toddintheshadows patreon

Please vote in the Song vs. Song poll!

🕑 Added 2025-03-23 04:20:22 +0000 UTC

Comments

Shiny Skunk

I'd love for you to do Dancer in the Dark in like a, "I would like for people to suffer in the same way I did" kind of way. (Great music tho)

JB@MSUDenver

I'm going to risk the wrath of some god with this but... If we're being fair and comparing each song's strengths then this is actually Madonna vs JJ & TL (for this you can blame their heavy handed production style). But a slightly bigger issue is Rhythm Nation's message rings hollow compared to Vogue which on so many levels actually achieves what Janet preaches.

Arbor Rainier

i wish

Wicked Dreamer

also, a poll of my two favourite hits of 1990 is just cruel lol. I very narrowly went with Vogue over Rhythm Nation.

Wicked Dreamer

a Gotye OHW would be very fitting rn…

Sugarpop

I am going to go R. Nation because some of the lyrics in "Vogue" are irritating. Two amazing songs.

Jesse

Also it’s gotta be Vogue

Jesse

Abracadabra or The Giver Pop Song Review!!!!

Connor Rankin

Oh boy oh boy I can’t wait for the Mo Bamba OHW

Céleste

Weirdly enough, Todd's already done two 2007 songs (This is why I'm hot and Face Down)

Castleknackers

Rude by MAGIC!?

Norman Buchwald

Vogue

Austin F

here's an odd factoid for you: because of that one hit, of monsters and men are the only icelandic artist to reach the top 20 on the hot 100. (i kinda wish they'd had another hit, because i love little talks...but it is very much a "fluke indie hit" song, so i'm not at all surprised that they only had one)

Arbor Rainier

there was a guy on reddit who supposedly got one of the ohw requests and said what song he chose -- i won't spoil the specific track in case people want to be surprised, but it is a 2007 tune which could possibly qualify for this ? that said, my first instinct was smth from the 2010s, in which case ,,,, icona pop ? gotye ? of monsters and men ? ylvis ??

Stephen

I don't mind who the next request is, as long as we get more Canadians

Dimetre Alexiou

Rhythm Nstion!

Lee Breezy

These requests are specifically One Hit Wonderlands

Angela

A Gotye One Hit Wonderland?

Taylor Abrahamse

Gotta be Rhythm Nation by a hair. The vid is just too iconic and shows so much talent, even more so than Madonnas. I know it should be about the song only but the vids n songs are inextricably linked.