Patrefans
EdgeCases from patreon
EdgeCases patreon

Just Add Mana — Book 2, Chapter 42 — Red Symphony, Part 3

🕑 Added 2026-01-01 15:00:24 +0000 UTC

Comments

BeanerOO

Excellent chapter! Also, the goat had me chuckling at work, which was awkward to explain haha

Defiant

Tyftc!

Ben Bass

TYFTC! I feel bad for our spiderlings, I hope they and their goats aren’t too put out. I also have to say it is nice seeing the Crimson Commander a little terrified of Cale.

Michelle Goodman

those poor fire elementals... getting harassed by Cale. and yes before i finished reading the fun facts... I was imagining something a lot more sexual.

Youkai-sama

You gittin yo Ass whooped, thas what's goin on! 😆

Gavriel

Welp, Cale has got to figure out how to kill through karmic lines and the like, or something even harder to stop.

Leander

I disagree, it was very interesting worldbuilding, giving us a glance at the wider machinations going on. It’s just the one chapter at a time format that is making it seem superfluous.

Larc

Thanks for the chapter. I've been enjoying this series quite a lot, but I've some thoughts that have been bugging me. In hindsight it's a bit negative, my immediate thoughts upon reading this chapter in isolation. But I figured I'd leave them in since there's probably some useful feedback buried in there. Just take it with a grain of salt, I still quite enjoy JAM :) I hope this reads better when taking the finale as a whole, but as it stands it took--and I counted--thirty paragraphs of lore-dumping before we got to the first action of the red commander in this chapter, which was deciding to cast the spell. Then about fifteen more before he actually cast it. Then Cale threw a few punches, and we panned to a rather out of place goat infodump in the middle of the action, little enough as it was, only for the two newly introduced characters to *also* do literally nothing. I guess what I'd ask is: was any of this information pertinent to the story, did we need the Red Commander spelling it out for us, as readers? Cale already suspected that these were abyssal relics, and identified which effrcts came from the commander's own magic, and which effects came from the relics. If I read Cale's part in isolation, he notices the endless font of mana coming from elsewhere, and dare I say that's enough for us readers to understand the Red Commander is connected to something, or someones, and from there draws and stores mana. As for the broken throne, we've been told what it does, yes. But is that information necessary, when we're about to, I presume, given the spiderlings, be *shown* what it does as well? Just things to consider. I'm noticing a tendency to focus on thoughts, over-explanation and several tangents right in the middle of the action. This works fine enough when Cale is impervious to harm and all-powerful, as has so far been the case, but less so when it comes to a book-ending smackdown between two realm-ending threats. I'm put to mind of the first moment Cale became Torment's Shadow, how, without musing over anytime, Cale rained spell after spell, singularly focused on destroying his enemy. I wish we'd committed to that more strongly.

Apoca

Don't stand between a man and his goat!

Neo3602

Oof, hope thoes kids are going to be ok.


More Creators