TheBlackEarl
patreon
Darker Than Gray Ch. 34
🕑 Added 2025-09-22 15:30:02 +0000 UTCSusan remained close to Daphne, both offering and seeking comfort while they waited for Amelia to process what she had seen. Harry watched the Head of the DMLE carefully, noting the way her jaw tightened and her fists clenched as she stared at Marlene.
Finally, Amelia moved. She walked slowly back to her chair and sank into it, her usual composed demeanor barely holding up. When she looked up, her expression was a mixture of anger, determination, and deep sadness.
"Marlene," she said quietly, "I want you to know that I will do everything in my power to ensure justice is served. What Sirius Black has endured is an abomination that cannot stand."
Marlene's eyes filled with tears that she had been holding back all this while, and she released a deep breath filled with relief.
"Thank you. You have no idea how much this means to me. To all of us."
"But," Amelia continued, her tone becoming more serious, "I need you all to understand that it won’t be easy. There’d be a lot of obstacles, none bigger than Cornelius himself.”
“Because of Lucius Malfoy?” Marlene asked firmly.
“He’s a factor, yes. And a big one. But Fudge has built his entire political career on maintaining stability and avoiding controversy. This revelation would threaten everything he's worked to achieve. In his mind, it would be better to let one innocent man suffer than to admit such a catastrophic failure of the system he oversees, even though it happened when he was not in office."
"Guess it’s too much to hope for justice to matter more than politics?" Susan muttered.
"In an ideal world, no," Amelia replied with a bitter laugh. "But we're not dealing with an ideal world. We're dealing with Cornelius Fudge, a man who values his position above almost everything else. And as you said, we're dealing with someone who has a very unhealthy amount of influence over him."
"Lucius has more than just political motivations for wanting Sirius to remain in Azkaban. Because of his marriage to Narcissa, he has a direct financial interest in keeping him imprisoned," Marlene said gravely.
"As long as Black remains a convicted felon, he cannot claim his inheritance or pass it on to any heirs he might have," Amelia explained, glancing at Daphne for a moment. "The Black family estate is one of the oldest and wealthiest in Britain. We're talking about millions of galleons, multiple properties including ancestral homes, and considerable political influence that comes with such wealth."
“Fat load of good that political influence did when it mattered,” Harry muttered darkly, making Marlene grimace.
"And when Malfoy turns eighteen..." Daphne trailed off.
"He'll inherit everything as the last surviving male with Black blood and no legal impediments," Amelia finished. "Narcissa can't inherit directly due to the male primogeniture traditions of the old pureblood families, but her son can. And what belongs to the son effectively belongs to the father who controls him."
"The longer Sirius remains in Azkaban, the more secure Draco's inheritance becomes," Susan said softly, squeezing Daphne’s hand in support.
"Malfoy has invested heavily in Fudge's administration," Amelia continued. "He's donated enormous sums to various Ministry projects, provided funding for political campaigns, and positioned himself as an indispensable advisor. The Minister's residence has been renovated twice in the past three years using 'anonymous donations' that everyone knows came from Malfoy coffers. Fudge relies on him not just for political support but for the financial backing that keeps his administration and his life running smoothly."
Susan looked disgusted. "So we're not just fighting against bureaucratic incompetence. We're fighting against active corruption."
"Correct," Amelia agreed. "Lucius has spent years building his influence network within the Ministry. He has allies in multiple departments, contacts throughout the Wizengamot, and considerable sway over public opinion through his connections with the Daily Prophet. The paper's editorial stance on most issues mysteriously aligns with whatever would benefit Lucius's interests."
"They won't just dismiss our claims. They'll actively work to discredit them and destroy anyone who supports the effort."
"They'll paint us as conspiracy theorists, attention seekers, or worse," Harry added grimly. "And they'll use every resource at their disposal to make sure the public never hears the truth."
