RoguePrince
patreon
The Young Lion Act 2 Ch 10
🕑 Added 2026-01-05 12:30:04 +0000 UTCDisclaimer: Just in case nobody realized I don’t own nor do I claim ownership of Game of Thrones, all characters and worlds belong to their real world respective owners. I’m just having some fun, that's all.
The Young Lion
Act 2 Ch 10: A Kraken or a Wolf
The Iron Islands remained as unyielding as ever, shrouded in a permanent veil of slate-gray clouds while the wind sliced through the stone towers of Pyke like a freshly whetted blade. Salt and seaweed bit the air, and the pungent tang of tar and iron from the harbor clung to every stone. Below, ships strained against their moorings, the rhythmic snap of black sails punctuating the cries of gulls that circled the cliffs. Theon Greyjoy felt a dull ache in his chest as he watched the restless waves, each crest seeming to mock his hesitation, daring him to return to the cold embrace of the sea.
After a silent, biting walk from the docks—marred by the mocking smirks of his supposed bannermen—Theon was escorted to the great hall of Pyke, the seat of his father Lord Balon Greyjoy. Inside the great hall, the hearth-fire struggled against the damp chill, casting weak, wavering light along the high, salt-stained walls. Balon Greyjoy sat at the head of the table, his long, gnarled fingers drumming on the rough wood in a cadence that matched the pounding surf.
Every line of his father's face spoke of a man of unyielding will, forged in storms and tempered by blood. Opposite him, Yara’s dark eyes blazed with an icy contempt, her arms crossed tightly across her chest. Theon hovered uneasily at the edge of the light, feeling their scrutiny like hot iron against his skin.
“You cannot remain beholden to the Starks,” Balon began, his voice deep and relentless like a crashing tide. “You are Ironborn. You do not bend. You do not bow. You do not serve. The North will fall in chaos, and we will claim what is rightfully ours. Why do you still cling to your wolf masters?”
Theon swallowed against a dry throat, the rich Ironborn ale in his cup turning to lead in his gut. “Father, I… Robb has put his trust in me. He has treated me like a brother. I cannot simply—”
“You cannot see beyond the snow and ice of Winterfell,” Balon interrupted, slamming a fist onto the table. The wood groaned under the strike. “Do you truly not understand? Wolves eat their own, and the North devours anyone weak enough to trust it. You are not a child. You are not a Stark. You are a Greyjoy. And Greyjoys do not serve; we take what we want with blood and strength.”
Yara’s voice cut in, sharp as the winter winds that used to whistle off the walls of Winterfell.
“Loyalty? You speak of loyalty while the rest of us see a boy prancing after wolves, begging for scraps of honor that do not belong to you. You have been molded by their cold halls, fed by their charity, and yet you still do not see the chains you have wrapped around yourself. Tell me, Theon: are you a wolf or a kraken?”
The words struck like a hammer against hot steel. He wanted to argue, to plead his case, yet each syllable felt frail, drowned beneath the roar of the Ironborn storm that filled the hall. He felt a rising tide of panic, a vice-like grip squeezing his heart. His breath came in shallow hitches, the stone walls seeming to lean inward with every word his father spoke.
Balon leaned forward, shadowed by the flickering torchlight, his gray eyes glinting with the brilliance of sharpened steel.
“You will choose soon. The North is open, its guards marched south. The Ironborn will strike, and you will either be with your family or against us. There is no middle path. No excuse or delay. The tide waits for no one. Will you stand as a Greyjoy, or continue to pretend you are a Stark?”
Theon swallowed hard and stared at the table. The words were simple but heavy as anchors. He thought of the young king Robb, the man who had looked past his name and seen him as a man grown. He remembered the warmth of the Stark halls, the laughter of foster brothers, and the way the Northmen had included him—not as a prisoner, but as a brother.
But his sister’s glare and his father’s cold logic reminded him that Winterfell was a gilded cage. Wolves had protected him, but they could just as easily abandon him to the cold. They were not his blood, not his family. He had heard the same in whispers at Winterfell. He was an outsider - not of northern blood. And blood mattered.
Theon could feel the pull of the sea in his veins, demanding allegiance to the family he had spent his life trying to honor, even when they seemed a distant, impossible standard to reach.
