Patrefans
athassprkr from patreon
athassprkr patreon

(Enchanting Melodies) Chapter 205: Tempest

🕑 Added 2024-01-21 11:44:52 +0000 UTC

Comments

ha vu

In a way, I assumed the prophecies were made so that the future it predicted would definitely happen. Like this one about Harry (allegedly) for example. Without the prophecy, Dumbledore wouldn't be constantly monitored and put a lot of unnecessary pressure on Harry. Without the pressure from Dumbledore, Harry might spend his entire time at school leisurely studying any interesting magical field, even the more useless one, then he wouldn't be as good as he is now. In a way, it is the pressure from Dumbledore that unlocks the most potential from Harry. Now, I think it would have been pretty hard for anyone to spy on Harry thanks to the "training" by Moody. Maybe it isn't even a prophecy, just something Flamel told Dumbledore to make the man act in a way that would turn any magical prodigy against him. Looking at every corner, being overbearing, alienating every, and anyone with a slight chance of destroying him. As mentioned in this chapter, the lady was a formidable seer and the thing is that we never know if seers saw the unexpected stuff that would happen without any input from the people who experienced it or if she saw a future and what led to it - which is why the prophecy was told - it guarantees the event it foretold happening. I think I read a story about a seer once, she did explain how it works for her in the story. She can see the fate of everyone around her just by looking at their faces. Fate is mixed of the unexpected and unchanging and the stuff the person can do to navigate or circumvent it. For example, she can foretell that a person would face financial difficulty but she also sees a way out of it if that person acts in a certain way. The event is unchanging but the outcome can change. However, what makes the girl truly dangerous is that she can see a personality, strengths, background, and everything which means she knows how people would react, and how well they can deal with problems in their lives and she can purposefully omit very important details to drive the future in the direction she wanted. So you know natural disasters right? If there is a huge flood that year, there is no way to change it. It would also be impossible for her to accurately predict where the dam would break or where a landslide would happen due to the rain. And she is unlikely to be able to change any of that. However, she can accurately predict who would lose their home and when and by seeing many people losing their homes living in the same area, and at the same time => She can predict that the area will face a natural disaster (doesn't what kind but she can make an educated guess). So she can warn the people to move away from the area thus saving their lives. However, there is also the fact that some can believe her and some don't. If someone thought that she was being sensationalist and refused to move leading to their death, then that is something unavoidable. After all, you can't change someone's personality or how they would react.

iTEX

I've never liked prophecy. Either they're real and the universe is inherently deterministic and free will and choice don't matter. Or their false and should be ignored. But in either scenario, any action taken (or not) doesn't matter, because prophecies are either guaranteed to happen or won't regardless of what you do. They're the xanatos gambit of author fiat. Hopefully it's just something to appease mad eye and not Dumbledore's actual reasoning.

TypistTyphon

Dumbledore need to be punched down hard! Fuck that guy


More Creators