nataliegold patreon

Help me pick a new show to start!

🕑 Added 2025-02-26 17:00:11 +0000 UTC

Comments

Çlôud

aww i would love it for peaky blinders to win hehe darn

Karl Siddons

I may be late to this but the only reason why I paid and signed up for the patreon because its a crime that Natalie hasn't seen Severance yet and I wanted to find out why yall haven't voted to watch it yet.

Jose 'Nihilus Outis' Morales

'Andor' is top tier Star Wars.

Logan Rodriguez

Would love to watch Alice in Borderland with you!!!

Cam Self

I love all of your reactions, however…. : I feel it’s a crime to yourself to include so many top tier shows within the same pole There are at least 3 shows here that deserve your attention and including them within the same pole only deprive yourself of their amazing emotional/directorial/cinematographical content when putting them against eachother… such as Severance, Andor, & daredevil, & better call Saul In my opinion ☺️☺️

Christian Walker

Ignore the poll! Go rogue and watch Severance! Not at all repetitive or boring. And you have a doppelgänger in the show!

Thoko

You're a liar. Daredevil is almost 10 years old, and I just said that Marvel made decent stuff 10 years ago. That's not anti-marvel. You're just an abusive person who wants to stop others from having their own opinion.

Thoko

Yeah I like that reaction channels have voting to let the fans pick, but I really don't like this whole thing of stopping after a season. I think that if a show wins that we should just see it through until the end

Thoko

Meh

Thoko

I think its subjective. If you're wanting the show to be like Breaking Bad, then sure it can feel slow at the beginning. But if you want to learn about what makes Saul who he is, then things are happening very quickly right from the first episode of season 1

Ojeda Gomez Angelo Mihaelle

Better call saul it's really good, maybe my favorite series, but I agree that is super slow until S3, so Daredevil will be good :3

Siti Dee

It looks like dd is winning the poll! No complains from me but i hope you'll consider watching Severance right after!

Nolan Hickman

You should watch Dexter if you haven't seen it yet.

Nick Mo

REACHER….REACHER…..REACHER…..REACHER

margo m

so close to severance…. we’ll get em next time i guess 😔

jamie jones

Erik your whole point of view is, i didnt like it so you should skip it. Without any regard for story implications

jamie jones

Thoko, Daredevil is one of the best things marvel has ever done. Youre just a hater who always posts anti marvel crap whenever you get the chance

Mauricio Morales

Castlevania would be a fun quick watch. FYI Season one is just 4 episodes long.

Yani Dodge

I tend to agree, I've just heard so many good things about Andor (and Daredevil s3 for that matter)! Apparently it's actually got good characters and storytelling and not bogged down with IP fan service.

Jason Gillman

Another fantastic new episode of Severance making me hope we can pull it together to win the poll! Come on guys!

Henkan

Amen. It's literally the RLM meme now with "just consume product and get excited for next product".

Joey Johansen

*chanting* Seh-var-ance! Seh-var-ance! Seh-var-ance! :)

Julian Lee

castlevaniaaaaaaaaa

Thoko

This channel was built on the decent marvel films from like 10 years ago back when Marvel content was actually ok. At some point we have to move on

Thoko

Meh

Thoko

Yeah I really want to see less of superhero stuff and less of star wars stuff. They've both become really boring and repetitive

Kevin Farrell

It's a bummer, especially because she seemed to like the first season.

Skyruff

Thanks!

Joel

Man, I'm so tired of superhero stuff. It was fun for a while but it gets a bit boring seeing the same character types deal with the same problems.

Rob E

Also it funny this poll comes out just as I’m in the middle of my own DD rewatch with nats reactions to the first 2 seasons lol was gonna do season 3 without them but now I may just wait and do season 3 in time with them if it wins

Rob E

Defenders is only 8 episodes if you want to watch it before leading into daredevil season 3. You’ve already met Luke cage in Jessica jones so the only member you’ll be in familiar with is Iron Fist and honestly that’s no loss. DD season 3 comes right after the events of that show and they do address some of the events and their effect on Matt but it’s recapped in the show itself to let you fill in the blanks but it’s up to yourself. Defenders also has Sigourney Weaver if that helps influence your decision.

