginzo

I think people are vastly overestimating how much they would enjoy Vinland Saga. Particularly, the second season. If you've been following the channel for a while, it will come as no surprise if they happened to enjoy the 1st season more than the 2nd. I can already see the comments now ranting about how Mason Quinn's opinion is wrong or how he doesn't understand the point. lol

giulsi

I voted for Vinland and really hope you'll consider a short series in between like Cyberpunk Edgerunners 🫶🏼

giulsi

My exact thoughts!

Monaf

vinland saga being the lowest % is criminal lol

Eric

I’m around the same age of the guys and I would love for less shōnen recommendations, they can be novelty for someone new to anime but they can be tiring quickly if you are not a teenager anymore.

Lesedi

Making me choose between demon slayer and JJK is like making me choose my right or left hand. That being said. Definitely Demon slayer. The creativity, the story. It'll be enjoyable from start to finish. (and good timing with the trilogy movies coming out this year)

Aaron Yin

there is no wrong choices here, hopefully one day they will watch all of them and more! :)

BiggusDickus69

Frieren or Monster

Alliyah Denei

PRAYING for Demon Slayer!!!!!!!!

Przemysław Polek

Was hoping for JoJo's Bizzarre Adventure

꧁Coltonius Maximus꧂

All excellent choices btw

Clorox bleach G

FMA and Vinland are both their cup of tea. Demon slayer is not for them at all

Frank the Tank

Have you seen FMAB? Have you seen AoT? Those provide the same feel of steady storyline with interwining pieces and character arcs and backstory. Have you seen death note? It mainly explores moral issues through a cat and mouse story. If you don't see the comparisons maybe try a re-watch of the 3. JJK will have to much information for them. It's only their 3rd anime. Demon slayer is a decent story, easier to follow but the worst of all the options. Top tier animation without a doubt.

Naya Se7en & Skylene Rains

Berserk! :)

Erlacine

I hope one day they do an animated show like helluva boss :D

scwyd

smokin rocks voting FMA

Kelley&Ivy

Going with demon slayer but tbh I wouldn't mind FMA bc it's been on my list for a while 🤷‍♀️

infires man

brooo, they would absolutely love Vinland Saga and it's getting the least amount of votes. i know it's cold in Wisconsin rn but i didn't realize hell had also frozen over.

Leif

I’m praying that FMAB pulls thru, even if Vinland can’t. It’s definitely your type of show. Demon slayer and jjk just don’t have the same complexity and depth as fmab and Vinland

Sam Harris

still holding out hope to one day see you guys watch BBC's merlin

peachy af

A vast majority of what they react to isn't even anime?

Johnny Blue

FMAB supremacy. It's #1 in MAL for a decade for a reason. The other 3 don't even come close to the legacy that FMAB brings.

Crispin

DEMON SLAYER!!!

Mehdi R.

Why do you say that? it’s nothing like the former

Frank the Tank

It's perfect for them. Especially coming off AoT and Death Note.

Kumba Marah

Cmon guys you know Vinland saga is the best option don’t do this 🙏🏾

Maisie

yessss I'm hoping so hard for this

Mehdi R.

i hope YT members come thru

Mehdi R.

I dont think FMA is going to be their cup of tea

Nate

Personally happy with the result of the poll but Vinland is the most up their alley and DS is probably the least.

Clorox bleach G

I have watched the entirety of MHA, and I read the manga as the show came out

Clorox bleach G

It regularly sexualises characters who are meant to be 15

ct

FMA Brotherhood for the win 🥇

peachy af

Legitimately might take them a decade to finish

Kevin

Yea, I’m going to push through to the end either way. I’ve heard a couple others say it took awhile to get into it but loved it by the end, so I’m holding out hope. It’s not particularly bad or anything, I’m just not sucked into it and craving the next episode like a lot of animes.

