xjuliettex patreon

Dr Who 4x8 Silence in the Library Youtube Edit CLEAN

🕑 Added 2024-05-08 21:00:02 +0000 UTC

Comments

Oliver

Saving the Doctor's live, being their love-interest with implications for other companions after her, creating Jack Harkness' immortality.

Oliver

Hmm, the big one I can't go into without spoilers for Juliette, so I won't. I also like the idea of a Matrix-like world where the issue of finite resources are dealt with by an enigmatic psychologist character who tricks you into filling in the gaps ("and then you remembered"). The concept of the living shadows is a little wacky but brilliant for a suspenseful story. The poetic but horrible ghosting. The cliffhanger which is imo wonderfully done with is repetitive chants by the ghosting crew member and the Donna-faced terminal. The way we are mislead into thinking Doctor Moon in Cal's reality is not aware of her situation but while he's in fact a crucial part of it. I can't remember everything I liked about it right now but I prefer this kind of storytelling to one-idea-plots but also to complicated multi-plot-stories where no plotline is finished or used in an interesting way. Just my 2 ct

demonic-myst

She the one allways brought up by the tenth docter

demonic-myst

She has a large impact on most the 10 docters seasons

The Dog Walker

What are some of those brilliant ideas?

chicks dig me

Why is Rose important?

Juliette Gaming

It's just SO well done! A beautifully sad and tragic tale. We are SO lucky to have such an awesome show 💜

demonic-myst

River is on par with rose in how important she is to new whos lore

Oliver

This two-parter has so many brilliant ideas all wrapped into one story. It's one of the best (double) episodes Steven Moffat wrote. I wonder if this was kind of his application to become the next showrunner (which he did, from series 5-10). And, yes, River Song is a lovely name...