Patrefans
C_Mantis from patreon
C_Mantis patreon

Chapter 339

🕑 Added 2024-06-21 19:00:20 +0000 UTC

Comments

nolan saylor

Sure it's silly, but little things of world building like perfumes still being a thing at high tiers, and not needing to be high tier to be enjoyable, are nice. 'speed waddled' I hadn't thought about how Toby would shrink down. A planet on the back of a giant is grandiose and awesome. A shrunken planet on a normal sized person sound beautiful. Bonsai taken to the extreme. Not tierist art, but genuinely nice. Our echo meets the MC. I enjoy that Matt made himself seen by the Monster Collective. Not agreeing to give info to them is smart, as they are still active ascenders. More so than that, without the bloodline essence the Monster Collective now has at least some additional reasons to not wish the Empire to fall. Well, not to be part of the reason it falls, if they are seemingly innocent Aster or Liz may join them. Martin the Warrior! I am happy with the reference to Redwall. Maybe that is my own assumption but I doubt it, and don't care regardless. I do like the image of tiny mouse on large turtle-man... who has an even tinier world on his back. Again the Feds make every interaction unpleasant. Yeah, the games of GPs are unknown to many. Best to avoid involving yourself for as long as possible. It truly does sound gorgeous. Assumedly no longer blinding at their tiers... or that is accounted for by the craftsmen. The Ascenders being truly supportive is a nice touch. The water ascender having a dry throat... -and the ascenders 'drowning' out his complaints. Matt going to greet the others is a nice touch as well. He is growing. I wish a name was given for the person at the rearguard, just for that extra bit of enjoyment if the name is the visible in the Minkala Chronicles chapter, or perhaps even the PoV in question. Poor Gan Le. Lucky Sects though, probably going to have another Ascender equivalent in a couple millennia. Yup Me probably will enjoy the company, maybe even becoming Gan Le's sugar mama... The most tanky family in existence. Virgil's grandfather was somehow worse?! I mean, he was in charge of the Feds when they were less forced to be restrained... but wow. Virgil is an easy bar to clear for morality and this is apparently underground. Allie to the rescue! Bring Carlos a friend!

Nicholas Grey

“Current exchange rates, which did fluctuate, put six hundred kilocredits around… a Tier 18 mana stone. Or it could be a few Tier 8 skills because they also usually sold for around a megacredit.” Why is something worth 600k (ie, 0.6 of a mega credit) worth “a few” (ie, more than one) items worth a full mega credit?

Alex

Of course they're gamblers. They're bored.

austin kutz

Nope, looks like he accidentally pushed the notification for an old chapter. Or was it Patreon fucking up?

Christian Sullivan

Old chapter ppl

Julie Smith

As usual, a good ending to the chapter. Who is the person and who deserves to know Matt's power? I'd guess Allister, the Tier 50 friend of Manny.

Quixotic

Why did this send out an email again?

Trevor Mergen

Thanks!

Dylan Kelley

In this world you are so wrong it hurts. This is more akin to a barter system with the caveat that everyone wants/needs mana so it's an easy thing to set up a sudo-currency around.

Dylan Kelley

In the very chapter you are referring to, Matt clearly suspects Gan Le is lying. It's also implied that everyone else also thinks he is. So while WE the readers know it's actually the truth, everyone in story suspects he has other motives or reasons for deceit.

tem

> I get the feeling he really wants nothing to do with wars. It was half of what he complained about when I had him trapped in my spirit place. This seems like odd phrasing/small continuity error. Why would Aster say she "gets the feeling"? That turn of phrase, denotes guessing/deducing, that they're not a 100% sure. Then she follows it up by saying Gan Le complained about it incessantly. So Aster 1000% knows he hates war and wants nothing to do with it. Continuity error comes in referencing chapter 329. Gan Le literally whinges to the whole of Team Zero about his disdain for wars and those that live for battle. He shares his whole sugar mommy plan with them and even tells them he was intentionally sandbagging to obscure himself. So Matt, Liz and Zack definitely already also knows that he wants nothing to do with wars and were present for his little ted talk. >* Poor guy, he really wants nothing to do with... makes a lot more sense contextually. It might not seem like an issue now, but when this arc is released as a book and people read these chapters an hour or two apart, its hard to ignore <3 PS Miniseries idea. Shorts of Gan Les' monologue complaints as he explores Asters spirit space. Maybe she even has tea once or twice with him. 👀👉🏿👈🏿

