Patrefans
carrarn from patreon
carrarn patreon

Irwin's Journey 337: The Machine

🕑 Added 2024-10-20 19:11:49 +0000 UTC

Comments

Antony Claughton

In which case why send 4 to begin with for the party, if 3 will stay at the portal? These are meant to be experienced mercenaries. For experienced mercenaries, they didn't seem to scout the base, be prepared for more people there or be ready for combat cards. Which given they couldn't know what Greldo and others cards were, seems a little odd. Irwin & co got VERY lucky. Their enemies were particularly unprepared, incompetent and arrogant, and then the searchers stumbled over the portal. Some of that is justified by the fact the mercenaries would normally consider themselves so strong, but for experienced operators they made a tonne of rookie errors.

Cal

My guess is that they thought 1 Niox with its incapacitate card was 'enough'. Suspect they were seriously underestimating the combat capabilities of Irwin and crew.

Antony Claughton

At some point I hope they discuss how lucky they were. Stumbling over the Niox portal was a 1-in-a-million chance. If all 4 Niox had attacked the base as a group, with surprise, with the one-shot incapacitator card, they probably lose. Only being able to reverse the ambush (twice) on a split party likely meant they achieved the overwhelming victory with no losses. And why was the split 3 Niox at base, 1 in the attack?

Nicholas Del Rossi

Just letting the readers know with certainty that he was not dead so we instead focus on the others reactions and the real danger to his mental health from his perceived failure, along side the damage caused by the one time use card is all I think would be needed to make it feel less, hmm not sure what the word is, fake? When the author makes you feel consequences then brings them back. It’s sort of makes the actual damage done feel less real focusing on the stress that Arwin might face at almost losing a member of his crew, along with the other tragic deaths of the blade maidens and booms resurfacing trauma rather than the red herring death, I think the impact of the death in the readers mind would also do a better job of concerning us of it being potential foreshadowing if that’s the direction you’re looking to go, Bit of a messy comment, but it gets the point across and since I’m writing this on a phone smaller than my hand, I can’t really fix typos or go over it to make it cleaner

Cal

Don't take those comments too seriously - your storytelling is incredible!

Stephen Pearson

Thanks for the chapter! :-)

Antony Claughton

Fine. I'll go. ==> Fine. Go. ones ==> once

Carrarn

I've seen your mentions about Boohm and what might happen, and I've added it to my list. For now, things are as I wrote them, but I'll take it into consideration for when I do the eventual rewrite. Still, thanks immensely for all the feedback!


More Creators