Deyui
patreon
Deyui NSFW Animation Audio Poll: Original or Third Party?
🕑 Added 2025-02-03 10:31:50 +0000 UTChttps://forms.gle/Aj3Qr7TYDGhxFxiz5
It's been brought up to me a few times that people feel conflicted about me using the stream clips for the NSFW Animations audio. Since I create those Animations for you, I want you to decide what I will be using moving on.
What would happen if continue using stream clips would win?
Nothing much would change for you, the NSFW Animations and the upcoming ones will contain audio clips from streams of the VTuber to make the Animation sound as authentic as possible. I will continue to have to crawl through the VOD library and find the fitting sounds.
What would happen if using hentai voice lines/hire a voice actor would win?
I will most likely be using the free hentai voice lines from the OpenNSFW Pack and maybe look to hire a hentai voice actor if I can find anyone that fits the criteria's. Most likely, I won't be able to find a voice actor that sounds anywhere close to the character I am making an animation of because the chances are low that I can find someone that sounds the same as the character and is also a hentai voice actor that I can pay to make audio.
Personal Opinion:
I just want people to be happy. Personally, hiring a hentai voice actor or using free voice lines from a NSFW pack is much less work for me since I don't have to crawl through the entire VOD section several days to find fitting clips and then clean the audio. Why I did use the stream clips however is because I want to bring you the highest quality animation and I believed that's by making sure that when the person talks, it actually sounds like her otherwise it would be kind of uncanny.
As for the ethicality of using stream audio clips, while I can understand how it would make it more ethical and less weird to people, removing the audio doesn't make the whole creating NSFW content of a VTuber/character and paywalling it not a grey area thing than it already is I think.
And of course I will always read through and adhere to any rules and guidelines the VTuber or character/series I'm making an animation of. There can be times where their rules/guidelines and opinions are hard to find so if I am going against any of the character's/people's wishes then let me know.
何度か言われたことがあるのですが、配信クリップをNSFWアニメーションの音声として使用することについて、賛否が分かれているようです。これらのアニメーションは皆さんのために作っているので、今後どの音声を使うか、皆さんに決めていただきたいと思います。
「配信クリップを使い続ける」が選ばれた場合は？
特に大きな変化はありません。NSFWアニメーションや今後の作品には、VTuberの配信からの音声クリップを使用して、できるだけ本物っぽく聞こえるようにします。そのため、引き続きVODライブラリを漁って、適切な音声を探す作業が必要になります。
「エロボイスを使う／声優を雇う」が選ばれた場合は？
基本的には、無料のエロボイス（OpenNSFW Packなど）を使用することになります。また、条件に合うエロボイスの声優が見つかれば、雇うことも検討します。ただし、作っているキャラに近い声の声優を見つけるのはかなり難しいと思います。同じような声で、なおかつエロボイスの収録を引き受けてくれる声優が見つかる可能性は低いからです。
個人的な意見：
ただみんなに幸せになってほしいだけ。皆さんが決めてください。ただ、個人的には、エロボイスの声優を雇ったり、無料のNSFWボイスを使うほうが作業が楽になります。VODを何日も探し回って適切なクリップを見つけ、それをクリーニングする必要がなくなるからです。
それでも配信クリップを使っていた理由は、アニメーションのクオリティを最大限に高めたかったからです。キャラが喋るときに、本物の声じゃなかったら違和感が出てしまうと思ったので、より自然にするために配信音声を使っていました。
配信音声を使用することの倫理について
配信音声を使わないほうが倫理的に問題が少ないと考える人がいるのも理解できます。ただ、音声を削除したとしても、VTuberやキャラクターのNSFWコンテンツを作って、それを有料で提供すること自体がグレーゾーンであることには変わりないと思います。
もちろん、私がアニメーションを制作するVTuberやキャラクター／作品のルールやガイドラインは必ず確認し、遵守します。ただ、場合によっては、それらのルールや本人の意向を見つけるのが難しいこともあります。もし私がキャラや本人の意向に反している場合は、教えてもらえれば対応します。
Comments
Suguha Kirigaya
I am okay either way! I think if the 3rd party option is easier for you that you could go that way. I think it sounds great either way. I know you put a LOT of time in your art and animations and it always shows. Thank you for always trying to give us a better experience!
littleshiroi
i havent really heard anything else besides the january ones but i think its decent enough
Kirby2019
I love the original voices but it is a little tricky. They give the best experience but I know it's hard to find and edit clips to match with the video. Ethics is the biggest concern because it might be akward for the talent to have their voice used for something lewd. But just like you said, lewds in general are a grey area. I think it should be fine but it would suck if people start complaining about it. Honestly I think finding matching hentai voice lines might be just as hard as finding matching VOD's, depending on what you're looking for of course. Hiring a VA is the most flexible option and there might be a few that share similar voices to some VTubers but it comes with a price. There's also no guarantee that a proper VA even exists so it might not be the best option either. I'd say do what you feel is best. Your content is already amazing so you don't need to worry about that. I can maybe help with some audio clips and where to find them. Fan Discords usually have a clips/noises channel which could be useful. There's also a guy on Twitter that made a ton of really nice audio clips but he removed all of his stuff soon after. I downloaded most of them hoping that I could use them someday. Maybe they can be of use to you too. Keep up the good work!
TAZZ
I originally was going to leave it in the form but I figured putting it in the replies could open discussion if anyone wanted to chime in. I hope i didn’t come across as rude or overly critical 😭 but I think you know I’m a big fan of your work and wouldn’t just randomly be an asshole to you lmao I genuinely appreciate how much you take into consideration our opinions. I think you have a good idea with using whichever “tool” works best for each scenario. It’s definitely a better idea I think to have each individual work be, well individual, and not operate under an umbrella rule for every work. Thanks again and I hope it won’t be much more trouble for you, you already spoil us 😭🙇
Deyui
Thanks for sharing your opinion! Also respect the boldness to do it right below the post when you could have done it privately via the Google Form. If we're talking about only quality and ethicality aside, then yeah the quality ceiling is definitely higher if I manage to find the right voice actor. I would think of using a mix of voice actors and original voice is the play then, where if I have a good fitting original voice clip, I will be using that and then whatever I can't find a good audio clip for, the voice actor can fill in for me. But in practice it's not always that easy.
TAZZ
For me the answer is less about the ethicality, and more about the quality differences between the 2 options. I think that you do a great job with finding the voice lines, however I think using voice lines has a lower ceiling of quality in general, since there will always be a level of “scuffed” since mixing the voice lines can’t ever “flow” as well as using a consistent audio source like you would get from a hentai voice pack or hiring a voice actor. I appreciate the uniqueness and creativity behind the idea of stitching together stream voice lines, but I think especially given the amount of time it takes you to do, I would prefer to lessen your load a bit so you have more time to take a break between works.
