Patrefans
Karp from patreon
Karp patreon

Jedi Insurgency 015

🕑 Added 2025-04-07 15:58:58 +0000 UTC

Comments

axiom

There's a couple shadows in legends that act even worse than the MC. And Yoda still consideres them good Jedi so the MC is still a good Jedi.

Nyarlathotep Flagg

Ehhh, nah. The basics of it was a take a certain Jedi diplomat had after the end of the war with The Brotherhood of Darkness. The wannabe-Sith of that era, that didn't really adhere to its teachings It was a bad enough idea at the time, and thoroughly misinformed as well - Not just misguided. It was born from a lack of understanding of both what led Jedi to go dark, and the details about how the war ended. Ultimately, a lot of Jedi questioned the realism of the Ruusan reformation over the years. But the philosophical clique that brought it about, basically reigned all the way into the final days of the republic. In no small part due to Yoda, who inherited his masters teachings and sat on the council for hundreds of years. The disconnect from the rest of the galaxy, allowed the council to trick themselves into believing that the Ruusan reformation had worked as intended, and was good for the galaxy overall. And since they elected their own members... With a super long-lived grandmaster? Well... Those who disagreed with their dogma, simply couldn't get far in their hierarchy. And although wise in some ways, being as old as he was, it was very hard for Yoda to learn some things. Blindspots his entire philosophy and mentality had created. And yet he did sometimes question things, when the outcomes deviated too greatly from what they would have expected. Yoda did fail, and hard. In so many ways. But in relative terms, he was still relatively open minded for a Jedi of his time, and really tried his best. Fear of accidentally falling into what was percieved as old mistakes/traps/pit falls kept him from seeing the truth. If given more time and eloquence, I believe Qui-gon could have changed his mind before it was too late. He did manage it after his death after all. But a lot happened before that, so maybe not. It's hard to say, and you can't ignore how much suffering their stance had already caused. Obviously, their structuring was not quite sustainable. Although one should probably ultimately blame The Republic and galaxy at large more than the Jedi in some ways. At least where the Ruusan reformation is concerned. It should have been questioned, repealed, or reverted long before things reached this point. After all, the Jedi were no longer participating so directly in politics. So they could not have changed it. In fact, to even protest its removal, they'd have to enter politics again. Which contradicts its conditions.

Nyarlathotep Flagg

"The truth of you forevermore shall be... Sidious." And soon the Galaxy might know that is the case.

Ben Lockwood

I really don't know the history of it, but was the ruusan reformations forced on the jedi, if it was you could look how long the old republic took to collapse compared to the ruusan reformation era. Based only it only took a thousand years you could call the reformation a failure of a grand order, along with the jedi purpose wasn't suppose to police the legislature, they were only the judicial branch of the government, so in a the collapse of the republic was their own fault.

Deathknight134

Oo, so much fun~! Persuade is such a hack, lol.


More Creators