"The influence extends beyond just the Ministry," Amelia warned. "Lucius has connections in the legal profession, among the old pureblood families, and even within Hogwarts' Board of Governors. He's spent decades building a web of obligations, favors, and dependencies. People owe him money, positions, or protection. When he calls in those debts to keep Sirius imprisoned, many will comply rather than face his wrath."
"Auntie, Sirius was imprisoned without trial. How is that even possible? I thought everyone was entitled to due process under wizarding law. Can’t we use that to argue in his favor?"
Amelia sighed deeply as she gazed at Marlene who pursed her lips in disgust.
"That's one of the darkest chapters in our post-war history, Susan. Immediately after Voldemort's defeat, the Ministry was completely overwhelmed. We had hundreds of suspected Death Eaters in custody, evidence was scattered or destroyed in the fighting, and there was massive pressure from the public to see swift justice."
She paused, clearly struggling with memories of her own participation in those dark days. "People were terrified and angry. They had lived through years of fear, watching friends and family members disappear or turn up dead. The public wanted blood, wanted to see Death Eaters punished quickly and severely. There were riots outside the Ministry demanding immediate executions. The pressure was unlike anything the government had ever faced."
"So they took shortcuts," Harry said with understanding.
"The Minister at the time, Millicent Bagnold, and the head of the DMLE, Barty Crouch, implemented what was called a 'deemed trial' system," Amelia explained. "For cases that were considered open and shut, where the evidence seemed overwhelming and the guilt appeared obvious, suspects could be sentenced without a formal trial. Officially, it was recorded as if a proper trial had taken place, complete with fictional transcripts and verdicts, but in reality, it was just a way to process cases quickly and move people to Azkaban without wasting time on legal formalities."
"That's absolutely horrific," Susan breathed, her face pale with shock. "How could they justify something like that?"
"They told themselves it was necessary," Amelia said bitterly. "That the evidence was so clear in these cases that a trial would be a mere formality. That the resources saved could be used to properly try more complex cases. That the public good required swift action. Every rationalization you can imagine was used to justify what was essentially mob justice dressed up in legal paperwork."
"And Sirius was caught up in this system," Marlene said quietly.
"I was there when Sirius was brought in," Amelia confirmed. "I was just a junior Auror then, barely two years out of training, but I remember it clearly. It's not something you forget."
"I know he blamed himself, but what was he like when they brought him in?" Daphne asked quietly, her voice barely audible. Susan wrapped an arm around her, pulling her closer.
"Deranged. Completely broken. He was laughing maniacally, but it wasn't the laugh of someone who was proud of what they'd done or someone who had snapped and embraced madness. It was the laugh of someone who had suffered a complete psychological breakdown. He kept saying over and over that it was his fault, that James and Lily Potter died because of him, that he had killed them."
"And everyone took that as a clear confession of guilt. A known associate of the Potters, found at the scene of Pettigrew's death, laughing like a madman and claiming responsibility for the Potters' murders. It must have seemed like the most open and shut case imaginable," Harry said gravely.
Marlene's voice cracked as she responded, tears flowing freely now. "He meant that if he had remained the secret keeper instead of suggesting they switch to Pettigrew, James and Lily would still be alive. He was blaming himself for trusting the wrong person. He wasn't confessing to betraying them. He was destroying himself with guilt over his mistake in judgment. The idea that he could have willingly handed James and Lily over to that bastard... it's not just wrong, it's impossible. Anyone who truly knew him would have realized that."
A long moment of silence set in as Harry and Susan comforted the mother-daughter pair, their arms wrapped around them respectively as they sniffed.
"So what can actually be done about this situation now? What are our realistic options, Auntie?" Susan asked.
"That's the challenge we're facing. Under current wizarding law, memories like the one we just viewed don't qualify as admissible evidence in criminal proceedings. They can be altered, fabricated, or manipulated too easily by skilled wizards. The Wizengamot has seen too many cases where false memories were used to frame innocent people or exonerate guilty ones."