Julian Robinson

Guys I think they’re ready for one piece

Julian Robinson

Jjk first

Julian Robinson

My friend who’s never watched anime ended up watching both season in 1 sitting. It’s an amazing anime

Kiki Varas

Lmao, Great then vote for Vinland saga. 🙌 I said I would choose Vinland saga not Jjk.

romaiiiii

my picks 1. Vinland Saga 2. Jujutsu Kaisen 3. Demon Slayer 4. FMA

romaiiiii

yikes

Love10 ❤️

FMA

Cjc

I guess I'm going to have to finally watch Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood. I thought Vinland Saga would win after the fuss people made about it not being in the last poll.

Zimm

1. Vinland Saga 2. FMAB 3. Jujutsu Kaisen 4. Demon Slayer

Money-Kate Olsen

Both Peaky Blinders and Alice in Borderland only have a handful of episodes left. I'm sure they'll be replaced by non-anime shows.

Marco Gutierrez

I wouldn't recommend JJK on my worst enemy. It's a terrible anime with no real stakes or meaning. Like Fairy Tail and Black Clover, protagonists will always just rally at the last second and pull some new attack or power-up out of their butt despite showing no training or effort previously. It's all fluff and no substance.

Emily G

It would be really cool to maybe see a non anime and non marvel show in the future. Something like Mad men or a comedy show like it’s always sunny! ❤️

Marco Gutierrez

Code Geass would have been a better anime to follow up after Death Note considering they're so similar, but Fullmetal it is.

Emily G

I agree!

Jcyn

Both shows would be absolutely phenomenal, tbh they could watch edge runners in the midst of whatever else they end up watching since it’s so short

Ginger

How about a non anime series? I could think of several.

J. Mattingly

Wolf’s Rain is such a classic.

Jess

I enjoyed Death Parade a lot and it definitely took a toll on me. I was trying to figure out why I haven't seen Wolf's Rain and I think around the time I thought about starting it, I watched Mushi-Shi instead (which I also enjoyed a lot). I'll have to go back and check it out.

Alexander Alayon Jr

Yu Yu Hakusho 🤣

Evolution64

You cannot watch FMA 03 without pirating it or buying a DVD set

Jenny Chlipala

Also on a side note with anime recs, Death Parade is a great series following the death games genre!

James Long

Has to be Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. And future suggestions: Cowboy Bebop, Monster, Frieren, Apothecary Diaries, and Violet Evergarden.

Jenny Chlipala

I’m excited for whatever y’all end up watching!! A more obscure and very interesting and deeper themed anime I think you’d all appreciate would be Wolf’s Rain. To me, it’s definitely up there with AoT themes about humanity and I really think you’d all enjoy the depth of the show (genre: dark fantasy, dystopian, post-apocalyptic)

peachy af

Literally my favorite protagonist of all time

peachy af

@ Kevin, damn that sucks. I hope it turns out alright when i watch it eventually

vertebra

FMA: Brotherhood

Jacob

Cyberpunk Edgrerunners or Vinland Saga are shows I think they’d like a lot.

Jacob

100%

Jacob

I agree

Alex2882

“I have no enemies” ahh comment

Jacob

I think they’d like Vinland Saga more but oh well.

Zack Sutton

Watch Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood from 2009 Not the OG 2003 ful metal Alchemist

Azmoz

I love FMA Brotherhood and would gladly watch it again, but voted for Vinland since so many people recommended it and I've never seen it

Kiki Varas

I feel like ppl are only voting for what they like for themselves and what’s popular instead of thinking what they’d like to watch the most. They’d love all of these series but if I had to decide which series they will connect with more between Jjk or Vinland saga for example, it’s gonna be Vinland saga that they will be perfect for them. I just feel ppl are voting for what’s popular or voting for things they like the most for themselves instead of thinking what series is right up there ally. In my opinion it’s shocking that Vinland saga is so low, when the plot and themes of that show is perfect for them.

Abdulaziz Faissal

You're making Vinland Saga fans look bad

Kalisa Fox

not really excited for any of these but still interested in ur reactions to em

Sophie So

I've been meaning to watch Jujutsu Kaisen myself so would be good to watch it with yous!

