Patrefans
Hanne from patreon
Hanne patreon

Chapter 55 Charge of the Korelian Knights

🕑 Added 2023-06-28 12:41:47 +0000 UTC
Chapter 55 Charge of the Korelian Knights

Comments

mytus123

final update done, not gonna modify anything more in this specific post :)

Hanne

Thank you. I am taking notes to see what to improve, or things to add.

mytus123

Dunno about you guys, but for me the standard bearer is a real MC here, the stage was his :) On that subject, I'm yearning for some last stand, sacrificial yet heroic kinda actions - in short a bit of meaningful tragedy and by meaningful I mean performed by not necessary main cast, yet not the nameless background either, hope to see some of that in a future. I kinda feel like for such a 'bleak' story (I love those kind, so I'm really happy with your setting) there is not really much of that, I can't really care about the fate of some random people, if I dunno even their names or at least impact of their deaths on other people and associated drama, so... I feel like there is a need for some more attachment and then a beautiful tragedy... please :) I've got one more, did you maybe though about some brief POV changes (a full chapter, maybe even two - but not one after another) to make some attachment with other characters in future? let's say some slave, show his grim daily life, his yearning for freedom etc. and then as story progresses we as readers can hope that he will be freed by our main cast or maybe by himself utilizing some current events. The only POV changes we had so far, were directly connected with our MC, all of them were pretty much always in the same perimeter as Lans and their main purpose was too boost/change our opinion about MC, even the pretty good one you did with Little Timmy. That's the jam for those kind of stories tbh, unless I'm delusional and that's possible too :) Since it got pretty long already I don't feel bad anymore for adding some extra feedback on top of that :) so characters... for me, up to this moment there is not enough work made for characters attachment, ofc Lans and Stefi are the exception (btw the name change forced on her, doesn't really sit well with me, so I hope she will go back to her real one in future, at least from time to time with our MC), actually the same goes with his family - there is still a bit of lingering attachment to them from the first chapters (good job, but it was so long ago we last saw them, that I don't even remember one of their names), and I guess a bit for the Callahan and his daughter, also maybe Sterling. The rest of the cast tho... is questionable, Felicity has moments but at the core it's a really annoying character (dunno if that was your goal, if so then good job), don't really have opinion about the mage girl from alternative Earth yet, and the alchemist despite the fact of spending pretty much the biggest amount of screen time with our MC is kinda 'meh' as a 'best friend' to our MC, and I believe Lans called him more than once like that, but there is no chemistry between them, at least I haven't seen any of it yet, so for me it boils down to the problem with 'show, don't tell'. Then we have the other soldiers (Hugo, etc.), but that's all I have to tell about them, they just exist... no feelings there so far (and I'm not talking about positives here only, Hugo had a really good moment when he was greedy after the fight with slavers, but there is no follow up so he became just 'bland'), Lastly, there are also children, tbh you can't really go wrong with them, but that's a really cheap move ;) and on top of that none of them can be really counted as a significant to include into 'main cast' so far. edit: I just thought about a brilliant idea, I think :) - why don't you make POV chapter for Lans' family after this battle, how do they fare atm, I feel like it's 100% win for you, you can do so much with that, some drama, straggle (after all their area is a subject to lost war, pretty much under occupation) make a reader feel for them, make me hope that our oblivious to their demise MC will be able to help them one day, let us know them better (backstory) - you know, long term planning, you could make updates on their situation from time to time (you got 3 POVs to use there), what's their take about each other or our MC, a lot of quality content there, before we get or not the long awaited reunion. It's just an idea, I hope you will use it tho, I feel like you can't go wrong with that one :D It'd be also a nice start to resolving the issues I mentioned at the start of this too lengthy feedback. I feel like you hit bullseye with the world building, all of medieval nuances and even MC's progression so far, it's really great... but in the end you are a story teller and that alone might not be enough in a long run. I'm pretty sure no one expects new MCs to pop up from thin air, but I feel like more engagement is needed in case of side characters, they might need a bigger roles and more screen time on top of gaining their own goals rather than only being MC's support (one doesn't need to exclude the other, but it would lead to some conflicts of interest which would need to be resolved one way or the other), having their own POV shown to us from time to time with some of their inner thinking included might be a good solution. Well there is a lot of things that could be improved, but most of them are not as impactful or harmful for me as those I mentioned here, I hope you find this feedback helpful.


More Creators