"The same goes for Veritaserum as well," Daphne said. "It can also be resisted by those with strong minds, and there are antidotes and other techniques that can fool it."
“Correct. But more importantly, it's considered a violation of a person's mental privacy. The law requires that any evidence be obtained through methods that respect basic human dignity and rights."
“Oh wow. That’s rich. Now they remember dignity and rights,” Susan remarked dryly.
"For a petition to be filed before the Wizengamot to reopen a case," Amelia continued, "we would need new, concrete, physical evidence that warrants such action. Documents, artifacts, witness testimony from living people who can be cross-examined—something that can't be easily dismissed or manipulated."
Harry felt frustration boiling up inside him. "Damn it all to hell. If Pettigrew were alive, we could have used any number of methods to force the truth out of him. His testimony, willing or otherwise, would have cleared Sirius immediately."
"Only willing. Evidence obtained by coercion is not acceptable. The case would be thrown out, even if the evidence is overwhelming. But you’re right," Amelia agreed with a regretful nod. "A living Peter Pettigrew would have been the perfect solution to this problem. We could have arrested him, interrogated him, put him on trial, and forced him to confess publicly. His very existence would have proven that Sirius couldn't have murdered him, and that would’ve opened the entire can of worms. But with him dead..."
"There's little we can do," Marlene said despondently, her brief hope beginning to fade like a candle guttering out. "All we have are memories, testimonies from people who weren't there, and my word. None of that will be enough to convince the Wizengamot to overturn the conviction."
Harry stared at the floor, his mind racing through potential solutions and finding each one blocked. Daphne sat beside him with her hands clasped tightly in her lap, her usually sharp mind struggling to find a way forward. Marlene looked defeated, as if the last of her hope was finally dying.
However, Susan had been quiet during this exchange, her brow furrowed in deep concentration. After several minutes of silence, she looked up with a determined expression.
"I disagree," she said firmly. "There is something we can do."
Everyone turned to her with surprised looks. Amelia raised a curious eyebrow, intrigued.
"What do you mean, Susan?" she asked.
"What we need is a by hook or by crook approach," Susan explained, her voice gaining strength as her idea took shape. "Yes, memories and Veritaserum aren't accepted as evidence in court because they can be manipulated or resisted. But there's something else that is considered absolutely undisputable. An Unbreakable Vow."
Amelia's eyes widened in shock, Harry sat up straight as if he'd been struck by lightning, and both Marlene and Daphne stared at Susan with a mixture of amazement and deep concern.
"Susan," Amelia said slowly, her voice carrying a hint of a warning, "Unbreakable Vows are incredibly dangerous magic. They're not called 'unbreakable' as a metaphor. If someone swears a vow and then breaks it..."
"They die instantly," Susan interrupted. "I know exactly how dangerous they are. But think about it logically. Sirius is innocent of the charges against him, right? So all he has to do is agree to swear an Unbreakable Vow to speak the truth regarding the betrayal of the Potters and his innocence regarding the murder of Peter Pettigrew and those Muggles. Once he's sworn the vow and survived, which he will, because he's telling the truth, all we need is for a solicitor to petition the case to the Wizengamot. They'll have no choice but to act on it."
The room fell silent as everyone processed this audacious suggestion. The logic was sound, even if the method was extreme and terrifying.
"If Sirius can swear the vow and survive, it proves his innocence beyond any possible doubt. No court in the wizarding world could ignore that."
"But it's also very risky," Daphne pointed out. "What if the wording of the vow is somehow flawed? What if there's some technicality or nuance that could kill him even though he's innocent of the main charges? Unbreakable Vows are notorious for being dangerous even when the person taking them is truthful, because the magic interprets the words with absolute literalness."
"The wording would have to be absolutely perfect," Amelia agreed. "Every possible loophole, every potential misinterpretation, every ambiguity would have to be eliminated. But Susan's right about one thing. If properly executed, an Unbreakable Vow would be legally binding proof of innocence that no court could dismiss or ignore."
