Patrefans
subbrief from patreon
subbrief patreon

Kirov Modernization Ship Brief (audio fixed)

🕑 Added 2024-08-21 17:24:06 +0000 UTC
Kirov Modernization Ship Brief (audio fixed)

Comments

Hierachy 1871

Google-maps just updated, and it shows Nakhimov with 10 UKSK Modules for 80 missiles, its not quite clear is Redut is installed or the newer Tor-style system will be but i guess this is a solrt of confirmation

Vincent Santilli

Some confusion about what you report when you say "The Kirovs are upgrading to the S-400 Fort-M system (naval version of the S-400), providing superior long-range air defense against... ballistic missiles". This is confusing because the Ukrainians have been hitting S-400 systems with ATACMS almost with impunity. In fact the reporter, David Axe stated "Ironically, the S-400 was designed to have an anti-missile capability, but it obviously doesn’t work."

SentientKudzu

Say what you want about the soviets. They build some sexy warships.

Alex Doll

You mentioned that four were built, but only two seem to be "active", one sailing other in refit. Did the others get turned into floating casinos for Chinese tourists?

Thomas Riley

Whilst they're very impressive vessels, I really feel that these ships are an example of putting all your eggs in one basket, similar to Yamato, Mushashi or Bismark. They're terrifyingly capable individually but at the end of the day they're a single target, any damage puts them in port being repaired. Similarly trying to effectively coordinate and utilise all the different weapons systems effectively must be a nightmare. I can't help thinking all the resources would have been better spent on multiple smalller vessels working together in a flotilla. I'm generally an advocate of vessels having a balanced mix of ASW, AAW and ASV capabilities (simply because you never know what you're going to come across and vessels often end up being deployed independently but this is really a huge investment in resources and it's difficult to see it successfully surviving against a carrier group...

Thomas Riley

Whenever you look at a kirov from a periscope "for example"... why do I think Aaron knows this more than theoretically....

Hierachy 1871

yeah i know, but hey, whats stated, might not be whats final

Aaron Amick

I'll do an update when the Admiral Nakhimov is doing sea trials. I've read so many weapon configurations about the modernization load out, it's difficult to confirm anything until it's at sea.

Hierachy 1871

Love the revisit to the brief Aaron! that being said, the 20 xGranit complex is actually being replaced by 10 x 8 3S14 UKSK VLS cells for a total 80 missiles. consisting of either Oniks, Kalibr, Otvet and tsircon. which actually makes it even more of a dangerous ship!

Connor

Great brief!! πŸ‘πŸ»πŸ‘πŸ»πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ

Andrew Devries

Great brief!

Levar

Was the Kirovs the reason the navy restored the Iowa class battleships during the final years of the Cold War? Also cool lecture love your submarine and ship briefs of navies from around the world.

Scott Cunningham

Thanks Aaron. Your sound is usually perfect. Not sure what happened on this one. Glad it could be squared away. What cool ships the Kirovs are. I can understand why the Russians hung onto them and modernized them despite the gargantuan expense.


More Creators