Stephen Coleman

I commented awhile back on DD S3 and if you did indeed like the first two, then S3 is more than a must-watch as it enhances each character's story and the stakes they're facing, all with a mere fraction of the gore of the other two seasons. Know that you WILL be lost, storyline wise, in Episode 1 without the Defenders, but in a nutshell, it summarizes what happens enough to track. ( I watched S3 without knowing about that and had difficulty calibrating mentally with the story at first). By midway through episode two, all of that is mostly irrelevant as Daredevil carries its own story again. IMO, S3 is the best single season of a show I've ever watched. Yes, I may have raised the bar to an unfair level. I also do not think there is a chance it falls short of expectation.

MrBreasticle

I would agree if daredevil season 3 wasn’t one of the best seasons in all of television. I was so surprised it gave me breaking bad vibes

Jason Gillman

I can like Marvel and not want three Marvel shows in a row

Erik Stevenson

Hard to say, she has patreon rewards for voting in polls, and depending on the reaction schedule may have to poll a show rather than just picking one since she picked Invincible S3 without a poll and noted she'd continue on into DD: Born Again without a poll.

Erik Stevenson

Defenders was mid at best and is extremely easily skipable. Certain fans want to believe that you have to watch every piece of connected media to get the 'real' experience, and that's just not true lol.

Civengard

Please consider watching Ms. Marvel ! It's not perfect but it's a really charming fun time especially followed up with The Marvels

Adam O Driscoll

Peaky Blinders not even being close in the polls 😢

jamie jones

This channel was built on marvel so why are you even subscribed here?

Jason Gillman

Legit I just want anyrhing but Daredevil to win, please. We just did a Marvel show.

Jason Gillman

She already watched Jessica Jones.

Skyruff

If Daredevil wins, I suggest Jessica jones season 1 then Defenders, then daredevil born again.

jamie jones

Thats a lie. There are character growth and major events for other daredevil characters besides matt in the defenders show.

Yusuf

Can't Severance is not winning!!!!

Chris Guerrero

Haven’t seen daredevil before so hope she watches season 3 so I can watch with.

DirectorInc

Andor needs to win.

Dominykas Veiveris

Always great to see polls like this, but also sad cause only one or two wins.

Billy B

Better call Saul literally in the top 5 shows ever made . Watch breaking bad first if you haven’t yet . I’m mind blown with people’s tastes in movies and shows .

Yasin

You're not serious people.

Siti Dee

TIE! 👏TIE! 👏 TIE! 👏

PrayTellCaesar

Im just going to have to console myself that you'll only see peaky s1 cause it gets slaughtered in the polls 😭

Jason Gillman

Yeah I’ll vote for Andor next time assuming Severance wins this poll.

Bobby Kraus

Please just keep Andor in mind for future polls… literally *the* one I’ve been hoping for from Nat since it aired

Thoko

Nooooo... I wanted Severance to win

Thomas Richter

Legion is pretty cool

Siti Dee

Well, then! Hoping with you for a tie!

romeo

Gotta be Daredevil

InfiniteCorpze

Fingers crossed for you. Pls consider a vote for Andor this round. We're hungry lol

InfiniteCorpze

Pick Andor for the people! Lol

Baron

Pass, nothing I would vote for in your poll. I look forward to future polls with content that I am excited for you to react to.

InfiniteCorpze

My baby boy Andor is doomed but he needs a comeback in the next poll. IT IS THE MOMENT

WackyJacky

Also you do not need defenders to know season 3 of daredevil. I mean, one thing in particular is important but that’s it

WackyJacky

I love all of these shows so much. It was hard to make a choice but I really love daredevil season 3 and I’ve got high hopes for born again. But man I could’ve easily picked severance or andor

Sam Kimpton

I'm torn between Daredevil and Andor....but Andor is SO GOOD

Spencer Wichmann

To be honest there might be a recap of the defenders in the "previously on Daredevil" part of Episode 1 of Season 3. Can't confirm but with the way Season 3 starts it would seem weird if they didn't add it

Jimathai

yes... and come to think of it, its actually pretty crazy how many ties we've had lately.

Emilie

Andor pleaaaaaaaaaseeee

Jonathan Wiking

Better call saul will loose this one but please put it on more polls when the trendig shows right now are finished 😆

Boomcity

Which she can do with Severance. Win/Win.

Boomcity

Looks like my plan of binging Severance with a free trial to Apple TV is going to pay off.

Siti Dee

Does she usually react to both if it's a tie?