Marlene looked deeply conflicted. "It could work," she said slowly, "but asking Sirius to risk his life on a magical vow... after everything he's already suffered, after thirteen years in hell, to ask him to potentially die for the chance at freedom... it feels almost cruel."
"But he's been suffering in Azkaban already," Harry pointed out gently. "And he'll continue suffering there for the rest of his life unless we do something. This would give him a real chance at freedom, vindication, and the opportunity to reclaim his life. I think if we presented him with the option, he'd take that risk in a heartbeat."
"The psychological aspect is important to consider too," Amelia added. "Black has been living with guilt and self-blame for over a decade. The opportunity to publicly prove his innocence and clear his name might be worth any risk to him. It could be the redemption he's been desperate for all these years."
Susan nodded emphatically. "And consider the alternative. If we do nothing, Sirius dies in Azkaban, forgotten and reviled as a traitor. His name is never cleared, his innocence is never proven, and injustice wins. At least this way, he has a chance to fight for his freedom and his honor."
Everyone sat in contemplation for several long minutes, weighing the pros and cons of Susan's proposal. The risk of oversight was high, but the reward was worth it.
"I can arrange for a conversation with Sirius Black," Amelia said finally. "In my capacity as Head of the DMLE, I have the authority to conduct interviews with prisoners when it relates to ongoing investigations or when new evidence comes to light. I could present him with this option and let him make the decision for himself."
"But even if Sirius agrees to the vow, we'd still need a solicitor willing to take up the petition afterward," Harry remarked. "And if I’m understanding things correctly, that's where we might run into serious problems."
"Exactly," Amelia confirmed grimly. "Once word gets out about what we're doing, and it will get out, because nothing stays secret in the wizarding world for long, Malfoy will know immediately. He'll use every resource at his disposal to pressure potential solicitors into refusing the case. Most of them won't want to go against him when the professional and personal costs could be enormous. Clients canceling contracts, loans being called in early, offices losing their leases, maybe even their families might be ostracized in pureblood circles… it’s going to be a huge mess, and believe me, Malfoy would do that."
Susan frowned deeply. "Auntie, can't you handle the petition yourself? You're the Head of the DMLE. Surely you have the authority to bring this directly to the Wizengamot."
Amelia shook her head regretfully. "If we had discovered new evidence through official channels, if this had come to light during a formal investigation or through proper legal procedures, then yes, I could act in my official capacity and bring the matter directly before the court. But what we're talking about here is a petition from the convicted felon himself. That requires following specific judicial pathways, which means we need either a licensed solicitor to represent him or..."
She paused, a thoughtful look crossing her face as a new possibility occurred to her.
"Or what?" Marlene asked curiously.
“Or we could contact Dumbledore. As Chief Warlock, he does have the authority to call for extraordinary sessions and to present matters directly to the Wizengamot without going through the usual legal channels. It's a rarely used power, but it exists specifically for situations where justice requires immediate attention."
Marlene looked skeptical. "I'm not sure Dumbledore would be as open-minded as you think. The Black family has such a dark reputation in the wizarding world, and Dumbledore lost so many friends and allies to Death Eaters who bore that surname. Bellatrix Lestrange alone tortured and killed dozens of Order members. His judgment might be clouded by those experiences and the prejudices they've created."
"Marlene," Amelia interjected calmly, "Dumbledore might be many things—secretive, manipulative, overly fond of cryptic half-truths—but he wouldn't knowingly let an innocent man rot in Azkaban. If he's allowed Sirius to remain imprisoned all these years, it's because he truly believes Sirius is guilty of the crimes he was accused of. Show him evidence to the contrary, and I believe he'll act on it."
Everyone stared at Marlene who remained unconvinced, but she nodded slowly as she considered the options before them, or the lack thereof. "If we're going to do this, I insist that Professor McGonagall be present as well. She knew James and Lily personally, she knew Sirius too, and she was part of the Order during the war. She might be more willing to listen with an open mind, and her presence could help keep Dumbledore focused on the facts rather than whatever preconceptions he might have."