The room smelled of smoke, tar, and sweat. Shadows danced on the walls like specters of past failures. He clenched his fists under the table, nails biting into his palms. The tension of the council pressed down on him like the tide. Theon’s mind spun with visions of battles not yet fought, of ships cutting through Northern waters, and soldiers dying because of his indecision. Every word from Balon and Yara tore at the fragile bridge between his loyalty to the North and his duty to his family. The Ironborn way, Yara reminded him, was straightforward: power through blood, strength through fear, and loyalty only to kin.
Yet his heart ached for the wolf-king who had trusted him, who had looked past his Greyjoy name and seen him as someone more.
He closed his eyes and saw Robb’s face, steady and earnest—a boy and a king trusting him completely. And then he saw Yara, proud and merciless, daring him to make the right choice. He felt split in two, each side pulling toward a different destiny. The wind outside shrieked, and he thought bitterly that the waves did not care for honor; they only consumed those foolish enough to stand against them.
o-O-o
After the council adjourned, Theon walked the stone corridors of Pyke, the torchlight flickering against the rough walls, throwing wavering shadows that danced like restless spirits. The smell of wet stone, tar, and the brine of the sea clung to him, as did the weight of unspoken accusations. He paused by an arrow slit overlooking the harbor where the waves churned gray and angry, a reminder of the power he would either inherit or lose.
He thought of Robb, of the King in the North’s trust, of Winterfell’s warmth, of the sense of belonging he had never truly felt before. Guilt gnawed at him, sharp and persistent, like a cold wind that would never end. And yet, even as his heart tugged northward to the boy who had become his brother, he could feel the pull of the iron islands, the echo of his father’s words, the glimmer of Yara’s fury-all reminding him that loyalty without blood was a fool's game.
That night was plagued by nightmares. He saw himself standing shoulder to shoulder with Robb on the battlefield, carving a path to the capital to rescue Ned and the girls. It ended with them returning to a free North, their new Kingdom freed from the yoke of the south, returning to the warmth of the castle’s great hall. He saw Sansa accepting his proposal before the Weirwood tree and standing by his side as his Lady. But then the dream shifted. He was sailing the Iron Fleet along the stony shore, the smell of wet rope and salt filling his nose. He saw Robb’s face—not with love, but with the crushing weight of betrayal as he realized Theon’s hesitation had doomed the Starks.
Every moment of indecision or inaction felt like a storm churning inside of him. Waves washed over his head relentlessly making him feel as though he were drowning, bobbying his head above just enough to get another breath of air only to be submerged again. He imagined his father’s eyes cold and unyielding, seeing only a boy too weak to stand as a proper Greyjoy. He imagined Yara’s disdain, her words repeating in his mind, the question that cut deeper than any sword ever could.
“Are you a wolf or are you a Kraken?”
He awoke in a cold sweat, unable to distinguish the salt of his dreams from the salt of the sea air in his room. He leaned over the stone battlement, the wind whipping his hair across his eyes. Somewhere beyond that horizon, a choice waited, and that choice would define him forever.
o-O-o
Unable to sleep, Theon dressed and wandered his old home, walking along the stone wall where he and his brothers played before the rebellion. A rare stillness gripped Pyke that night; the usual howl of the wind had died to a low moan, leaving only the rhythmic, insistent thunder of the tides against the cliffs. Theon walked alone, boots echoing softly against the rough-hewn flagstones, each step a reminder of the heavy weight pressing down on him. The cold seeped into his bones, carrying with it the scent of salt and iron - the very essence of his home.
He stopped at a private balcony, overlooking the harbor, the open sea stretching endlessly before him. Ships rocked gently in their moorings, the black sails silhouetted against the dark, storm-laden clouds. Each wave was a whisper of possibility and peril, reminding him of the choices he had yet to make. He held the letter Robb had sent with him clutched in his hand. He had hoped to broker an alliance, but the weight of the parchment felt like a chain.
Yara approached from behind, silent as a shadow. She leaned against the stone railing, her dark eyes glinting. “You look like a man carrying the weight of the ocean in his chest,” she said, her voice sharp. “Or a boy afraid of drowning in it.”
