GreatM8SFM patreon

Help me by voting on what looks better please and thank you

🕑 Added 2020-08-06 20:10:45 +0000 UTC

Comments

Strumpf

Right, brighter pic

Silent One

Man, really hard to say. Both look good honestly.

Aarongeddon

2nd

before

Jean-François Bédard

2nd

cam

am i the only one that prefers the “before” version

Gk

I like the 2nd one more than the first. I wouldn't mind seeing if some of the lining can be less thick on some parts though. I think the Ears on this one specifically benefit a lot from the outline, but the bottom seems a little dark.

Paps

Oooh this is exciting! I love the new look

Before

OmegaSimp

I dig after a lil more

after

I prefer the before version if I'd have to pick one.

KuroKnight01

I like very much the second one but the first still has something that make me like it in a different way, but the colors and the contrast with the outline of the second one make it looks more bright i think

Jack Jagger

That looks great! I can't wait to see an animation with the new style of shading!

HellSpawn

after

Crystal Sipp

After

Ramon O'Sionnach

The "after" does feel more like the show

After is better :)

Ikkiya

After

JellyDonut

Wouldn't it have been better to make a strawpoll?

Herbie

After

Pancake

after

before

Zetsubo

I love both but right is more cartoony, I think that's cooler

HerpaDalio

Righto daddio

KingCrimson

All the above

Chazzy

before

Xan

Left

I like the Before, but maybe the After could work for me better with similar shadowing like the Before

Armallama

After

Right

Ryan Carrillo

After.

DeusInMachina

Before looks more realistic to me so that's the one I prefer.

Cat in a bed sleeping

After

Flash Deku

I love them both (but I'm bias as hell, Jirou is my favorite character), but I feel the one on the right is cuter

Anthony

After

TenPin

After

Great M8

Styles can change and evolve and improve

Harryblum

left

Eric P.

Right (the after side)

織田方

The left side is always your style

Ricardo

I like the right

Mirumoto Tsubasa

The right side looks more like anime while the left is more 3d-looking. Both are good! I like the right, and I think it has less danger of veering into uncanny valley territory.

Bean

I'm going to say before.

after

Daniel Turner

Before

Biostar

Gotta say the right

Jorge Smith

After

David Izzo

right

Spectras

The one on the right for me

Ellaria Gable

Right! 100% for me!

i like the left because it looks smoother and thus animation looks smother but the right is a great for an image but id love to see that style in animation to make a final judgement

Kaiyeti

I would have to see both in animation but I am agreeing with Chae on this one. THe left one looks move natural when moving but the right one is great while still though again I would need to see the right one animated to be sure.

AngryS

The after 100%.

Saif-999

For me definitely the “after”

Caustic Hornet

I prefer the right one though I agree with the other comments that an animation, even a short one would help.

Alpha_Doom

Right, 100%

Both? Need to see an animation first

vinny8boberano

I'd have to agree. From the still shot, there are pro's and con's to both: 1 - P: Softer colors & shadows / C: Edges can look blurry, 2 - P: Sharper edges and higher contrast / C: Shadows & 'natural' edges can give incorrect position/proportion due to being too sharp

Ronald Morrison

First (Left) one. Feels and looks way more like YOUR style than the right one.

enzo

right

Apache

We'd have to see what the outline one looks like in motion tbh.

SharkMessiah101

I kinda like both

Emil Yi

Right one

Left for animations right for posters/pinups

LeoZiggy

Left one

Agentx

After, I'd say. Don't know about in motion.

Monkeii

I think the left for animations and the right for posters is nice since the outlines on the right one make it look more like the anime I think and the left looks more real. If I have to stick with just one then I would go for the before.

The right one

Afrokage

Right definitely

Kinky no Kyoukai

Absolutely the newer one!

Leo

leeeeeft

s0n1cb00m

I myself have always loved designs with outlines so the new version is better to me.

Tyler

After 100 percent

right

Michael L Blunt

Left for me.

GrimOmen13

I say before

that stupid mf

Before, tbh

Omorfia

After 😍

jackerrør

After for sure

Silvers

After

Red Kawa

before for that sexy stomach

Onetoughact

Both are greatM8, but I would choose after

Before is better imo.

Nick BrianJerkedOffToPsylocke Ford

Personally, I like the after. It just makes more sense with that art style.

Hunter Mackey

The black lines make it so much better. If it isn't that much harder to do, i say switch it over.

i prefer the new style

TailOfGod

after

After

musicmancs

after

cittran genericlastname

Yup. After is better :)

.1PercentOfGerms

I like the after version, really nice shader you made

After!

Joe Hawkins

Much prefer the before to the after. Yes, definitely the before.

ptor

cel-shading can be cool in static images, but in animation I prefer old style

left(old), right make's it look like it's more 2d. the old one look more realistic to me

after for sure

Great M8

They're supposed to be "harsh" because that's how animes are shaded, It's meant to replicate the actual style of the series

WiredRM

After does look more authentic to the source material, but I still like "softness" of Before more. The cel-shaded look is less... sexy and more cartoon-y? Maybe it'll be less jarring when in motion.

B-RADZ

This might be weird but i like the first for the shading of the face for express... (left side). but the belly lighter shade because lack of emtion. That said if you had to choose a side and can't go in between go left.

Great M8

what kind of work

Sagrel

It needs some more work but I'll say the after

Afrosty

After

Kenshiro

Before

Vain D.

Before was better

Nicholas C

I think the after is a bit to harsh as it makes the shadows look jagged but other than that looks real cool. I think that this image looks better with the after but I could see the before working better for some image as the depth is easier to see.