"I don’t see why that would be a problem," Amelia agreed. "McGonagall has a reputation for fairness, logical thinking, and intellectual honesty. She's not easily swayed by emotions or prejudices, and she values evidence over assumptions."
The conversation gradually began to wind down as they discussed practical details, like when to approach Dumbledore, how to present their case most effectively, what to do if their plan failed, and how to protect themselves from the inevitable backlash. As the afternoon wore on and the winter sun began to set outside the windows, it became clear that they had covered all the ground they could for the immediate future.
"I think we should take some time to prepare properly," Amelia finally said. "I need to arrange the meeting with Black and work out how that conversation should unfold. You three need to decide how you want to approach Dumbledore and McGonagall, and we all need to think carefully about the exact wording of any vow that might be proposed. This is too important to rush, and we'll only get one chance to do it right."
"Agreed completely," Marlene said, standing up with more energy than she'd had when they arrived. "Amelia, I can't thank you enough for listening to us, for believing us, and for being willing to risk your career for justice."
"Don't thank me yet," Amelia replied with a wry smile. "Thank me when Black is free and able to reclaim his rightful place in your lives."
As they prepared to leave Bones Manor, Susan hugged Daphne tightly once more. "Whatever happens going forward, we're all in this together," she whispered. "No matter how dangerous it gets or how powerful the people opposing us are."
"I know," Daphne whispered back, her voice filled with gratitude and determination. "And that means everything to me."
-Break-
Ever since Susan had suggested the idea of the Unbreakable Vow, Harry found himself intrigued with the concept. It’d made him wondered why Unbreakable Vows weren’t a more standard part of the justice system anyway. Surely, if someone was facing a life sentence or the death penalty, why not offer them the option of swearing an Unbreakable Vow of innocence? It would certainly make trials more efficient and dramatically reduce the chances of wrongful convictions.
His theory had led him down the path of discussion with an unexpected companion, and the answer he’d found was complicated and involved both practical and ethical considerations.
Unbreakable Vows were classified as dark magic by the Ministry, and there was significant ethical debate about whether the state should be asking citizens to risk their lives to prove their innocence. It raised uncomfortable questions about coercion and the fundamental principles of justice.
Still, Harry felt it could be offered as a voluntary option. Not required, but available for those who wanted to prove their innocence definitively.
Apparently, the concern was about psychological pressure. Could someone be pressured into taking a vow they weren't completely certain about? What about cases where the person is innocent of the main charge but guilty of related crimes that might be encompassed by the vow? And there was the practical issue of wording. One poorly chosen phrase could kill an innocent person.
All in all, Harry had reached a simple conclusion. The wizarding legal system was full of flaws. This was just one more example of how some basic improvements could make things work so much better for everyone involved. But tradition and fear of change were powerful forces.
Riddle’s diary was quite an informative source of information in this regard, and although a part of him was not entirely comfortable discussing such an important topic, especially in that whiny Draco Malfoy persona, it’d been a revelation. Furthermore, Tom seemed more forthcoming with answers as the discussion went on, undoubtedly intrigued, and Harry hoped the next time he wrote in the diary, its guard would be further lowered.
Harry was brought out of his musings when he felt a hand on his thigh, and he glanced over to Daphne who gave him a look of concern. Harry shook his head to reassure her, taking her hand and giving it a soft squeeze.
“Just thinking about stuff,” he said. “It’s time?”
“Yeah,” she said quietly, looking around.
The Great Hall was buzzing on their first night back and Harry found himself seated with his group. Daphne and Susan sat on either side of him, while the other three had taken up spots right in front of them.
“Looked lost in thoughts, Harry. Wonder what it was about,” Hannah said teasingly, eyeing the three of them suggestively.