DumpsterCoffee

> "currency has no intrinsic value" What a strange non-sequitur. Totally wrong, and totally irrelevant to the discussion. It's like you just wanted to broadcast your ignorance to the world in order to please some sort of internal bias, and because you didn't get a reaction the first time, you have to try again.

Istyatur Elestel

Fiat currency (Credits) has no intrinsic value. But mana stones aren't just currency, they are also a store of mana and instrisicly have the value of whatever the mana in the stone is worth.

Violet

Friendly reminder that currency has no intrinsic value. The value form is not innate to anything.

DicedOnions

Or she will get her authority think that makes he queen of the realm and break the rules of war causing an early true war. Would be good for the empire if that happens because nobody would want another true war right after a brutal war against the federation

Maya

oh i only now realized that the conversion chart in chapter 4 and 8 is about monetary value of each tier, i always thought it was about how much mans each tier of stone held, yeah, no i see much more why matt's talent is so ridiculous on an economic scale now

DumpsterCoffee

To be fair, the exchange rates described for the Corporations feels more like what was intended all along. While we have to take Matt as an unreliable narrator (as his musings on how things work and what's possible are blatantly contradictory), he has often thought of a Tier 14 skill as being worth several Tier 8 skills. Based strictly on the Empire's economy, it should be closer to 2e11 (at least within an order of magnitude), but if we were to retcon the Imperial exchange rate of mana stones to be based on actual mana content, then a Tier 14 skill should be worth dozens of Tier 8 skills. Our clearest indicator of the intended exchange rate for skills is for Endurance, which trades for a Tier 14 skill. We have a confirmed report of a team trading the skill for 10 Tier 8 skills. So this is clearly the economy Mantis pretends the Empire has. Of course, if the wealth scaling worked like that, then there is no way a Tier 5 Matt could have provided his orphanage with an endowment.

DumpsterCoffee

1. I imagine that the Empire is using anti-scrying methods to protect Waters talents, the same as they're doing to protect Matt's talents. 2. Anyone attempting to divine Waters talents will assume that the Empire is employing anti-scrying techniques. 3. Getting nonsensical results for talent scrying just confirms that the Empire's anti-scrying techniques are working.

Istyatur Elestel

Its not so much as "not adapting to change" as "trying to help mantis with math". Lots of things are connected to mana stones, so such a change breaks a lot of cannon. for example, if mana stones have 20% less mana per tier(conservative, considering what this suggests) Matt should be at the point where powering up T40 rifts takes days, not decades; cannon interacts with cannon and you can't just change it without causing ripple effects that usually cause problems. Truthfully, Mantis did a pretty good job with most of it, though he needed to retcon mana concentration to make it work sensibly. the empire currency is the only thing that is compeletely nonsensical.

Violet

Ah, I see, you're asserting that prior canon overrides declared canon and ignoring the fact that canon can change. I'm not reading things that aren't there, you're just not adapting to change.

WierdWebLurker

So if you drop the negatives, it would be "they were being paid to advance past Tier 35," which would be false; that's a buyout, which the Great Powers specifically didn't want to do. What usually happens is "they were being paid not to advance past Tier 35." That's how Great Powers keep their Ascenders in the war tiers, with various cash and resource incentives. That's not what's happening here either. What's happening is a "partial buyout." As stated back in the negotiation chapter, the other Great Powers are paying Manny (and MLA by extension) not to hold them at Tier 35, with the expectation that they'll probably advance out of the war tiers by the time the Empire's truce wears off. Therefore, "(paid not to be (paid to not advance.))" It's kind of an odd sentence, but it perfectly encapsulates how atypical the agreement was.

skewness7

Unacceptable. And here I thought that Kar'tan greets his foes.