Siti Dee

Omg severance and daredevil in a poll dont do this to meeee 😭 (voted severance anyway) BUT i wont be hating if dd s3 end up winning cuz s3 was the best thing anything mcu ever did as a whole

Erik Stevenson

Ehhh, we literally just got through a Marvel show, would be nice to take a beat before going back to the Marvel train.

Ashley

I would love to see Andor, Severance or DDS3. But mostly Andor and S2 of Andor is coming very soon. Like by the time you would finish S1, S2 should be a few eps in.

Ashley

Its one of the best Star Wars things ever made and it should absolutely win. But it just wasn't highly viewed. I hope it wins tho.

AlimarM

I just mentioned Severance in passing a month or so ago thinking it wouldn't show up in the polls anytime soon but here we are. I am surprised and glad it's in the poll. Hope it wins as it's a very very good show.

Ridley

no way andor is losing :(

Alex Le

Guessing she doesn't do Japanese shows because Japan doesn't have fair use laws and therefore is subject to copyright strikes at any time. Many other channels have gotten many strikes due to having anime content on it.

Jimathai

hoping for a tie!

Alvin Everett

Daredevil S3 & Born Again is a must

Logan Kerlee

That would've made me so happy! I'l vote on that over most anything else.

Franz Liszt

Oh yeah the best show of this decade so far is winning. That's what I'm talking about!!! (yup still is)

Logan Kerlee

It has to return! I'd love for her to check that out! :)

Logan Kerlee

I'd enjoy this.

JarHead0351

Where is "Sons of Anarchy" it's a great shows with so many twist and turns and Heroes and Evil Villains that you don't see them coming

shalece p

me hoping for daredevil

Sean Obrock

With the new season of Andor on the horizon, I'd love to see this win!

Erik Stevenson

Severance must win here, S1 is very good, S2 so far is some of the best TV I've seen in years. Also, perfect kind of show for reactions where there's some mysteries, some reveals, some interpersonal drama, just A+ stuff. No shade to Daredevil but this was an easy vote for me.

Will Morgan

All amazing shows, but Severance stands out even among this competition.

Rob E

This is a poll for what to watch first right because all these shows are peak.

The Jarl

no legend of vox machina? it's such a great show hope it comes back to the polls in the future

Daniel McGuinness

They’re like 25-30 minute episodes, and there’s multiple chronological lists that focus on the main arcs if you really wanna shave off some time

Jacob King

Severance is an astonishing original work. Daredevil S1 is very of its time and I wouldn’t recommend S2 to anyone. Netflix Marvel was an experiment that ultimately didn’t work.

Beth Brown

Natalie, i passed on voting on this one because i don't like any of them. But i'd like to suggest the Sopranos and Ash vs the Evil dead. Ash isn't just for Natmares since its 3 seasons, each episode is 30 minutes , so it'll go faster than u think.

Gavinmc

Love Severance, but went with Andor as I feel it is the best Star Wars series so far.

Mike Hell

I think Vodo means a patreon exclusive is the only way she'd do it, and it's way too long for even that, so it's probably never gonna happen.

jamie jones

Lol nat doesnt wanna do defenders plus daredevil because its too long, but you want her to do a 140 episode show?

HeyItsSuper

Man this is a tough pick, these are all really good imo, hope Natalie gets around to them all at some point

Hades

If you do watch daredevil season 3, I think you need to watch a recap of defenders first to understand the context of what’s happening

JD Shick

I think it's completely fine to just go on to Daredevil season 3 with just watching a recap. As fun as Defenders is, you don't really need to watch it if you can get caught up with a quick video or something. Though watching Jessica and Matt interact is great.

FateMalone

daredevil please

Daniel McGuinness

Star Wars: The Clone Wars on a poll WHEN

Adam Pedersen

Severance is amazing!

Joseph salazar

Nooooo daredevil lol

Mike Hell

Here's hoping! I am okay with DD too, I am just really interested in what Natalie (and everyone here who hasn't seen it, for that matter) thinks of Severance. I am currently obsessed, if I wasn't telegraphing that enough...

Tyler Douglas

Hopefully Andor wins! Some of the best Star Wars in a long time and a second season is coming soon

Joshua Rodriguez

Come on Daredevil!!!!

Donovan Jeffery

I'm torn between Severance and Daredevil.

Mike Hell

I don't know if you did that on purpose but... what vodo said!

Mastervodo

That's what she said!