Brady Schwartz

ngl don’t wanna watch any of these 4 but will😂

Claudia Escarcega

I haven't watched Fullmetal Alchemist myself but I hope it wins 'cause that would be the perfect reason to finally see it

Sophie So

This!

Julie

Just want to echo the other comments about making sure you watch the correct FMA series! There are two Fullmetal Alchemist animes, one from 2003 and one from 2009. Both start out the same, but the manga that the shows were based on didn't wrap until 2010, so the first anime was only partly based on the manga, and spun off into its own original story once it ran out of source material halfway through. The 2009 anime (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood), though, is 100% faithful to the original story, and is rightfully considered one of the best anime of all time. You guys will love it, it's literally a perfect series.

ChainChompBraden

I genuinely believe Vinland Saga is only losing this poll purely because it's the anime the fewest number of voters have seen. Ah well, as long as they get to it eventually.

David Stevenson

I agree, its still early in the poll so hopefully it turns around

Alex2882

There should be an extra slot for anime instead of those movies that 90% of the audience don’t care about

Alex2882

Vinland Saga last place…. Rtarded ahh votes smh

cabosetek

Voting for Full Metal, but would also highly recommend Solo Leveling

TexasSnyper

Way to make the choice tough. 3 excellent choices and Vinland Saga.

Cody Book

Please make it the brotherhood version. Closer to the manga and a much better series

victoria

you HAVE to watch demon slayer im begging 😭

remina

Demon slayer might be my least favorite show here lol

Chosos Wife

Vinland saga is the best from AOT. Demon Slayer is good animation. FMAB is good in general. JJK is the best in terms of action and fighting and power scaling etc

Tom Murray

Jeez way to make it tough! I like these all but im voting for the one I think yall would like watching

Kiki Varas

How is Vinland saga not the top? It’s literally a perfect series for them and I’ve literally always seen many many comments recommending Vinland saga to them. I get ppl like demon slayer and full metal alchemist and they’d probably like it too but Vinland saga is a perfect series for them. It’s a genre right up there ally with great themes, I think more ppl should vote for Vinland sage this time bc even though fullmetal is great, we need to think what they would love the most out of these and I think Vinland saga is probably perfect for them compared to the other ones.

Rianne R

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, I beg!!!!

Elle

yes!

Ana

I wanted MHA because we need a change of pace. Both anime’s they watched were dark and depressing and all these animes on the poll are also dark and depressing. Like where is the variety? There so much more genre of anime and they’ve been stuck in one genre 😭😭

hex1c

How Vinland Saga are not the top pick blows my mind

Chuck Norris

I’ve also seen AOT and Vinland but I was told those are kind of different from most animes and I kind of get it after watching Solo leveling

BroKobe2404

I would love to see HunterXHunter as well

Kevin

Holy, if you thought Solo Leveling was good then you’ve got so many amazing shows ahead of you that will blow your mind. I’m jealous haha

CedricQ

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood please.

Michael Aldana

Also I recommended the English dub for full metal 🔥

BroKobe2404

I think jjk and demon slayer are more action and peak but vinland and fullmetal are more storytelling. I would love it if demon slayer or jjk would be next. Ive voted for demon slayer as well :)

Michael Aldana

I'm sure it'll eventually be on there

Ana

This doesn’t apply to you obviously 🙄

Seth

All of those are great, but in my eyes, FMA is king. Can't think of a better anime IMO. You should definitely watch Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood though (the one from 2009), as it is faithful to the original story, unlike its predecessor from 2003. I'd also recommend the dub. It's one of the greatest and among the few that more people enjoy in English than not.

BroKobe2404

I think its the highest rated show together with aot and atla, so I think that says enough lol

Kevin

I feel the same way about not being hooked. I’m trying to watch it for the first time. 15 episodes in and bored out of my mind. I think there’s a massive nostalgia skew for it unfortunately, wish some better animes were on the poll

Frank the Tank

FMAB for the win!

PKKite

Make sure it's FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST BROTHERHOOD it follows the actual story from the manga that the creator made. The one from 2003 had to change the story as it came out while the manga was still being made and imo its not as good still a good watch but I advise people look at the original story first in FMAB ALSO FMAB has a Allstar cast dub that should really be watched

Frank the Tank

Nah

Coraima Corona Montijo

Yaaay Full Metal!!!!

Elle

yeah I might plan on watching too it if it wins. I feel like they should specify if they are watching fullmetal alchemist or fullmetal alchemist brotherhood because I heard that brotherhood is just a remake but more accurate to the manga

Jesiii97

Voting for FMA, but I think Vinland Saga would also be a great show to watch!

Shellyse Bell

More people needa watch Vinland Saga cause why's this masterpiece in last place right now lol

Yarod Razo

Sadly they dropped it at s2 because it's not your typical "strive for vengeance" story after that 🥲 but man is it beautiful. To each their own tho I see why they wouldn't want to keep watching

maxi

Hinata gang! Hinata is so underrated but he's easily one of the best characters.

maxi

Same here. Good storytelling and character developments.

Ana

Yes it’s been so many requests idk why it didn’t make the poll

Yarod Razo

Man I'd give more if they'd watch Bojack horseman. Just finished it a couple weeks ago and yeah ...🙂

peachy af

Same here! I watched one episode and it didnt hook me but plenty of people speak so highly of it i might just watch it if it wins to see whats up

Yarod Razo

It's dated at 9. Something on a lot of sites, so it's good lol I've heard nothing but good things

Ana

Jjk fans and demon slayer fans let’s work together. Vote for demon slayer then next poll we all vote for Jjk. We need a new gen anime. Jjk fans think about it. You’ll have to wait for 2 whole shows to finish before getting to jjk. But if you vote demon slayer. You’re winning next poll for sure and only have to wait for demon slayer to finish

peachy af

I fucking love haikyuu. Im sure nobody couldve guessed that though

Jennimo

I'm sadddd I think their perspectives about it would be top tier

peachy af

Surprised to see no my hero academia? Its not my favorite anime by any means but i think its decent and they would like it imo

Angad Kang

Everyone who is not voting fma vote jjk less goo and also please do 3-4 eps a week it takes months for 1 anime series pleaseeee!!!!!

Elle

I’ve never watched fullmetal but it seems to be winning, is it good? Ive watched everything else but I wanna know how good fullmetal is compared to them

Jennimo

Tell me you haven't watched and understood the story without telling me

maxi

Yes, I'm down.

spiritkit

And for your GenX member berry Ashley Johnson played Chrissy Seaver in Growing Pains. (And she was in an avengers movie) she has a bafta for Last of Us, so does Laura Bailey.

Ana

We can turn the vote if we work together. Vote for demon slayer now then demon slayer fans will vote for jjk and we can skip full metal

Josh Gibson

Honestly I mean we are looking at 61 episodes with FMA vs 36 with Vox... at this rate we will get Vox in 2028😭🤣

Ana

Yeah so help demon slayer and give a vote lol

privatedadbod

If Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood wins please consider watching it dub. The dub is so good.

spiritkit

They loved the Dungeons and Dragons movie. And it's all the voice actors they don't know they love!!!

maxi

I can't believe both Demon Slayer and JJK are losing. Wow. So disappointed.

Asura

Lol no My hero academy? Damn ok in this list i would say Demon slayer

maxi

I mean, MHA does the same thing.

Slick447

They would love Vox Machina

Alexandra

Haven't watched any of those anime. Personally those choices aren't my cup of tea. Voted Vinland because it seemed like the one I would be most interested in. Hope you guys enjoy whatever option gets picked!

Ana

And solo leveling is actually one of the weak ones. Check out kaiju no 8

maxi

Those are such two specific random recommendations lol. I love it.

