Blake Hart
patreon
I became my best friend's slut for Halloween – Part 1
🕑 Added 2024-10-27 11:52:57 +0000 UTCEveryone in this story is 18+
Hey everyone! 🎃 As promised, here’s a little Halloween treat! This story will be updated daily from today through Wednesday. I’ll also have more regular updates for you tomorrow. Have an awesome day!
Hi, I’m Elijah—but these days, most people just call me Eli. I’m 19, a sophomore in college, and with Halloween right around the corner, I can’t help but think back to last year. I was 18 then, and I’d spent weeks planning my costume, perfecting every detail. I wanted to push boundaries, so I decided to cross-dress, go all out, and really surprise everyone. But what I didn’t expect was that this bold choice would lead to me losing my virginity… to my best friend, Bennett. It was a night that changed everything between us, and, well, it’s a story worth telling.
It all started when I was at my sister's place, standing in front of the mirror while she helped me get ready. This year, I’d decided to go all out and dress as a girl. Seeing myself like this, with makeup and a tight dress, felt surreal. It wasn’t just a costume—it was something I’d fantasized about for years but had never had the courage to actually do. Until tonight.
I could feel my pulse quicken as she handed me a pair of black stockings, her smile encouraging but knowing. My hands shook a little as I slid them on, the fabric hugging my legs in a way that was both foreign and thrilling. “You look good,” she said, adjusting the hem of the short skirt I’d borrowed from her closet.
I glanced at myself in the mirror, barely recognizing the person staring back. My sister had outdone herself. The makeup, perfectly applied, framed my face like a work of art. She’d used eyeliner to make my eyes look bigger and brighter, a hint of blush to give me a soft, natural flush. Being a makeup artist, she’d accentuated all my best features effortlessly, but the real magic was in the contouring. She’d sculpted my face beyond recognition, making my cheekbones sharper, my jawline softer.
My lips, painted a soft red, curled into a nervous smile. I felt a rush of something unfamiliar. Was it excitement? Fear? Maybe a bit of both. It was like staring at a different person—one I’d only imagined in dreams and fantasies. And now, she was standing right here, staring back at me.
"You ready?" she asked, handing me a wig that cascaded in waves down my shoulders. My heart raced. Was I? Could I be?
My sister carefully placed the blonde wig on me, adjusting it until it fell just right over my shoulders. I couldn't believe what I saw in the mirror. I actually looked... stunning. The weeks of preparation had paid off—my body was smooth, every inch of hair painstakingly shaved away. I’d gone all in: spray tan, fake lashes, perfectly manicured nails, and even the padded Wonderbra I’d borrowed from my sister, which gave me the cleavage I never thought I’d see on myself.
My face was smooth and soft, a far cry from the usual scruff I wore when I let my beard grow out. “Oh my God, Elijah,” my sister gasped, her eyes wide. “You look just like me! It’s uncanny!”
She wasn’t exaggerating. At 5’5", I’d always been shorter than most guys, and my features were more delicate than I cared to admit. My body shape had always leaned on the feminine side too—a round ass that I usually hid under baggy clothes, but tonight, framed by a tight corset and a slutty little dress, it was impossible to ignore.
I turned to the mirror, feeling both a sense of disbelief and... something else. A thrill. I looked so girlish, so real. As I admired the transformation, my phone buzzed. It was a text from my best friend, Bennett: “Dude, you gotta get here rn! So many hot bitches, you wouldn’t believe it!”
I texted back, "Bro, chill. And don’t get too drunk before I get there. Work’s done now. I’ll be there in 20." I couldn’t help but smirk as I hit send. Bennett had no idea what was coming. He didn’t know I was at my sister’s, let alone that I was dressing up like a girl. As far as he knew, I was stuck at work, which was my excuse for skipping pre-party beers with him.
But the thought of how he’d react when he saw me? That sent a little thrill through me. The element of surprise was too good to resist.
Then, an even better idea popped into my head. “Leah,” I said, grinning wickedly, “let’s take a picture.”
Leah didn’t need much convincing. As a makeup artist, she knew exactly how to get the best angles and lighting for the perfect picture. We took several shots, her arranging my blonde locks to fall just right, slightly obscuring my face but still showing enough to make me look mysterious. When she snapped the best one, it was like looking at twin sisters—identical down to the pout we both threw at the camera.
I pressed my cleavage together, using what little I had, but with Leah’s expert contouring and the push-up bra, it actually looked convincing. With the perfect lighting and a subtle filter, the end result was shocking. I had to admit it: we looked like two hot bitches.