James Fisher

ONE PUNCH has more laughs

Joshua Hutter

Hope Legends of Vox Machina comes back in a future poll. I think you will like it!

Joshua s. Jackson

If you haven't seen "One Piece" on Netflix, I would love to see that in a pole sometime.

Joshua Yambalia

Andor is probably the best star wars show out of all that have been released. It would be nice to start it especially since the new season is coming up. But i have also recently rewatched all of Peaky Blinders and have been reminded why it was such a top show.

George Roybal

ANDOR!

Darryl Low

Happy Wednesday Nat. Hope you and Tyler had an amazing weekend in the mountains. The scenery looked spectacular. Going to vote for Daredevil this time. Severance wasn't my cup of tea at all 😅 Have an awesome day Nat 💛

john Alexander

You don't need to watch Defenders. Watching a recap or something will be just fine. Somebody probably already has a video with everything you need to know between season 2 and 3. In fact do a reaction to that video as well in case you have any questions about something they may miss or gloss over.

Edward Rahardjo

We get treated to a lot of great shows this year. Severance S2, Andor S2 and White Lotus S3. All must watches in my opinion. Start with Severance S1

mrhalfbit

THIS MIGHT BE THE HARDEST POLE IVE SEEN ON HERE.

K.N.

It's Severance's time! I tried to get Nat to check it out since S1 3 years ago, but now that people are actually noticing how good it is, it might actually have a shot.

Cliff

Such a tough decision, Severance is current and really good, Andor is the best live action SW series, Better Call Saul is one of the best things I’ve ever watched, and you can’t go wrong with Peaky.

Heliastein

Daredevil will make no sense whatsoever....

RustafanX

These are all good choices! 😅

Jordan Freemyer

Please enjoy all shows equally. (Yes, I voted for Severance despite loving both Andor and Better Call Saul.)

Joel

If Daredevil and Severance end up tied, you should probably start with the non-Marvel show lol

giovanni colombo

One day, One Piece Live Action will be back on a poll, and I'll be a proud part of the 12% that will vote for it...

Arthur Bridges

with Andor S2 starting soon, she needs to catch up on S1

Bobby Kraus

They don’t even know what they’re missing 🔥

Mastervodo

I dunno Mike! Severance has pulled ahead of Daredevil at least 3 times in the last hour! IT'S A SLOBBERKNOCKER!

InfiniteCorpze

Please y'all we neeeeed Andor

Christian Padilla

Severance patrons unite. Don’t let your innie down

Maia Wilson

Aw man this tough!! Severance and Daredevil and both SOOO good!!!

Daniel McGuinness

Severance, Daredevil AND Andor? Oh this poll is a bloodbath

Christian Padilla

SEVERANCE GUYS PLA

jamie jones

Born again season one is 9 episodes.

Danishprince

It all comes down to how popular the reactions are on YT unfortunately. If something doesn't do well in terms of viewers there's not much sense in spending time and money in making more videos of it :)

Chris Jarrett

All good shows, patrons won’t be let down

BettleBug

All amazing shows but I'm absolutely obsessed with Severance

Kubochaan

severance yess

Cliff

Man, what a loaded poll. Tough decision but I think the safe bet is to react to all of them simultaneously 😂

Mike Hell

lol Severance is in a poll! But so is the highly requested Andor ... AND Daredevil S3… Well, I hope Severance survives going against DD (maybe 2nd place can just replace Invincible when it’s finished in a few weeks?) and I'm not at all against Daredevil, it's just that it's another 13 episodes and I think Born Again is like 18 episodes, so it's a massive time commitment. Anyway, thanks for including Severance in a poll but I wouldn't bet on it beating Matt Murdock.

Katelyn Burns

please i need the Natalie severence reacts like a fish needs water

Adeptus_Retardes

You should check out From. It's got 3 seasons rn and a 4th coming in (I think) 2026

UngawdlyJish

Great poll! I voted for Andor cuz I could go for a rewatch before the new season drops.

Joel

I think she watched it before she started the channel

Jason Gillman

She’s already seen Breaking Bad

Jimathai

yes... season 1 and 2 and JJ season 1.

Lawson

love severance but it’s gotta be daredevil

Curtis

Watch a Defenders recap or read a synopsis (or both lol). I’m a big superhero guy but Defenders was just clunky. Some cool moments but not great overall. DD S3 is immaculate though and really gets back to S1 vibes. Dark and grounded

Jason Gillman

Yeah this please.