“Mind out of the gutter, glutton,” Susan retorted, throwing a chicken bone that struck her friend right on the nose.
“Hey!”
Susan smirked.
Shortly after, they made their way out of the Great Hall and back toward their respective common rooms. Right when they reached the Grand Staircase, Harry caught the eyes of both Daphne and Susan.
“We need to take care of something quickly. We'll catch up with you all later."
Tracey's eyebrows shot up as she stared at Daphne. "Oh, really? All three of you need to 'take care of something' together?" She exchanged a knowing look with Hannah. "I'm sure it's very important business that requires all three of you."
Hannah giggled softly. "Very serious business, I'm sure. The kind that can only happen in private, away from where anyone could see."
“Exactly,” Tracey nodded, grinning. “And all three of you are needed? Must be quite challenging. I’m sure it’d be very tiring.”
Neville grinned but looked slightly embarrassed by the teasing. "Right then. We'll just... head back to our common rooms and pretend we don't know anything about whatever this is."
"You three are absolutely terrible," Daphne said with exaggerated exasperation, yet smiling fondly. "Not everything is about what you're thinking."
"Of course not," Tracey replied with mock solemnity. "I'm sure this is about something completely innocent and academic. Perhaps a joint study session on very important theoretical topics."
“Charms, I bet,” Hannah nodded emphatically. “Why, only the other day I read about one that could make your man’s hands on your titties feel more—”
“And that’s it. We’re out,” Susan said loudly, cutting her off.
"We'll see you all tomorrow," Harry said firmly, though he was fighting back laughter as the redhead dragged both him and Daphne with her.
"Try not to spread any wild rumors while we're gone," Daphne called out.
"Us? Spread rumors?" Hannah asked, her eyes wide. "We would never do such a thing."
As the groups separated with final waves and barely contained giggles from Hannah and Tracey, Harry, Daphne, and Susan began making their way through the castle toward their real destination. The halls were quieter now as students settled in for the evening, and their footsteps echoed softly on the stone floors.
When they reached the corridor that led to Dumbledore's office, they found Professor McGonagall waiting for them, her expression curious and slightly concerned.
"Mr. Potter, Miss Greengrass, Miss Bones," she greeted them formally. "I must admit, I'm quite curious about why I've been asked to be here this evening, and by Madam Bones no less. Her message was rather cryptic."
Harry met her gaze steadily. "Everything will be clear very soon, Professor. I promise you that what we're about to discuss is important enough to warrant your time and attention."
McGonagall frowned slightly at the non-answer, her sharp eyes studying Harry's face. "That's rather vague, Potter. I hope you understand that my time is valuable, and I don't appreciate being summoned without proper explanation."
"I understand, Professor, and I’m sorry for the secrecy," Harry replied respectfully. "You'll understand why once we're inside."
McGonagall's expression remained skeptical, but she didn't press further. Instead, she turned toward the stone gargoyle that guarded the entrance to Dumbledore's office.
"Fizzing Whizzbees," she said clearly.
The gargoyle sprang to life and moved aside, revealing the familiar spiral staircase. The four of them stepped onto the moving stairs, rising slowly toward the headmaster's office.
When they reached the top and McGonagall knocked on the door, Dumbledore's familiar voice called for them to enter. The office looked exactly as Harry remembered, filled with whirring silver instruments, portraits of former headmasters, and Fawkes perched regally on his stand.
"Ah, Professor McGonagall, Mr. Potter, Miss Greengrass, Miss Bones," Dumbledore greeted them, his blue eyes twinkling with curiosity behind his half-moon spectacles. "I must say, I'm quite intrigued as to what this meeting could be about. Such an unusual group for an evening conference."
He gestured toward the chairs arranged in front of his desk. "Please, make yourselves comfortable. I confess I'm wondering if this might be connected to the attack before the holidays."
Harry shook his head firmly. "No, headmaster. This is about something else entirely. Something much more significant. Madam Bones will be explaining everything, and I think it would be best if you heard it from her directly."
