Patrefans
Torsten Hewson from patreon
Torsten Hewson patreon

v2 c77: The Misty Duel Part 1

🕑 Added 2021-11-09 03:01:35 +0000 UTC

Comments

Philip

The Qi Blades increased from weight to ten. Tigu bounced up and down, her eyes searching the mist. Something isn't quite right with the first sentence? from weight to ten? eight to ten?

paul Emmer

This is a hard one but i agree with moosh 7 if you choose to let Tigu loose after a close fight her compasion for the lad could give face to the situation as she realizes it isnt always about winning Good luck with this one

Bat

The fight to me has the perfect amount of serious and fun mixed together.

aj0413

Personally, I think both chapters went over well, but I think the majority of the feedback I think you should hear is: "Don't over think it too much and strive for perfectionism." Ultimately, the scene isn't like the original Yu Ren + Fox ending which had many implications on future plot points, so I feel like spending too much time on it would be overly detrimental instead of adding much to the story.

BaguaBrady

very well said

Moosh7

Seems people are pretty divided on if they like playful Tigu or tiger Tigu better. If the current serious battle version of her is true to her current character then I personally say go with that. I agree playful Tigu is more likeable, but it seems to me that part of Tigu's character arc is learning the subtleties of human interactions. Her taking the fight in a more lighthearted way to impress her opponent's injured family member could be the type more subtle behavior she grows into in time. Or maybe she learns to do that in this very battle making it a heartwarming experience for all. That sounds like something that would happen in this story.

Ace High

I desperately want a character to canonically use a technique called "Yeet" on another

Daniel Gesualdi

In a way it kinda dose belong to another novel tigas specifically.

Andrew

I liked it when she played along too. Thank you for the chapter. I found a really cool series you're 1 of my favorite authors so I thought I'd share with you. https://www.royalroad.com/profile/3091/fictions

Corrections: "The mist started to gather around the Lad. Her form became instinct, and her sword wavered as it seemed to disappear and reappear." Lad=Lady? "The Qi Blades increased from weight to ten. Tigu bounced up and down, her eyes searching the mist. Wary for the illusions, and a sudden blade in the back." weight=eight

The Lost Pages

I like this. And I preferred the Tigu who played along. Like she could both be annoyed and amused by damp pond's actions.

gugu

First part is confusing, "During breakfast Yun Ren had questioned them on their whereabouts after the meal." who them?

BRUNO ASTUR

The Tigu part is much better, but I miss the brothers interaction... maybe start with it then move to her.

Ichypa

It’s okay, but I have to say I miss the section with the Grand Ravine guy. I had been wondering what he had going on as one of the few real contenders and the guy from the “strongest sect” around, so not seeing him is a loss IMO.

Zacle

I don't remember the old version super well but this version is quite nice. It does need some editing though

Umut Numanoglu

Why not keep both? It is the same fight from two different perspectives. This chapter just needs some editing. Tigu speaks about two persons in the beginning but Gou Ren is not mentioned until the end. Also I'm very very surprised that Tigu did not throw them off the roof. I mean she is a cat, you can't leave something / someone on the edge of a cliff and not await them pushing it down it is against their nature

Demian Buckle

Thank you for the Chapter.

ericksond

I know that battles are necessary but for some reason this chapter seems off and does not belong. It felt like it came from another novel. I know because I always gauge how I felt after reading every chapter. Let me read the earlier version and I will update my comment. At the very least it seemed like a staggering jolt from the near perfection of the previous chapter. And I look back at all the other chapters with battles and they all felt more… subtle yet sublime.

Midjji

The first half of this version is better but the second half is much worse. Gou befriending the crippled kid was a good idea, forming more ins and attachment. Also Gou sitting with the crippled kid lends itself perfectly to tigu confusing which one of the two she is looking at, and her challenging misty lake lady as unworthy of Gou as well.

LurkerIV

I like this this version feel better

Carsten Bak Larsen

The following paragraph appeared twice: "For the first time in the tournament, Tigu formed a Qi Blade. Misty Lady was supposed to be strong." and the following I guess was supposed to be about a Lady, not a Lad? "The mist started to gather around the Lad."

Guessed

I liked the version with tigu showboating, this one isn't bad either but there are a couple of awkward bits in the beginning; Gou not getting mentioned by name and the Orchid's Petals being referred to as Blades of Grass

Benji

Ooh, fun chapter! Just make sure to double check before posting this, there was a good number of grammar and spelling mistakes =)

geogio13

I will admit that I personally liked the old version a bit better. Not that there is anything wrong with this one, just that I enjoyed the slightly more showy and playful tone where the two of them were hamming it up a bit, like how Tigu wanted to at the restaurant.

