Patrefans
alwaysrollsaone from patreon
alwaysrollsaone patreon

A Soldier's Life - 291 - Strength of Giants (edited on 6-28-25)

🕑 Added 2024-11-07 05:14:44 +0000 UTC

Comments

Kevin O'Malley

Unless he gets the ghost killing artifact, which Konstantin may well have looted from the Emperor's palace, there was no way to get thru the wraiths to get back to the dungeon. But yes, based on the essences, he should camp in that dungeon until the rewards dropped off. Also, should loot the full runic armor they left on the surface.

Trevayne

Thanks for the chapters. I can see the criticism for using a hard-to-replace potion for a fight like this, but this probably was the best opportunity to see what this potion does, without the risk of a combat to the death. If he comes across a similar potion, he can use it with more confidence having some idea of how it works.

Space Cadet

just like a game of d&d. characters tend to hoard single use items to the extent that they never get used. I am not sure I see the value in a potion that increases your strength for 2 minutes, so using it when you have a set up like this is perfect. The only other time to use it is waiting outside a dungean room.

Marnie

Either my consumption of the essences or the dreamscape amulet made the learning process much easier for me than *befo. Spelling before

Erick Thiemke

corrected

Erick Thiemke

think i edited it - word searhch coes up zero

Erick Thiemke

edited

Erick Thiemke

edited

Erick Thiemke

edited

Erick Thiemke

corrected i think

Thaabit Rivertree

This is so frustrating. Mynesha cant even speak for herself. At this rate, they will either be putting a petulant, immature child on the throne or Glisha, effectively. It also doesnt make sense why they cant just take zorana themselves. Its obvious gerring invovled with them will only lead to more trouble. The only benefit so far that Eryk has found is safety on the road and possible dungeon access. This just feels out of character for Eryk. He isnt one to get manipulated so hard or so long.

HappyNoms

His pathway to freeing maveith's sister is...checks notes...not pragmatically offering thousands of gold, not offering a runic blade, or an artifact, or essences, ah, here's the plan, just engineer the election of the supreme leader of all orcish government. Yes, the obvious choice. Definitively giving that a bit of side eye, but for going that route, the writing is good. The realism and subverting expectations of the sharp 30 second fight was a brilliant choice and helps sell the whatever-it-takes track Eryk is set on.

Mercutio Montano

Giants are among my favorite races. Only their arrogance makes them weak. 100 giants, working together, with careful understanding of their terrain, are neigh unstoppable. In D&D, ALL gamemasters save their player's lives when they have their giants be solo OR not target the 1. Healer 2. Mage. Because that's who should die 1st ... all the time. Every time. For some darn reason, many player groups don't really protect their backline well, and, if a GM is so inclined, that backline would be crushed in 1 or 2 turns.

Andrew G.

I don’t agree with most of the criticism of this chapter. Abrupt or anticlimactic fights here and there shows self awareness of the genre, it’s not a flaw. Sometimes, we have to see the fruits of the progression effort. This isn’t a video game where every opponent is scaled off of your level. I also think it makes a lot of sense to use a potion here seeing as the opponent is unknown, larger, has magical tattoos enhancing abilities, magical armor, and just took a potion himself. Hindsight is 20/20, yeah maybe Eryk didn’t need it in retrospect, but it makes sense for the character in context to have made the decision he did. Not everything a protagonist does has to be prescient or facilitates the plot, that’s how stories start feeling contrived. This is more realistic and I appreciate and it’s why I think you’re one of the better writers in this genre.

IndyBart

I’d love to just see a series of recap chapters as a giant montage scene of him solo in the Shimmering Dungeon as he harvested the snot of it.

Andrew Crews

She looked at me, a little annoyed. ❌[“You] defeated him too quickly in front of his warriors. You took a lot of honor from him today.” She sighed**, “After that** if word spreads, others will be hesitant to challenge our progress.” I didn’t understand orc culture. Was Glasha blaming me for winning too fast? As we rode away, I missed the feeling of power the potion had given me. ❌[As we rode,] I yearned to feel it again, and my mind drifted toward returning to the Shimmering Labyrinth. Edited: She looked at me, a little annoyed. “You defeated him too quickly in front of his warriors. You took a lot of honor from him today.” She sighed. “After that, if word spreads, others will be hesitant to challenge our progress.” I didn’t understand orc culture. Was Glasha blaming me for winning too fast? As we rode away, I missed the feeling of power the potion had given me. The craving crept in—I longed to feel it again, and my mind drifted toward returning to the Shimmering Labyrinth.