Istyatur Elestel

One - all rift stones are the same size, unlike artifical mana stones Two - in the Empire, a T18 mana stone is worth somewhere around 5e19 T8 mana stones or 3e31 credits, instead of 6e5 credits. Assuming 1 empire credit = 1 corporation credit, which is probably not the case, but i bet it isn't a 24 order of magnitude difference either. This is why we know there is an error: a T 18 mana stone has exactly 1000 times as much mana a a T8 in the same volume of space. So it should be worth a few thousand to maybe a million times as much depending on how much that 1000 times space reduction matters in a world with bags of holding and storage rings.

John

Thanks!

Desidia

When Aura rifts first gets mass produced, there's going to be a lot less people going into Minkalla. I always wondered if it's possible for Matt and the Emperor to pump so much mana into Minkalla, so that it evolves and gain an eighth floor.

ShivaMcTimber

I think we will have both Manny and Allister POV - at least I hope so. it would be interesting to get the Guild perspective.

Desidia

I wonder if we're going to get Allister's inner thoughts. The author said the next chapter was going to be an Emperor POV.

Desidia

Are talent appraising talents that rare? I wonder why no other GP knows about Duke's Water's talents at this point. The Emperor is t50, but this doesn't stop him from secretly copying the talents of lower tiers from other GP's. Why aren't there talent appraisers from other GP's that's not telling other people about Duke Water's talents? It'll be funny if there's a group of talent appraisers that's scratching their heads, wondering why their secret investigation into Duke Waters keeps showing up as farming talents. Their first thought would be; how is the Empire hiding Duke Water's talents?

Gjim

Dang, we just got Redwalled, I do believe.

Violet

Which is why it has to be the actual amount of mana present, or there's literally no difference between the Imperial and Corporate systems.

Tijay Arnie

I knew that were a reference there, that was just tickling a corner of my brain

Raymond Lenihan

When they talk about mana stones in terms of currency they are talking about rift made mana stones, which means they all have the same amount per tier. We are given the amounts in a table in book 1 or 2.

Violet

But that's exactly what this chapter seems to imply, unless the idea is that in the Empire, a Tier 18 stone the size of a house is of the same value as one which is the size of a fist.

Jason Hatter

It was mentioned when we first met her as part of Team Zero.

Jason Hatter

No, they were noted as dating, when she first appeared as part of Team Zero

habu987

If we get some hares and badgers to show up, too, I'll be a very happy camper! Redwall was such a seminal part of my childhood.

Jason Hatter

It was great to get a callback to those valiant elites.

James Skinner

And Gan Le! Now there's a trio.

Jeff Wells

It's the only accurate phrasing possible (though more descriptors would make it a little clearer). "They are being paid to tier up" is incorrect, which is what it would say if you dropped the negatives. Ordinarily, they would be paid to NOT tier up. They are being paid to not be paid to not tier up. It's the only correct way to say it.

Jeff Wells

Aiden has been paid by the Empire for thousands of years to stay below tier 35. The other GPs are paying the Empire and MLA to prevent the Empire from paying MLA to stay below tier 35 for thousands of years. It's a soft-buyout. MLA can stay below 35 if they choose, but the Empire may not encourage them to per this agreement. Paid to not be paid to not tier up.

Kelly Bryan

Redwall is on a low tier world in the Monster Collective, new headcanon.

Elaine

good chappie

Istyatur Elestel

A "TN Mana Stone" is generally assumed to be a full TN Rift mana stone which does have a set mana value and cannot be recharged. No one is suggesting a half-used mana stone is worth the full value.

James Harrison

It's a typo p sure, unless

ShivaMcTimber

"A shocked Allister sprayed his tea directly into Manny's face." Opening line in the next chapter probably.

ShivaMcTimber

Haha "We could not talk or talk forever and still find things to not talk about."

Pat Sprehe

Sergio survived! That’s the Empire guy from the 7th floor Minkalla Chronicles.

