Patrefans
athassprkr from patreon
athassprkr patreon

(Enchanting Melodies) Chapter 141: The Defense Conundrum

🕑 Added 2023-10-01 08:39:18 +0000 UTC

Comments

athass_prkr

Here's the thing, the only way a magical economy could work would be if it was entirely separated from the muggle one. And to do that, natural materials can't be considered currency. The only value a wizard could have on anything is its magic. Anything you can buy in the muggle world is worthless in the magical one, especially since transfiguration and transmutation are a thing. If wizards needed anything from there, they could easily just take it. However, there are professions that do take materials from the muggle world, but treat them alchemically and then sell them. I the magical world, only magic matters. In this chapter, Remus' wealth (Muggle and magical) is something of a plot point so I won't spoil it, but he'll have to have dabbled on both sides to make his money.

Veniat

Some ingredients are harder to grow, I'd assume even with magic that would be true, or leather like I mentioned, or just basic materials like aluminium, lead, things people without magic could mine en masse. Also, would creating or mining ores with magic affect the end result? Could it interfere with alchemical or ritual effects? Could mining ores without magic do the same? They'd have to use compulsion charms on an entire chain of people, from the miners to the people on top. Ores are traced and registered from the mines to the refineries, to the end consumer. A person suddenly having no idea where their materials went would want to figure out where they went and if they went to someone trying to manufacture weapons or something like that, even fertiliser is traced incase it's being used to make bombs. An official person in the know would make more sense, and if they knew they could check if that money was conjured or not; to me it makes more sense to have muggleborns or people like Remus making the transactions in secret.

athass_prkr

I forgot to address that tbh. The goblins don't really accept normal gold. They like artefacts more, which is what gives value to the magical currency. Gold, silver and bronze are just metals that are perfected to that kind of enchantment. Mining gold or buying it and selling it to the goblins wouldn't work. I wanted to say it was why the Goblins were so happy to fund curse breaker investigations since they can find rare enchanted items, which they treasure more.

Veniat

For all his manipulations, Dumbledore in this story really is incredibly ignorant and out of touch. Just the bit about Remus not being able to afford Wolfsbane, it's not like muggles don't mine gold and other materials that Remus could sell to wizards so he could afford wizard assets.


More Creators