Andrew Crews

Either my consumption of the essences or the dreamscape amulet made the learning process much easier for me ❌[now]. According to Glasha, I pushed the group until late evening ❌[the first day], making over fifty miles. Edit: Either my consumption of the essences or the Dreamscape Amulet made the learning process much easier for me than before. I must have been pushing the group hard because, by late evening on the first day, we had covered over fifty miles—something even Glasha took note of.

Andrew Crews

I weighed my response. How could it hurt to brag a little? “Iwas scouting the fleet as it traveled through Kraken Bay. I saw a lot of Mynasha in action.” (I prefer a stronger innuendo, see below) ❌[“You] were with the Hounds that plagued the fleet?” Mynasha asked, now somewhat curious. ❌[“You] are a Hound then?” She either didn’t catch my reference to her being almost nude, or perhaps she wasn’t embarrassed. Edit: I weighed my response. How could it hurt to brag a little? “I was scouting the fleet as it traveled through Kraken Bay. Saw a lot of Mynasha in action—she really laid bare the power of magic.” “You were with the Hounds that plagued the fleet?” Mynasha asked, now somewhat curious. “So, you are a Hound then?” Either she didn’t catch my little joke, or she just had no shame—both seemed entirely possible.

Invalid Entry

THIS is what it took to get him to think of returning to the labyrinth? That’s honestly been one of my biggest gripes. He could go there with a small competent team and grind for a year or two and come out a god. I’m sure essence returns would tail off somewhat but there’s so many rooms he could keep finding safe ones to grind for the essences he needs. Not to mention if he could find a mage or potion or artifact that could temporarily share the effects of spellforms between two people, which sort of seems like something that should be possible within this system of magic. Maybe just a spell no one has developed because there are so few use cases I guess.

ShadowOfHavoc

Having read both the pre edit and post edit version of this chapter. I never got the feeling the MC was OP in this fight. My main take away was his lack of subtlety, for 4 books he kept all his cards close to his chest, only revealing what he needed to to those close to him. Now that he has started to share some of his secrets with his companions, he seems to not really care what he might expose to strangers. I personally think he would of won the fight no problem even without using the potion maybe not in like three moves like in the original but still.

ShadowOfHavoc

Even with the edits giving us his reasoning I still think it is a waste. To be 100% honest it feels like a cop out and an easy way to get rid of a strong potion.

Deliver roo

I agree that it must be clear that this is an important duel and not Eryk casually showing off how much better than the orcs he is. So it will make sense that he decides to use one of his best potions.

ShadowOfHavoc

I agree him drinking the potion doesn't really make sense. Using that potion in a non life or death fight is a waste.

Steven Savage

should just be "chosen to attach to"

daniel dantas

This has already been shown, but you being better, stronger means nothing in this world, the winner is decided in a split second by the one who adapts best, in a fight without using his best cards, orc simply did not know and did not expect to fight with someone so skilled and apparently strong enough to hurt him, simple, for me eryk is in the right measure, he has been through a lot and is constantly training and perfecting himself while he sleeps, his skill needs to be lethal, konstatin trained him for that

daniel dantas

I think it makes sense, eryk has trained with the best in the empire and has at his disposal a device that allows him to train constantly, added to the potion, he SHOULD have an easy victory, not everything needs to be so hard fought, another point is that even if the orc was skilled, he couldn't use his tattoos and was surprised by eryk's unexpected strength because he didn't know what he had drunk, simple as that a great champion falls

daniel dantas

i have a question, these tattoos work using ether right? If eryk hits them with the mage slayer, will the tattoo lose its effect? if that's the case, then even with tutuage activated, the slightest scratch would make them lose the buff and in that moment of surprise and momentary weakness, eryk can win quickly

daniel dantas

he doesn't need to know the strength of the enemy, in pure mastery he can defeat the orc with the same ease, during the fight it seems that the potion served only to destabilize the orc with a blow, when he could defeat him only by attacking weak points such as, hand, thighs and finally finish the fight in the same way, instead of the fight ending in 3 secs, at most it would last 15 and that being generous

daniel dantas

But author, why does he need to drink? I understand that he can't use his air shields, but he can defeat this orc just as easily without the use of the potion, him using a forcing potion to match 1 orc seems unnecessary when his experience is so high in fighting multiple orcs