Derze

Quite sure that would be regulated. Plus, who has that many tier 8 skills shards? Besides the Mcs

Derze

most of the citizens don't actively sell to other Great powers, so unless they are Tier 15 or one of the Big guys up top, the local economy for each Power is not really affected

Xarow

Thanks for the great chapter. I really want an itemised list of their rewards and their planets with a breakdown of details etc.

Matt

Thanks that was beyond me too.

Austin Koos

I'd really like to see her fight Tier 35 Matt. Getting hit in the face by the equivalent of a Tier 50's mana pool every second lol

Mezmer

Is Martin the Giantslayer a reference to Martin the Warrior?

Blake N.

Yeah, that’s why it’s mentioned that it’s nice of him to check in again. It’s not the first asking for permission, but a repeat to be sure

Blake N.

No, the emperor is going to tell the guilds leader in the next chapter.

Violet

It's the amount of mana actually in the mana stones that they value. A Tier 18 stone /can/ store more, but that doesn't mean that every Tier 18 stone does. If you view currency as needing to have a 'real' value (it doesn't - goldbugs btfo), then the Corporation's model makes more sense than the Empire's. Mana is the capacity to do work (both in the physics sense and in the economic sense), whereas storage capacity is merely the potential to acquire the capacity to do work. But, again, currency doesn't need to have 'real' value, just exchange value.

Andrew Adams

I'd just ignore anything to do with these economies. they don't stand up to even a cursory glance.

Istyatur Elestel

"There was still some markup for the higher-Tier stones due to their mana to size ratios, but it still meant that a Tier 18 mana stone might only be worth a few dozen times more than a Tier 8 stone in the Corporations" thats a definit math error, should be a few thousand times more. 1000 for the mana, few for the markup.

James Faulkner

Here we goooooooo

DumpsterCoffee

So much for economics. The Corporations, who are depicted as masters of economic systems, prize mana stones for their mana. Therefore, they value a tier 18 stone the same as a dozens of tier 8 stones, despite the tier 18 stone having over 1000 times as much mana as a tier 8 stone. Sure, that makes sense. Of course, the valuation of mana stones in the Empire has never made any sense either, but this is just...

KollegvomMirgan

Tftc really looking forward to next chapter

Violet

I think the currency arbitrage would only function in one direction: buy empty Tier 18 mana stones in the Corporations and then use them in the Empire to buy saleable goods to sell in the Corporations. But yes, mana stone arbitrage does sound like it would be a potential gold mine. The factors that Andrew K mentioned would also be part of the arbitrage process and might limit your profitability. Currency arbitrage is an old way of making a lot of money, though. That's why currency exchange desks were so lucrative, particularly in the pre-Euro European Union.

Aaron Hardin

That is how all trade works, things are less valuable in one place and more valuable in another place, and the difference between the two needs to be large enough to overcome the costs of transportation, and any other costs, such as tariffs. We don't know if there is money to be made in this, but if there is, there is undoubtable some trade of mana stones going both ways, but given the tiers of the mana stones involved, as the ones doing this are higher tier, the wealth level they are working with is immense, so there are likely far more lucrative things they can do with their time.

Andrew K

Question for things like this isn't really if there's money to be possibly made that way considering face-value prices. It's whether there's enough monetary gain left on the table to be worth the time (particularly compared to other money-making opportunities) after taking all the secondary costs and constraints into account. Things like import/export tarrifs, travel/shipping costs, market volume limitations (natural or imposed by government regulations, and effective split due to competition running the same trading strategy), and such can all alive away huge chunks of potential profit margin. Even if there's initially a lot of profit left on the table after considering those factors, the other relevant parties will almost shift behavior over time until it's either not very lucrative or tightly controlled by some small group benefiting from regulatory capture.

John Balman

Damn tease lol that ending 😂

william wallace

Dont look too hard at the economy… it gets messy quickly.

Andrew K

Normally, a great power would pay off Ascenders and the like to stay at tier 35 for a long time for strategic reasons. Part of the war settlement was a payoff to the empire not to do that in the case of MLA, and a chunk of that payoff is going right to MLA just like a full buyout would.