Dumbledore and McGonagall exchanged a meaningful glance, both clearly puzzled. Before either could ask another question, the fireplace suddenly flared with green flames, and Amelia Bones stepped through.
"Headmaster, Professor," she greeted them with professional courtesy, brushing soot from her robes. "Thank you for agreeing to this meeting."
"Madam Bones," Dumbledore replied, rising from his chair. "This is indeed unexpected. I hope nothing serious has occurred."
"In a manner of speaking, something very serious has occurred," Amelia replied gravely. "But not in the way you might think."
Before anyone could respond, the flames flared again, and Marlene stepped through. McGonagall’s eyes widened as she stared in shock at her former student.
"Marlene?" She whispered, her voice barely audible.
Marlene's expression softened as she looked at her old Head of House. "Hello, Professor. It’s been a while."
"I feel this is clearly more complex than I previously suspected," Dumbledore remarked, his eyes darting from one to another. “Why don’t you tell me what this meeting is about, Madam Bones?”
" Albus, I'm going to need you to retrieve your pensieve," Amelia said, taking charge of the situation. "What we have to show you is too important to rely on simple explanations."
The request clearly surprised Dumbledore, but he moved without hesitation to the cabinet where he kept his pensieve. "This is most irregular, Madam Bones. But I assume you have good reason."
"The best possible reason," Amelia confirmed as Dumbledore set the silver basin on his desk. "Justice."
Marlene stepped forward, her wand already in her hand. "What you're about to see concerns Sirius and the night James and Lily died. Everything you think you know about what happened is wrong."
McGonagall’s eyes widened with shock, while Dumbledore's expression became grave and intensely focused.
"That's quite a claim," Dumbledore said quietly. "I hope you understand the seriousness of what you're suggesting."
"I understand it better than anyone," Marlene replied, pressing her wand tip to her temple. "Because I've been living with the truth for more than a decade, unable to do anything about it."
She drew out the silvery strand of memory and let it fall into the pensieve, where it swirled like liquid starlight.
Dumbledore and McGonagall both leaned forward to enter the memory, their expressions serious and concerned.
The wait felt eternal. Harry, Daphne, Susan, and Marlene sat in tense silence, each lost in their own thoughts about what was happening in the memory and what would come next. Amelia paced slowly near the fireplace, her professional composure masking the anxiety they all felt.
Finally, both figures emerged from the pensieve, their faces showing the profound impact of what they had witnessed. McGonagall looked stricken, her hands trembling as she gripped the arms of her chair. Dumbledore's expression was grave and deeply troubled, his usual twinkle completely absent.
"Dear Merlin," McGonagall whispered, her voice shaking. "Sirius... all these years... he's been innocent."
She turned to Dumbledore with anguish written across her features. "Albus, we let an innocent man suffer in Azkaban. How could we have been so wrong? How could we have failed him so completely?"
Dumbledore was quiet for a long moment, his mind clearly working through the implications of what he had seen. That was most certainly an authentic memory.
"And you... dear girl, what you suffered... and you..." McGonagall turned to look at Daphne with new understanding. "You're not really Greengrass's daughter. You're Sirius's child."
Daphne nodded, her own emotions threatening to overwhelm her. "Yes, Professor. Sirius Black is my father, but he doesn't know I exist. My mother was forced to hide the truth to protect both of us."
McGonagall's expression crumbled with the full weight of the injustice they had all been party to. "An innocent man in Azkaban, a daughter who can't know her father, a woman forced to live a life of anguish for years..."
"Which is why we're here," Harry said, speaking for the first time since the adults had emerged from the memory. "We want to make it right. All of it."
Dumbledore turned his attention to the younger members of their group, his expression thoughtful. "And what exactly do you propose we do, Mr. Potter? I’m sure you know there would be legal obstacles. Memories are not accepted as evidence, and even if it’s the truth, we don’t have any new evidence supporting Sirius’s innocence."