Theon turned to her, finding her gaze unwavering. “I don’t know what to do,” he admitted, his voice a whisper. “Everything I’ve known, everything I’ve been taught, it pulls me in opposite directions. Robb… Father… the sea. I’m being torn in two.”
Yara’s expression softened a fraction. “Theon, listen. You think this is just about Robb Stark? It’s more than that. It’s about who you are, and who you will become. Are you a wolf, timid and loyal to another’s cause, or a kraken, bound only by the tides of your own choosing?”
Theon’s heart thudded painfully in his chest like a drum marking his indecision. He thought of Robb’s trust, of Winterfell's warmth, of a life he had known as a boy among wolves. And yet, Yara’s words rang with undeniable truth-the Ironborn were his blood, his family, his heritage. The sea called to him like a living thing, whispering promises of power and freedom that he had never truly known.
Yara placed a firm hand on his shoulder, her cold fingers grounding him. “You’ve lived too long in the shadows of men who are not your kin. You’ve forgotten the bite of salt and the taste of victory. The North… Robb Stark… he is not yours to serve. Your loyalty lies here. And yet…” Her voice softened slightly, almost a whisper, “I know this choice will cost you more than you can imagine. That is why you must choose wisely.”
Theon swallowed, trying to steady the tremor in his hands. He could feel every heartbeat as if it were a drum marking his indecision. The wind whipped around him, tugging at his cloak and tearing the edges of his thoughts. The cries of seagulls and distant splash of water against the harbor reminded him that the world moved relentlessly, that inaction could be as deadly as any sword.
“I don’t want to betray him,” Theon confessed. “If I follow Father… I am betraying everything I believed in, everything hoped for, everything Lord Stark believed I could be.”
His mind drifted to Ned Stark, while Yara’s eyes narrowed.
“You are thinking like a boy. You are thinking of loyalty as if it were a chain you cannot break. Loyalty is a tool, a weapon. To rise, you must wield it—bend it, even break it. Robb only trusts you because he sees a Northman. He doesn’t see what you are, or what you could be. If you let that trust dictate you, you will remain a dog in the North, whining for scraps.”
Theon felt the weight of her words crushing him. She spoke with the authority of the sea he’d always dreamed of. The unyielding force of iron and the tide, yet he couldn’t suppress the memory of Robb’s blue eyes—too pure for a world of blood. The pain of potential betrayal twisted in his chest, a knife he could not remove.
o-O-o
A few days passed, and Theon spent most of them isolated in his solar. Finally, a messenger arrived, a boy with uncertain eyes clutching a roll of parchment sealed with silver wax—the Stark direwolf. Theon’s chest tightened as he held it. The paper was slightly damp from the sea air and smelled faintly of the pine forests of the North. Every nerve in his body seemed to tingle, as if warning him of the storm contained within the scroll.
He broke the seal carefully, afraid that even a careless gesture might alter the fragile chain of events that Robb unknowingly had set into motion. The parchment was stiff, slightly damp from the sea air, and it smelled faintly of pine he remembered from the forests of the North. The ink was dark and precise, every letter written with the weight of a command and the urgency of discretion.
Theon, my friend, the tides are turning. I’ve opened a path south, but we must move quickly. I need your father’s ships faster than expected. If we are to see our people free, we must act. Soon my forces will carve a path for King’s Landing. Have your father’s fleet meet us there, blocking the harbor. Move swiftly and help me rescue our sisters from the Lion’s clutches.
The words were urgent, carrying the unmistakable undertone of kinship. Each sentence struck like a smith’s hammer, reverberating in his chest, making him aware once again of the gravity of his situation. He read and reread the letter, tracing the ink with trembling fingers, tasting the salt of the air on his lips, and hearing the echo of Robb’s voice in his mind.
This letter was not merely a call for aid; it was a lifeline, a plea of loyalty, and demand for a fulfillment of trust. And yet, with each line, Theon felt the crushing weight of inevitability pressing upon him. He thought of Pyke, of the harsh towers and stone halls that his people had built, the blood of his ancestors coursing through his veins, and the unforgiving waves that had shaped his people into the finest sailors the world had ever seen. Creatures of storms and steel. To follow Robb would be to betray his own blood. To ignore Robb would be to betray the only true friend who had ever treated him as an equal, a brother.