RedEyeLordofFire

I don't understand this economy. Any idiot with half a brain can just buy tier 8 mana stones in the empire sell them in the corporations then buy tier 18 mana stones in the corporations and sell in the empire. Rince and repeat easy money.

Andrew K

It can be a bit confusing, but I personally still really liked that phrasing - really highlights how odd that bit of the war settlement was.

Abriel Blauer

Sorry about that, but not sure if I understood that phrase correctly: " they were effectively getting paid to not be paid to not advance past Tier 35" Can someone please translate that in layman terms?

darwensassistent

Great chapter, just wanted to comment that this section about the planet buy out for matt was really confusing to read. Too many negatives "they were effectively getting paid to not be paid to not advance past Tier 35, but he didn’t care that much."

Havokk

re reading this I think the very best part of this chapter has to be Zach and Susanne actually getting a real date

Tim Johnson

ahh thats right, got them mixed up, JR is the one who made him the bonding device for his talismans.

Havokk

Just have DW give her a lesson on authorities... she will think she understands him and try then kill herself trying for it

Fozzy

I was really hoping for a description of the "Furious Thrust of the Rooster" skill

Violet

Poor Gan Le getting a reminder that the only reward for good work is more work. I wouldn't be shocked if the leadership of the Sects was purposefully fucking with him for going out of his way not to be too exceptional. Someone with good impulse control should go with Allie, because she's /not/ going to like what she finds. Or, really, someone with better impulse control than Allie, which isn't exactly a high bar. For entirely dispassionate and pragmatic reasons, I volunteer Aster for the job.

Alex

I think this might actually be the definition of Gan Le’s hell. Yun Me has stayed at Tier 35 for a million years because she lives to fight Pinnacle Elites and Ascenders with her unyielding defensive powers. She’ll be teaching Gan Le all about how he can block attacks from Ascenders with his face. Poor guy, he might actually defect from the Sects.

yannick schwende

I loved the chapter. Shows all the pomp such an event needs. Also liked Matt's reaction to it. Can totally relate. I would leave as soon as he does as well

C_Mantis

That is correct

MikeL

Obviously Cosmind would be the best mind teacher, but I would have thought Kurt would have a lot of insight also.

Havokk

ahhh Gan Le got his sugar momma but gets stuck with a warrior and knowing he will never be out of war range lol

Alex

Allister, Tier 50 of the Guilds. JR is on the don’t tell under any circumstances list, since he has a habit of selling anything and everything for the right price, and the Corporations are borderline enemies of the Empire, with projections earlier in the series saying they were probably going to join the Light and Shadow war against the Empire.

Alex

The Rune Soldiers didn’t deserve any part of their terrible lives. Virgil really does need to die horribly.

Thomas Todd

It's Alister the Guild t50. Manny mentioned it when their meeting broke up a few chapters ago. Their conversation will probably the be Manny chapter for Monday

Thomas Brusilovsky

Nice, slowpaced chapter to close out the matt part of the arc. Great stuff as always!

Teatime42

Ah, the leader of the Guilds.

Ellariayn

Wait, if this ARC is ending on the next chapter, that means that we have to wait and see whom Matt is referring to in the last paragraph! You’re evil Mantis 😂

Uuds

Typo: "..leading the pursuit off on a wild goose chase buying enough time." To "buying enough time for..." The defenders to regroup or something?

Tim Johnson

JR? i thought Manny already confirmed with Matt that JR could know in preparation for the true war.

Bob Bryan

Again, really hope Virgil dies. Ripped apart by a tier 50 black and white hole perhaps. Are tier 50 space piranas a thing? Rip rune soldiers, you didn't deserve that.

Ben Heggem

I like it

C_Mantis

yup they are dating.

BagFullOfLizards

Ooo, this has me looking forward to the emperor POV so much

Owen Kaz

Here it comes, time to see how another faction leader reacts to the possibilities of an endless future

Ben Heggem

Okay I must’ve missed it or forgot but Zach and Susanne??🤣

R.M.

Amazing

Luna_1001

Thanks


More Creators