Case 272: The Annecy Shootings
🕑 Added 2024-02-10 08:11:32 +0000 UTCOn September 5 2012, a cyclist driving through the French Alps came upon a shocking scene. Married couple Saad and Iqbal al-Hilli, along with Iqbal’s elderly mother Suhaila al-Allaf were shot execution style while sitting in their BMW in a secluded parking spot in the woods surrounding Chevaline. 7-year-old Zainab al-Hilli clung to life on the ground nearby, while 4-year-old Zeena al-Hilli was nowhere to be seen. A local cyclist, Sylvain Mollier, was also fatally shot in the brutal killing spree.
An international investigation quickly raised more questions than it did answers. What were the victims doing in this isolated area? Had they been targeted as part of some sinister activity or were they killed at random by a lone psychopath?
Team:
Anonymous Host - narration
Elsha McGill - research, writing
Milly Raso - creative direction
Mike Migas - production, music
Andrew D.B. Joslyn - music
Comments
Bob Trenwith
AR I wasn't making a negative comment about Americans. I am just asking that they use the correct pronunciation for the location of the case. But ... there is one Americanism I have to complain about ... WTH is "I COULD care less"?
Matt Hudson
Fantastic episode. An excellent delivery of intriguing and frustrating case. May the victims rest in peace and hopefully receive justice one day.
Nompilo Ngcobo
Love this podcast❤️. Please cover South African case Thabo Bester🙏
Paulette
Says someone who wishes to be identified entirely by an arm.
Jason Barber
Yeah seriously: we all know what they meant and equally know Casefile aren't being derogatory in any way at all - so what's the problem? Most people don't work in mental health, while an increasing number of us are so over the PC Police whining endlessly about every kind of wording that doesn't fit the latest 'language' decided on by social workers obsessed with never offending anyone - ever. Harden up Buttercup: outside your workshops is a whole *planet* who couldn't give a sh!t which words are used -- only the intent behind them -- and none of the Casefile writers are being offensive at all.
Stacey Carson
It’s a kind and respectful approach to avoid labelling someone based upon one (ableist) characteristic that they may have. It allows us to see a person as more than their diagnosis…. This has been a lovely strength-based trend in healthcare for some time now ❤️
David Rogosaroff
Why?
AR
Don't tarnish all Americans with this mispronunciation. Before George Bush Sr took office, we as a culture pronounced the word "ih-rock" and my experience is that it's only been since the 90s that everyone just started pronouncing it in the laziest most disrespectful way possible. I still say "Ih-rock" though. We exist!
Carolyn Barry
Yep. It's like the Jon Benet case - we will never know thanks to police botching it early on
Benjamin
Live 10 minutes from claygate and somehow hadn’t heard this case before! Great episode
Stacey Carson
Hi team! Love this episode. Can I please ask that you use person-first language in future episodes? The term ‘schizophrenic’ could be replaced by ‘X was living with schizophrenia’, for example. Useful link for more info: https://pwd.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/PWDA_LanguageGuide_A5_WEB.pdf
Ally Jakubicka
Perfect crime? Sounds like a poorly executed investigation.
J. Chips
Unsolved murders like this case really keep me up at night! 😰
Bob Trenwith
You appear to be whining about something.
Byron Ridenour
Bob is always in the comments whining about something
Megan Brennan
You replied much kinder than I would have 🥰
Casefile True Crime
Hi Jamie. You should have heard the opening theme. Did it not play?
Casefile True Crime
Happy new year Bob
Connie Archibald
Another fascinating story, going to it again!
Bob Trenwith
If it was him the gun would have to have been very close to the scene, and none was found.
Sam Gorrie
How did they rule out the initial cyclist who found the bodies? Seems potential to claim to have found the bodies but was actually involved. Incredibly hard to believe and surreal case all round
Bob Trenwith
Even major coincidences happen more often than you would think. Like the well-known story of a couple who had met as adults going through one of the wife's family photo albums, and the husband recognising himself and his family in the background of one of those photos which was taken as a 5 year old. Unless we have more evidence I think we have to trust that this avenue was properly explored. Doesn't mean there is nothing in it either, but I just like to pull up people who jump to absolute conclusions ... after all, we have attacked police here before for doing the same thing to the exclusion of all other avenues of investigation.
Marc Surlis
Ah, misremembered who had the passports in the pocket! And yeah, coincidences happen but it's a major coincidence that both her husbands died on the same day surely!
Bob Trenwith
How is the victim having the his own and his family's passports in his pocket a red flag? And ... coincidences happen.
Marc Surlis
It's entirely possible I missed it when listening, it would not be the first time! But two questions: - the wife's og American husband dying the same day, coincidence?! Hardly? - someone's jacket had their passports in the pocket? How is that not a case closed revelation?
Bob Trenwith
Do Brits or the French pronounce Iraq as Eye-rark? If not, could you please save American pronunciations for American cases. It feels like you're leaving your origins behind.
Jamie Thomas
Did you forget the opening bells or did I miss them somehow?
SalBee
This story is unreal.
AR
This case!!! So excited to hear your rundown of this complex mystery
Eileen
New Casefile makes my life better.
Paddy Murphy
Literally where the truth is stranger than fiction.