“Let’s test something,” I said, my mind already running with a wicked idea. “Send the picture to some of your guy friends—ones who don’t know you well—and see if they think I’m a girl.”
Leah, ever the prankster, was more than happy to play along. She quickly threw on a flattering filter, added a cheeky caption: Me and my sister Eli’s Halloween party got cancelled 😢. Someone want to host instead? ❤️
She sent it to a few guys she’d matched with on Tinder, and the responses were immediate.
Leah's phone glowed with excited responses from handsome strangers:
"Ofc bby, you 2 look great btw 😍"
"👀 Yass! Pls come here, and bring your banging sis too 👀"
"You and your sis are 🔥 Come thru, I got a bud who rlly wants to meet her 🥰"
And maybe it was stupid, but as a guy, you don’t get many compliments. I always felt pretty average as a dude. But as a girl? I was a solid 8, maybe even a 9.
Leah drove me to the party, and I glanced over at her, feeling the nervous energy building. "Can you please just follow me inside? Meet some people, and then you can go?" I asked, trying to sound casual but feeling anything but.
"Of course, I can come say hi," Leah reassured me with a smile. "But don’t be nervous, you look so good. Besides, isn’t it time to let people know you’re—"
"Not tonight, please. Just come with me," I cut her off, my voice more desperate than I wanted.
"Okay, little bro, I’m coming," she said with a laugh. "But I can’t stay for long."
My sister’s heels and mine clanked against the pavement, and I had to admit—we looked really good. As we approached the house, the music pounded through the walls, vibrating with the energy of the Halloween party inside.
And then, there he was—Bennett. He spotted us from a distance, and before I could even process it, he started whistling and howling in our direction.
“As charming as ever, and he didn’t even bother with a costume, as usual. Typical Benny,” Leah muttered, her tone tinged with a hint of resignation.
However, my own heart pounded in my chest, the anticipation of it all nearly overwhelming me.
But as I tried to steady myself, glancing down at the bodice of my dress. The fabric clung to my curves, hugging me in ways that made me feel both vulnerable and powerful. My legs were encased in the black stockings, and the stiletto heels I wore made every step a calculated move. I had practiced walking in heels for weeks as well.
Bennett didn’t seem to notice it was me at first. “Leah! I didn’t think you’d be here! So nice to see you!” He pulled her in for a hug, then glanced around, asking, “Where’s Elijah, and who’s your hot friend here?”
He turned toward me, and for a brief moment, I felt like a piece of meat—prey, and Bennett was a voracious predator hunting me. The thought surprisingly made my body surge with adrenaline.
But after a few seconds, I noticed his brow furrow as he squinted at me, then his eyes widened in disbelief. "No way! Elijah??"
I kept my composure, pouting my lips slightly as I raised my voice a little higher. "Who’s Elijah? I’m Eli, Leah’s sister," I teased, then burst out laughing. Leah quickly joined in.
Bennett, still reeling from shock, eventually caught up and started laughing harder than both of us. "Brooooo! That’s fucking sick! I legit thought you were a girl. It’s wizardry!"
"Not magic, just a wicked makeup artist," Leah chimed in with a grin.
"Of course, Leah, this was probably all your idea, right? Freaking brilliant!" Bennett said, shaking his head.
"Actually, it was Elijah's id—" Leah started, but I cut her off quickly.
"Yeah, yeah, her idea, obviously. You know how she is," I shot Leah a knowing glance.
"Typical me," she smirked, playing along. "Anyway, I gotta head out—got my own Halloween party to crash." She hugged us both, and as she embraced Bennett, he joked, "Shame to see you go, hon. I always thought you were the one that got away." He puckered his lips exaggeratedly, aiming for a playful kiss.
Leah rolled her eyes. "Yeah, no. Bye!" She turned to leave.
"Guess I’ll have to make do with your hot little sister, then," Bennett smirked, smacking my ass.
"Benny, dream on. And be nice to Eli!" Leah called out as she strutted back to her car. "Happy Halloween, boys!"
As we yelled our goodbyes, Bennett’s hand lingered on my ass a little longer than I expected. He gave it another playful squeeze, laughing. "Damn, it’s just like jello."
We both laughed again, but beneath all the joking, there was something else there—an undercurrent of tension that neither of us could quite ignore. At least, I couldn’t.
Comments
Blake
This story actually adresses just this. Happy reading:)
Jules
Stories like this are so hot but do these straight boys love the person under the makeup? I’m off to read more and find out!
