Patrefans
M.J. Markgraf from patreon
M.J. Markgraf patreon

Blue Star Enterprises Chapter 2-47

🕑 Added 2024-10-21 12:00:16 +0000 UTC

Comments

Silver Beard

@ Shmooggie - no life for at least 10 years... if you are any good you won't miss them. Be more worried about budget cuts than missed dates

ben russ

Congrats on getting in. Be prepared to have no life for the next four years ;)

Shmooggie

Yooo I’m an first year engineering student

ben russ

Fair, and this is your sci-fi world not mine (and I do love your story telling, this is me being nit-picky); however, it does not take the core getting hit to render it useless. One of the primary reasons the US has the strongest military is because of its Electronic Warfare capability. EW applied correctly can and does result in the US's enemies literally hurting themselves because we convinced their computer systems to target their friendlies. In addition, any hit to any data lines can cut off functionality from the core. I struggle to believe that chips that are more advanced than our own wouldn't be able to independently operate systems at a level equivalent to supercomputer control. Where I do see a supercomputer being relevant is solely in either directing EW, running an AI, or processing vast amounts of data.

mmarkgraf212

Understandable. The ships can be operated without the computer core. There are computer systems in all of the electronics. Having the supercomputer is more about assisting with automation and some other neat features that make Alexander's ships punch above their weight class. It also helps him stretch his limited fleet personnel, which is essentially just Captain Na and his people along with Branston at the moment. Losing it would be extremely detrimental but if the core is hit, they probably have other concerns.

ben russ

That was probably the best most realistic part of the whole series.

Silver Beard

Battlestar Galatica ftw!

Silver Beard

He's a month out from getting new super chips, etc. let's not push more than resource gathering and see what tech he can come up with?!

ben russ

Oftentimes in fighters and other aircraft there are two or even three flight computers steering the aircraft, each independently making decisions using their own methods and then checking them against each other. And that is done intentionally.

ben russ

There is no reason for a big centralized computer for a large spaceship. And I would argue that especially for ships flying a military designation there should be no centralized computer. A centralized anything is a target that crippled the corresponding capability. There is no reason that a targeting computer, for example, needs to be controlled by the same computer running the navigation. Now the navigation is important in targeting, so you would want a crosslink exchanging data, but they NEED to be able to function without each other or some centralized computer.

ben russ

Engineer here (both electrical and mechanical, who works in aerospace and defense)... I don't get the obsession with supercomputers. I've shut my mouth about the hand waviness when it comes to computer "chips" in this story, but the whole supercomputer hand waviness is pushing it over the top. (See explanation in comments)

mmarkgraf212

The good ol sunk cost falicy. Is it better to wait for a breakthrough, or move forward with what's available?

Silver Beard

He needs a breakthrough on the gravity plate. The station he wants to build will not work well long term. He needs to make one big ring. His projects, ships yard, etc. fill that little thing he's started in zero flat and the expense/time will have been wasted.

mmarkgraf212

That's assuming he has his pick of ships and crew, which he doesn't. Easier in the short term just to ferry people on the same ship that's doing patrol.

Gabriel Melnik

It's when things scale up that this becomes a money dump.

ShadeByTheSea

Plus in hostile space where you have limited crew than armed transports make a lot more sense. It's not perfect, nor best practice, but you have to work with what you have. It's relatively safe too as long as he's not transporting random people.

Zachary Patterson

Thank you for the chapter!

ElAdri1999

If fuel is not an issue then it should be fine, but I think Alex will get around to making are armed transport

Hammy

Agreed. It why most wet navies have armed logistic ships. But I do not think he is up to building a ship from scratch yet.

Gabriel Melnik

It's not the best idea to use warships as transport ships unless you are really strapped for cargo space due to budget. You can haul more things with less fuel when dealing with an armed transport ship than a warship working as a taxi.


More Creators