liamcatterson patreon

Charmed Replacement

🕑 Added 2024-10-22 13:28:11 +0000 UTC

Comments

Zaitlin

Merlin is so good, l loved it.

Taylor Walgren

Merlin!!!!!

Burak

Monster (anime). A thrilling, mystery anime. A perfect show to react to.

Octavia

Back during XFs S3 wrap party... when we all babies... https://imagizer.imageshack.com/img922/4205/ijrUa1.jpg

Samantha Russell

Lost is so wild, you have to do it!!!

Frederick

i would vote for Lost also ..ahh but i like Merlin also, so much indecision lol

stylinsezra

would love to see you react to criminal minds

Octavia

I was a huge XFs fan back in the day. Even got to visit the set in Vancouver several times. When it was in a groove, it was brilliant... but it had plenty of misses also. Personally, in looking back, I think its parts are greater than its whole. It also hasn't won the Pilot tier poll yet, whIle LOST did. But XFs is still an iconic show. I just feel LOST is timeless.

Breadcrumbs

the X Files! Lost is cool too and all, but the X Files changed the TV game first. So I vote X Files, and then Lost next time :)

Ed Green

You said recently you miss Once Upon A Time. Lost is the closest show you're going to get to Once - some of the same writers, some of the same actors, several references, same structure. And there would also be some 'duck your head' moments. One of them in particular I'd be anticipating. For a more consistently fantasy genre show I'd also suggest Lost Girl.

Octavia

LOST. It deeply influenced so many shows that came after that you've watched... like Once, The 100, etc...

Peta D

The x files! Please please please! My all time fav show and I think you would love it!

Nancy Nicolai

X-Files 👽or double up on Supernatural 😎

Bella Nfuka

Merlin 1000%

Danny Ramirez

You should react to lost.. what a great show

Bex Davies

I'd love to see Criminal Minds reactions. Slightly different to other crime shows

Kirstie Brote

I mean, if not for X-Files, we wouldn't have a lot of the other, more recent shows everyone loves! It's iconic, and I'd love to revisit it.

Michael

Burn Notice

Jenny Manchulenko

You should react to Lost, that is an awesome drama X-files was great also.

Stephen Nadeau

Merlin would be great!

Audra Foxgrove

An absolutely top tier show that does not get enough reactors!

Alyssa Bernd

MERLIN!👀

Tom Jordan

Castle If you're into Crime Drama

Eddie

Chilling adventures of Sabrina (Netflix)

Jacob Bess

Merlin would be cool

ingrid vedeld

Pll, criminal minds, castle, 911...any of them would be awesome, but x files would be cool too.

Emma Samuel

I love both X-Files or Merlin. I think you'd enjoy either!

MelGoethals

just reading the comments, i agree with criminal minds or 9-1-1 as long running. a shorter one, but fantastic is hannibal.

Liam Catterson

I have already reacted to that

Kayden banford

9-1-1

star

Id love to see hannibal

Charlie

I'd love to see Merlin

Audrey Bowen

Oh I love Merlin!! That show doesn't get enough attention

Ariel17

Fringe

Tia

I love X-Files but I think Merlin might be the one to really be a good replacement based on the style of the show. Both are great shows but Merlin based on what you are reacting to and based on the fantasy type element with the magic. Misfits is another show I would recommend but it's such a short series so that can be done outside of being a replacement. I am also not sure if you ever watched Smallville before but if you did not, you would LOVE the journey of that series.

Raven Dark

Stranger Things

Kazz (Charmed4lifekaren)

X Files, Lost, or Criminal Minds would be my recommendations.

NamlessMidnight

Both X-Files and Merlin sound like great ideas for Charmed replacement! Asides from these two, out of the pilots you've checked out recently some of my suggestions would be Ghost Whisperer, 9-1-1 and Castle. But I honestly think so many great suggestions are being made in the comments for this one that no matter which show gets picked it'll be great to see 😄

After Show Reactions

lol you could do the reboot.

Michelle Linardis

Oh, 100% Xfiles!!! 😍😍

Mariah Libby

9-1-1 is also amazing. PLL is also great

Mariah Libby

Shadowhunters

Nina The Ravenclaw

Merlin or Criminal Minds

darion greenlee

I think you'd like 9-1-1 and it's spin off 9-1-1 Lonestar!!

Clare B

Oh I love the idea of the X files and merlin - happy with either if those!

caitlin

I'd love to see you react to Lost. It's an amazing show and has a big fan base. As you are a reactor that reflects at the end of an episode, lost would be perfect for your reaction style :)

DazzleFae

So it's nothing like Charmed or any of these, but one day I'd definitely suggest the show This Is Us. It's so good! It's just about normal people, but it's probably one of the best shows I've ever seen. So definitely recommend that for some day.