Deliver roo

It would make sense if the stakes were higher, considering that he doesn’t know the strenght of the enemy and the extent of the effect of the potion. In my opinion the real problem is that it just seems like he wants to show who has got the best potion so the result is an overwhelming display because the best warrior with the best potion and the best weapon is the obvious winner. At least there is an hint that it may serve to scare others so it may not be a total waste.

Erick Thiemke

maybe - the warlord couldnt use his tattoos to enhance himself which are a big reason why they are fearsome opponents (going back to the battle in the collegium)

Erick Thiemke

he couldnt use his tattoos to enhance his physcial traits

Erick Thiemke

he needed to be 100% certain he would win. he couldnt use aether. I will do better in an edit explaining

Erick Thiemke

i will do a better job writing it but it was either win or the escort mission would end here.

Erick Thiemke

i am going to add something about Glasha monitoring the fight for use of aether. the Warlords tattoos are their biggest strength - enhancing their strength, speed and endurance. He wasnt able to use them so drank the potion

Erick Thiemke

this encounter was expected by Glasha...maybe not that it would be her half-brother standing in their way but this is why they hired Fortuna's Chosen

Erick Thiemke

this is why he was hired to escort them though. they knew others would try and pervent them from reaching their destination. i will try to write it better when i edit it today

Erick Thiemke

i will add something that he needs to imbue the entire potion for the full effect. aether restoratives are different.

Erick Thiemke

i will add something about needing to consume the entire potion for the 'full effect'

Justin Garrett

I agree MC swordsmanship fits and is not OP considering how it was obtained through studying with elite fighters and champions. Drinking the potion of strength is makes sense due to challenge of the beating the warlord with holding back not to kill him and facing an unknown skilled opponent.

Labruta146

once the seal is open it expires pretty quickly from what i remember and he also didnt know how strong the effects would be

Zera

If that was his only strength potion, I agree it was a terrible choice to use it against someone he should have the advantage. There should be a bad consequence later on because he wasted it, or he could learn/buy some other strength potions to replace it, otherwise his dumb actions just don't get punished which always leaves me with a bad taste as a reader.

daniel dantas

I think it's exaggerated and strange that he drank an entire dungeon potion for 3 seconds and for a duel, this potion could save his life, why did he drink it all?

Mason W

It is a bad idea to get involved in the orc supreme politics just for Maveiths sister. This feels like it will end badly.

Sean Kauffman

10min potion seems a bit much for a 1-1 duel. Maybe edit so he only drinks a sip or something like he learned with the mana recovery potions.

Ryan Oakes

Eryk has trained with and sparred with the best people in the empire. He can also train every night with the amulet with said people and constantly improve in skill. He could've probably beat the guy without the potion, but has no frame of reference for how good warlords are. So taking the potion wasn't a bad thing to do to guarantee victory. The potion on top of his skill SHOULD have made the fight easy and quick. Everything checks out. We also don't know if this warlord is anywhere close in skill to the other warlords. This warlord could be a character we see in passing in the story. Not every fight needs to be hard fought. Having a strong character isn't a bad thing. I don't understand why people desire tragedy for others or for everything to be hard fought.

Otto Kovar

Title: 129 - Cherished Champion

visigoth

It might be the absolute worst thing to do given his situation but my pride really wants Eryk to tell these honor-bound orcs that they, in fact, have no such thing. Typical in martial-based honor systems. So far orcish manipulation isn’t very subtle, Ms Glasha - or should I say, Mrs Glasha-Mateo xD

1536539

Thank you for the chapter

1536539

He really shouldn’t reveal any more of his abilities, i even think he showed too much, it is always better to be greatly underestimated and dismissed then to be overestimated and seen as a threat or even worse, a rich bounty.