He paced the narrow chamber, the floorboards groaning. The waves slapped against the castle’s base, and Theon felt as if the sea itself were testing his resolve. For days, he could not act. He carried the letter everywhere, feeling the creases against his fingers. He imagined Robb waiting, trusting, preparing to meet him with open arms, unaware that his "brother" was considering a different path.
Every instinct screamed that he should answer Robb’s plea, that honor and duty demanded it. But every fiber of his being, the teachings of Balon, the culture of the Ironborn, the call of the sea, the call for raids, demanded a different path. He could almost hear the ancient kraken whispering to him, urging him to embrace the identity that had always been his, to seize power where he could, to make his mark before being swallowed by the northern wolf’s glory.
He thought of Balon’s plan to seize the undefended North. His father’s words echoed, harsh and uncompromising: “The North is weak, ripe for the taking. Only the Ironborn have the courage to seize it. Only the Kraken can strike when the wolf is unaware.” The promise of power, of being more than a pawn in a Stark game, was intoxicating. Yet the weight of the coming treachery pressed down with relentless force. He walked to the balcony again, the letter clutched tight. The waves below rising and falling with indifferent rhythm. The scent of salt and seaweed stung his nostrils. Time was running out.
Days passed, each marked by the relentless crash of waves and the creak of ship timbers. Theon couldn't sleep, barely ate. The letter, once a symbol of hope and trust, had become a weight pressing upon his chest, a constant reminder that he had to choose, and that no choice would leave him unscathed. The sea wind carried the smell of salt and brine into his room, mingling with the faint metallic tang of iron and the soot of the castle’s lanterns. Every sense seemed heightened, every sound magnified, as if the world itself were forcing him to confront the reality of what was to come.
And yet, despite the fear, despite the guilt, a part of Theon felt a flicker of exhilaration, a thrill at the prospect of seizing his destiny. The kraken in his blood stirred, a reminder that he was not a wolf, not a servant of the North, he was a Greyjoy. Born of storms and salt, capable of shaping his own fate.
o-O-o
Theon awoke before dawn. He made no announcement, gave no word to his father or his bannermen. He simply walked down to the dock, the letter from Robb still in his hands, feeling the weight of the parchment as if it were both a sword and a chain.The harbor was shrouded in a fog that clung to the hulls like a shroud. He walked along the dock, wooden planks slick beneath his boots, hands deep in his pockets. The smell of rope and the tang of iron from the ships grounded him. Around him, the harbor stirred. Sailors shouted, and the sound of pulleys punctuated the air.
The horizon was dim gray as the sun touched the waves with muted gold. Theon drew the letter from his coat, staring at the direwolf seal. He imagined Robb trusting him, and the thought stabbed like a knife. But then he pictured Balon’s pride, the promise of glory, and the relief of finally embracing his heritage.
The letter would not choose his path for him. The sea would not choose for him. Only he could decide the course, only he could determine his path. And in that moment, the waves, the salt, the iron, and the weight of history all pressed upon him, urging him forward.
His heart raced. He could feel the pulse of the sea beneath the dock. He thought of the Stark armies marching south, and then of the kraken lurking in the depths. His breath came in ragged bursts, tasting of salt and iron.
With a resolve as cold and hard as the sea, he tore the letter. The sound of ripping parchment was sharp and final. He let the fragments scatter, watching as they danced above the waves—a testament to the choice he had just made.
Theon strode toward his ship, the splintered fragments of Robb’s trust swirling in the morning breeze. The crew watched in silence, sensing the tension in his posture and the cold storm in his eyes. Reaching the deck, Theon turned to face them.
“We sail north,” he declared, his voice steady despite the war within. “Winterfell is our destination. Prepare the ships. Make ready for a journey none of us will ever forget.”
The crew erupted into a flurry of activity—ropes pulled, sails unfurled. Theon felt a sudden surge of power, a cocktail of guilt and exhilaration. He was no longer a passive participant. He had chosen. He had acted. The kraken in his blood had won, and there was no turning back.