Josh Gibson

I actually asked about Vox Machina years ago when they were finishing up with avatar the last air bender and they said after legend of korra and attack on titan they were going to look at Vox....😭😭😭

Jake Gering

What do you mean? This is for what the next anime will be once Death Note finishes.

remina

Vinland losing it’s so over 😔

Diablos Cafe

Yeah it is, shits amazing I wish that was on the poll

T T T

please consider Haikyuu. or Bojack Horseman... lol 2 completely different shows

Ana

Jjk fans vote for demon slayer since its second place and us Demon slayer fans will vote jjk next poll. Let’s work together. Just reply if y’all down. We’ll get both first instead of having to wait for full metal

Adri Sweat

Yall really should check out Vox Machina!!

Diablos Cafe

Solo leveling!

spiritkit

Melee tooooooo!!!!!!!

spiritkit

Still no Legend of Vox Machina? You guys are missing out!! Dungeons and Dragons based on a campaign created and performed by the players and world builder themselves kickstarted and paid for by fans?! Come on you're killing me smalls!!!!

Evolution64

You cannot watch FMA 2003 without pirating it or buying the DVD

Ana

Yeah hopefully

《Silv3r》 •

Vineland saga and FMA ate good picks but the other ... nah

V STAN

I know right!!! We'll just have to hope it'll be there next time

Roxana G.

JJK please!

Ana

Noooo I’m disappointed.MHA should of been added to the poll 😭😭😭

V STAN

I'mma go with Vinland Saga, and hopefully MHA can make it into the next poll

Michael Aldana

Hopefully it's full metal alchemist brotherhood

V STAN

Facts, hopefully it's in the next poll

C. J. Ramirez

If fmab wins has to be dubbed

Clorox bleach G

Although I don’t like Vinland personally, they would love it. And although I like MHA personally, they would hate it.

Julian Robinson

Please do JJK

V STAN

Same!

Clorox bleach G

If I remember they said on a live they want to play the game first, could be wrong tho?

Clorox bleach G

Some people have reading and writing disabilities that make it hard to follow along with subtitles

Sarah

I love anime but I'd love to see more movie reactions if I'm honest. We don't really get that many especially compared to episodes for shows and alot of us are most excited for movies. 🩷

RunAwayCloak

Vinland fan base is way smaller than every other fan base on the list also a lot of people dropped it at season 2 it’s not winning at all

Clorox bleach G

Imagine coming off of amazing and very serious stories that make you question ethics and morals in real life and then starting MHA how disappointing that would be.

BroKobe2404

can I also just quickly say how dope it is that you guys are watching anime now, Its something you can keep watching at any age and enjoy it like nothing else. Thank you guys for keeping up with these Much love :))

Arudorin

All the choices are great! I wouldn’t mind what gets choosen

mbdd

Do fullmetal alchemist Brotherhood. When fullmetal alchemist was made the source material was still being written so the story had to be changed. Kinda like the last few seasons of GoT. Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is the remake that followed the actual story.

Christian Cruz

So no more death note? Whaaat I would’ve voted death note if it was up there

Clorox bleach G

They would hate demon slayer, it’s bloody weird sexualising children constantly

Chimera

Can we get some confirmation that it's "Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood"? It's a more complete experience, whereas "Fullmetal Alchemist" isn't fully accurate to the original story.

Jake Gering

todomeowmo

Demon slayer and JJK! Hopeful for MHA next!

Dy'Nasha

demon slayer losing again, im grasping at straws

Faiza

FMA but make sure you watch the Brotherhood version. The other one didn’t fully adapt the manga and went off with its own random plots and Brotherhood is faithful to the actual plot / story

Josh Gibson

VOX MACHINA COME ON IV BEEN ASKING SINCE AVATAR THE LAST AIR BENDER ENDED!😭

JTTobi

Demon slayer!

Eric Wallace

Fullmetal alchemist *brotherhood* I hope

E A M

Definitely react to FMA Brotherhood guys

RunAwayCloak

Shut up it’s their channel that can watch in in whatever they wanna watch it in

Jennimo

Still no My Hero Academia love 😣

Kel

Voting for JJK just because it’s been on my list forever and this would make me actually watch it (which is exactly how I ended up watching Death Note with you haha). Everything is more fun with Badd Medicine!