Patrefans
Felixfalck from patreon
Felixfalck patreon

Like milk..

🕑 Added 2023-02-19 00:00:02 +0000 UTC

Comments

Felixfalck

Don't worry, you didn't come across as either! I very much appreciated your insight and didn't find it neither rude nor aggressive in the slightest!

Carthoris

Apologies if I seemed sort of rude or aggressive with that, I just like to share my thoughts so writers can have a better idea of what their readers are liking and disliking. I mean in the end you should take the story in the direction that you want and are satisfied with as making everyone 100% happy is just an impossibility. And if I really wanted to see things work in a certain way I could always start my own branch and see what happens. That is the beauty of chyoa.

Felixfalck

First of all, thank you for the elaborate and insightful feedback. As the writer I've found it to be difficult at times to put myself in the place of the reader. What makes sense to me at this point doesn't necessarily make sense to the readers yet, or even at all. I'll admit that I'm not entirely satisfied with my handling of Rebecca's departure either. I wasn't initially gonna make the changes as retroactive to her as I did, but ended up with that direction regardless on the basis of her punishment for intervening with the game. My initial idea was for the game to tie a nice ribbon around the character's new identity to make their existence with that identity make sense. I'll probably end up doing the complete opposite for the next branch of Chicken out. As for Alice's arc and the wish in general.. In the original (Source material if you will) story the winning party are brought to a different realm of sorts where they're back to their original body and mind. They're also face to face with their new variant, as well as the game incarnate. While I want to do a similar gig for my endings, I personally think it'd sort of defeat the purpose of being 100% your original self when in the "wish realm" as you'd 10/10 wish everything back to normal if things were as dire as they currently are. Perhaps one would keep a few mundane changes because they're convenient or objectively better than what was originally there, but that'd be about it. They will of course have memories of not only how they used to be themselves, but the other contestants as well. For what I have planned, I imagine the victor to be in the wish realm with their original body, while the conscience of the game inhabits their new, corrupted one. As they're in the wish realm, talking to the admin and mapping out the details of their wish they'll slowly drift into the new corrupted version of themselves. The longer they take to map out the wish, the more it'll be influenced by the effects of the game. In this way I'll be able to experiment with a wide variety of endings (over time). It should also enable characters like Alice to properly inflict whatever mischievous, hate fueled fates upon their "friends" as they want.. The original Alice would certainly not want that. The slightly or completely corrupted one however.. I hope this covers most of what your concerns, especially regarding the ending. If the way "Ruby" was basically deleted from the group of friends was poorly handled or an undesirable outcome I'll take it with me for all future interpretations of the concept^^

Grif end

While i also agree with that we should keep in mind that pehaps the winner would get a glimpse about reality as for what is the point if that's the case it's that someone might lose their motivation. For example the others might had dropped too if Alice chickened out at the early game

Dyamonde

excellent analysis, valid points throughout

Carthoris

Also while I am really enjoying this story and think you're doing a great job I do have one complaint or disappointment if that is a better why to put it. It was how the chickening out was handled. I feel like it kind of defeats the purpose of the wish at the end. Like say with Alice, she wants to use the wish to fuck over all her friends (that may have changed with more recent changes to her but we'll go with that for this example). Because Ruby chickening out cause reality to be completely changed and nobody remembers how it use to be, Alice has no reason or want to fuck her over with her wish. Should Kitty and Bitch chicken out reality will be changed to fit their new selves causing everyone to no longer know each other or even be 'friends'. This would then completely destroy Alices ending arc, wanting to make her friends lives worse with her wish. You could say this same thing with Kitty. She had deduced that she was the only one with enough of her mind intact to use her wish to fix everone. However should Alice and Bitch chicken out it will break her ending too. Everyone would have completely new lives, never having met or become friends. Kitty would no longer have any drive to fix them as this is just how they've always been. Plus she doesn't even know them and would just be confused as to why they are all together. So yeah I felt like it breaks the endings or at least implied endings of the story. Sorry that was long but I wanted to share my thoughts because of how much I've been enjoying your story.

Carthoris

Will admit I got a bit bamboozled with that title.


More Creators