Jimathai

Question... if Better Call Saul wins will you be doing Breaking Bad as well? Its one of the few all time great shows thats not in your catalog so far.

Berry

Severance is the best show on TV right now. Better Call Saul is one of the best shows of the decade, but it is a slow burn. Andor is easily the best Star Wars show. Peaky Blinders is a really good, very entertaining period piece. Daredevil isn't bad but clearly the odd one out.

Alberto Ramirez

Well this wasn't an easy poll lol Considering you've already covered seasons 1 and 2 of DD, I went with that option. Especially because Born Again is coming out next week. BCS is one of the greatest shows I have ever seen, so please keep that in future polls. Andor is so, so good. And season 2 is coming out soon (something to consider). I haven't seen Severance or Peaky Blinders, so can't comment on those.

Joel

Kinda hoping we don't follow up a Marvel show with two seasons of another Marvel show

Dominique Cloet

Oh, and if Daredevil wins. All you need to know is Matt fell down a big hole. Tbh I really don't remember much more from Defenders

Kcia S

SEVERANCE 100%

Artisanbloodbank

I rarely comment on here but istg if Daredevil S3 wins over Severance, the greatest show of this generation, I'm gonna pop off

Katie Kiesel

Daredevil season 3: I fully agree that a recap of Defenders is enough of a background to watch season 3. Even just reading a synopsis would be good enough, as almost all of s3's plot is fully unrelated but does have some context from it

Dominique Cloet

I cancelled my subscription so it doesn't really matter for me. But am I the only one who thinks it's kinda a shitty move to not finish shows once you start them? I'd be fine with dropping a show you don't enjoy, but putting later seasons of stuff you liked on a poll kinde bothers me.

Bobby Kraus

Andor is also ending after S2 so not a massive time commitment… please Andor it’s so unbelievably amazing

Gabriel Curran

PLEASE SEVERANCE IS SO GOOD

Jason Gillman

Please vote for Severance guys

Boomcity

One day we will see the sun rise and watch along with Nat reacting to Vox Machina. Or we bribe her. Jk 😆

jamie jones

She’s been very clear on this matter. A 100 episode anime show will not get done. To copyright strike happy. But feel free to keep asking on every poll

Danishprince

I thi k you could easily power through Defenders as its only like 8 episodes. You already know Daredevil, Jessica Jones and Luke Cage and Iron Fist doesn't really matter much

Bobby Kraus

Andor Andor Andor Andor Andor Andor Andor Andor please Andor

jamie jones

The defenders is only 8 episodes and you liked the characters of daredevil, jessica jones and luke cage. Daredevil season 3 continues right from how the defenders leaves off. Daredevil season 3 is way better than the defenders, but the defenders is still worth a watch. Luke cage was good but i get you dont wanna watch 13 episodes of that on top of everything.

Joel

Hoping for Severance, the best show on television right now by far

Skellyp

Who says it needs to be Patreon exclusive? I’m just saying I pray for her to react to it one day. That’s why I donate a 1$ a month, so I can see her polls, and if it’s ever on it, I will vote. The show is too good to never watch it.

Matthew

Also wanted to add that New Rockstars put out a Defenders recap that covers the entire first season in less than an hour, if you want to take that route. The only real connective thing between that show and DD S3 is how it begins. Literally none of the storyline is carried over or connected in any way, iirc.

Joshua Decker

Severance, Andor, or Saul all work for me

nexus

Have you watched season 2 of dare devil

Matthew

BCS is an amazing slow burn of a show, but my vote is for DD S3 so you can jump into DD:BA asap!

Mastervodo

Nat won't do it because it's anime, and it's too big of a commitment for a Patreon exclusive. Just sayin'.

Brian Leonard

I went with Daredevil to go on to born again, but I really have no interest in any of these.

Śéáń

Please include some bad shows in order to make these choices easier.

Timothy Mills

Please react to Cobra Kai some day

Chris H

Daredevil season 3 is so good!

Mastervodo

OK you marvel fans! It's now or never! Time to teach these Star Wars fans who the TRUE fans are! Disney fans! Kinda sad to see Vox Machina not on the poll so it can get crushed again. (Just kidding LOVM fans! I want it to win someday too!) Seriously though - I'm really looking forward to the new Daredevil: Born Again series, so I hope Daredevil S3 wins. Even though I don't think Nat needs to watch it to watch Born Again.