Adunn

I’m glad he didn’t. I feel like author intentionally sets up situations for outsiders to be impressed by his accomplishments and strength but it’s been super overdone in this story and feels really forced.

Salvo

I would have Eryk spit the concealed cork out of his mouth to get him off balance after the shield block. Konstantian’s training was all about cheating! This would be better as the next guy will demand no potions.

Chachi

imo he should’ve maimed him to get back at glasha. eryka has been nothing but foolish letting glasha control him like a puppet

Pope Yoda I

MC has had his stamina commented on numerous times. Going by the formula: More Essence = More Dong, MC probably stands a good chance.

Andrew

Thank you!

M van Dongen

Women and communication.....🤣 If she wanted a different outcome she should have communicated her wants/needs.

PatronTurtle

Feels like a waste of a potion. This trip better be worth it

Silver Beard

The Orcs would likely win that one. They are physically more robust than humans.

Jordan

I agree with ‘TheAlreds90’. The orc Warlock is supposed to be at the pinnacle of their warrior society. That wasn’t reflected at all in the fight. He can’t be this much of a pushover even with the potion being in effect. Also, adding potions seems against the spirit of the duel. They also weren’t used by the pathfinder leader in the past so it’s a little odd that they’re being added here.

Jordan

“I had to agree on that point as we were outnumbered two to one but did have three spell casters.” …one but ‘we’ did have….

Pope Yoda I

"Can we just have a literal dick measuring contest next time?"

Silver Beard

Still find it curious Glasha hasn't figured out or mentioned Eryk's abilities. Disappointed Eryk didn't correct the idea that it was he alone and not a 'pack' that thwarted their advance or downed the Roc. If he wants to 'brag' that's the way to go.

Jordan

“And this is what you have chosen to attach the Mynasha?” the -> to ? ‘Attach the Mynasha’ sounds odd and I’m guessing ‘the’ is a typo, but I’m not sure.

Silver Beard

Thanks for the chapter. Glasha is/was hoping to force Eryk to fight a dozen duels- building up 'stolen honor' before the Election so his inclusion as a First would be accepted. Use of spell forms would have been even quicker, but perhaps fatal too.

Jordan

“I don’t recognize see any Pathfinders among them.” The above sentence has an extra word. ‘Recognize’ or ‘see’ needs to be removed for it to make sense.

Win Rar

If he didn't use the potion, I think the fight should have taken longer but because he did use it, it fits. So I agree with your take.

Jordan

“I pushed until late evening the first day, making over forty miles, according to Glasha.” I -> We We makes more sense as Eryk isn’t by himself and is part of a group.

Jordan

“It was the death of Trakor that spurned others to remove the Supreme.” spurned -> spurred

Kbzzy

I think it tracks considering how good he has been in armed combat against other strong orcs, even when outnumbered

TastyApple

I don’t think the MC was too OP. I think the opponent lacked fight IQ though lol. Against a patient and more thoughtful opponent, I think our MC would have a little more trouble.

Ivan Kanewske

Maybe have the fight last a touch longer, If he fights Konstantin would the fight last longer? Is an Orc warlord so much less skilled than Konstantin a long term well trained hound?

william wallace

Fight seems a bit quick unless the orc is a scrub. Maybe have the orc use the potion mid fight and have eric at least take some damage? Or lean into eric totally out classing him?

Alex

It doesn't make sense for MC to use a potion for the fight. If he looses still alive. It is first big Orc fight in BC - why not test the warlords.skill and let Benito make.some $$$. Maybe let Benito sway Eryk to drag out the fight a little and win some money from Mayasha

TheAlreds90

I don't think he is too strong but that the warlord is not strong enough. I would have expected more skill out of him.

Eriach

Potentially-hand wag-

Nick Nicholson

Seems like an unnecessary waste of a potion

Eriach

You got this, just take your time. ♥️ and tftc

Win Rar

Orcs Pride for chapter title?

Erick Thiemke

4th of 4 for last weeks cycle. Tomorrow is a WOrld Sphere chapter, but I plan to edit these last two chapters of Soldier as well. Some things didn't flow well in my mind. A question for readers - is the MC too OP in this fight? He used one of his aces to make sure he won but I could have drawn it out some


More Creators