liamcatterson patreon

Charmed 5x08 "A Witch in Time" Full Reaction

🕑 Added 2023-09-18 21:03:14 +0000 UTC

Comments

Kirstie Brote

There's a continuity error in this episode that I can't unsee ever since I noticed it years ago: When Phoebe gets out of Piper's car and is running toward Miles, you can see her running in her Ugg boots.

Grace

Loved this episode. So different and shocking, and also wholesome and sad. Great episode. Thanks so much!

Samuel Fernandez

you thought this was a regular episode, Phoebe saving Miles, then she can't save Miles and suddenly...PHOEBE AND PAIGE ARE DEAD like what...?!

Samantha Russell

I've always loved Piper's little head bops in the last scene... so adorable!!

Liam Catterson

"Remember a couple of episodes ago when you said 'one of the sisters almost got disintegrated'?" NOOOOOOO Also, not great for Paige given the last episode and now this!

Ed Green

Remember a couple of episodes ago when you said 'one of the sisters almost got disintegrated'? My theory of this episode is that future Cole teamed up with the Charmed Ones to rule the underworld for good, and that the reason the warlock's spells are so unusually successful is they were created with the power of three and the Book of Shadows. Another idea is that they worked because only Cole has ever been that powerful, because no other demons have ever had a soul and so been able to pick up powers in the wasteland. It might have been a better move for Piper to show her unhurt arm to her past self, then pinch her and have her watch the bruise appear. When you talked about Piper witnessing two of her sisters die, it reminded me that she, unlike Phoebe, witnessed Prue die. Quite the trauma to re-experience. Full death count (not counting almost-deaths) is now up to: Prue 2 (stabbed by dragon, killed by Shax), Piper 3 (killed by Rodriguez, impaled by Prue, shot by Alice), Phoebe 3 (killed by Rodriguez twice, this), Paige 1 (this).

Keith Byrne

I remember seeing "that bit" with Paige and Pheobe and the Bacarras in the attic 20 years ago and it was wild and unsettling then and it is wild and unsettling now. Gotta love time travel though. D: