Patrefans
TheLifeandTimes19 from patreon
TheLifeandTimes19 patreon

Huntsmen of Winter

🕑 Added 2023-03-17 19:08:15 +0000 UTC

Comments

ModNsparksPhilo22

Nice buildup. I can’t wait to see the aftermath of the ironborn’s attack. I have 2 questions though: did Benjen confide his insecurities/misplaced guilt (from chap 6) to Ned/Hadrian? Would it be possible to have the Boltons as staunch allies (given their shared first men blood heritage, general zeal to their bloody traditions, and the Ryswell connection)? I’m not expecting Roose to get soft, but it’s possible to provide him with enough incentives and some fanatic rhetoric to sway him and get him as the alternative extreme to Ned’s honor/pacifism.

Ouki's Lips

Nice suggestions. The only untenable one is the standing army instead of men at arms. The average life expectancy of humans in medieval era (that GoT is based on) was 30 years. Moreover, women outnumbered men by a ratio of at least 1.5, and women were not considered for fighting (or other heavy duty manual labor) even in barbaric cultures unless as a last resort. That means, at an absolute maximum, only 20% of the population is even in the physical condition for manual labor (by medieval misogynistic standards). Keep in mind that all the major trades need to be maintained since the people of that time barely produce enough food to survive as it is. And keeping a standing army means you can't "forage" for food since you're in your own territory. The Lords can somewhat compensate for keeping some small guards active by extending the smallfolks' work days and denying vacations, which most lords already do. For reference, if you look up modern militaries you'll actually find that they're all less than 0.5% of the total population. As stated in the wiki, the total population of the North is less than 1,000,000. That means the absolute maximum size of a standing army would be only 5,000 soldiers. That's barely enough to guard the houses of the noble families, let alone the roads. It's just not economically possible for them to have a whole reserve army on standby. The best option to choose is to train your men-at-arms in small unit tactics, and then assign 4 to 9 conscripted smallfolk to each man-at-arms when war-time comes. That's pretty much what they already do. The only way Harry could improve it is to mass-produce weapons and armor so the smallfolk levies can be armed with something other than wood-cutting axes, and maybe have every lord run some small annual drills with their smallfolk so they have more fighting ability when the time comes for war.

Eric

This is an interesting development. Lord Reed seemed to accept it a little to easily to be believable. Instead perhaps you could work on having the skinchangers be sent to Winterfell as early as possible so they can be properly taught both their gifts and a basic education. As opposed to waiting till their later years. If you are looking for loyalty then try to indoctrinate them as soon as possible. Also if he is looking to have additional control over his lords he should look at having a professional army as opposed to men at arms. Recruit young boys, have them trained constantly in group tactics, outfit them with uniform equipment then create an officer core based on merit as opposed to the normal lord leading his men at arms and their levy troops. in addition to that work on training some of the officers in logistics and find some combat engineers. It makes it more difficult for the landed nobility to revolt when there is an army that can tear down your castle


More Creators