Theon Greyjoy, son and heir of Balon Greyjoy, would steer his course into history, choosing to turn against the one who had called him brother. And that choice would come to haunt the young Greyjoy for all his days.
o-O-o
The Eyrie had always been a place of impossible beauty. Perched above the world, its pale towers seemed carved from cloud and sky alike, untouched by the grime and noise of the realms below. Once, Lysa Arryn had taken comfort in that. Once, the height had made her feel safe.
Now it felt like a cage.
The wind pressed endlessly against the open arches, carrying with it the thin, sharp cold that never quite left these heights. It whispered through corridors and galleries like a thousand murmured secrets, tugging at curtains, rattling shutters, brushing against skin as if the mountain itself wished to be heard.
Lysa stood at the window of her solar, staring down into the mist-choked valleys far below. She had been there for hours—she was certain of it—though time had become a slippery thing since Petyr’s death. Some days passed in a blur of tears and memory; others stretched on endlessly, each moment sharp and vivid, every thought clawing for attention.
She wore black, as she had every day since the news arrived. The fabric clung too tightly at her shoulders, and she found herself tugging at it absently, fingers trembling.
They had taken him from her.
Petyr’s voice still echoed in her mind—soft, reassuring, clever. He had promised her safety. Promised her love. Promised that the Vale would finally be hers in truth, free of the wretched judgment of the great lords and finally an escape from the shadow of her sister’s children.
And then the wretched raven arrived.
Publicly executed, the message had said. Alongside traitors and schemers. As if he had been nothing more than another name to be crossed from a list.
Lysa’s lips twitched, her expression shifting suddenly—not to grief, but to something dangerously close to a smile. They thought he was weak. They thought she was weak.
A sound behind her broke the moment.
She spun, heart racing, before recognizing the figure at the door. Lord Yohn Royce stood there, broad and solid in his bronze armor, runes etched deep and worn smooth by years of use. He had removed his helm, though he rarely did so these days in her presence, and his face—lined, stern, honest—betrayed nothing beyond careful restraint.
Behind him, a young servant lingered nervously, clutching a rolled parchment sealed with green wax.
“My lady,” Royce said, bowing. “A message from the Riverlands.”
At once, Lysa’s mood shifted again. Her eyes sharpened, and she crossed the room with sudden energy, skirts whispering against the stone.
“From the Starks?” she asked, too quickly.
The servant nodded. “Yes, my lady. From King Robb’s host.”
Royce hesitated, just for a heartbeat. “May I suggest we read it together?”
Lysa waved him off. “Read it.”
The servant swallowed and broke the seal.
As he read, the chamber seemed to grow colder.
The letter spoke of movement—of Lannister banners sighted near contested borders, of Tywin Lannister maneuvering his host through lands dangerously close to the Vale’s lower valleys. It spoke of strained supply lines, of opportunity, of justice long delayed.
Robb Stark wrote carefully, almost respectfully. He did not command. He suggested. He painted a picture of an enemy exposed, of a chance to strike a blow that would echo across the war.
When the servant finished, silence fell like a blade between them. Lysa stared at the parchment as if it might leap from the boy’s hands.
“They come closer,” she murmured.
Royce stepped forward. “They skirt our lands, my lady. Close, yes—but not openly hostile.”
“They march beneath our mountains,” Lysa snapped, her voice rising sharply. She seized the letter and crushed it in her fist. “As if the Vale were nothing. As if we were already defeated.”
“My lady,” Royce said carefully, “Tywin Lannister is known for provoking rash responses. This could be a feint—”
She laughed. The sound was sudden, bright, and entirely wrong.
“A feint?” she repeated, turning to him with a wide, brittle smile. “Do you think Petyr’s death was a feint, Lord Royce? Do you think my husband, your liege lord, was a feint?”
Royce stiffened. “No.”
“Do you think they feigned the gallows?” she demanded. “The blade? The crowd?”
Her voice wavered, and just as suddenly, the smile vanished. Tears welled in her eyes, spilling freely as she pressed a hand to her chest.
“They killed him,” she whispered. “They took him from me. From us.”