STORRM

Tigu bounced away, greeting {creating} some distance. The Qi Blades increased from weight {eight} to ten

Reiner Fox

agreed, and I liked the fact of the kid with crutches sitting with Gou ren

Joel Bullock

I guess it's more in character for Ti Gou to be annoyed but I preferred it when she joined in the fun boasting personally

Jeff Petkau

If it's going to end mid-fight like this, a few lines earlier at "building up steam" might be a better cut point.

Mantiqore

Damp Pond lol I love that nickname

Jeff Scott

The other version was more fun, but this was more in character. This version is better.

Will mILLER

Perhaps things will get a little steamy for Gou Ren in the coming nights.

Kara Nina

But not taking a fight seriously just wouldn't suit Tigu's character.

Damian

I think I liked the older version with how That opening bit with tigu and mist lady. Other than that is it fine to me

Scipio

I get why both versions exist, one is the predator, and the other the friendly cat. That being said, I agree, I think the friendly cat is better

taukid

I definitely love Tigu's pov for the tournament and seeing an rans fight. The main fight is great, too, but I feel the prefight dialogue lacked the fun playfulness of the previous version. And it would be a fun call back if the boy was sitting with Gou Ren and Yun Ren.

Nick

Thanks for the chapter. Certainly much better than the previous attempt.

SoulofaGremlin

Worth it. Hope Tigu has other tricks up her sleeves other than her claws.

Colby Last

The biggest problem with the previous version was the timing. The old sect finally finding Jin Rou has been an arc everyone was looking forward to for a long time and it was frustrating to suddenly have it switch to the much less anticipated tournament that Jin Rou isn't even participating in.

J B

I suspect she's a foregone loss at this point. It's the NEXT fight that might get particularly interesting, and greatly depends on how Ti Gu handles herself in her victory. Gracious, and the next battle'll probably be civil but closer. If she gets all cocky, Damp Pond will likely drown her.

RageBone

I am pretty happy with it too. You even delivered those mistakes i asked for. Thanks.

Jan Alexander

Great fight scene. I want to see Xianghua's steampunk contraption

Daniel

I really hope Tigu kicks Damp Pond's ass into next week.

Benjamin White

I don’t know how far ahead you’ve planned the arc but this one and the other one would probably be better if they’re merged with each other, for example the first half of both as one chapter and the second half of both as another. It seems that way you could get everything you want from these scenes unless of course you’ve planned for the brothers part to be the first half of the next chapter.

J B

A nice improvement, minus some minor stuff that a good editor'll fix. I like the addition of the literal steampunk. I'm glad to see Tigu still observant, still playful, still prideful. the whole 'Damp Pond' bit made me grin.

vetusanimus81

Version 1 felt more fun and light hearted

Andrew

Thank you!

Bunny Waffles

" During breakfast Yun Ren had questioned them on their whereabouts after the meal., Both had turned a shade of red, and let out frantic denials that they had done anything last night.? Is a bit confusing as to who the two are. While you mention Gou Ren a sentence or two afterwards, he isn't mentioned at all beforehand, so it seems confusing as to who the two you are referring to are at first read.

Robert Mullins

Delayed and edited is better than on time and unedited. Similarly delayed and edited is better than delayed and unedited. It's already 10pm (where I'm at), few will mind if you push it back a little longer to wait on proofreaders or wait until tomorrow morning.

Christopher Meeks

I did like how the brothers adopted mist kid in the previous version, still this is pretty good and I do prefer seeing some of tigu's fight instead of cutting it at the start

Summercat

I preferred Tigu playing along with Damp Pond's antics, seeing she was playing it up for someone.

"The qi blades increased from weight to ten" Eight to ten

The GrandMage

You repeat "For the first time in the tournament, Tigu formed a Qi Blade. Misty Lady was supposed to be strong." both before and after she looks to the announcer and he starts the match. I'm assuming it's just supposed to be one or the other.

Enochi

Ooh really enjoyed this I like your fightsm

Gavin Turlock

There is a duplicate line.For the first time in the tournament, Tigu formed a Qi Blades. Misty Lady was supposed to be strong. Tigu glanced at the announcer man, who for some reason hadn’t started the fight yet. He had a massive grin on his face, and was rubbing his hands together. “Begin!” he boomed. For the first time in the tournament, Tigu formed a Qi Blade. Misty Lady was supposed to be strong.

No Step On Snek

The phrase "For the first time in the tournament, Tigu formed a Qi Blades. Misty Lady was supposed to be strong." is repeated twice. Otherwise, feels a lot better than the first attempt

Max Thomas

"For the first time in the tournament, Tigu formed a Qi Blades. Misty Lady was supposed to be strong." appears twice


More Creators