"We have a plan," Susan said confidently. "It's not without risks, but we believe it could work."
Amelia stepped forward to take control of the explanation. "Albus, we've given this considerable thought. The traditional routes for overturning a conviction are blocked by the lack of acceptable evidence and by political interests that want Sirius to remain imprisoned."
"Ah, that does sound like you are talking about Lucius," Dumbledore agreed grimly. "And Cornelius would be reluctant to admit such a massive failure of justice, even if it happened under the previous administration. He is a man of stability, and he would do anything in his power to maintain the illusion."
"Which brings us to our proposal," Marlene said, her voice steady. "We want Sirius to swear an Unbreakable Vow declaring his innocence."
McGonagall gasped audibly, while Dumbledore's eyebrows shot up in alarm.
"An Unbreakable Vow?" McGonagall said, her voice filled with horror. "But that could kill him if there's even the slightest error in the wording!"
"Which is exactly why it would be accepted as irrefutable proof," Daphne explained calmly. "If he swears the vow and survives, no court in the wizarding world could continue to claim he's guilty."
"The risks..." Dumbledore began.
"Are considerable," Amelia acknowledged. "But so is the alternative. Sirius Black will die in Azkaban if we do nothing. This at least gives him a chance at freedom and vindication."
"And you believe he would agree to such a thing?" McGonagall asked.
"I believe he would embrace the opportunity," Marlene said with quiet conviction. "He's been blaming himself for James and Lily's deaths for thirteen years. The chance to publicly prove his innocence and clear his name would be worth any risk to him."
Dumbledore was quiet for a long time, his mind clearly working through all the implications and possibilities. Finally, he looked up at the group assembled in his office.
"Assuming Sirius agrees to this vow, and assuming he survives it, how do you propose we proceed legally?"
"That's where we need your help," Harry said directly. "As Chief Warlock of the Wizengamot, you have the authority to bring this directly before the full court without going through the usual channels. You could call an extraordinary session and present the evidence yourself."
"It would certainly bypass the problems with finding a solicitor willing to take the case," Amelia added. "And it would give the matter the gravity and authority it deserves."
McGonagall looked at Dumbledore intently. "Albus, we have a moral obligation to act on this. We failed Sirius once. We cannot fail him again."
"I agree completely," Dumbledore said firmly. "Regardless of the political consequences or the personal risks, justice must be served. If Sirius is willing to take this vow, then I will do everything in my power to ensure he receives the fair hearing he was denied all those years ago."
There was not even an ounce of hesitation in either his voice or demeanor, and Marlene felt tears of relief beginning to flow.
"Thank you, Headmaster. You have no idea what this means to me. To all of us."
Dumbledore nodded with a sympathetic look on his face.
Suddenly, the fireplace suddenly flared with green flames once again and everyone turned around. This time, however, the arrival was completely unexpected and unwelcome.
Minister Cornelius Fudge stumbled through the flames, his face flushed with panic and his usually immaculate appearance disheveled. His bowler hat was askew, his robes were wrinkled, and his expression was one of barely controlled hysteria.
"Albus!" he cried out, rushing toward Dumbledore's desk without seeming to notice anyone else in the room. "Thank Merlin you're here! We have a crisis! I can’t believe it!"
Everyone in the office stared at the frantic Fudge in surprise, wondering just what could get him so hysterical.
"Cornelius, please calm yourself and tell us what happened."
Fudge looked around the office for the first time, finally noticing the assembled group. His eyes widened in confusion as he took in the unexpected gathering, but he shook his head, his panic overrode his curiosity.
"It’s Black," he gasped, his eyes wide and his voice cracking with strain. "Sirius Black escaped from Azkaban!"
TBC.
Comments
TheWateringWizard
Ohhhh fuck… such a good plan, unintentionally ruined by Sirius ^^
Elias
well fuck that complicates things