Royce’s jaw tightened. He glanced briefly toward the inner chambers where young Robert Arryn slept, guarded night and day. “My lady, I grieve with you. Truly. But your son—”
“—is safe,” Lysa cut in sharply, the tears vanishing as quickly as they had come. “Because I keep him safe. Because I will not allow Lannister filth to crawl any closer.”
She ascended the dais with restless energy, pacing now like a caged animal.
“They think I'm weak,” she said. “They think the Falcon hides behind stone and sky while lions feast on the realm.”
Royce followed her with his eyes, unease growing. For weeks now, her moods had come in storms—grief turning to rage, affection to suspicion in the space of a breath. Orders were issued and rescinded, servants praised one hour and dismissed the next.
The lords of the Vale whispered. Quietly and carefully.
“We should send scouts,” Royce urged. “Test their strength. Harass supply lines. The Knights of the Vale have not ridden as one in many years. To commit the full host—”
“—will crush them,” Lysa cut him off. Her eyes burned with fevered intensity. “Do you know how long I have waited for this? For justice?”
Justice.
The word felt wrong in the chamber.
“They will pay,” she continued, her voice trembling with emotion. “For my sister’s children. For my husband. For Petyr. For every lie whispered about me behind closed doors.”
Royce took a breath. “And if Robb Stark is using us? If he’s drawing us into a battle not of our choosing?”
Lysa tilted her head, studying him, and for a moment her expression softened.
“Robb Stark is a dutiful son. Seeking justice against the wretched lions,” she said gently. “As I am a grieving widow. He understands family and loss.”
Then her face hardened.
“And even if he does use us, what of it? The Lannisters will die all the same.”
She raised her voice, no longer speaking only to Royce, but to the assembled lords now filtering into the chamber.
“Send out our forces,” she commanded. “Send the Knights of the Vale. Every house. Every sword that is sworn to me.”
The room went still.
Royce stared at her, disbelief flickering across his usually impassive features.
“My lady,” he said slowly, “every man?”
She turned fully to him now, her composure cracking completely.
“Yes,” she hissed. “Every man. Every knight. Every boy that is old enough to hold a spear.”
Royce swallowed, unsure of the path of their Lady regent . “Everyone?”
For a heartbeat, she froze before she screamed.
“EVERYONE!”
The sound echoed off the stone walls, shrill and raw, carrying down the corridors like a wound ripped open.
“I want them gone,” she shouted. “Not a single Lannister left to crawl back to the Rock and tell tales. I want Tywin Lannister to know what it means to lose everything!”
Her breathing came fast and uneven now, hands clenched into fists at her sides.
“They took Petyr from me, they took my husband,” she whispered, voice cracking. “They laughed while they did it. I will not stop. I will not rest. I will not be denied.”
Inside her mind, Petyr’s voice answered her—soft, approving, telling her she was right, that this was love, that this was what strength looked like.
Royce bowed, stiff and formal.
“As you command, my lady.”
He turned away, already issuing orders, though his face had gone pale. As he left the chamber, his thoughts lingered not on Tywin Lannister—but on the small, sickly boy sleeping in the Eyrie’s inner rooms, and how much longer the Vale could endure its lady’s unraveling.
Left alone, Lysa returned to the window.
Far below, clouds parted to reveal the green veins of road and valley where armies would soon march. Horns began to sound—low, echoing calls bouncing from peak to peak.
The Knights of the Vale were riding to war.
She pressed her forehead to the cold stone and smiled through her tears.
“Wait for me, Petyr,” she thought. “Just wait a little longer and I will give you the justice you deserve.”
The Falcon had spread its wings, and somewhere beyond the mountains, the Lion was about to feel its talons.
Comments
Rogue67
Betraying Robb
Daniel
So he's betraying them or he's warning Rob he's betraying them
Kinz
There is another paragraph that is doubled when he receives the letter from Robb
Rogue67
Yeah I wanted my readers to get a better grasp of the difficult decision Theon was put into when he had to choose between his family and his loyalty. Also thanks for letting me know about the paragraph double.
Ekko
Tftc Love your version of Theon's Betrayal. All the stuff from Martin reduced to the actual emotional struggle and the ultimatum. He really is a little bitch. P.S. This paragraph is doubled: "To follow Robb would be to betray his blood. To ignore him would be to betray the only friend who had ever treated him as an equal.:
